4 ms·
No, it's not the same. The lack of proportionality is precisely why the UK/EU is such a hard place to conduct business. These rules don't stop anything about a
by manigandham 8y ago
No, it's not the same. The lack of proportionality is precisely why the UK/EU is such a hard place to conduct business.
These rules don't stop anything about ads, they just make them less targeted. Not a big deal, but it will increase the costs of serving users and thus decrease the total amount of commercial projects started.
- Tomte 8y agoI find it funny to claim that the US could be more proportionate than the EU. Less targeted ads are exactly what we need. That's what the regulation aims for! Your argument is like claiming that unfortunately, due to car dafety regulations, we cannot enjoy as many fatal accidents as we once did. And to make my point of view clear: not all businesses deserve to exist. We as society decide which business models and behaviours are okay. "Decrease the total amount of commercial businesses started" cannot ever be a persuasive argument.
- manigandham 8y agoThis issue isnt about privacy... Nobody reasonable is arguing that it's a bad idea to let customers control their data. The actual issue is that the rules are vague and thus create a lot of confusion and waste that affects all companies, while not providing any real protection against the massive conglomerates that abuse data in the first place.
- knuththetruth 8y ago>The #1 complaint about ads is that they are not relevant, so this does nothing but increase that problem. The #1 complaint about advertising is that in 2018, it has evolved into a shadowy, insecure brokerage of surveillance data that it obtains using all kinds of under-handed tactics. If the GDPR curbs this in the slightest, it will be a net positive for people of Europe.
- manigandham 8y agoIt will not curb it. Facebook and Google who control 90% of the ad industry will already have consent from billions of people by the end of the day, and the increased regulation will only increase their market share as the safe and reliable avenue for advertisers and further strengthen their monopolies and data activities.
- Tomte 8y agoFacebook certainly doesn't have full consent under the GDPR. They are playing games, and don't respect the requirements that the GDPR puts on "consent": focussed, freely given (non-punitive), fully informed.
- manigandham 8y agoSure, one of the most valuable companies on the planet with an army of lawyers doesn't know what it's doing. Or maybe it's because the rules are confusing and messy and you have a different interpretation?
- hk__2 8y ago> Sure, one of the most valuable companies on the planet with an army of lawyers doesn't know what it's doing. This a fallacy, not an argument. [1] > Or maybe it's because the rules are confusing and messy and you have a different interpretation? Please point out which rules are confusing and/or messy. Virtualy every single blog post about GDPR points out how it’s well written compared to other juridictions on the same subject. The language is clear and the website provides a Q/A section as well as concrete example for every point. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_authority
- manigandham 8y agoYes, a company worth over half a trillion dollars with access to the best legal teams around the world has authority on whether it has done what it can to be compliant or not. And authority is how the legal system works, not everyone can just practice law without going through the proper education and licensing. > Please point out which rules are confusing and/or messy. The comment thread you just replied to -- the one where you seem to saying that random HN commenter is more accurate than Facebook's entire legal team on regulation that is supposed to be unequivocal -- is a start.
- solomatov 8y ago>Less targeted ads are exactly what we need. That's what the regulation aims for! I have nothing against targeted ads. I am against targeting ads and collecting/distributing my data without my explicit consent. E.g. mobile companies selling my real time location because there's some obscure sentence in their 90 page terms of service.
- takeda 8y agoAnd this is exactly what GDPR does, you then have an option to opt-in. I wish regulation like GDPR would also be implemented in US, but really unlikely.
- solomatov 8y ago>And this is exactly what GDPR does, you then have an option to opt-in. I mostly like GDPR. Ability to opt-in and being of charge of your data, i.e. removing it from a service if you want to, and the right to export and move it to another service are great and long due. What I don't like is that it's a principle based regulation and thus it can be applied arbitrarily and selectively.
- dennisgorelik 8y agoPlease learn from the experience of dealing with side effects of GDPR in EU first, before trying to push it to the US. The side effects would include: 1) Reduced number of services available to EU customers. 2) EU users will be trained to click "Agree" without reading, because web sites would ask them for permission very frequently, and users do not have time to read web site policies anyway.
- hk__2 8y ago> 1) Reduced number of services available to EU customers. That’s not a bad thing. If services that don’t want to protect their users’ privacy can’t operate, that’s a good thing. > 2) EU users will be trained to click "Agree" without reading, because web sites would ask them for permission very frequently, and users do not have time to read web site policies anyway. How does this have anything to do with GDPR?
- ajuc 8y ago> UK/EU is such a hard place to conduct business is it though? According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ease_of_doing_business_index#Ranking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ease_of_doing_business_index#R... USA is 3 positions behind Denmark which is in EU, and just one ahead of UK.