10 ms·
A few words on Doug Engelbart (2013)
- camillomiller 8y agoNice piece, but let me defend the headlines. Did Engelbart envision the computer mouse? Yes. Is he highly regarded as a public personality for that? Yes. Hoping that a headline could convey the complexity you need an entire section of a blog post to explain in a complex way is never a good critique of journalism. For that you need to run a special feature, or you promote a book. You can't expect the New York Times to illustrate the true nature of Doug Engelbart on the first three lines of his obituary. Same applies for every scientist or "big mind" kind of person.
- AriaMinaei 8y agoWell I read the NYT article. It is not only the headline that misses the point. The whole piece does.
- zeth___ 8y agoEngelbart did not envision the brain dead point and click thing apple introduced (with a single button[0]), or microsoft slightly improved version (with two buttons[1]) and that we have made ever so slightly better since then [2] [3] [4]. What he envisioned was a 32 state machine (or 256 if you count all the non-keyboard buttons) which could be positioned anywhere on a screen: https://99percentinvisible.org/app/uploads/2014/12/1450065_10154835434955223_600605115474172169_n1.jpg https://99percentinvisible.org/app/uploads/2014/12/1450065_1... Something that would cause you to switch modes completely between typing and using it. A modal input mode for the gui, in the same way that vi is for the keyboard. The closest thing today is the razer keypad for gaming [5], and even that is not integrated into the OS a tenth as well as what Engelbart had and by default barely supports chording. [0] http://dynamis.no/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/1984-Apple-Macintosh-Mouse.jpg http://dynamis.no/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/1984-Apple-Maci... [1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/0b/Microsoft_Serial_Mouse_2.0A-8521.jpg/1280px-Microsoft_Serial_Mouse_2.0A-8521.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/0b/Mi... [2] https://www.technologyuk.net/computing/computer-systems/images/mouse08.jpg https://www.technologyuk.net/computing/computer-systems/imag... [3] https://files.pccasegear.com/images/1459844620-RZ-NAGA-CHROMA-th.jpg https://files.pccasegear.com/images/1459844620-RZ-NAGA-CHROM... [4] https://www.wired.com/images_blogs/gadgetlab/2009/11/oomouse-proto.jpg https://www.wired.com/images_blogs/gadgetlab/2009/11/oomouse... [5] https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/817GlmVDffL._SX425_.jpg https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon.com/images/I/817GlmVDffL...
- schpaencoder 8y agoWell, are’nt you missing the point here? Conflating features with intent?
- zeth___ 8y agoNo. The mouse introduced in 1984 was philosophically incompatible with Anglebarts mouse like device. Watch the mother of all demos and see the difference. Apple: https://youtu.be/S7AL7tkQ7d0?t=13m8s https://youtu.be/S7AL7tkQ7d0?t=13m8s Mother of all demos: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yJDv-zdhzMY
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DonHopkins 8y agoI recently posted Doug Engelbart's advice to a young software developer, with some links to interesting videos about his work on the chord keyboard and glove, and also a link to a new product called "Tap" that seems to be inspired by his work (more links and interesting stuff about Doug Engelbart's work in the discussion): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17121629 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17121629 I just ran across a new device called "Tap", a wearable tap glove that functions as both a bluetooth keyboard and mouse! https://www.tapwithus.com/ https://www.tapwithus.com/ I haven't had any "hands on" experience with the Tap, but it looks very cool, like a modern version of Douglas Engelbart's and Valerie Landau's HandWriter glove! I asked Valerie Landau about it (wondering if it was her company), but she hadn't heard of it before. They have an iOS, Android and Unity3D SDK that appeared on github recently, so you can look at the code to see how it works: https://github.com/TapWithUs https://github.com/TapWithUs Valerie Landau interviewed by Martin Wasserman https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=62ig8ecXlrA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=62ig8ecXlrA Q: What did you find most impressive about him as a person? A: His humility. He was such a humble man, and his steadfastness of keeping his vision. Often times leaders like Doug, who many people call a prophet... In our society, we tend to think of the leaders as these sort of charismatic, ambitious people, and I think that Doug really broke that mold, in that he was a very humble, really shy person. Q: Do you have any last minute comments or observations about him to finish up. Or a good anecdote? A: I think -- I wanted to say one thing that Doug told me many years ago. And this is really for the software developers out there. Once, this was in the 90's. And I said, Doug, Doug, I'm just started to get involved with software development, and we have this really cool tool we're working on. Do you have any advice, about ... for a young software developer. He looked at me and said: "Yes. Make sure that whatever you do is very modular. Make everything as modular as possible. Because you know that some of your ideas are going to endure, and some are not. The problem is you don't know which one will, and which one won't. So you want to be able to separate the pieces so that those pieces can carry on and move forward."
