7 ms·
Tired of the eternal startup excuse to justify bad behaviour when it comes to protection of consumer privacy. If it is impossible for some startups to respect
by Barrin92 8y ago
Tired of the eternal startup excuse to justify bad behaviour when it comes to protection of consumer privacy.
If it is impossible for some startups to respect strong privacy practices maybe we simply don't need those startups.
This 'startupism' is almost an ideology. No mechanical engineer would complain about safety regulation just because it means that they cannot start a business in their garage. In other industries, strong safety standards and regards for customer privacy is simply the norm, not an annoyance.
- manigandham 8y agoAlso tired of people thinking that a company not wanting a rule means they were intending to do the exact the opposite of that rule, especially given said rule is incredibly vague and designed to be applied "on principle". Fortunately for all of us, safety regulation is actually very specific in requirements.
- mintplant 8y agoUpthread we have the claim that "most early-stage startups use the... best practice of 'delete=1'," pretending to delete user data while actually retaining it. So, the exact opposite of the rule.
- manigandham 8y agoYes, and many things will remain that way with GDPR because of necessity (ie: old invoices and transactions will continue to have your details). Most startups are doing their best to be good stewards of data, and they didn't need big global regulation to force them. But do let me know when GDPR actually does anything to deal with ISPs, credit unions, medical companies, and plenty of other institutions that have breaches all the time and have endured roughly $0 in penalties.
- lathiat 8y ago> Most startups are doing their best to be good stewards of data, and they didn't need big global regulation to force them. lol
- manigandham 8y agoSo you work for a big company like Canonical. Glad to know you guys always get it right: http://www.wired.co.uk/article/canonical-warns-2m-users-of-personal-data-breach http://www.wired.co.uk/article/canonical-warns-2m-users-of-p... https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/07/hack-exposes-e-mail-addresses-password-data-for-2-million-ubuntu-forum-users/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/07/hack-...
- kadenshep 8y agoWho he works for won't negate the fact how ridiculous the original statement is at just bare face value.
- lagadu 8y ago> Most startups are doing their best to be good stewards of data, and they didn't need big global regulation to force them. If that were true we wouldn't be seeing daily threads here (like this one) that effectively amount to "I don't want to follow the law/protect the data I collect" for months now.
- manigandham 8y ago...you just repeated it again. Not wanting regulation does not mean not wanting to follow the law or protect data. Complying with GDPR can involve a significant cost, but as said multiple times already, the issue isn't data privacy and security but the vast ambiguity of the law. Costs and risk explode when the rules are vague and applied "on-principle". There are numerous comments on this page that keep saying you need "a good reason" without realizing that is absolutely useless in a legal sense and can open up a large volley of litigation against any business.
- Spivak 8y agoIf you're a small company and making a good faith effort to acquire express consent from your users for data collection, follow best practices to secure that data, and allow users to delete their data (even if it's a manual customer service driven process) then I don't see why you have any reason to be afraid. You're not opening yourself up to litigation from random 3rd parties -- they can only file complaints to regulators who will decide how to respond.
- jeremyt 8y agoWell then, you’ve never been the target of a lawsuit. Forgive me if it doesn’t make me comfortable that the decision whether to file a lawsuit against me or not is left to some often uneducated and inexperienced regulators.
- brobdingnagians 8y agoI think it is an important point about "many things will remain that way with GDPR because of necessity (ie: old invoices and transactions will continue to have your details)". Most people doing business have _very_ legitimate reasons for having sensitive data; invoices, charges, security, etc. all require having personally identifying and sensitive information, and GDPR recognizes that-- but what it means is that companies _will_ and _should_ have customer information. Just because it isn't sitting in their database to improve customer experience doesn't mean it won't be sitting in the billing department for accounting & auditing purposes. So GDPR doesn't actually change much about people having your data, just kind of shuffles it around.
- sunir 8y agoWhy is delete=1 a best practice? There are competing concerns here. The government has now decided for everyone. Agree or disagree it is not worth implyng immorality where no immoral intent is present.
- fiddlerwoaroof 8y agoI’m not sure that delete=1 is a good idea, because you’re still mutating database records. But, it’s often lot cleaner conceptually to model state as an append-only log of assertions and retractions or via a log-structured system, where you never delete old records but just push a new index record that leaves the appropriate record out.
- _delirium 8y agoSure, but it also leaves a much bigger attack surface, because you still have all the deleted data ready to be leaked, as has repeatedly happened in practice. It's only a cleaner solution if your risk accounting allocates close to zero cost to that, which is what most startups do. It's hardly only EU bureaucrats who have pointed this out. See Bruce Schneier from a few years ago: https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_toxic.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2016/03/data_is_a_tox...
- fiddlerwoaroof 8y agoYeah, my point is just that the way databases have been developing recently has been towards eliminating mutation and deletion. The GDPR’s conception of deletion is fundamentally opposed to these models. However, you can sort of match the two by storing personal data in a separate key-value map, using the (random) key from that map to link your data to the personal data and then just deleting the map entry when someone asks to be forgotten. The annoying part is retrofitting data scrubbing into things like data warehouses and other systems of record, without accidentally deleting data you have a legal obligation to retain to satisfy, e.g. anti-money laundering laws or audit requirements.
