7 ms·
Based on the inverse correlation between star size and frequency, this doesn't surprise me at all. It seems like there is an obvious further inference to make
by perl4ever 8y ago
Based on the inverse correlation between star size and frequency, this doesn't surprise me at all.
It seems like there is an obvious further inference to make - people have debated whether life originated on earth or not. Given that the vast majority of planets do not have a star, and given that we know there are chemotrophs even on Earth that prove it is possible to live without a sun, it seems overwhelmingly likely that life came from one of these rogue planets that was large enough to retain enough heat underground for the evolution of life over the first few billion years of the universe. That would also neatly explain why evidence of life appeared so soon after the Earth became solid.
- havemylife 8y agoI'm not discounting the possibility of life on Earth originating from somewhere other than Earth. However, why would the early conditions of Earth not be sufficient for life to begin over say any other object in space with the base elements for life? How life began is obviously still an unanswered question, but if the conditions for self replicating molecules were sufficient early on for Earth, I'm not sure why billions of years would be needed for life to form versus several hundred million years.
- toong 8y agoEarth needed ~ 2 billion years for life to start. Frequent solar winds - especially in the first few billion turbulent years of the universe - basically sterilize planets and the whole 2-billion-year counter gets reset to 0. Planets that exist without a solar system, but do retain sufficient heat, might have been out of solar winds harm ?
- Peaker 8y agoLife on Earth started within a few hundred million years, not 2 billion years.
- havemylife 8y agoI'm by no means well informed on these topics, but I'm unsure where you're getting your 2 billion year estimate. Furthermore I thought that Earths magnetic field shielded from solar radiation, and additionally that there's a significant amount of radiation in space anyways. Further questioning I have though is, does solar radiation penetrate through ocean water? What radiation is between solar systems or what rogue planets would likely encounter, and how that effects single cell life, amino acids, organic compounds, and any other building blocks to life?
- gambiting 8y ago>>Further questioning I have though is, does solar radiation penetrate through ocean water? Barely. 10km of water will shield you from almost any amount of radiation, and we know of life forms which live at those depths, so they could have developed even when Earth was completely bathed in radiation.
- arethuza 8y agoLife appears to have started on Earth remarkably soon after the creation of the planet and the subsequent formation of oceans - ~130 million years by some estimates: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis#Earliest_biological_evidence_for_life https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abiogenesis#Earliest_biologica...
- hyperpallium 8y agoIf you're a fan of Moore's Law and the Singularity, you'll love the reasoning of backtrapolating the exponentially increasing complexity of life over time... to get 0 well before the formation of the earth https://www.technologyreview.com/s/513781/moores-law-and-the-origin-of-life/ https://www.technologyreview.com/s/513781/moores-law-and-the...
- DoctorOetker 8y agoyou mean well before the big bang: e^(a*t) = 0 for t=-infinity
- hyperpallium 8y agowell yes; technically they use one base-pair as the origin of life (which is probably still a little too small). From looking at the graph, and the 300 milion year doubling, they seem to put life complexity at about 256 base-pairs at the origin of the earth. There should be a link to the actual paper in the article.
- whatshisface 8y agoThat goes below a discontinuity, 256 base pairs is well below the smallest organism ever observed. A single gene is on average around 10^4 bases, and the simplest organisms have around 10^3 necessary genes. Life below 10^3 base pairs may not evolve at the same speed. It's certainly not safe to talk about it in terms of base pairs, in that era there might not have even been any.
- hyperpallium 8y ago> smallest organism ever observed ...today. Life was simpler back in the day. For example, RNA world. This more primitive life might not survive more sophisticated life. (thougn it's also possible it's still around, but we haven't noticed it; or haven't recognized it as life). IDK if small enough, but viruses are simpler. If it can reproduce - e.g. a short strand of DNA or RNA or even something simpler - it could form the beginnings of "life" as a precursor, even though it wouldn't meet our current definitions of "alive". There's theories of fatty spheres being the first "cells" (really, "kinda sorta cells").
- quietbritishjim 8y ago> life appeared so soon after the Earth became solid It took hundreds of millions of years, possibly up to a billion years, for basic life to form on Earth. I would say that is not "soon"; it's a really long time. The obvious response to that is, yes it seems like a long time, but it's not much on geological time scales. But it feels to me that there's an implicit circular argument here: the whole reason that geological time is measured in terms of such huge spans is because it took life such a vast amount of time to get to the point where humans exist to discuss it (understandably).
- neuronic 8y agoBut that's mostly because humans aren't an achievement of "life". We were never a development goal of "life" nor does the universe care very much about us - even if we built megastructures directly harnessing the energy of black holes and stars. If current knowledge is remotely correct, heat death will happen, no matter how immortal Homo deus will become. The quarks are against us. And if complex systems theory teaches us anything then it would be preposterous to assume any ultimate superiority in understanding the universe on our part. Who knows who wrote crazy alien versions of Hacker News posts 2 billion years ago in one of the other couple of thousands of galaxies seen in Hubble Deep Field alone...
- quietbritishjim 8y agoHumans are really just an example, I regret mentioning it. All significant developments in life (e.g. multi-cellular lifeforms, post-Cumbrian explosian animals) took hundreds of millions to billions of years.
- kamaal 8y agoIn fact given the fact evolution is a process without a goal. Intelligence could be even more rare among multicellular lifeforms.
- Brockenstein 8y ago
- rpedela 8y agoI generally don't like the assumption that life had to come from space because we don't know how life is created and it appeared so soon in the history of Earth. That is certainly a possibility, but it also possible that creating life from chemistry is easy. Just because we haven't figured it out yet doesn't mean it is hard. Obviously figuring out how it works is hard, but the mysterious mechanism may be simple.
- tiemand 8y agoOne problem I have with pan-spermia is: Why is there only one tree of life? Not several independent trees. If life evolved in one of the exo-planets, is not possible that several independent forms of life evolved in several planets and some ended up on Earth.
- sandworm101 8y agoOne tree (us) either appeared first and dominated resources, or we wiped our the other trees. Evolutionary forces work at levels above species. Two trees can compete with each other. If this happened it did so at the microbe level. Physical evidence would be extraordinarily difficult. If we did find evidence of another tree it would be so 'alien' to our tree that might mistakenly call it extraterrestrial.
- ASalazarMX 8y agoAnd since panspermia is necessarily done with microbes, they would get outnumbered and munched by our microbes if they arrived after our tree dominated our planet. Unless other planets happened to give birth to hardier, more virulent microbes, then welcome Andromeda Strain.
- stephengillie 8y agoThe individual nucleobases (cytosine [C], guanine [G], adenine [A] or thymine [T]) are made from the 4 most common elements, and appear to be modestly simple molecules. Is it so unbelievable that they naturally occur like methane or sodium glass?