10 ms·
Vermont passes first law to crack down on data brokers
- eveningcoffee 8y agoI believe that these practices should be completely outlawed. I could in principle not see it anything less than a form of unlawful surveillance.
- ravar 8y agoI am personally happy to see that this happened in Vermont and not on the federal level. We now have the opportunity to see the impact this has on the citizens of Vermont and whether or not the regulations are effective. Nothing beats experimentation and the scientific method.
- dmitriid 8y agoData protection laws existed in Europe long before GDPR. Every country had them. And companies would simply disregard them until they became GDPR with the promise of fines and enforcement.
- fuck_google 8y agoCompanies also had a much harder job following the numerous country specific data protection laws before GDPR. GDPR actually helps both companies and individuals as it unifies the regulation within the EU. Unification makes it easier for companies to comply and helps both companies and users in understanding the rules. And it can already be seen that GDPR drives the unification of data protection rules outside the EU as well, since there has been a growing need for such unification for a long time.
- nightsd01 8y agoThat’s a bit extreme. Most of this data gets used for targeted advertising. While that sounds (and sometimes is) shady, it also enables a lot of niche companies that had a much harder time existing before. For example, what’s the point in showing ads for custom quadcopter parts to an 80 year old grandmother who doesn’t know what a quadcopter is? Data should be regulated and protected much more than it currently is. But the idea of banning it entirely would have a lot of negative effects. Let’s be smarter than that.
- adamnemecek 8y ago> lot of niche companies that had a much harder time existing before. Oh the horror.
- pacala 8y agoIf I need quadrocopter parts, I'll search for quadrocopter parts. I don't need your ads to push quadrocopter parts on me on the hope that I might be slightly more interested in them than an 80 year old grandmother. I need you to build a good product and display it in a good store.
- Justsignedup 8y agoAds are unsolicited untrusted information. Though sometimes you want to get the word out about a specific thing. But this is where getting people's social circles hearing about something and trying it is important. I definitely see a few needs for advertisement. But mostly down sides IMO.
- ende 8y agoThis really cuts to the core of the issue. Consumers will naturally seek out the things they wish to buy. Nobody needs to be distracted from their activities to be told what to buy. All advertising should be strictly confined to designated areas specifically intended for consumer searching.
- tdb7893 8y agoThere are a lot of movies I went to after I saw an ad for it which I never would have searched for on my own (and I can say the same about restaurants and a couple other peoducts). Consumers aren't going to search for something they don't know exists in the first place
- wlll 8y agoYeah, but if you hadn't seen those ads, and not watched those movies, would your life really be worse than it is now? > Consumers aren't going to search for something they don't know exists in the first place If a consumer doesn't buy something they don't know exists, does it really matter? Life, at least for me and the people I know, doesn't revolve around finding things to spend money on.
- crobertsbmw 8y agoMy biggest concern are insurance companies and potential employers.
- astura 8y agoIf insurance companies and employers use that information (as well as creditors) it become subject to the FCRA; as well as subject to state, local, and federal laws about lending, insurance underwriting, and employment. This information merely existing (for advertising purposes) doesn't suddenly make it legal to use it in specifically illegal ways. For example, it's a standard practice to use a person's credit history and credit score during insurance underwriting - data shows people who are responsible with credit have less claims, so they have lower premiums. However, say you live in Massachusetts. In Massachusetts it's illegal for insurance companies to take your credit history and credit score into account when determining policy premiums. So insurance companies are not allowed to access your credit if you live in Massachusetts even though that information is widely available and used in other states.
- crobertsbmw 8y agoIt seems so obvious that this is happenening, but I’ve never really thought about it before. Like the article says, “that’s the point.”
- curun1r 8y agoHow many businesses have a point of presence in Vermont? I can't imagine many, and if any do, they'd probably just move rather than comply with a law that would harm their business. This strikes me as being largely symbolic and not likely to have much of an impact, unless other states follow through with similar consumer protections. However if Deleware were to pass legislation like this, that would be a lot more meaningful.
- llukas 8y agoUE, Vermont... next please ;)
- sarcasmic 8y agoFor more details, see the Vermont Attorney General press release [1] and the H.764 bill full text [2]. Cynical prediction: Vermont has less than a million residents. It may be both easier (as in less effort) and less expensive, if you're a data broker, to just cease trafficking in the data of anyone tangentially associated [3] with the state of Vermont. [1] http://ago.vermont.gov/blog/2018/05/24/a-g-new-data-broker-law-is-good-for-vermonters/ http://ago.vermont.gov/blog/2018/05/24/a-g-new-data-broker-l... [2] https://legislature.vermont.gov/bill/status/2018/H.764 https://legislature.vermont.gov/bill/status/2018/H.764 [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vermont#Population_changes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vermont#Population_changes
- michaelbuckbee 8y agoThere are some number of companies making the same decision wrt GDPR and the EU, so it wouldn't surprise me. That being said, there will come a tipping point where it _does_ make sense and regulation like this is part of how it gets there.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> That being said, there will come a tipping point where it _does_ make sense and regulation like this is part of how it gets there. That's assuming the jurisdictions have the same rules as one another. If they have different rules, or conflicting rules, or rules that conflict with some other jurisdiction's data retention requirements, it becomes a huge mess. And the probability of the US adopting the GDPR verbatim is practically nil.
