4 ms·
Because eventually, you could just lease a new car and not worry about maintenance or warranty or your own safety anymore. My mum has a 2005 car which she conti
by gambiting 9y ago
Because eventually, you could just lease a new car and not worry about maintenance or warranty or your own safety anymore. My mum has a 2005 car which she continues running due to the reasoning of "why change the car if this one works" - and that's correct, but I added up all the repairs we did to it in 2017 and the parts + labour totaled about ~$6000 in that one year, and it looks like 2018 will at least match that. ~$6000/year gives you $500/month that could go towards a lease on a brand new car and then you don't have to worry about anything, instead of pumping money into a car that will eventually break down in such a way that fixing it will cost more than it's worth.
- matwood 9y ago$12k over 2 years for maintenance seems extremely excessive. That can replace the whole engine in a small car. It could also mean the car never had any proper maintenance done (like oil changes), and now serious engine parts are having to be repaired. I have a '05 Tundra and just had to replace the entire ABS system, so while it was being worked on also did all of the belts, water pump, etc... and came in ~4k. There shouldn't be any maintenance except oil and maybe tires for the next 2-4 years.
- gambiting 9y agoIt's a Land Rover Discovery 3 - we had to have the whole undercarriage redone because it was getting some serious rust, so it had to be sand blasted and re-done from scratch, that alone was about $4000. Then we spent $1000 on a set of new summer tyres(winters will come next this year I suspect), and the A/C compressor seized up completely - that was about $1000 for the part + labour. This year we had to do the suspension maintenance, replace the brushings etc, that came to about $1500. Then the rear locking differential broke, it was about $2000 for a new one + labour. And just last week the car went into limp mode, the suspension lowered, the transmission wouldn't really shift - had to get the car towed to a LR garage. Turned out to be some tiny sensor, but diagnostics, plus part plus labour plus towing came to about $500. Then you have the annual maintenance, but that's not a lot compared to the rest. The car has about 200k miles on it and actually the engine runs absolutely fine, no issues there. Yes, I guess it's a very complicated car with loads of electronics that can go wrong, and when they do go wrong it's expensive. But it's not a far fetched idea that my mum would be better off with getting a brand new car which doesn't suffer from random issues where you have to get the car towed to the garage.
- matwood 9y agoOuch. Those old Land Rovers are known to have issues, but people love them. $12k over 2 years is still cheaper than buying a new one for $50k+. Obviously it's a different conversation if your mom is willing to step down to a small Japanese hatchback or something cost efficient. Otherwise, it is like a guy I know complaining about paying $600 to replace the headlight assembly in his Porsche. Well yeah, it's a Porche.
- philliphaydon 9y agoThose old land rovers rust like crazy for people who go to the beach and never wash their car after, the salt water (even when you drive near the beach and not on) causes major rust.