- 8y ago
- pilsetnieks 8y ago> especially given said rule is incredibly vague and designed to be applied "on principle". You know, I'm starting to feel that at least some of this contention is based on how Americans interpret the law vs. how Europeans do it. Somehow it seems that Americans (and the UK) has this huge legal corpus but everything has to be nitpicked to the letter, or the common law judges' interpretations may vary wildly, and some people might skate on technicalities, i.e. abuse of the letter of the law. Whereas in civil law, which the EU is, there's less leeway for interpretation, however, the spirit of the law is also taken into account.
- manigandham 8y agoIt's the opposite. "In-principle" creates lots of potential for interpretation, depending on who is doing the reading. The spirit of the law is also taken into account all the time in America. It's really not as simple as you make it out to be and the EU has plenty of argumentative litigation.
- ng12 8y agoHere's a thought: regulation like this is, along with the heavy-handed ideology that lead to it, is the reason why the EU is still lagging regarding technical innovation. I think this attitude is the primary reason Silicon Valley took hold in the USA and that the EU has nothing comparable. If the EU wants to legislate itself out of the future they're more than welcome to do so -- and I applaud every site who makes the tough decision to stonewall EU users.
- Barrin92 8y agoI'm not onboard with the idea that Silicon Valley holds a monopoly on technical innovation. Getting people to click on ads on smartphones doesn't capture the entire scope of technology. Europe's economy is roughly as large as that of the United States. Many world-leading companies from the car industry, to chemicals, to biotech reside in Europe. The US holds one dominating advantage in one subset of technology. Consumer-facing internet tech. While a lot of people employed in this field commentate on this website, it's a marginal part of the tech industry, and it's not worth sacrificing privacy for, Europe does not need Silicon Valley to produce high-value products. And if adtech is supposed to be the definition of the future, rather than genomics, complex manufacturing and the life sciences than I'm okay with us skipping that part. There are business models that don't rely on sacrificing the attention and privacy of consumers.
- lajhsdfkl 8y ago>The US holds one dominating advantage in one subset of technology. Consumer-facing internet tech. While a lot of people employed in this field commentate on this website, it's a marginal part of the tech industry, and it's not worth sacrificing privacy for, Europe does not need Silicon Valley to produce high-value products. > it's a marginal part of the tech industry Hilarious
- ng12 8y agoThat's exactly my point. The EU is built for entrenched institutions. There is no entrepreneurial spirit -- and that's why there's N-number of self driving car companies in the US and zero(?) in the EU, for example.
- stale2002 8y agoHey, man, that's totally fine that you don't want those services. Which is why those services are responding by blocking all EU customers. Seems like a win win for everyone. Businesses don't have to deal with ounerous laws, and EU citizens don't get to use those services.
- lagadu 8y agoPlus it leaves the market open for other businesses who are actually compliant so they can capture a bigger slice of the market than the existing services. There really is a lot to win.
- zerostar07 8y agoif a preexisting startup doesn't care for the market, its probably because it's too small to be worth it. This is not 1999, most ideas have been tried at least once. And experience shows that "extra privacy" is just not a selling point.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> if a preexisting startup doesn't care for the market, its probably because it's too small to be worth it. It's not just that. It's that there is no money in cloning unsuccessful startups. Nobody wants to copy you until you're a success, but by then it's too late. By then the first mover has the momentum and resources. This doesn't change that. By the time a startup becomes successful it will have the resources to pay compliance costs and enter the other market. The problem is that having to exclude EU users until you're big enough to afford compliance will cause more ventures to die on the vine, before they ever become successful enough for anyone to want to copy them. It also puts the local EU startups at an obvious disadvantage, because they have to pay the compliance costs up front instead of only after proving themselves in the US market.
- closeparen 8y ago>No mechanical engineer would complain about safety regulation Mechanical engineering projects are too costly to be undertaken casually in the first place. Regulation is unlikely to be the long pole, so do you don't hear them complain about it. It only takes a few minutes and some easily self-teachable skills to start serving HTTP traffic; now it's going to take a few months and some lawyer hours to create the bureaucratic cover for doing so.
- ItsMe000001 8y ago> Mechanical engineering projects are too costly to be undertaken casually in the first place. Yes, because of the implications, as the parent said. Just making stuff is cheap these days, that's not just true for software. You don't have to build a factory, if you want you can even outsource the actual construction entirely if you don't want to go through the trouble and remain flexible, just like "cloud computing" using startups. > It only takes a few minutes and some easily self-teachable skills to start serving HTTP traffic; Because people do it without caring for or knowing the consequences. > now it's going to take a few months and some lawyer hours to create the bureaucratic cover for doing so. I don't understand your point, it's exactly what the parent said? Yes, this forces the startups to actually care about the consequences of what they are doing.