6 ms·
A computer virus with an entirely new purpose
- dmlorenzetti 16y agoCyber security experts say they have identified the world's first known cyber super weapon designed specifically to destroy a real-world target... Allegedly an explosion of a Soviet gas pipeline was caused by a bug intentionally inserted into control software stolen from the United States. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siberian_pipeline_sabotage http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siberian_pipeline_sabotage Not a cyber weapon, but close enough in spirit, I think.
- tptacek 16y agoI'm not an expert on Stuxnet (or really malware at all) but this whole thing seems extremely overblown. Is it interesting that there's a piece of malware out there that targets industrial controllers? Absolutely it is. It's probably not just some bored college kid. Is it a "cyber missile" aimed at the heart of Iran's nuclear weapons program? Probably not. Among other things, the IP ranges it's "targeting" aren't specific to Iran. Also, there's no evidence connecting it to Iran. Whenever you see a better-than-average piece of offensive computing technology, your first thought should be "extortion", and your second (distant second) thought should be "competitive subterfuge". Extortion happens all the time, and you rarely read about it, because the targets don't want to talk about it. And, while there's never been a corroborated story about an actual cross-state offensive strike using IT technology, there have in fact been cases where industry leaders have whacked on each other using security flaws. The reporting on Stuxnet seems too captive to tidy and palatable narratives for me to take seriously. It doesn't help that these stories are sourced mostly to SCADA security experts. There are some great people working on SCADA problems, but that field takes everything annoying about computer security PR and amplifies it.
- forensic 16y agoIsrael has been pretty public about its desire to stop the Iranian nuclear program. This kind of plausibly deniable attack sounds just like what Israel has been wanting. And they have the talent to get the job done. So why not? A nation state sabotaging an enemy's nuclear weapons without it being traced back to them. That's a pretty nice thing to have. While what you're talking about is of course the most common scenario, it seems like a no-brainer to me that the NSA/DOD/IDF would spend money on preparing to make these kinds of attacks even if they rarely or never implement them. I don't see why the author's theory is implausible.
- tptacek 16y agoThere is no evidence to suggest that Israel has anything to do with this. None. But here we are, speculating on whether Israel is targeting Iran with "cyber attacks". This is my problem with any story that suggests any country is using security flaws as a weapon. As a professional matter, nothing in any of the reporting or analysis of Stuxnet suggests to me that this would have cost more than low-six figures to build cold (meaning, what it would cost to have a contractor familiar with malware and runtime security but not familiar with the particular software targeted here). It'd be significantly cheaper if you had devs with industrial controller backgrounds assisted by an exploit-dev contractor. So, yes, Israel could have been behind this attack. And the NSA could have been behind the Twitter XSS worm. It could be Putin ordering all those DDoS extortion attempts on gambling websites. But I doubt it; it's probably just someone's scheme to make money. Talk to banking security people sometime; crazy stuff is happening every day.
- forensic 16y agoWhat would Putin's motivation be to make DDoS extortion attempts? Means, motive, opportunity. Putin has no motive to extort pennies from gambling websites. He has better ways to make money. The NSA has no motive to make the Twitter worm. But Israel has a gigantic motive to make something that would sabotage a nuke plant in Iran. That's the difference. I agree that it's speculation - I just think it's plausible speculation.
- Qz 16y agoNo hard evidence (yet), but there is definitely circumstantial evidence.
- eli 16y agoWhat IP ranges? These computers aren't connected to the internet. The article speculates it was spread by a contractor's infected USB drive. (I agree that the hyperbole is a bit much, though)
- tptacek 16y agoI'm getting this detail secondhand and have probably mangled it. Please know: I am not a Stuxnet expert.
- zephyrfalcon 16y ago"These computers aren't connected to the internet." Right, the article seems to imply that a nuclear reactor's control system (or whatever it uses) runs Windows, and is connected to the internet. I really hope that that isn't true...
- sliverstorm 16y ago"Memory stick"? Is this a ram stick or a flash drive?
- aik 16y ago"Memory stick" is generally synonymous with "flash drive" or "usb stick" or "thumb drive"...
- sliverstorm 16y agoI know. I just hesitate because "memory" in my field almost always refers to RAM.
- astine 16y agoFlash drive. There's a number of flash drives that autoexecute when inserted into a computer. These are a known vector for software infections. As far as I know, ram doesn't generally hold memory after it's been powered down. Ram sticks don't make sense as a vector for a virus as far as I can tell.
