9 ms·
1958 Imperial: What It's Like to Drive an Auto-Pilot Car
- neves 8y agoWhen you read this kind of text from old magazines is that you see that humanity is really getting better: "What it does. This is not easy to explain to women and the mechanically innocent. Not that the gadget is particularly complex;"
- userbinator 8y agoYou can definitely date a nontrivial piece of writing, at least approximately, by the language it employs. I'd say humanity has gotten better in some ways, but also worse in others.
- aerovistae 8y agoCan you give an example of a way in which we’ve gotten worse?
- maratd 8y agoPeretend I said something politically incorrect and insert your outrage below this comment. Be sure to use some derogatory adjectives, unrelated to anything previously said, to describe me.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- aerovistae 8y agoI'm not convinced that's a new phenomenon. Certainly I've seen no evidence that it is and a great deal that it isn't.
- MBCook 8y agoThat may simply be an artifact of most writing we have from older periods was professional, like magazine articles. Not personal/casual, like Reddit/HN.
- aerovistae 8y agoYou don't even really need examples of casual writing to discern that this attitude is nothing new. I mean, look at stories from throughout history, from the debates of Roman senators to Salem Witch Trials and back to Chinese oracle bones-- since when have people ever avoided ad hominem attacks, fallacious logic, and overwrought outrage on topics they barely understand?
- pvillano 8y agoPeople used to have duels over arguments.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- randyrand 8y agoKeep in mind that the definition of better has not stayed the same over time.
- PhasmaFelis 8y agoWhich is part of what "getting better" means.
- foota 8y agoI think parent's point is that if we look forward 50 years even the most progressive of us might not agree that progress has been made (or think that we've regressed in some way), whereas new people will see vast progress.
- taneq 8y agoEven reading something from the 70s, it's jarring how much the language and what's considered acceptable has changed.
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoI do like the description of "mechanically innocent" though.
- jacobush 8y agoYes, but except for that the text struck me as very modern. I would not have batted an eyelid if it was written today.
- csours 8y agoMy grandmother was born in the 1920s. There was a self-enforced 'femininity' back then, wherein women told themselves that they couldn't, shouldn't, or didn't need to understand things, and that their husbands or fathers would take care of things. I'm personally very grateful we have moved past this. My grandmother would break down at the slightest hint of technical discussion. She never understood computers as anything more than a fancy typewriter.
- pentagonpapers 8y agoTrying to enforce this with my younger sibling. Computers are cool, chess is cool, working on cars is cool. Turns out little siblings tend to like what their older siblings do (great for me, I have something I can teach!)
- JasonFruit 8y agoDo you believe people in the 1840s were better than people in the 1770s? Or people in the 1950s better than the 1920s? I'm not convinced there is any consistent progress, as opposed to a simple preference for the times in which we live.
- niftich 8y agoA fascinating account of a feature we'd now recognize as 'cruise control'. Despite the technical details being different than modern systems, many of its behaviors are familiar -- like the surreal rollercoaster-tow hillclimbing -- while some have been rectified in more modern systems, like better engine braking to regain the target speed. I believe the UX of vanilla cruise control is a good fit for what it does: it's a fire-and-forget, opt-in mode that's disengaged with a tap of the brake or its own button. It's simple to reason about: do I want the car to gun it at a constant 70 mph, or no? You can run a quick mental judgement call and decide whether to engage it or leave it off. This is completely unlike any other 'assist' feature that came later: ABS, automatic emergency braking, and especially adaptive cruise control. And, in my opinion [1] this vast difference between adaptive and classic cruise control is a safety risk -- features that override driver behavior in case of a condition the car identifies need to have no false negatives, need to be on by default and opt-out instead of opt-in, and need to not be disengaged by trivial inputs like lightly tapping the brakes. In Tesla's particular case, the opt-in UX was even worse, because its automatic emergency braking wouldn't engage if autopilot was off [3] -- a decision contrary to sane user expectation, and completely unlike cars of other premium automakers. And the fact that their emergency braking still can't detect all stationary hazards in a travel lane is tragic. I'm not convinced that classic cruise control is a good case study (or anecdote) to compare emerging driver assist, autodriving, and safety features with. It simply has the exact opposite semantics than every other feature that we have since put in our cars. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16772748#16774258 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16772748#16774258 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12097671#12097911 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12097671#12097911 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12011584 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12011584
- jgibson 8y agoHave you got a specific case for [3]? I couldn't find anything in the original "A Tragic Loss" post that would indicaate that AEB gets disabled when autopilot is off. This is the first I've heard of this behaviour and I'd like to find out more. I was thinking about getting a Model 3...