- bouvin 8y agoI was fortunate enough to meet Doug Engelbart at a Hypertext conference years ago, where he was a keynote speaker. Very friendly and soft spoken man. From the his keynote, I got the distinct impression that he was disappointed and a little saddened that we had not progressed further than we have. His vision of augmenting the human intellect through the use of computers was both bold and hopeful, but instead we are barraged by click-bait, fake news, trolls, and social networking sites carefully engineered to keep us hooked—not much of an augmentation.
- walterbell 8y agoAt least we know that negative augmentation (a) works, (b) is profitable. Now we need to show the same for positive augmentation. Apple could develop privacy-oriented augmentation demos for their AR glasses, e.g. using local-only analysis of user data and preferences.
- willvarfar 8y agoShould the recent focus on privacy be projected onto Doug Engelbart's aims on positive augmentation? Can you have positive augmentation without privacy? In the demos it brings to my mind this idea where everyone's terminals are stitch-together as one massive desktop, rather like a pen-and-paper office you can go around browsing other people's desks. And perhaps a lack of privacy helps in a corporate office environment? ADD: it makes me wonder if my team couldn't have some kind of modern 'pc anywhere' where you can connect to each other's desktops. So people don't feel spied on you could have the camera feed of those who are currently sharing your desktop just like in the demo shown in this obituary.
- walterbell 8y agoEven those unconcerned with privacy ("click-bait, fake news, trolls, and social networking sites") have not achieved augmentation. Someone concerned with privacy could design a protocol for consent, to enable the secure information sharing required for augmentation. > some kind of modern 'pc anywhere' where you can connect to each other's desktops See LogMeIn which also owns GoToMyPC.
- ipsum2 8y agoThis is from 2013, if anyone else had a double take on "Doug Engelbart died today".
- Angostura 8y ago"Ah, so like Google Wave"
- schpaencoder 8y agoYou know, I think google wave was so close to this augmenting human intellec thing, perhaps the product was killed because it threatened to cannibalize other segments of up and coming products from google, I have no idea. But I clearly remember the feeling I had when discovering it.
- vidarh 8y agoI think the idea was good, but it was simultaneously over-engineered and under-engineered. Over-engineered in that it tried to do too much in too complicated ways. Under-engineered in that they didn't then invest enough in evolving the technical solutions into something more reasonable. I'd like to see someone try to simplify it into a more workable starting point.
- edejong 8y agoIt also didn’t really perform well at all.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jamesgeck0 8y agoThis was the major barrier to use for me. Every new message in a thread made performance a little bit worse. A thread with 100 messages in it was distinctly laggy and unpleasant to use on my Core 2 Duo laptop.
- samatman 8y agoWho knows what the political problems were (Wave was an acquisition), but technically I think it was held back by OT being a poor fit for the front end stack at the time: Google was making most of their webapps in Java compiled to JS. The modern virtual DOM-diffing approach is a much better fit for OT, and I'd love to see someone try again.
- m_mueller 8y agoThe failure to replicate Engelbart's vision of collaborative UI plagues me every day. I have to think of it every day I'm forced to use Skype, Lotus Notes, Excel and a bunch of different screen sharing services. Google Docs is probably the closest we got, but I'm not allowed to use it for my work anymore for now. The fact that we have ubiquitous cameras, microphones, bandwidth, input devices and compute power, but can't even achieve the level of integration they had back in the 60s - it's just mindboggling.
- walterbell 8y ago60's research landscape and 2018 commercial landscape have different priorities. There is little economic incentive today for interoperability protocols for augmentation, yet even the biggest companies have only a partial data view and subset of UX talent. The closest we have is the web, which remains a battlefield between "old" and "new" media, e.g. DRM is a higher priority than augmentation.
