10 ms·
Tesla needs to sell more expensive Model 3s so the company doesn’t ‘die’
- bryanlarsen 8y agoA car that's unprofitable at a rate of 3000 per week might be highly profitable at 10000 per week.
- abc_lisper 8y agoOnly if the fixed costs are not a large part of the price.
- caconym_ 8y agoIt's like the Michael Scott Paper Company all over again.
- mediaman 8y agoYou mean, only if the fixed costs are a large part of the price? Fixed costs don't scale with production because they're fixed. If variable costs are nearly all the cost of production, then scaling production doesn't fix anything.
- abc_lisper 8y agoYeah. It’s mildly sarcastic. The costs of machinery, factory, people are fixed. They are not breaking even because they are not working at full capacity
- babuskov 8y ago"We lose money of every sale, but we make it up on volume"
- inteleng 8y agoIdiotic comment.
- xkjkls 8y agoThe article does a bad job explaining what "unprofitable" means. Unprofitable on a pure gross margin perspective? After you take into account warranties or financing? Unprofitable after you amortize R&D? It should be more clear on what they mean finance-wise there.
- bryanlarsen 8y agoThat's what happens when you create an article out of a couple of tweets.
- otalp 8y agoSummary of Tesla's situation: - Tesla currently has 2.67 billion in cash. - About 1.1 billion of this is in loans that need to be returned early next year - Around 40% of their cash in hand is from refundable deposits, from people who thought they would get a $35k car - Tesla cannot make $35k M3s at a profit(this is widely accepted, and even Tesla hinted at it), they'll lose money even making $42k cars. They need to make $50k cars to earn a decent profit - When asked in the earning call last week about reservations and how many people chose to cancel/take up their car once offered, Musk stunningly called the question "boring" and "boneheaded" and went on take questions from a youtuber for 20 mins. This was considered unprecedented and bizarre and stock dove. - Tesla is losing about 800-900 million a quarter, so they will run out of money without a cash infusion. Literally everyone knows that Tesla will need to raise capital this year. - Musk though, has insisted that Tesla will not need to raise cash because they will be "profitable by Q3 or Q4". Reminder that they lost 780 million in Q1, and even small profits won't be enough to prevent running out of cash. In order to make profits they need to sell 10,000 cars a week. They were supposed to produce 5000 cars a week in 2017. They have just now been able to produce 2500/week. - Even bulls say that Musk is bluffing and he will eventually raise cash this year. Moody's downgrade of Tesla to essentially junk stocks makes it harder to raise cash at good interest rates. Moreover, there is speculation and some evidence that the reason Tesla haven't already done so, is that they are under SEC investigation which would prevent them from raising cash without disclosing a lot of details harmful to them. - Tesla has access to standard credit lines for about 500 million, but they recently had to pledge their Fremont factory to just maintain these credit lines. - A lot of Tesla's financial executives have left the company - a red flag to many including Jim Chanos, who famously shorted Enron due to similar indicators. The head of autopilot left and the head of engineering left 'for vacation' last week. - Tesla's autopilot is complete false advertising. Their original autopilot was developed by MobilEye. MobilEye hated tesla's exaggeration of the system's capabilities and withdrew their supply after a person died using autopilot. Tesla responded that mobileye was jealous of Tesla's superior "Enhanced Autopilot" which has hardware capable of full self driving. It is universally accepted that enhanced autopilot is worse than mobileye's system right now, and in general both are basically lane-keeping system with AEB. Waymo and GM/Cruise are far ahead with their FSD capabilities than Tesla(again, widely accepted) - Part of Tesla's debt comes from bailing out Solar City, a completely unprofitable company loaded with debt that was run by Musk's cousins. - Starting from 2019 and 2020, all the major automakers are bringing out electric models. This will further damage Tesla's competitiveness, since they have the wost QA and build quality due to their haphazard and panicked development process Despite all this, the market cap of tesla is larger than Ford, Fiat and nearly equal to GM. Their inflated market cap(which even Musk admits is inflated) is fuelling their funding which inflates the market cap even more as they lose more money trying to make bigger promises. A classic example of a huge bubble. What does Tesla have to it's advantage? Tremendous marketing and brand value. They're probably inching towards or even surpassing Apple What does Tesla have against it? The realities of running a business and actually making the products.
- lgbr 8y ago> it is also likely to cannibalize sales of the Model S so the net benefit to the bottom line might be negligible I'm skeptical of this. This is like saying that BMW's 1-series cannibalizes sales of its 3-series. There's a huge difference in comfort, space, performance, and practicality between the Model S and the 3. If a Model S is at all within your budget, even the base Model S is going to be a whole lot more car than almost any Model 3. Beyond that, there's easy ways for Tesla to sweeten the deal. For me, Tesla offering free supercharging on the Model S but not on the Model 3 had me order a Model S immediately.
- dragontamer 8y ago> Beyond that, there's easy ways for Tesla to sweeten the deal. For me, Tesla offering free supercharging on the Model S but not on the Model 3 had me order a Model S immediately. Why not just buy supercharging on the Model3?
- Bedon292 8y agoThey aren't offering unlimited supercharging on the 3. It is just pay per use. Unlimited has a lot of value to it over a lifetime.
- lgbr 8y agoBecause free supercharging easily makes up for the price difference. Some poeple use something like 4 supercharges a week, which at $20 a charge means $160/month.
