26 ms·
The Engineer vs. the Border Patrol
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoSadly it looks to me like the best case of "winning" is that they'll just keep doing the same thing and call them "DUI checkpoints" instead. It's not about catching people breaking the law, it's about harassing just enough people that the general population fears them and complies with any demand and writing citations and making money while doing it.
- newman8r 8y agoI think they meant 'extemporaneous' instead of 'contemporaneous' although I'm not 100% sure. I've been stopped at one of these checkpoints in California and had my vehicle searched. I'm just glad that I didn't have any cannabis in my car because they promptly informed me that even though it was legal in the state, the checkpoints are federal - so you could be in hot water.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pulisse 8y ago"Contemporaneous" is correct. What is meant is that the notes were written when the events they describe occurred.
- newman8r 8y agoThat makes sense, and now I see why they might mention that, since the incident was from 2002
- late2part 8y agoWhy did you consent to the search?
- jasonwatkinspdx 8y agoDoesn't matter. In Kansas outside Salina, highway patrol pulled me over because my new car had a temporary tag, which they claimed was in the wrong location. It wasn't: KS and OR differ in where they want you to put it. I declined consent for a search, at which point they put hands on guns and ordered me out of the car. They spent about an hour tossing everything they could remove into the ditch. There are some real top to bottom jerks around with badges, and with those folks, knowing your rights is effectively meaningless.
- tptacek 8y agoDid you follow up on this with the department?
- jasonwatkinspdx 8y agoI called their precinct, got told to go pound sand in not so many words.
- anigbrowl 8y agoPeople who have had their rights infringed shouldn't be asked to invest more of their time and/or money in procedural wrangling with diminishing probabilities of restitution for their original injury. there are strong correlations between biased enforcement and biased litigation outcomes, and that doctrine of qualified immunity virtually guarantees litigation will be highly asymmetrical from the outset.
- tptacek 8y agoI asked him "if", not "to".
- 8y ago
- jasonwatkinspdx 8y agoA friend was in a similar situation for a while: crossing a CBP checkpoint multiple times every day for work in south Texas. At some point he decided to try to stand up for what he considered his rights in a similar way: not being combative, just not cooperating. He was thrown in jail for 3 days, then the charges were dropped. He talked with lawyers and the ACLU. The ACLU were quite frank that they have limited resources, and so they have to prioritize cases that have the ideal defendant and political optics. If he fought it personally, the cost would start at five figures. The folks doing this know there's a high barrier to holding them accountable and leverage it wantonly. The worst thing about these "contempt of cop" style arrests is, despite the charges being dropped, once you're in the system's pipeline, if you mess up about any of the restrictions, paperwork, court appearances, etc, you become a criminal. It's easy to imagine a lot of folks might fall into that trap for innocent and mundane reasons.
- djsumdog 8y agoThe biggest problem in trying to stand up against it is US v. Martinez-Fuerte, effectively making these stops legal at the federal/constitution level. The only way to fight it would be a heavily organized protest; enough people that they couldn't arrest everyone/would fill the jails.
- Zak 8y agoThey usually don't arrest people who refuse to cooperate. There are a large number of videos if you search "checkpoint refusal" on youtube.
- anaonmous32rt4 8y agoAs a non-white person, there's no way I would refuse to cooperate with a US police office or other authority figure. The price of refusal can be very high, including being arrested, put in jail for a few days, or even being shot dead. Unless you're rich or connected, the US can be a very cruel place.
- 8y ago
- mindslight 8y agoGood for him! But even if he "wins", I'm guessing all of the past criminality will remain unpunished - as opposed to throwing the kidnappers in jail, and civilly compensating all of their victims, and similarly prosecuting the leaders for conspiracy. When asked to oversee agents of USG itself, courts seem to take the attitude that eg telling a murderer to not do it again is good enough. And lacking the threat of punishment, the thugs will just move on to the next profitable harassment scheme that hasn't yet been cracked down on. Given that we've all been victims of this same pattern for decades, all I can really wonder is are those newfangled assassination markets ready yet? Kickstarter for justice seems to be the only way we'll be able to get it.
- itchyjunk 8y agoIn a more abstract view, is it the incentive of money thats drawing in these bad actors? Is it the power of authority that drawn in bad actors? Can you generalize that all CBP checkpoints are bad? What are some of the good stuff they have done? Should there be a way to crowd fund legal case? I find reading articles like these makes me question too many things but I don't know how really to process it. Outside of hitting the up vote button, there isn't much I can do to contribute to improving this or most situations.