- justinjlynn 8y agoIt's not just that -- systems like the one Engelbart presented really benefited from all users essentially sharing the same memory space; everyone was on the same computer at the same time. As it appeared to the machine, there was essentially one user and that user was a gestalt of all the people using the system at the time. Now we have a web of different machines, which don't trust each other (because we don't trust each other); we haven't progressed in much the same way because we have much different constraints. In a sense, if Engelbart's system was a completely shared space in which everyone lived and was trusted, then of course our systems are inelegant by comparison. We're driving around in assault vehicles interacting with each other at a distance through signs, signals and the occasional open window. But then again, we're not solving the same problem Engelbart was solving. Can we emulate that experience? Of course we can, but we're going to have to change how it operates quite significantly, in order to have it fit with our differing, more complex, social requirements.
- justinjlynn 8y ago
- rini17 8y agoI can't help but point finger toward academia - CS is concerned with intersection of technology and math and the result is "applied" to users. Augmentation of human intellect just won't fit into this paradigm.
- j2kun 8y ago? "Human Computer Interaction" is a subfield of academic CS.
- rini17 8y ago"Human Computer Interaction" != "Augmentation of Human Intellect"
- j2kun 8y agoYour comment says that nothing in academic CS would allow for such a study. Clearly HCI does. It has not yet achieved Engelbart's vision, and it might not be trying to anyway, but it's clearly a framework that cares about how humans can and should use machines, not simply math.
- rini17 8y agoNo, the comments don't say that. What I'm trying to say is: HCI has not yet _recognized_ Engelbart's vision.
- chvid 8y agoI agree that modern products are far away from the original vision of collaborative hypermedia. But it is important to remember that these are research prototypes and not popular commercial products; in that way they lack the finish and the real-life validation a commercially succesful product has. Why has collaborative authoring not been taken further? As far as I can tell it is not for the lack of trying. Maybe the vision of two people working simultaneously on the same document is wrong? In the way that is not actually what people do; rather if you do something together the natural process is splitting it up and delegating.
- ThJ 8y agoI'm on a team of 4 people working on a giant accounting spreadsheet simultaneously. It wouldn't be possible without collaborative editing. Previously, the same team has worked on white papers simultaneously. In theory, we could've done that by merging documents near the end, but we were adding, dropping and moving sections while writing everything, so the end result wouldn't have been the same. There are other areas where I sorely miss collaborative editing. I want every piece of application software to support it. I hate transferring files. I love sharing live documents. My problem is that few people outside of this team I'm talking about seem to understand how powerful collaborative real-time editing can be. People of all ages are still emailing me Word documents like it's 1997. My head is in the future, the world is living in the past. Same goes for smartphone usage, really. Try sending calendar invites to someone who's barely aware of the calendar on his phone because he only uses it for Instagram and calling his mates. Technologies to augment the human intellect are all around us, but most of us are really bad at using them.
- chvid 8y agoJust to clarify; I am not saying that there isn't a use case. I am just questioning whether it is the general case that products should designed around and maybe that is the reason why we don't see more of it. If you have 4 people writing a book together would you really sit there in realtime with 4 cursors and typing away on the same document? Or would you structure, delegate and spread things out across time and space (doing most of the work) and then later edit and merge it together.
- JoeSmithson 8y agoIs there a way to get all of Brett Victor's blog posts? One's like this don't seem to be linked from his main page (unless I'm missing something obvious)
- madprops 8y agoThere's something very organic about the system in his demo that feels almost surreal
- jstewartmobile 8y agoComing down from the mountain with the tablets to find a brand new golden calf is not a new thing. And Engelbart, as good as he was, was still no Moses. It's like, even if we had an actual implementation of his vision, what would we do with it? Cure cancer? Or, would a bunch of corporate d-bags use it to sell more opioids to people who don't need them? I'd put my money on the latter.
- whywhywhywhy 8y agoNot everything has to have an impact as grand as cure cancer to make peoples day to day lives better.
- jstewartmobile 8y agoThat is not the point. Augmenting human intelligence, while leaving the hearts as they are, is a loss, not a gain.