- dragontamer 8y ago> Because free supercharging easily makes up for the price difference. Some poeple use something like 4 supercharges a week, which at $20 a charge means $160/month. 4-supercharges a week implies ~1000+ miles per week. And its only ~$9 a super-charge last time I checked (https://twitter.com/TheRealPTFI/status/920306238830735361/photo/1 https://twitter.com/TheRealPTFI/status/920306238830735361/ph...) If the car lasts to 300,000 miles at 250-miles per super-charge and $10 per charge, that's $12,000 over the lifetime of the car. And that's a relatively extreme case. No charging at home, no charging at work, no charging anywhere except at super-chargers for all 300,000 miles of your car's lifetime. An absolutely absurd result but still doesn't make the Model3 comparable to ModelS. And hell if I'm going to a charger if I buy a car like this. I'm buying a home-charging station so that I don't ever have to go somewhere else to charge. Charge at night every day forevermore. ----------- Note that the Model S and Model X only receive 400kWh of supercharger credits per year (~1000 miles). So what, that's like $100 / year?? After that, you have to pay supercharger fees. So its not like your extreme use case even saves much money.
- practice9 8y agoAn offtopic note, but those analysts' comments included in the article made me smile. They now as much as the next guy on hackernews or reddit.. How about old good "wait and see what happens"?
- thisisit 8y agoOn Tesla's viability, stock price and debt, I think there can't be better quote than this: Tesla’s current price is arguably fair if most cars are powered by electricity in 10 years, if most of these cars are made by Tesla, if Tesla can make those cars with sufficient margin and quality control and can service the cars properly, and if Tesla can raise additional capital sufficient to cover a $3 billion annual cash drain and another billion to service its debt. https://www.researchaffiliates.com/en_us/publications/articles/668-yes-its-a-bubble-so-what.html https://www.researchaffiliates.com/en_us/publications/articl...
- Analemma_ 8y agoI like this quote, because it seems to be something that TSLA bulls and bears can mostly agree on and thus gets to the heart of the actual empirical disagreements between them. For my part, I'm a Tesla skeptic because my evaluations on the likelihood of those clauses are: > "most cars are powered by electricity in 10 years" Unlikely. The average age of a car on the road is about 11.5 years (source: http://news.ihsmarkit.com/press-release/automotive/average-age-vehicles-road-remains-steady-114-years-according-ihs-automotive http://news.ihsmarkit.com/press-release/automotive/average-a...), so even if electric vehicle sales went to 100% tomorrow (and they won't), this wouldn't be true. It's possible fuel prices will skyrocket in the meantime and get people to scrap their ICEs, but with fracking and other deep extraction, I wouldn't bet on it. > "most of these cars are made by Tesla" Unlikely. Even if Tesla becomes a healthy and established carmarker, I can't imagine a situation where they are the only one selling electric cars in the late 2020's. Everyone else is getting their electric cars onto the road, and outside the HN bubble, most people are not so enamored with Tesla that they would refuse to even consider buying something else. > "if Tesla can make those cars with sufficient margin and quality control" Possible, but I think it's unlikely. Despite year after year of promises by Musk, Tesla still struggles with both margins and quality control, and I haven't seen any evidence that it's getting better (and there's every reason to believe it will get worse as they seem a bit desperate to scale up production) > " if Tesla can raise additional capital sufficient to cover a $3 billion annual cash drain and another billion to service its debt." I don't know enough about financial markets to make a solid guess here, but this seems iffy to me in light of all the other givens about Tesla, especially if markets tighten in the next few years (up until now, Tesla has had the good fortune to need cash-raising in an era of low interest rates, cheap money and bull markets. That may not be the case the next time they need capital) Hence, I'm a bear. I don't necessarily think Tesla will go out of business, but I think their current valuation is absurd.
- transfire 8y agoDear Mr. Musk, If you can make me a TRON-like one-to-two seat motor pod, for around $10,000 then you can take my money. Sincerely, The Guy Who Really Wants a TRON-like One-To-Two Seat Motor Pod
- consumer451 8y agoIt's an estimated $15,400 single seat, but these folks may have you covered. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ElectraMeccanica#SOLO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ElectraMeccanica#SOLO
- robin_reala 8y agoRenault Twizy? Add some glow-in-the-dark pinstriping and you’re there and just a little over budget (~$10.5k converted from £).
- ataturk 8y agoI only want one if it can expel the solid wall of light behind it.
- andrepd 8y agoRenault Twizy?
- matte_black 8y agoBased off of Elon Musk's last tweet, it sounds like he's preparing to leave the company. Can Tesla do this without him?
- fetus8 8y agoMaybe that's exactly what they need, a different "leader", maybe someone with a bit more experience in the manufacturing space...
- MBCook 8y agoSeems like Honda or Toyota or Ford or someone who actually knows how to make cars needs to buy them and fix this. Tesla’s electric car plumbing seems to be fantastic but they can’t make a good car on top of it (at volume, price, quality, and on time). Selling their tech to someone who knows how to do that would be an amazing combination. I suppose they could go straight licensing too. But I think it’s clear they can’t continue as is, they’re doomed that way.
- matte_black 8y agoAgreed. At this point Elon is holding onto Tesla leadership for egotistical reasons. He's done a good job getting the company up and running but it's time to hand the reins over to someone who actually knows what they're doing when it comes to pumping out cars.