3 ms·
The stagnation represents the end of peak globalism, right before it flips back to growing nationalism (underway now). This cycle will continue to repeat. Incre
by adventured 8y ago
The stagnation represents the end of peak globalism, right before it flips back to growing nationalism (underway now). This cycle will continue to repeat. Increased nationalism will bring about more war, general national conflict and invention. The easy gains from globalism for this cycle have been mostly tapped out. Tension and competition between nations will spur a new wave of innovation. Just as one example, the US and China will increasingly race each other for every advantage they can manage. Globalism is increased tranquility and a lowering of friction at a cost of dynamism, nationalism is a nasty irritant that produces pearls at a cost of stability and peacefulness. Despite the desire by some to view nationalism as evil, it's as natural a part of the cycle as globalism, and just as required. The nationalism flip occurs because as you get toward the end of the globalism expansion cycle, the entropy hits lows, the possible gains from the globalism cycle get exhausted, and the people that were comforted by the prior gains, grow restless in the stagnation. High levels of entropy are a requirement for great technological leaps forward and great societal change, as people prefer to go to sleep in their comfort otherwise, stagnating. Globalism spreads comfort (distributes gains - technological, process, etc - made by some nations across most nations), nationalism riles survival responses and increases desperation.
- JimboOmega 8y agoThe argument is for a trend far beyond that; that perhaps those cycles do matter but there is a 700 year trend in one direction. Even the globalism to nationalism trends that drove both world wars (after common wisdom thought them impossible since economies were too linked) is really a small factor, at least in the analysis of the article. I don't even think that your analysis is correct in a broader context. The fall of the Roman Empire and the rise of manoralism (and constant conflict in Europe) was not innovation and didn't particularly drive it. The staunch nationalism of the Chinese empire didn't drive innovation (though it did mean less conflict). WWII may have held in it (or pushed forward) the seeds of much great innovation - rocket science, computing, plastics, antibiotics, nuclear science, etc. But what innovation would have occurred without it? What would the lives lost have contributed? I don't think it's fair to say that rapid change is only possible in such an environment of conflict. Great advances occurred in the interwar years, too.
- adventured 8y agoIt's not just the active wars of nationalism that unleash waves of invention, it's the cultural atmosphere, the lingering of such over all nations. At high levels of nationalism you can feel the tension in the air across the globe, it alters how people behave and how they think. Nations stop cooperating as much, and start competing with each other in an aggressive manner more. That's the core of what spurs the increased invention, rather than war specifically. War plausibly can prompt and enable a short, unsustainable, burst of heightened levels of invention. WW2, as an atmospheric, a cultural change agent, didn't just go away when WW2 ended. It's reasonable to consider that the impact it had on people would last for decades. For the generation or two that primarily lived it, it permanently changed how they think and view the world. Most of the great advances we've enjoyed post WW2, were sparked in the 20 or 30 years after WW2. Globalism spread those advances and refined them; which is what we've been mostly doing since the collapse of the USSR in the early 1980s after oil imploded. This cycle of globalism began somewhere between the late 1970s and mid 1980s. edit: to add to my opinion here - I view the invention that occurs under nationalism vs globalism, as tall spikes vs low gentle waves. Invention doesn't cease under globalism, the nature of it changes. Nationalism will deliver intense blunt trauma invention, that may be impossible under other circumstances and or require a far longer timeline. If it's 1960-1965 and you tell the US Government they can acquire an immense leg up on the USSR by plowing $10 billion into some focused great technological leap forward attempt, they're probably going to do it. That's the application of blunt trauma to technological progress. The difference between: we should consider doing XYZ thing, versus: we must do XYZ thing and do it now. Would the modern superpower version of the US Government - eg in ~1994-2004 at the height of its superpower status vs other nations - do projects like that? I'm skeptical the solitary superpower version of the US would create the Internet or go to the moon. In the next 20 years, in heightened nationalistic competition with China, I think you're going to see a revival of that spirit.
- 5DFractalTetris 8y agoI don't think nationalism is necessarily hawkish, indicative of survival responses or desperation. I think a little bit of nationalism is a comfort to those participating in it, as indicative of their faith in the wellbeing and character of their compatriots. Especially after a mostly-successful period of global trade marked by a recession, the new nationalism feels a little bit more like the spirit of buying locally, and seeing your neighbors at the market. A person can take pride in their self without feeling a need to do violence to neighbors; why shouldn't nations be the same? If you're happy in your nation, you want that others in the nation be happy too, as (with tolerance) you abide the same laws and, while economic inequality declines, mostly have access to similar resources. You also want that these others are able to contribute to the economy without coercion into dangerous or objectionable trades, which means more light industry and less tolerance for what the President calls "dumping." That isn't so much a hawkish impulse as the desire to decline a gift which seems too generous, if you will. Especially after successful global trade and the burgeoning pride in items manufactured locally with global materials, I don't foresee a return to solitary autarchic superpowers. If anything the tendency I'd predict would be more trade in raw materials, and more local labor by those who would once purchase import products, like a kit car economy. 3D printing and stuff are a part of this too. I can't claim to see the future but that's my opinion on what I'm seeing.
- mr_overalls 8y agoIt may be a natural cycle, but full warfare between nuclear powers these days could end human life (and hence, further innovation) on Earth.