- sjg007 8y agoThey get Federal grants to pay for the police cooperation / joint activity. The politics will be local and the locals get a pass since they usually cooperate or become well known. Even a license plate reader will say the car is local. These areas tend to be conservative as well so they view the law enforcement presence as useful.
- deegles 8y agoAs an immigrant (with legal status), I couldn't imagine showing the slightest bit of resistance to any sort of CBP officers. I cannot put myself at risk trying to combat unfair policies due to the imbalance of power. Thank you to those US citizens who are doing what they can.
- Someone1234 8y agoEven just speaking out is getting dangerous, particularly for the people just entering the pipeline now as you have to provide all of your social media accounts so they can keep and eye on your speech. It is only a matter of time before you'll sit down in a citizenship interview, and they'll have a print out of your social media posts and a bunch of questions about any that seem to criticize the government.
- digi_owl 8y agoI seems to recall a story where a couple of people were denied entry after reaching a US airport because they had tweeted a joke that got misunderstood.
- fmihaila 8y ago> I seems to recall a story where a couple of people were denied entry after reaching a US airport because they had tweeted a joke that got misunderstood. http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-16810312 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-16810312
- jellicle 8y ago> It is only a matter of time before you'll sit down in a citizenship interview, and they'll have a print out of your social media posts and a bunch of questions about any that seem to criticize the government. What you describe has been the case in the US since the early 2000s. The "matter of time" is about negative 15 years or so. People on HN often seem to think the government is insanely slow-moving and incompetent. While there are various snags, the whole system moves constantly and is staffed by many perfectly competent people who ask questions like "why aren't we checking the social media accounts of citizenship applicants to weed out the terrorists and commies?" and before too long, they are.
- Zak 8y agoIt seems to me that Martinez-Fuerte was wrongly decided. The court treated it as a dilemma between stopping all traffic passing a particular point with no suspicion at all, and requiring a warrant from a judge based on probable cause. There was already legal precedent for a middle ground at that time: the Terry stop, requiring only reasonable suspicion based on evidence as determined by the officer and subject to later review by a judge. More generally, I don't think government agents should ever be able to detain and question people in public places without reasonable individualized suspicion based on evidence. To whatever extent the law fails to prohibit such actions, it should be changed.
- koheripbal 8y agoThe Martinez-Fuerte ruling specifically applies to a section of US territory along the border. The ruling accepts that illegal border crossings DO occur and that therefor Border Patrol need jurisdiction to stop and question people within a reasonable distance from the border in areas where illegal border crossings occur. A less penetrable border would be the cleanest solution here.
- JshWright 8y agoSo, your argument is that because people who cross the border illegally exist, it is reasonable to suspect anyone who is within 100 miles of the border crossed it illegally?
- kurthr 8y agoSince the "border" extends 100 miles inland, covers the majority of large cities and 2/3 of the US population, I don't think this is a clean solution. It only seems that way when you aren't personally affected.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 8y agoBorder stops have to have a connection to an actual border crossing regardless of where they occur. CBP can't conduct suspicionless searches of 2/3rds of the US population.
- HissingMachine 8y agoI don't want to derail anything, but does anyone sense the irony of that little addendum at the end of the article. The one that refers to Trump being such a clear danger to rule of law that Slate felt the need to increase reporting on rights violations, and it being at the end of an article that mainly deals with BS that went through Obama administration without audit or inquiry.
- lightedman 8y agoUh, Obama wasn't President in 2002. Maybe you should actually read and comprehend the article first?
- late2part 8y agoYou're being downvoted because people don't like it when you remind them that the Emperor has no clothes.
- 5DFractalTetris 8y agoReminders that the Emperor has no clothes are an exonerating justification regularly accepted in courtrooms for summary executions conducted by police officers in the United States.
- anigbrowl 8y agoI'm downvoting because the addendum is clearly separate from the article content rather than derivative of it, and because it's arguably objectively correct: many abuses in immigration and other areas of law enforcement did indeed take place under the previous administration, but trends in enforcement and litigation have reversed. I'd also point out that the strict immigration enforcement under Obama was meant as a concession to immigration restrictionists who demanded a 'secure border' before they would consider any reform or revision of immigration, and was thus conducted in spite of rather than in pursuance of the Democratic party's policies in an effort at bipartisanship, which has turned out to be singularly lacking in reciprocation. Despite the relative heavy-handedness of enforcement under the Obama administration and a subsequent (but not necessarily consequent, due to economic factors) transition to negative net migration, immigration restrictionists simply doubled down on their demands and started asking for a physical wall.