- 8y ago
- foobar1962 8y agoMike Hawthorn famously (or infamously) died in a Jaguar with a hand throttle, which could be considered a simple form of "cruise control". It's the feedback systems that make cruise control safe: controlling the car's speed and not the simpler task of controlling the throttle position.
- hartator 8y agoWhat feedback systems? The system described doesn’t seem that different of a regilar cruise control.
- twtw 8y agoRegular cruise control is a feedback system, comparing the current speed to the desired speed constantly and adjusting the throttle to make the two match. A fixed throttle would result in wildly varying speed based on road grade and other factors.
- jaggederest 8y agoI drive most of my miles these days with ACC and lane keeping on, and I find that the article is generally still correct when relating to a newly automated function of driving. I watch more for peripheral threats and have to pay attention to the throttle only when I feel unexpected acceleration or braking, or if there's a tricky condition that ACC might not handle correctly. I hope, as time goes on, those moments decrease in number and danger.
- Roritharr 8y agoSame here, Fan of ACC & lane keeping. The one thing that bugs me about my car (2018 VW Tiguan Allspace) is that it'll never get "better" at ACC & lane keeping. The factory defaults are what it's going to be, compared to how some tesla owners describe their cars to handle more situations better over time.
- tolien 8y agoInflating by CPI, the option cost $805 at today’s prices [1]. For comparison, the brochure for a model year 2016 Audi A3 reckons cruise control was a £225 and ACC a £575 option i.e. $300 and $763 at current exchange rates. 1: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%2486%201954%20US%20Dollars http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%2486%201954%20US%20Dol...
- OliverJones 8y agoWhy the higher cost back then? "A reversible electric motor, a flyball governor, and associated electrical gadgetry." Making that kind of precision mechanical stuff isn't cheap. Making the "gadgetry" from discrete components isn't cheap. Making it in low volume isn't cheap. Making it keep working when splashed with wet road salt and then frozen isn't cheap. Plus, it was a premium feature and probably was priced accordingly. Electronic stuff is cheaper and works better. Even though a flyball governor is a cool mechanism.
- tolien 8y agoIt wasn't my intention to imply that it was expensive - within an order of magnitude of current prices shows how relatively cheap it was, given that electronics and sheer scale will have driven down the cost of parts (if not necessarily the end user cost). I expect the difference is in the vendors' margins (i.e. nowadays the option price is almost pure profit/salesperson's commission).
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jakecopp 8y ago> It does not invite highway hypnosis. The explanation for this lies in your past driving experience. You lend the Auto-Pilot a duty you have been trained to perform yourself, and this somehow makes you just a little uneasy. It is not an entirely relaxing thing to sit back at 70 m.p.h. and feel the engine get gas from some other agency than yourself; your alertness is more likely to be heightened than lulled. This slight wariness stays with you as long as the device is working, even after thousands of miles have been logged. This exact same sentence sounds like it could be applied to Tesla's Autopilot (correctly or not I don't know!)
- Piskvorrr 8y agoCould be, but isn't. Even with modern cruise control, you're just freed from the accelerator; there's still plenty of driving tasks to keep you alert ("what is that opposite vehicle's intent? Is there something in that shadow, threatening to enter my path? Which of the three closely consecutive exits do I take?"). With the promise of "it drives itself", you're prone to leaving the driver's seat, figuratively speaking (although there are people that have done literally that).
- walrus01 8y agowow, 1950s thinking indeed: "this is not easy to explain to women".
- m_st 8y ago> This is not easy to explain to women and the mechanically innocent. How insulting! As a father of two girls (and a boy) I'm glad such statements aren't common anymore.
