9 ms·
Golden Rice meets food safety standards in three leading regulatory agencies
- jseliger 8y agoThis is fantastic news; for more background on golden rice and the process of making better food, I recommend Charles C. Mann's book The Wizard and the Prophet: Two Remarkable Scientists and Their Dueling Visions to Shape Tomorrow's World. It's an amazing story, though the length of time it's taken to get golden rice from the lab to the market has been horrific.
- DubiousPusher 8y agoThanks for the rec. I recently read 1491 and really enjoyed it. So now I'm really looking forward to this.
- sp332 8y agoSince the page seems to be struggling to load https://web.archive.org/web/20180525203140/http://irri.org/news/media-releases/golden-rice-meets-food-safety-standards-in-three-global-leading-regulatory-agencies https://web.archive.org/web/20180525203140/http://irri.org/n... (ahem https://archive.org/donate/ https://archive.org/donate/)
- farnsworth 8y agoI'm not clear on what it exactly is - a hybrid of different rice varieties, or a GMO, or something else?
- ollin 8y agoPer Wikipedia: > Golden rice is a variety of rice (Oryza sativa) produced through genetic engineering to biosynthesize beta-carotene, a precursor of vitamin A, in the edible parts of rice.[1] It is intended to produce a fortified food to be grown and consumed in areas with a shortage of dietary vitamin A,[2] a deficiency which is estimated to kill 670,000 children under the age of 5 each year. So, yes, genetically-modified to produce more beta carotene.
- maoistinquisitr 8y agoWhich is fundamentally stupid because the beta-carotene to vitamin A pathway is highly limited. The whole idea is wrong. Vitamin A deficient people need vitamin A. Stuffing extra beta-carotene into them will just turn them orange and have other bad effects.
- robbrown451 8y agoIs this likely to be popular in areas of thew world where it isn't strictly needed, such as the US? I find it aesthetically appealing, although they don't say whether it tastes any different from white rice.
- wohlergehen 8y agoIf you want just the aesthetics, add just the tiniest bit of turmeric. It dyes like crazy and if you add little it adds nearly no taste.
- JasonFruit 8y agoOr saffron, which adds a subtle and addictive taste.
- roylez 8y agoIn retrospect, safe doesn't equal healthy, and the damage is usually recognized decades after. I don't think people know coke was unhealthy in the first day. GMO food is still very important though, considering globally we may have a food crisis. However, until that happens, nah, thank you.
- giggles_giggles 8y agoOne big reason we haven't had a global food crisis is because of GMO food. Norman Borlaug's (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norman_Borlaug#Expansion_to_South_Asia:_the_Green_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Norman_Borlaug#Expansion_to_So...) work in particular comes to mind as being almost single-handedly responsible for staving off massive famines. Part of that work involved selective breeding to produce a strain of wheat that would produce more output in the same acreage.
- KingMob 8y agoThat seems unlikely, given that we waste ~40% of all food produced (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_waste#Global_extent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Food_waste#Global_extent). I think distribution is a bigger issue than production methods. And that discounts any Black Swans lying in wait from transgenic organisms; we may still yet have a disaster, since GMOs don't yet have same track record as pre-industrial agriculture. OTOH, industrial agriculture has been pretty awful, so maybe GMOs are a step up from THAT...
- ben509 8y ago> given that we waste ~40% of all food produced That's a non-sequitur, and you're adding the loss stats in with waste. > And that discounts any Black Swans lying in wait from transgenic organisms; we may still yet have a disaster... Once it's a black swan, it's already discounted, the term itself means the thing is unlikely. I think the subject deserves more study, but we have people dying of hunger right now, and that's plainly more compelling than "something really bad might happen, we have no idea what, why or how likely it is."
- ysleepy 8y agoSo, is it safe to plant in the world or will it irrevocably merge into the gene pool of naturally occurring plants? This is the true concern about GMO, since people royally suck at introducing new species into ecosystems, an action that often cannot be undone.
- BurningFrog 8y agoRegular rice is absolutely not "naturally occurring". Also... where else would you plant it?
- oxryly1 8y ago> Also... where else would you plant it? I definitely prefer the Big Ag corps answering that question... and until they have an answer don't f*ck with the one environment we live in.
- Turing_Machine 8y ago> Regular rice is absolutely not "naturally occurring". Definitely not. Its genome differs from its wild ancestor in many respects. To name just one, like most domestic grains it's resistant to "shattering" (i.e., the seeds tend to remain attached to the plant, rather than falling off and/or being scattered when the plant is blown by the wind). That is a great feature for farmers, but means that the plant would likely go extinct in short order if left to itself (because the seeds wouldn't be scattered on the ground).
- John_KZ 8y agoWhat's the EU status?
- Kalium 8y agoAppears to be no verdict rendered as of yet.