- pdfernhout 8y ago@jstewartmobile wrote: "Augmenting human intelligence, while leaving the hearts as they are, is a loss, not a gain." That is a brilliant insight that more intelligence may be a bad thing if your heart is in the wrong place. Sorry to see your comment being downmodded and greyed out. At the risk of the same happening to me, here is support for your point on "heart". Albert Einstein said in the 1940s: "The release of atom power has changed everything except our way of thinking... the solution to this problem lies in the heart of mankind. If only I had known, I should have become a watchmaker." More by Einstein: http://www.sacred-texts.com/aor/einstein/einsci.htm http://www.sacred-texts.com/aor/einstein/einsci.htm "But mere thinking cannot give us a sense of the ultimate and fundamental ends. To make clear these fundamental ends and valuations, and to set them fast in the emotional life of the individual, seems to me precisely the most important function which religion has to perform in the social life of man. And if one asks whence derives the authority of such fundamental ends, since they cannot be stated and justified merely by reason, one can only answer: they exist in a healthy society as powerful traditions, which act upon the conduct and aspirations and judgments of the individuals; they are there, that is, as something living, without its being necessary to find justification for their existence. They come into being not through demonstration but through revelation, through the medium of powerful personalities. One must not attempt to justify them, but rather to sense their nature simply and clearly." And Lewis Mumford said in the 1930s: "As a civilization, we have not yet entered the neotechnic phase: we are still living between two worlds, one dead, the other powerless to be born, in a cultural pseudomorph.... Paleotechnic purposes with neotechnic means, that is the most obvious characteristic of the present order." (Technics and Civilization pp. 265-267) Thus my own sig standing on the shoulders of giants: "The biggest challenge of the 21st century is the irony of technologies of abundance in the hands of those still thinking in terms of scarcity." I participated in Doug Engelbart's Unfinished Revolution II Colloquium run by Stanford. I brought up some similar ideas there as well. Like in this email thread I started: "[unrev-II] Is 'bootstrapping' part of the problem?" http://www.dougengelbart.org/colloquium/forum/discussion/2168.html http://www.dougengelbart.org/colloquium/forum/discussion/216... "This is one reason why I think just stating the Bootstrap's Institute's (or the colloquium's) goal of "bootstrapping" human or organizational ability as a goal is not adequate. It has to be a question of bootstrapping towards what end? There has to be an accompanying statement of human value." I've continued to develop that theme elsewhere, like: "Recognizing irony is key to transcending militarism (2010)" http://www.pdfernhout.net/recognizing-irony-is-a-key-to-transcending-militarism.html http://www.pdfernhout.net/recognizing-irony-is-a-key-to-tran... "The big problem is that all these new war machines and the surrounding infrastructure are created with the tools of abundance. The irony is that these tools of abundance are being wielded by people still obsessed with fighting over scarcity. So, the scarcity-based political mindset driving the military uses the technologies of abundance to create artificial scarcity. That is a tremendously deep irony that remains so far unappreciated by the mainstream." The dangers of increasing intellect unmatched by increasing heart was also a underlying theme in my book-length essay "Post-Scarcity Princeton, or, Reading between the lines of PAW for prospective Princeton students, or, the Health Risks of Heart Disease (2008)" http://www.pdfernhout.net/reading-between-the-lines.html http://www.pdfernhout.net/reading-between-the-lines.html A lengthy extract from there: """ Let's flip back to the beginning of PAW and try again to find a more challenging article that explains PU mythology. Perhaps the president's letter on page 2, "A Library for Scientists" will do. PU President Shirley Tilghman describes a new library that will replace several "isolated" departmental science libraries with one "scientific" library. According to her letter, the new library "will symbolize the increasingly interdisciplinary nature of the work in these fields on our campus". The question is, where do you even begin to tell a university president so obviously proud of her new library that making science and engineering studies even more isolated from the humanities is the opposite of what Princeton University needs to do to survive as an ethically viable institution? And that splitting ethics from innovation was at the root cause of a lot of evil in the world in the past? There is a lot of talk of facilitating "interdisciplinary" work in her letter, but if you read between the lines, you'll see that the implication is it will be between different branches of science and engineering, not say, between biologists and sociologists, or mechanical engineers and historians. In case Professor Tilghman has not noticed, there is a picture on page 21 of that same issue of PAW of a shark about to eat a Princetonian floating in DeNunzio Pool [...] Maybe she had better look into that? It can't be good PR under any circumstances, can it? I had not known PU's scientists had got that far in their shark breeding experiments as they are sometimes hard to keep in captivity (real scientists, not sharks. OK, that's just a joke, both are hard to keep in captivity. :-) [...] Still, are those PU scientists and engineers doing a good thing? Wouldn't it make it harder to recruit prospective talent for the PU swim team? Or are the sharks in DeNunzio part of some new training regime? Unless that is supposed to be a visiting Yalie about to get eaten? That seems a little harsh, even by intercollegiate competitive standards. :-( Still, maybe rather that "make the world a better place through advances in scientific understanding", perhaps when you make an anti-social shark "smarter" (with or without the laser beam :-), what do you have except a bigger problem? :-( For example from a review of "Deep Blue Sea": "So, in an effort to save their funding, they want to take one really good go at making this...serum? I don't remember, brain activating protein...stuff. So, they conduct their test on the shark. And it WORKS! Yay! Congratulations all around! These guys f--ing rule! And it's all parties and cupcakes until someone's arm gets eaten." Also [from another review]: "Some scientists are out in the middle of the ocean, trying to reproduce proteins in shark's brains. These proteins are the cure for Alzheimer's, and one character even gives a half-assed speech about how she's driven by memories of her father's mental illness. Well, to harvest more protein, that scientist makes the shark's brains four times bigger than normal and now the shark's are super-smart and eat all the scientists. Hooray." I'm sorry to say that the internet consensus on PU's smarter sharks is that they are not a good idea. :-( Or maybe "Deep Blue Sea" was just a poorly made horror film. :-) """ To be clear, I feel Doug's heart was in the right place -- even if he maybe took that for granted in others.
