3 ms·
Careful. Much of the consciousness is more than the brain argument arrises from pro-life religious groups. They argue that brain death, or lack of a physical
by sandworm101 8y ago
Careful. Much of the consciousness is more than the brain argument arrises from pro-life religious groups. They argue that brain death, or lack of a physical brain, does not preclude consciousness. This is to support anti-abortion rules and prevent the removal of life support from the brain dead. These arguments are a minefield of religious dogma.
- zepto 8y agoYes! We should only consider ideas that nobody anywhere is misusing.
- krageon 8y agoMaybe where you are, but not where I am from. Here, you are considered a religious extremist if you do not support abortion (and I think that this is the reasonable stance, but that is not relevant right now). I'm thus not very concerned with what secondary agenda you associate this argument, and I will definitely not be careful of having an uncertain stance just because this is the case.
- CalRobert 8y agoHuh, have heard a lot of arguments from pro lifers lately and this wasn't one of them. A discussion of the nature of consciousness and its mechanisms would have been refreshingly elevated, to be honest. Incidentally we're having a vote today on that very topic.