- ScottBurson 8y agoMy default stance on GMOs is one of caution — in fact, I supported the failed California GMO labelling proposition — but really, I think that their risks and benefits should be evaluated individually. Lumping them all together, either for advocacy or for opposition, is like lumping together all synthetic pharmaceuticals. So although there are some GMOs I'm concerned about, Golden Rice is not one of them. I'm not an expert or anything, so take that for whatever you think it's worth, but nothing I've read suggests to me that it's likely to cause a problem. This could change given new information, but I don't think that those of us urging a certain caution do ourselves any favors by opposing every single GMO, even those that are pretty clearly beneficial.
- alexandercrohde 8y ago> This could change given new information, but I don't think that those of us urging a certain caution do ourselves any favors by opposing every single GMO, even those that are pretty clearly beneficial. If only we could say things are "clearly beneficial." However we still don't understand allergies, autoimmune disorders, or nutrition well. On top of that, there's the whole field of gut bacteria that we're just starting to take seriously. I reflexively push back because proponents won't admit GMO is a giant experiment. I'm open-minded on the idea of letting people experiment en-masse with their health. But considering 33% of Americans are obese, I'm not entirely sold from a pragmatic perspective.
- maxerickson 8y agoThe idea with golden rice isn't to feed it to fat Americans as a novelty, it is to make it available in countries where 650,000 children are dying each year from vitamin A deficiencies. Concerns about allergies and autoimmune disorders and such associated with golden rice are comparable to illiteracy, so be sure to wear it proudly.
- alexandercrohde 8y agoThen why is the US FDA approving it? Nowhere in this article does it say this won't be sold in America.
- Aelius 8y agoHuh. Didn't think HN would be the place to find anti science sentiments. Seeing a lot of antivaxxer type logic being employed here in the comments.
- hellowrld 8y agoFrom http://online.sfsu.edu/repstein/GEessays/goldenricehoax.html http://online.sfsu.edu/repstein/GEessays/goldenricehoax.html "In order to meet the full needs of 750 micrograms of vitamin A from [Golden] rice, an adult would have to consume 2 kg 272g of rice per day. This implies that one family member would consume the entire family ration of 10 kg from the PDS [?] in 4 days to meet vitamin A needs through "Golden rice". This is a recipe for creating hunger and malnutrition, not solving it. Besides creating vitamin A deficiency, vitamin A rice will also create deficiency in other micronutrients and nutrients. Raw milled rice has a low content of Fat (0.5g/100g). Since fat is necessary for vitamin A uptake, this will aggravate vitamin A deficiency. It also has only 6.8g/100g of protein, which means less carrier molecules. It has only 0.7g/100g of iron, which plays a vital role in the conversion of Betacarotene (precursor of vitamin A found in plant sources) to vitamin A. Superior Alternatives exist and are effective. A far more efficient route to removing vitamin A efficiency is biodiversity conservation and propagation of naturally vitamin A rich plants in agriculture and diets." -Vandana Shiva
- kazinator 8y agoNote that this 2.2 kg of rice by dry weight!!! Rice something like triples in weight when cooked, so we're talking almost 7 kg of cooked rice.
- maxerickson 8y agoA later golden rice has a bit more than 20x the beta carotene. So like 100 grams of rice by dry weight, a modest single serving (300 or 400 calories).
- Turing_Machine 8y agoWhat you have posted is a link to a second-hand opinion piece that was copied from an old Tripod site. Here's a peer-reviewed journal article that provides real data: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2682994/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2682994/ Note that they found that a) Vitamin A is readily absorbed from the golden rice and b) their estimate is that 50 grams of golden rice per day would be sufficient to provide the RDA for a child.
- cmroanirgo 8y agoI remember seeing a documentary on this is the past. The main things I got from it was: 1. It was designed for countries with high levels of Vit A deficiency (as other comments have noted). Those countries now use simple Vit A pills. There is no need for 'Golden Rice'. 2. It has been trialled in Asia but due to it's yellow colour, the people didn't even want to eat it. In their mind, rice is always white. I also seem to recall that it is a project that has failed in a few countries to be accepted as a replacement for traditional rice. I do not understand why FDA approval was sought, nor why it's for sale in the US. This documentary (it might be the one I vaguely remember) shows how the Phillipines has a government programme which gives Vit A pills twice a year: https://youtu.be/TPRqRjCT_vE?t=11m6s https://youtu.be/TPRqRjCT_vE?t=11m6s EDIT: (formatting)
- baybal2 8y agoIn the meanwhile, I was struggling to find a normal "asian" rice in Russia few months ago. Have not found a single store that sold IR8 like rice.
- petesh 8y agoNote, from the FDA letter: "... the concentration of B-carotene in GR2E rice is too low to warrant a nutrient content claim ..."