- swsieber 8y agoMoreover, the chance of a verbatim GDPR in the US being interpreted the same way is even smaller. Though I do have hope that there will be a common base that gives compliance amongst all regulatory areas.
- CPLX 8y agoI believe that would count as the law functioning as intended.
- 64kbisalluneed 8y agoAmen!
- matte_black 8y agoWe’re going to end up with some HIPAA like regulations on collecting data and it’s going to be a massive pain in the ass. The scary part is the big companies will have the money to lobby for regulations to be written in a way that is easy for them to comply with while shutting out smaller companies and startups.
- downandout 8y agoThis law applies only to data brokers in Vermont. From the article: Data brokers in Vermont will now have to register as such with the state; they must take standard security measures and notify authorities of security breaches (no, they weren’t before); and using their data for criminal purposes like fraud is now its own actionable offense. It defines data brokers as businesses in Vermont that buy and sell data on people with whom they have no direct relationship. Seems like a reasonable law - unlike GDPR, they aren’t trying to reach outside of their jurisdiction, they aren’t trying to wipe out entire business models, there are no absurd fines, it’s easy to know if you’re violating it (because you would know that you have setup a data brokerage in Vermont), etc. My guess is there are only a handful of “data brokers” as they define that term within Vermont, so this affects very few people.
- matte_black 8y agoI didn't stand up for the data brokers because I wasn't a data broker, etc.. etc.. when they came for me, there was no one left to stand up... etc
- quantum_magpie 8y agoThis quote only works when you're using other neutral, but unrelated-to-you parties. Data brokers are scum. They do not produce any value, they do not improve the society, they have no positive effect on anyone. No reasonable person should stand up to protect them from liability.
- lovich 8y ago
- erentz 8y agoI’m still not understanding the controversy and kickback around these regulations. The hysteria around GDPR has been silly. My home country has a Privacy Act, it’s terribly weak and has little enforcement but the principals in it were drilled into me from the very start of my career. Customer data is really important. It must be kept private and not shared. And we should only have what we need to have for whatever we’re doing for them. I don’t know why those principals are so hard for people to swallow. Now in the states when I hear mobile carriers are selling my location data without my consent, and so on, I get completely irate. It boggles my mind why people think that kind of behavior should be allowed.
- Ensorceled 8y agoThese are separate Things with some overlap. A Saas company that does nothing fishy with users data, may still be concerned with the harsh, company destroying penalties associated with GDPR. Indeed there have been dozens of discussions on HN about this. It may be FUD, but it’s real. The other people are doing terrible things. Please don’t assert the people in the first group are actually in the second.
- TAForObvReasons 8y agoIt's probably better stated as: > The people doing terrible things are trying to convince other companies that they will be destroyed by the GDPR
- Ensorceled 8y agoPerhaps. But the large fines are a concern without too much prompting from the problem companies. Not saying the GDPR is bad, I’d personally like to see it applied every where.
- bsder 8y agoOkay, so what was Ragnarok Online doing that it had to shut down?
- oliv__ 8y agoI'm all for spreading information but I can't help but cringe at the frowny, holy attitude Techcrunch displays here like they just discovered this stuff is happening. Please. Spare me the tears. You knew about this all along, it just wasn't fashionable to write about it before.
- shubb 8y agoThis crackdown on data brokering bothers me. I'm writing from the medical data industry. Data isn't neccesarily about unwanted creepy stuff. In other industries, customer data can be used to recomend the right stuff, or make the kind of movies people want to watch. That stuff enhances peoples lives - in individually small but additive ways. In my industry, data really can save lives. For instance the prime minister of my country apparantly wants to apply AI to peoples GP records to spot people who have undiagnosed cancer. This seems pretty viable to me - even in the most simple case you could quickly spot families with high cancer risk, offer the young women in them gene sequencing, and then offer the ones that are carrying super high risk cancer genes preventative treatement. You'd certainly save lives this way. There are a lot of very scary ethical questions in my industry. Widespread use of genetics to price insurance. Employers requiring employees give access to medical records before confirming employment. And much more. But I do worry this backlash will make it much harder to do good.
- chris0009 8y agogeneric viagra is outstanding amongst other known medications ever. About each grown-up in America has known about the medication and can reveal to you what it does.for more information and need to buy generic viagra online pls visit..... buy generic viagra online https://www.rxnrx.com/generic-viagra.html https://www.rxnrx.com/generic-viagra.html
- _salmon 8y agoThrough the article, I looked at Acxiom and it seems like they have an opt-out form. Who knows if they actually obey it but they probably have your data anyway so it's worth a shot: https://isapps.acxiom.com/optout/optout.aspx https://isapps.acxiom.com/optout/optout.aspx
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]