- hartator 8y agoA good move from the democrats will be to ageee to the border wall against the removal of these unconstitutional checkpoints.
- anigbrowl 8y agoInsofar as you consider them to be unconstitutional, why are you bargaining (at great fiscal, diplomatic, and social expense) for relief from something you con't consider to be legitimate in the first place?
- throwaway29990 8y agoIt's possible to believe that having an immigration policy and laws is a legitimate and constitutional need for the country, and still think that the way they're being enforced is neither legitimate nor constitutional. Instead of having a secure border line, where we enforce immigration law, and legitimately ask everyone to identify themselves, we have this giant zone extending well into the country where people are presumed to be crossing the border. If we simply physically controlled the line itself, this zone would not be necessary, and the conflict between enforcing immigration law and the fourth amendment would go away.
- HurrdurrHodor 8y ago1. Click on link. 2. Get huge GDPR banner. 3. Close tab. GDPR, the new productivity booster.
- rb12345 8y agoIt's not even a compliant banner at that, given the opt in is a requirement for viewing the site...
- Asooka 8y agoDoubly ironic in that the article describes abuses of power by immigration officials. "To read about this abuse of power, consent to our abuse of power". At least we can still say no to one.
- Moodles 8y agoA hilarious video on how to quickly get through border security: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFxijuRjX1U https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WFxijuRjX1U
- Asooka 8y agoI'm downvoting you not because I disagree with people exercising their rights, but because you're spreading information that, if followed in the places where it matters, will be the quickest way to get your teeth kicked in and land you jail.
- late2part 8y agoBetter to have your teeth kicked in and land in jail than to passively support corruption and abuses of power.
- anigbrowl 8y agoIn many cases they're the same thing, given the probability differential in enforcement; a strategy that works great for people in one group can also be the excuse for excessive enforcement against another, who indirectly pick up the tab for the first group's sociopolitical privilege debt. Disadvantaged outgroups should not have to incur predictably higher levels of abuse for their political concerns to become valid.
- Asooka 8y agoYou are free to do that, of course and I applaud you for fighting for your rights. However, the video gives the wrong impression that this is a method via which one can go through a checkpoint with less hassle, whereas in reality if this method works, you're dealing with cops that won't bother you needlessly anyway; but if it doesn't, you're dealing with cops that will make your day a living hell for standing up for your rights. From a game-theory perspective it's absolutely the worst choice. No matter of standing up for your rights seems to have any systemic effect anyway. My perspective might be different because I grew up in the Eastern Bloc, where the winning strategy was always complying while hiding contraband and bribing officials. No amount of anyone fighting for any rights ever had any effect, what happened in the end is that the economy collapsed and things had to change at the top forcibly. If you want to fight because of some personal sense of honour, of course you should do that. But from an everyday practical game-theory perspective, the winning strategy for both the game and the meta-game is to comply with whatever the cop wants to see.
- devtul 8y agoIf someone needs a simple and clear example of "corrupted by power", just read the excerpt below. In a Jan. 28, 2008, letter to university president Robert Shelton, local Border Patrol union president Ed Tuffly stated, “We will be aggressively pursuing action against Mr. Bressi and/or the University on behalf of our agents for the internet postings which Bressi has undertaken using video obtained while he was acting as a University employee. If it is determined that the [Arizona] law does not apply to Federal law enforcement officers, we will lobby for an amendment to the State law to ensure that we are protected.”
- mherdeg 8y agoThe pre-election date on that letter was interesting. The Slate article is kind of silent on what happened during the Obama presidency on this. Did they continue Operation Stonegarden as-is throughout those two terms?
- hfdgiutdryg 8y agoHere's my thought: the only thing that will save us from this insanity is driverless cars. When the Constitution was written, there weren't cars. You walked or rode a horse. There were no licenses or insurance, there were no DUIs. There was no legal requirement to prove that you were legally entitled to operate a motor vehicle on a public road. These stops seem to largely depend on our relationship with driving cars. The necessary evil of DUI checkpoints is obviously a crutch they're leaning on heavily. At a minimum, self-driving cars will force them to work a bit harder to scheme up clever legal interpretations allowing them to continue operating.
- pjc50 8y agoDriverless cars won't save you, and this is described as an immigration issue. The police will end up with the same remote access to cars as they have to phones.