- qrbLPHiKpiux 8y agoThey are! We just keep them to ourselves! (Father of two girls and married)
- qrbLPHiKpiux 8y ago> This is not easy to explain to women and the mechanically innocent. 1950’s such an alive time!
- Tepix 8y agoHas cruise control been improved so that it takes into accounts reduced visibility when going over hills?
- gambiting 8y agoNo - and why would it? Its only job is to keep the speed of your vehicle constant, if the visibility is too low to travel safely at the chosen speed, you should disengage the system.
- gwbas1c 8y agoThis is a good example of someone who can't explain a simple concept. The author uses pages and pages when a very simple explanation would make a lot more sense. I think a lot of new technology is explained this way, and that's why some people think certain new technologies have magical properties. Referring to cruise control as a "robot" is, in hindsight, idiotic.
- analog31 8y agoIn the author's defense, virtually nobody understood feedback control systems in 1958. Most people still don't, but describing it as a computer may make it easier to understand today. Also, it looks like Popular Science hasn't changed.
- hartator 8y agoActually thought it was well written, except the women comment, and it was doing a good job of explaining how the technology worked. Pointing to the same limitations cruise controlle is facing today, hills feeling uneasy, too fast, or too slow as there is no context, etc.
- csours 8y ago> Referring to cruise control as a "robot" is, in hindsight, idiotic. Much like 'AI' the definition of 'robot' shrinks to the pool of things which technology has not conquered. That is to say - Speech Recognition is not AI, Image Recognition is not AI, etc etc. As soon as it has its own name, we no longer call it AI or robotics.
- engi_nerd 8y agoThe concept is simple to you because cruise control is such a common feature in cars that you only notice its absence. You understand exactly what a cruise control does and how to control one. Now consider being in the 1950s -- probably you had never even imagined the concept of a device that automatically regulated the throttle position of your car. And also imagine that your overall knowledge base was much less -- the average person of 1950s western civilization was exposed to much less information on a daily basis than the average person of 2018. One of the base definitions of the term "robot" is "a machine capable of carrying out a complex sequence of actions automatically". Given that definition, I hardly think that calling a cruise control a "robot" idiotic. But what we call robots are far more complex and integrate narrow AI, so our threshold for calling something a "robot" is much higher than what would have passed for a robot in the 1950s.
- hackpert 8y agoOther than the obvious and horrifying casual sexism that others have highlighted, the most interesting part to me is the diagram at the bottom. The system was mechanically simple enough to be largely explained in one small diagram that a near-layperson (and clearly not women!) could largely understand. Such things are amiss from popular media today because our systems are so (often perhaps unnecessarily) complex.
- gist 8y ago> horrifying casual sexism that others have highlighted Horryfying? You think that this is 'horryfying': "This is not easy to explain to women and the mechanically innocent." It's 1958. And yes most women (and especially at that time) tended to be less interested in mechanics. Not to say that there weren't women who were but nothing wrong in stating a point like that. Nobody cared back then either. And it wasn't horrifying that is a big exaggeration. I watch a TV Show on Jet Airplanes. My wife has zero interest in watching that show or anything related. Ditto for my daughters and for that matter any past girlfriend. Of course there are women who watch and enjoy the same show. But I would love to bet anyone that the number of men far outweighs female interest. Separately women make jokes about men and sports. That isn't to say that all women don't like sports or all men do. It's just a generalization that is rooted in truth and there is nothing derogatory about saying that either.
- actuallyalys 8y agoThis is disingenuous. "This is not easy to explain to women..." is saying that women categorically would struggle to understand it, to the extent that they need to be mentioned as a separate category in addition to the "mechanically innocent." It's not simply observing that fewer women would be interested. The other flaw in your argument is that casual sexism like this is why women are less interested in mechanics (or at least appear that way). If I lived in the 50s, why would I want to read a publication that casually implies I'm not smart enough to understand it? Candidly, the number of commenters willing to defend casual sexism is a big reason why I've lost interest in Hacker News.
- hackpert 8y ago