4 ms·
That's not how disbelieving works. People disbelieve facts that would cost them to believe. If I believe in climate change, I have to make expensive life chang
by BurningFrog 8y ago
That's not how disbelieving works.
People disbelieve facts that would cost them to believe. If I believe in climate change, I have to make expensive life changes (sell the SUV, buy a Tesla, etc). Therefore I will not believe in it.
This belief is 100% honest, BTW. This is key to understand!
For diamonds, the incentives are reversed. If I believe that artificial diamonds are as good as the natural kind, I can get a wedding ring much cheaper. So I will probably believe that!
If I have already bought natural diamonds, I might believe something else. But it doesn't matter much, since I'm not buying more diamonds.
- goodpass 8y agoErm, I think it’s more like “I have a certain worldview that is only consistent if climate change isn’t real” or “this belief is part of my identity, which means the idea that it could be wrong is threatening to my identity”.
- BurningFrog 8y agoYeah, those are also important. This is a big topic :)
- ballenf 8y agoOr, believing in X empowers the opposition and weakens the party who cares about the people I care about.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> If I believe in climate change, I have to make expensive life changes (sell the SUV, buy a Tesla, etc). In part this is true, but none of those are necessary, but what is neceaary for most deniers if they flip is “abandon my political tribe, whose leaders have defined the belief in climate change as outside the bounds of the tribe.” That's really very nearly the only factor that matters.
- lopmotr 8y agoThe tribalism goes both ways. Sadly, it's hard to be a pragmatic optimist and say "Yea it's probably going to change but there's also nothing we can do about it without killing millions of people through economic destruction and we'll likely adapt anyway (humans can adapt their civilizations in the time scales of climate change - see the rapid growth of Chinese cities), so let's not worry too much." Then everyone sees you as their political enemy.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Sadly, it's hard to be a pragmatic optimist and say "Yea it's probably going to change but there's also nothing we can do about it without killing millions of people through economic destruction and we'll likely adapt anyway (humans can adapt their civilizations in the time scales of climate change - see the rapid growth of Chinese cities), so let's not worry too much." That's not really pragmatic optimism, it's intense pessimism about human capability to adapt society deliberately in the face of a changing knowledge of economic payoff matrices without mass destruction mixed with bizarre faith that human society will adapt to changing payoff matrices without mass dedtruction. There's no difference in the behavior that supports than denialism, the only real difference is that denialism is, for all its lack of grounding in reality, at least more self-consistent.
- lopmotr 8y agoBut in real life, do you actually expect we will stop climate change before it causes any serious harm? When do you think we'll start doing that? We've done almost nothing so far but what we have done is incrementally developed technology to allow humans to comfortably survive severe weather like storms, floods, and droughts. So I say pragmatic because it's a continuation of what we already do, and optimistic because I believe it will be successful at saving us. I've yet to see a highly likely climate change prediction that couldn't be defended against with engineering on a scale smaller than what we've already achieved.
- pbecotte 8y ago
- ThomPete 8y agoMost people believe in climate change also the so called sceptics as the climate is mostly changing. The disagreement mostly is about how severe its going to be and how much human affect it.
- briandear 8y agoBut see, any debate at all is blasphemy. The inability to accept skepticism is anti-science. There was a worldwide scientific consensus that Eugenics was a good thing in the early 1900s. But somehow the overwhelming “evidence” of its “benefits” suddenly fell out of favor. People that are hysterical about climate change are, incidentally in favor of the government curtailing freedom and controlling the means of production. To me, climate change is an acceptable trade off to avoid living under Bolshevism. When scientific “truth” becomes a political rationale for totalitarianism, then there’s a problem.
- irrational 8y ago>If I believe in climate change, I have to make expensive life changes (sell the SUV, buy a Tesla, etc). I think "have to" is a bit strong. I absolutely believe in climate change. But I have no intention of selling (or stop driving) my 2004 Chevrolet Suburban.
- jacobush 8y agoWedding rings are supposed to be expensive, that’s the point. It’s basic signalling. You know this, deep down. Of course there are exceptions, but those are often about explicitly signalling some other virtue. Like hipness.