- slededit 8y ago> necessary evil of DUI checkpoints WA doesn't have them (against the constitution), and it gets along just fine. In fact with the NHTSA's own data Washington's ratio of traffic fatalities attributed to alcohol is closely inline with states that do have checkpoints. [1] The evidence simply doesn't show that DUI checkpoints are necessary or effective. https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/Publication/812450 https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/Publication/8124...
- StudentStuff 8y agoSimilar wrt undercover police cars, we have some restrictions that make 'em much less common: https://reason.com/blog/2014/10/20/washington-man-busts-cop-in-unmarked-car https://reason.com/blog/2014/10/20/washington-man-busts-cop-...
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoYeah, they'll arrest the car and leave your sorry ass hanging out on an Arizona highway
- tomohawk 8y agoIf there was adequate enforcement of immigration at the border, there would be no need for these internal checkpoints.
- Karishma1234 8y agoAs a brown immigrant myself I asked a white farmer in Arizona why they are putting up with this shit in their region. He was pretty frank that he personally never gets stopped there and he is actually very happy that immigrants are being harassed by border patrol. "Don't like it ? Don't come to my country. Obey the law however stupid it sounds. " that was his response. Many of these people and mostly white conservatives are so much cornered that they will gladly break their own nose if it could spite non-white people somehow. Whether it is border checkpoints or H1B harassment, green card backlog for Indians/Chinese or abuse of DACA children all eventually ties into the white America's deep rooted racism towards non-whites and a misplaced sense of superiority and resting on past laurels. This is not to paint entire white community in bad light. Most libertarians are white, ACLU, Cato, FEE, Reason all are mostly white too. But a small intolerant minority wins and in this case it is the racist whites. P.S. In my conversations with white conservatives in midwest and fly over country I realised that their true hatred for people like me (Brown) does not stem as much from the skin colour but by the fact that they see more and more of non-white people in leadership positions. Why are so many silicon valley companies lead by Indians ? Why did Trump appoint a brown Ajit Pai ? How come a woman named Tulasi become Congresswoman ? How come China have become so rich ? They are mostly facing these questions without realizing lower birthrates of whites is mostly the reason for this.
- late2part 8y agoI struggle to understand the point of your post. There are bad white people? Is that the gist of it?
- Karishma1234 8y agoThe point is : - Anti immigrant policies are loved by white conservatives. - White conservatives are happy to face loss of their own freedom and money just to spite others. - Immigrants barely get deterred by such moves but the proponents of these policies get hurt more and more. For example no good company bothers to have any operations near the border. US Mexico border towns are ripe with low productivity jobs, crime, smuggling and government corruption.
- 8y ago
- arenaninja 8y agoAs a non-white naturalized US citizen whose ethnicity is heavily targeted by CBP activities, they make me nervous and I'm not surprised to hear that they repeatedly overstep their boundaries (irony!). I see the current enforcement of our immigration laws fueling a parental crisis similar to what we currently see in black communities, the bill will be due in a decade or two.
- mrnobody_67 8y agoIt strikes me that anybody who says America is a "free" country is absolutely delusional. -America has the highest percentage of it's people locked up in jail -People spend time in jail even though they are not convicted because they cannot post bail, which disproportionately punishes the the poor -The laws are so complex, and so many, almost everyone breaks the law multiple times a month. Enforcement is highly subjective and at the whim of prosecutors and law enforcement officials - This story
- jessaustin 8y agoBy the time we leave public school we've heard the "freedom" spiel thousands of times. We hear it from the news, every time we turn it on. Some people listen to the news primarily so they can hear the repetition of the comfortable old litany. A relatively recent innovation is talking about foreigners who "hate us for our freedom", rather than e.g. for our bombs falling on their homes. It takes a lot of work to ignore reality so thoroughly.
- mrnobody_67 8y ago"It takes a lot of work to ignore reality so thoroughly." America seems to have done a good job indoctrinating the belief though, starting at a very young age. Even press freedom, is arguably relatively poor: https://rsf.org/en/ranking https://rsf.org/en/ranking Objectively, US is 45th on the list, below Lithuania, Czech Republic, Trinidad, Jamaica and Namibia. Not even top 20% in terms of press freedom! But if you ask most people, they would say US is #1 (or at least top 10) in the world.
- allthenews 8y agoWhat are the criteria used to rank journalistic freedom?