- qq66 16y agoWhat if you were to create RAM sticks with a small amount of flash and a controller onboard, and then swap these with generic RAM sticks?
- blasdel 16y agoThat would require direct physical access, and if you had that there's a lot of much easier ways to root a box.
- bdonlan 16y agoYou could put data on there, sure, but typically the OS won't try to execute garbage data left over from a previous boot - it'll just get overwritten. I suppose you could have it swap out data after boot, but there are easier ways when you have physical access.
- bigmac 16y agoA bit more discussion at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1699405 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1699405
- docgnome 16y agoI'm confused. What is the method of delivery for this program? I sure hope no one is hooking up nuclear power plants to the tubes in such a way that it's even possible for the computers that control the reaction are able to make talkies to anything. That just sounds like a really bad idea. And the plot for a really bad Hollywood action flick.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- sunir 16y agoSneakernet. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sneakernet In this case through USB keys. Presumably people updating software on the machines or running diagnostics. Possibly USB dongles to unlock the machines.
- docgnome 16y agoRight, but I'm assuming that there are controls over nuclear control machines. That would seem to render this method of "attack" rather impractical unless you had an inside man. In which case it seems a rather round about method of sabotage vs just planting a bomb or yanking some wires or something.
- azernik 16y agoFrom the article, speculation is that the virus was embedded on the USB drive of a contractor who works on multiple setups, possibly without his or her knowledge; one of the virus's most interesting features is that it can then spread, without user intervention, as soon as the USB drive is plugged into a vulnerable machine, and from that machine can spread onto other USB drives plugged in later. It doesn't take an inside man - only an inside snippet of code, which you can foist on an unsuspecting worker or consultant. Also, the chain of transmission can be indirect, so that even if you can't get a physical item into the target, you can plant it somewhere else where it eventually spread to the target (only so many degrees of separation between any two power plants, it seems)
- aik 16y agoHow is it that the virus is like a "military-grade guided cyber missile" yet it is transferred by "memory stick"?
- aik 16y agoHere's a much-less-sensationalist description (from symantec.com): Stuxnet infects Windows systems in its search for industrial control systems, often generically (but incorrectly) known as SCADA systems. Industrial control systems consist of Programmable Logic Controllers (PLCs), which can be thought of as mini-computers that can be programmed from a Windows system. These PLCs contain special code that controls the automation of industrial processes—for instance, to control machinery in a plant or a factory. Programmers use software (e.g., on a Windows PC) to create code and then upload their code to the PLCs. Previously, we reported that Stuxnet can steal code and design projects and also hide itself using a classic Windows rootkit, but unfortunately it can also do much more. Stuxnet has the ability to take advantage of the programming software to also upload its own code to the PLC in an industrial control system that is typically monitored by SCADA systems. In addition, Stuxnet then hides these code blocks, so when a programmer using an infected machine tries to view all of the code blocks on a PLC, they will not see the code injected by Stuxnet. Thus, Stuxnet isn’t just a rootkit that hides itself on Windows, but is the first publicly known rootkit that is able to hide injected code located on a PLC. In particular, Stuxnet hooks the programming software, which means that when someone uses the software to view code blocks on the PLC, the injected blocks are nowhere to be found. This is done by hooking enumeration, read, and write functions so that you can’t accidentally overwrite the hidden blocks as well. ... Fascinating: http://www.symantec.com/connect/blogs/stuxnet-introduces-first-known-rootkit-scada-devices http://www.symantec.com/connect/blogs/stuxnet-introduces-fir...
- spyder 16y agoAre they really running very critical systems on Windows? Yes, the are :( : http://www.neowin.net/news/nuclear-reactor-isnt-using-a-licensed-copy-of-windows http://www.neowin.net/news/nuclear-reactor-isnt-using-a-lice... And another related story from 2003: http://www.securityfocus.com/news/6767 http://www.securityfocus.com/news/6767
- bockris 16y agoPre-cursor to IceBreakers in William Gibson's novel Neuromancer? Life imitates fiction.
- pyre 16y agoLife imitates fiction when fiction influences life, or when fiction just points out basic principles of life.