- javajosh 8y agoThere is always this tension between idealism and realism within engineering. Victor descries the ignorance we show the idealism of Engelbart, and Englebart, in turn, expressed "sadness" at how little progress we've made. And yet, consider someone else Victor considers a hero, Seymour Papert, inventor of the Logo programming language. When we learned it on the Apple IIe, it was without connectivity to any other device, and usually with just the manual to guide us. Collaboration was happening, but on a much longer time-scale. It wasn't milliseconds, but rather months and years. It wasn't mediated by network packets, but by shrink-wrapped software boxes and expansion cards purchased at big-box retailers. A remarkable amount of progress happened on that slow, physical time-scale, but much of it was incompatible with shorter time-scales and global messaging. For example, Windows, having grown up in the slow time-scale, was hit hard by the fast time-scale, it's immune system non-existent. It's too easy to wave away the problems we really experienced (and experience) with malware. Englebart made simplifying assumptions that people wanted to collaborate, and were not malicious and did not want to harm each other. But these assumptions are all false, and a large, possibly majority proportion of modern engineering effort directly and indirectly addresses these unfortunate realities.
- ThomPete 8y agoVery well said. Also just think about the open source community and how much of that is built collaboratively. Not by sharing a screen but by sharing a repository and developing ways to work on the same project. The intent of Engelbart I still have been fully realized just in different ways.
- icc97 8y agoThis is a pretty fascinating set of videos from the 1995 Vannevar Bush Syposium [0]. Vannevar Bush's atlantic article [1] was one of the main inspirations of Engelbart. It has Douglas Engelbart talking about 'The Strategic Pursuit of Collective IQ' and collective IQ seems like a good description for what Bret Victor was trying to talk about as one of Engelbart's goals. However it also has presentations from Tim Berners-Lee and Alan Kay amongst others. It's at a cross over between the world that Engelbart and Kay imagined and what the internet and the web became as we know it now. [0]: http://www.dougengelbart.org/events/vannevar-bush-symposium.html http://www.dougengelbart.org/events/vannevar-bush-symposium.... [1]: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1945/07/as-we-may-think/303881/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1945/07/as-we-m...
- kencausey 8y agoTangentially related: Squeak has long included a remote collaboration tool called Nebraska (http://wiki.squeak.org/squeak/1356 http://wiki.squeak.org/squeak/1356) that, if I recall correctly, supported multiple mouse cursors (referred to as 'hands' in Morphic). This of course may be due the original development of Squeak as a direct descendant of Smalltalk-80 (via Apple) by Alan Kay and Dan Ingalls among others who were I'm sure more than familiar with the work of Doug Englelbart.
- jamesgeck0 8y ago> Our hypertext is not the same as Engelbart's hypertext, because it does not serve the same purpose. Tim Banners-Lee is pretty upfront Engelbart's hypertext was a direct inspiration [1]: > I didn't invent the hypertext link either. The idea of jumping from one document to another had been thought about lots of people ... > Doug Engelbart in the 1960's made a great system just like WWW except that it just ran on one [big] computer, as the internet hadn't been invented yet. Lots of hypertext systems had been made which just worked on one computer, and didn't link all the way across the world. > I just had to take the hypertext idea and connect it to the TCP and DNS ideas and -- ta-da! -- the World Wide Web. 1. https://www.w3.org/People/Berners-Lee/Kids.html https://www.w3.org/People/Berners-Lee/Kids.html