4 ms·
It astonishes me how rapidly San Francisco has mobilized to get the scooters off the street in comparison to how little they have been able to accomplish to get
by ChuckMcM 8y ago
It astonishes me how rapidly San Francisco has mobilized to get the scooters off the street in comparison to how little they have been able to accomplish to get the poop, needles, and condoms off the same streets.
I know which I would choose, if I was told to pick one or the other to be removed from city streets.
- sjburt 8y agoI don't think anyone is trying to run a poop-sharing business that the city can go after.
- anothergoogler 8y agoIf the poop is free, are you the product?
- danso 8y agoWhy would it astonish you? The posted article is about proposed regulations, not resources for enforcement. Is it the case that San Francisco has no laws regarding littering and public defecation?
- JumpCrisscross 8y ago> The posted article is about proposed regulations, not resources for enforcement. Proposing and negotiating regulations and creating a pilot permitting regime costs money and, more expensively, attention. It is remarkable that, given the multitude of political failures currently going on in San Francisco, that this has been prioritized.
- deft 8y agowhich would you rather go clean up?
- ChuckMcM 8y agoIf I were a city supervisor looking to maximize the health and welfare of people walking on my city's sidewalks, I would fund getting rid of the disease threat before I spent funds on the mechanical threat.
- olefoo 8y agoYes. Let's get rid of the messy, inconvenient, disease ridden humans. All hail the robots; rightful inheritors of San Francisco. /s
- Karrot_Kream 8y agoNobody needs to get _rid_ of the humans. We can use the enforcement money and energy on removing shared scooters to building restrooms for the homeless and having a dedicated street cleaning force to power wash streets.
- heckanoobs 8y agoSF already has those things. The bathrooms are expensive because they need technology that prevents ppl from hanging out in them, so they automatically lock down and power wash the inside after every use. The sidewalk cleaning is also expensive, it costs the city millions per year to power wash the civic center sidewalks every morning. And that's just a fraction of the area. These expensive things don't make the city better they just improve the quality of life for the homeless population, which can now boom until the quality is right back where it started. Would you then add even more bathrooms and street cleaners in response or realize that cleaning the mess isn't going to solve this problem?
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoOne is a well defined company you can sue into oblivion, the other are homeless people with almost no assets who are probably in and out of jail all the time. See also the difference in fighting a well defined country in a war (which can be won) and fighting an insurgency (which is much harder to win).
- ChuckMcM 8y agoOn the surface yes. But to sue a company into oblivion you have to create statutes (legislation time cost) and create a process for identifying violations (do cops do this? meter maids? city workers?) establish a legal team task force to handle those prosecutions (more money for the DA? a new team? outside counsel?), follow through those prosecutions (court costs, sheriff costs), and finally collect judgements (collection costs) As compared to putting accessible restrooms and disposal bins around the city and cleaning them weekly.
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoOne could argue that putting out more street side bike racks would also help the problem if you are arguing that rule enforcement isn’t the answer.
- conanbatt 8y agoThe city government has failed. San Francisco will not improve its homelessness situation until it gets get by an economic crisis. I think the city is done for. It will hit a growth ceiling on population and taxes, but homelessness will keep rising and property prices will be unaccessible. As lower income people leave the city, it will devour everything.
- bytematic 8y agoMadison, WI did the same thing. I think both issues can be tackled in parallel though
- heckanoobs 8y agoI would love it if people who think SF's homeless problem is easily solvable would create startups to solve it. Unfortunately they're all busy making the fourth, fifth, sixth, electric scooter company
- dahdum 8y agoSolving homelessness is a very high bar, and I don’t think anyone thinks that’s an easy issue to tackle. However SF is uniquely failing to prevent feces, needles, and condoms off the streets. To prevent public daylight IV drug abuse in the densest city center. To prevent tens of thousands of car breakins from happening on organized crime scales. All while spending ever more money putting little band aids on the problem, like increased budgets for feces removal. These aren’t problems most cities faces on that scale, why is SF struggling so much comparatively?
- heckanoobs 8y agoI think the climate has a big role in this. In NYC you see the same homeless ppl for about a year, then the hard winter weather hits and they (hopefully) head somewhere warmer. NYC citizens don't have these difficult conversations that SF citizens have looming over them, because the climate conveniently and quietly wipes the slate every year. SF on the other hand can be a forever destination with outdoor livable weather year round.