- admiralpumpkin 8y agohttps://rsf.org/en/detailed-methodology https://rsf.org/en/detailed-methodology Two clicks.
- arkem 8y agoI had an experience with a border patrol checkpoint in Arizona in 2009. I was driving from Yuma, AZ towards Vegas (probably on US-95) in a rented brown Prius with Washington state plates as I was flagged down by the border patrol. At the checkpoint the officers looked at me with disinterest (probably a combination of the dull routine and because I looked like a white US citizen). First they asked me if I was a US citizen and I said no, and suddenly they were looked far more interested. They asked to see my passport and informed me they'd need to search my vehicle and I was to open the trunk. I complied, opening the trunk and passing my passport to one officer while the other went to the rear of the vehicle to start a search. A few seconds later the officer with my passport notices something and urgently signals the other officer. At this point I was worried that my paperwork must not be in order and that I was in trouble. Once the other officer rejoins the first they briefly confer and then they hand me back my passport and apologize profusely for the inconvenience saying that they didn't realize that I was a diplomat before sending me on my way. The kicker is that I wasn't a diplomat, merely a bureaucrat on an official trip to the US and any "diplomatic immunity" I had was the thinnest kind of intergovernmental courtesy. At first this story was funny to me as the time I accidentally wielded diplomatic immunity. However, more recently I find it less amusing as instead I consider it a tale about how the changing assumptions of the officers significantly affected the nature of the interaction and how different the interaction could have been if their assumptions had been less favorable.
- avar 8y agoI don't understand how you think the officers in question did anything wrong. I'm not American, so I have no stake in defending the US border patrol, but this is what I'd expect border patrol anywhere in the world to do. Their entire job function is to prevent illegal entry, toll violations etc. By your own account you were in possession of a valid passport clearly indicating that you're working in an official capacity for a foreign state. Why would border patrol anywhere in the world continue to detain you at that point? Is there some illegal immigration problem in any country on Earth stemming from people in possession of official government passports indicating that they work for their respective states that I'm unaware of? How is this not as clear of a signal as anything short of the agent personally recognizing you as a foreign ambassador that you should be sent on your way?
- throwawayeu 8y agoIs it wrong to be anti american? I am from europe and I cant imagine to ever travel to a shithole country like this. I cant drink beer in public. There are weapons everywhere. Its run by complete idiots. Why would anyone want to go to this place? I really dont get it.
- mattlondon 8y agoDoes anyone have a mirror of the article without the consent-wall?
- mcone 8y agoI visited Tucson, Arizona several years ago with my parents and the area south of town resembles a war zone. There were blackhawk helicopters searching for illegal immigrants, hundreds of CBP vehicles all over the place, dozens of buses waiting to transport the illegal immigrants to detention facilities, and of course the military-style checkpoints where officers with assault rifles can essentially do anything they want to you (many of these checkpoints are in the middle of nowhere). I'm a natural-born citizen and I was afraid. I can't imagine living down there and going through those type of checkpoints every day.
- Natsu 8y ago"War zone" really gives people the wrong idea. South Tucson has some very nice neighborhoods, including one of the best schools in the state. There is a fair bit of air traffic due to a nearby air force base[1] but this is not something most of the residents are generally concerned with. The checkpoints are legitimately annoying, though. Most people simply identify themselves and pass through peacefully--the Supreme Court has already decided that you must identify yourself. If you want your right to remain silent, you have to actually say that, oddly enough. Granted, it's clear that he wanted to be arrested for civil disobedience, just mentioning that for anyone who prefers to go on their way. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davis%E2%80%93Monthan_Air_Force_Base https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Davis%E2%80%93Monthan_Air_Forc...
- chiph 8y ago> The CBP checkpoints are good at one thing: catching American motorists with dime bags of pot Like Willie Nelson. https://www.texasmonthly.com/articles/the-best-little-checkpoint-in-texas/ https://www.texasmonthly.com/articles/the-best-little-checkp...
- ctoth 8y agohttps://craphound.com/scroogled.html https://craphound.com/scroogled.html
- 0x445442 8y agoIt's these types of issues I believe a massive coalition could be built around. Without attempting to ignite a flame war here, I'll just say it would not surprise me at all if this fellow was a Trump supporter nor would it surprise me if he were not. What I have noticed over my 34 voting years is an extremely well coordinated effort by every major media source to distract the electorate from these types of issues. For example, a quick search on Bing/news finds hits on the referenced Slate article and an article on Reason which illustrates my point. But the only other references I get hits for are local news sources.