5 ms·
Reading in this article about Kepler, it seems like the spirit of his discovery was more in the vein of numerology than science in the way we idealize it - he a
by perl4ever 8y ago
Reading in this article about Kepler, it seems like the spirit of his discovery was more in the vein of numerology than science in the way we idealize it - he appears to have been looking for pleasing relationships like Bode's law and just happened upon something better by accident.
- jessaustin 8y agoThis seems a bit harsh. He made a general statement that would be falsifiable by any series of careful astronomical observations. Rather than being falsified, his statement has been verified by subsequent observations. Perhaps you meant to make a sort of "right-place-right-time" argument, but that hardly would be "numerology".
- marcosdumay 8y agoWell, he got a bunch of numbers, looked at them until he saw some meaningless pattern, and told the pattern to everybody. It's the same kind of thing numerologists say they do. He certainly kept a very open mind, he wouldn't get the correct result otherwise, but as far as appearances go, he looked exactly like a numerologist. (And from the mixing that astrology, numerology, and astronomy had at the time, he probably sounded like a numerologist too. Maybe even identified himself as one.)