- extension 16y agoI have trouble believing that any moderately sane or respectable nation state would deploy this thing. It's roughly the equivalent of launching thousands of missiles at completely random targets around the world, but programming them to only go off if they land on the enemy, hopefully. It also opens a Pandora's box of mutations and clones. It's far too evil and stupid for any country below NK insanity levels.
- bkmartin 16y agoMy first guess was that it was the US. Yes, I'm a citizen of the US. I do believe my country would do this. If this isn't the US, and we aren't creating things like this, then I would be completely shocked. I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if it came out that we've been developing things like this for the last 5 to 10 years. Our government has historically never been behind when it comes to tech weapons innovations, at least not in the last 70 years.
- tptacek 16y agoYou got downvoted, but I think this is exactly right: very low chance of decisive success, maximal chance of embarrassing international incident. Not a good way to attack a rival regional power.
- nl 16y agoOk, I get your argument that this is overstated, and I wouldn't be surprised if you are right. But why would someone have written it then? It's not like they were using it to try and steal credit card numbers of send spam emails. It had a very specific purpose, and according to the linked article didn't seem to require manual intervention to turn on (or off?). It seems to have been a one-shot thing - wait for a specific set of events, and then run that mystery command. Blackmail/Ransom theories are easier to believe than a state-run cyber war program - but the reported logic of the program seems to make it pretty hard to blackmail someone with. It appears to have been designed to cause maximum damage once, with as little warning as possible. That's the opposite of what you want with a ransom/blackmail situation.
- azernik 16y ago
- CallMeV 16y agoShadowrun only feels fun when you know it's a game of fantasy. When cyberpunk concepts previously only seen in the pages of a William Gibson book start erupting into this mundane, boring world of the daily commute and the weekly shop, unfolding into the public consciousness like an ink-stained, holographic neon rose, the fantasy doesn't seem so much fun any more when you're looking at it from the inside. Not so jolly when it ceases to be a game.
- ck2 16y agoHere's a thought - don't put mission critical computers on the internet? Remove usb ports?
- pdx 16y agoI used to do industrial controls, so let me give the unfamiliar a little background on these systems. You have PLC's, (programmable logic controllers) often redundant sets of them for critical systems, that run the code that controls the facility. They are networked together via proprietary data networks with no internet involved. These units do not run windows, or any operating system usually. They have no USB ports, hard drives, or monitors. They are hardened against temperature, dust, and power fluctuations. Once the facility is running properly, the PLC's do everything. No human's need to make any decisions about facility operation. However, sometimes, humans want to tweak a setpoint or override a safety interlock because they know a sensor is bad, or they want to run a certain automatic operation in manual, because something has changed in their process. For this, they have windows based graphics interfaces with pretty animated pictures of valves and motors and pumps and fans and reactors and pipes and ductwork, all of which change their state based on the status of the actual valve or motor or pump or fan. To do that, these windows based PC's are networked to the PLC's, to query them for state information. So nobody is "running a factory on windows". Think of these as terminals into your webserver. If you lose the terminal the webserver keeps on trucking. Also, just like terminals, you can have as many windows PC's as you want tied into the PLC network, so if you lose a couple, you still have others, in case there's something that you really don't want to lose visibility of. At no point is this network tied to the internet, for obvious reasons. Usually, the drives are locked out on these systems using physical locks, so only engineering staff can load anything on them. USB is trickier, as I can imagine people hooking up legitimate devices such as sirens and flashing lights and even just speakers for audible alarms, all via USB, which exposes the USB ports to the operators.
- docgnome 16y agoThanks. I took a tour of a lumber mill one time that was all automated. It was pretty cool. To be honest, the way these nuke plants are described is less secure than the lumber mill. I really, really hope that's just really terrible reporting.
- stonemetal 16y agoSounds like you haven't been in the industry in a while or we just happen to hit different cross sections. The industrial automation company I worked for bought off the shelf "Industrialized" PCs dropped in a motion controller card and went to town. Their older systems ran QNX(real time unix) with the GUI and all the data right there on the system. Their newer systems were Windows\In time(a real time windows addon) based. So yes there are people using windows to control the system. I have seen systems where there is no air gap between these windows based systems and the Internet. In fact I have remotely logged in to systems in plants via vpn and worked from home.
- api 16y agoThe cyberpunk writers like Gibson were the most prophetic of all the sci-fi authors of the 20th century. This is straight out of the Sprawl trilogy.