4 ms·
Yes, indeed, I hesitated to use that word. However, unless it's a zero cost perfect hedge is a gamble in one way or another. Suppose our hypothetical farmer ca
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
Yes, indeed, I hesitated to use that word. However, unless it's a zero cost perfect hedge is a gamble in one way or another.
Suppose our hypothetical farmer can buy a put option to underpin the sale price. He probably needs to borrow, or put up a large portion of his liquid capital -- having no working capital, or being exposed to a large debt makes buying the option risky, and if the price rises/doesn't fall heavily then he took on that risk with no physical gain. Repaying the debt, or handling other contingencies without sufficient capital could then sink the farmer.
I'll bet those farmers don't have buildings insurance either.
It becomes a gamble if one is subsisting.
That's not to say anything about power dynamics, a lone farmer is going to get a put option from an international buyer that heavily favours the buyer -- otherwise the buyer is acting unreasonably.
It may not be entirely rational but poor people often have no insurance.
- sokoloff 9y ago> Suppose our hypothetical farmer can buy a put option to underpin the sale price. Futures and options are different. Options are the right but not the obligation to buy or sell at a given price and time (and often at any point up until that time). This optionality comes at a high price. Futures are the right AND the obligation to buy or sell at a given price and time. This construct, because of a better balance between buyers and sellers [of the contract], costs much[, much] less per $1M than options. > It becomes a gamble if one is subsisting. Life is a gamble by that measure. I tend to think that things that reduce overall variance to be hedges and things that increase variance to be gambling. Selling futures against a future crop harvest for me is on the reduce variance/hedge side of the line, by a lot. Buying jet fuel futures as an airline? Same.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoThere's a gamble in selling a future too - if your crop fails and you have to buy yourself out of your obligation. The upstream supplier can afford to do so, especially if they can buy on a different continent if a widespread famine/drought happens. Of course for an airline with ready access to capital then the risk is virtually zero in buying futures; it is always going to be a hedge. Cashflow in that situation will be very different though. Capital is king, as they say.
- sokoloff 8y agoYes, I think you're observing that there is no way to guarantee a risk-free profit in business against all possible outcomes.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoOk, I think it's more nuanced than that. Loosely my hypothesis is - the ability to hedge risks is curtailed for those at the leading edge of commodity production in developing nations because of the tiny margins; whilst those further up the chain who're relying on the labour of the poorest are able to hedge because they have access to ready capital and aren't subsisting. The risk is unfairly loaded on those receiving a disproportionately small share of the profit from their production. I don't think that's quite the facile truism you're characterising it as. HN appears to see an impossibility in someone not being able to afford to hedge effectively - so it seems I'm wrong? Perhaps no developing world commodity producer ever fails or suffers privations, because they can all afford to hedge all their risks./s
- sokoloff 8y agoCrop failure has been a risk for farmers for over 10,000 years. This is not a capitalist introduction; the penalties for crop failure used to be far more dire. Today, whether or not the risk is "unfairly" spread or the share of surplus is "disproportionately small" is a matter of opinion.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoSeriously? No one suggested it was an imposition of any financial culture - just that mitigation of risk is costly. However, I can't imagine what sort of ignorance leads one to believe, as it appears, there's no unfairness in distribution of profits or risks in comestible (or pretty much any) supply chain.