7 ms·
The background for the article is 'tilt erosion time' and the large number of tidally locked planets in the habitable zones of numerous low-mass stars. Many
by nabla9 9y ago
The background for the article is 'tilt erosion time' and the large number of tidally locked planets in the habitable zones of numerous low-mass stars. Many new discovered planets are tidally locked: Kepler-438b, Kepler-442b, K2-3d, K2-155d. It was previously assumed that tidally locked planets would not be habitable. New climate modeling seems to change this view.
No snowball on habitable tidally locked planets
https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.08904 https://arxiv.org/abs/1705.08904
Stabilizing Cloud Feedback Dramatically Expands the Habitable Zone of Tidally Locked Planets
https://arxiv.org/abs/1307.0515 https://arxiv.org/abs/1307.0515
Tidal obliquity evolution of potentially habitable planet
s
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1101.2156.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1101.2156.pdf
- jerf 9y ago"New climate modeling seems to change this view." And this modeling was confirmed to be accurate... how, exactly? This strikes me as a classic case of goosing the model until it says what you want it to say, and then getting in the news. We have no reason to believe these models. We have no reason to believe prior models, either. We have no reason to have any confidence in our ability to model a tidally locked planet, of unknown and arbitrary chemistry, around an unknown star, for unknown periods of time, with unknown orbital characteristics across geological time, with zero data points. We particularly have no reason to believe in any estimates of how long such a system could last; it doesn't seem to do life much good if there's a place for it to exist for a couple of million years, followed by freezing. The simulation is almost certainly unstable here; very small changes in the stability of this configuration will have massive changes to the result over even a few million years. There's also more to life than just a comfortable temperature. Life is possible on Earth in part because we have a moon and plate tectonics keeping this stirred up, so some of our vital nutrients don't just sequester themselves somewhere chemically convenient after a couple of million years and then hang out there for the rest of the planet's existence. Do these types of planets have a solution for that? We have no idea. (One advantage of the Earthlike planets is that we do in fact have an idea... we know it's at least possible once.)
- nabla9 9y ago>We have no reason to believe these models .... What is your level of expertise or knowledge of planetary astrophysics and climate modeling?
- jerf 9y agoSufficient to know our data point count is zero, and the model can not possibly have been verified against anything. This does not require extensive study. Furthermore, as a bona fide, credentialed expert in computer science, I observe with the full power of my credentials that other fields frequently abuse modeling to get into the news, and that as I said, this shows all the hallmarks of being one of those. There is a profound, mathematical way in which models simply spit back out at you what you put in. This profound mathematical understanding seems to be broadly lacking, and it makes people grant wildly excessive credence to unverified models. As just a single for instance, I expect you have no idea how many models they ran that produced lifeless planets until they finally found one that yielded a result conducive to life. Given the almost-certainty that these systems are deeply, deeply unstable, I expect it is almost certainly the case that they had a large number of runs where the system simply ran away in one direction or another. Edit: I challenge the downmodders to produce a single data point about an eyeball planet in a habitable zone and demonstrate a model that correctly represents it. "We have to have data before we can verify a model" is not some sort of wild anti-scientific statement; the belief that a model can be trusted without validation is the wildly anti-scientific position! If some of you are mistaking this for a position on the climate debate, note that we do have data for Earth's climate. Not as much as we might like (could always use more!), but it's certainly much greater than zero. You can literally get more than zero data just by walking outside and observing the temperature right where you are. This point has nothing to do with the climate debate on Earth.
- duncan_bayne 9y agoPerhaps relevant is that we have also been very bad at modelling the recent and short term future climate of our own damn planet! Things are finally settling down to the point where models match independent data, e.g. the recent research into sea level changes as measured by satellite. So now, finally, we can start making informed policy choices based on cost benefit analysis. (Actually, no, who am I kidding - Greens worldwide will keep hating on industry and capitalism, and everyone else will keep pretending AGW isn't real. But at least we could start forming rational policies if we wanted.) Back on topic, to assume that we can make any kind of predictions about the climate of life bearing exoplanets seems like the height of arrogance given the state of the art in climate modelling.