4 ms·
Is there a country that has tried "regular property rights, except for real-estate, which is owned entirely by the state and leased directly to its current tena
by derefr 9y ago
Is there a country that has tried "regular property rights, except for real-estate, which is owned entirely by the state and leased directly to its current tenants with no subleasing"? So e.g. an "apartment building" would be a building owned by the state, segmented into units, each of which would be rented from the state to individual tenants; and a "house" would be a building owned by the state with the whole thing rented to one tenant.
In such a situation, there'd be no real real-estate speculation, and levels of rent-extraction above cost would be controlled by municipal bylaw (as they'd effectively be a tax.) Property development companies would all either be nationalized, or would be private government-exclusive subcontractors.
Basically: imagine China, but instead of privatizing every industry all at once, they had kept construction and property management state-run. How would that look?
- namibj 9y agoMaybe soviet Russia/GDR?
- v_lisivka 9y agoYou can fly to Russia or North Korea and see it by your own eyes. In short: very small and cheap apartments and lack of up-keeping.
- gowld 9y agoChina does^Hdid this for real estate. https://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahsu/2017/03/21/good-news-for-chinese-homeowners-premier-li-offers-some-clarity-on-land-leases/#511e4ccc7b4a https://www.forbes.com/sites/sarahsu/2017/03/21/good-news-fo... "Last Wednesday, Premier Li Keqiang said a real estate protection provision that would ensure individual’s access to property under a 70-year lease would be renewed unconditionally is being drafted. This will help to quell ongoing fears that wealth garnered from one generation will be removed after the 70-year lease ends by the government. And while this does not address the fate of 20-year leases, the precedent set in Wenzhou may be replicated in other areas."
- tacostakohashi 9y agoThat's basically the Housing Development Board system in Singapore.
- wahern 9y agoIn Malaysia, Singapore, and Hong Kong (all common law jurisdictions) leaseholds are more common, I think, than freeholds, at least until very recently. Leasehold estates are commonly 99 years or less (50, 60, 75, etc). I don't know how well this works (I only have a superficial knowledge of the property market from my travels and relations) but I imagine it becomes a problem when you have major improvements. For example, imagine a condominium. As a political matter the government isn't going to kick out 100 tenants just because the leasehold on the land terminated. So I suspect that in terms of revenue the governments are no better off than relying on property taxes. In the few cases I'm personally familiar with the typical scenario seems to be that the government offers renewal terms at a highly discounted rate a couple of decades before the lease expires. It seems like a pointless contrivance. Certainly freeholds are nicer from the perspective of efficient markets because you don't have arbitrary dates to contend with. Imagine trying to sell land with only 10 years remaining on the leasehold. The seller can expect very little, which is to be expected and not per se problematic. But more importantly 10 years limits the types of things you can use the land for, especially if you're risk averse. In general buyers will find it difficult to find land with a remaining term long enough to recapture the value of improvements, so liquidity would suffer significantly. Seems to me property taxes are a much simpler, more consistent, and theoretically fairer way for governments to capture the value of land. And that's ignoring Henry George-style land-value taxes. I suppose leaseholds may make it easier for governments to actually kick people off land if they're committed to doing so. The end of the lease is a nice, neutral date to implement some difficult policy objective.
- lr4444lr 9y agoWhat is the typical term length on mortgages there? If someone needs to refi when there are too few years on the lease than the person can come up with in principal for that many years, there's going to be some serious pain all around.
- wahern 8y agoThat's a great point. I don't know enough to answer, though. Here's a short, interesting article a quick Google search found: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/housing/understanding-what-happens-at-the-end-of-a-99-year-lease https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/housing/understanding... What caught my eye was "And when the flat reaches 69 years, CPF savings cannot be used to finance the mortgages." CPF is the mandatory savings program, sort of like Social Security and Medicare, except you can borrow against it. So basically if there's only 30 years left on a leasehold you can't borrow against your CPF account. My guess is that as the leasehold nears expiry your ability to securitize simply goes down to nothing, probably long before termination. And even before then you probably start paying a premium because if you default the bank is stuck with a rapidly depreciating asset. From what little I've gleaned from my travels and from the academic literature, I think Americans enjoy an exceptionally liquid property market and efficient financing market, particularly for residential property.