6 ms·
This is a sadly dishonest sounding comparison... "The train runs at a top speed of 79 miles per hour on the leg between Miami and Fort Lauderdale compared to a
by BurningFrog 9y ago
This is a sadly dishonest sounding comparison...
"The train runs at a top speed of 79 miles per hour on the leg between Miami and Fort Lauderdale compared to an average speed of about 34 miles per hour for cars"
- matte_black 9y agoIndeed, the average speed is likely lower. Traffic from Miami to Ft Lauderdale is horrendous in rush hour.
- ubernostrum 9y agoTop speed of 79 is also the case for Caltrain in the SF Bay area. Which only happens on certain stretches of track, and can be affected by how many stops a particular train needs to make or how many others are ahead of it.
- melling 9y agoWhat’s the average speed? For a distance of 30 miles, shouldnt we be able to build a train that averages 60 mph for 30 minutes? China is working on low-speed maglevs.
- ComradeTaco 9y agoIts possible to achieve substantially higher speeds, but that would require grade separation and electrification, which are much too expensive for a private company to take on.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoThe maglev in Changsha between the airport and HSR station runs at 100km/hour. It is on a viaduct for much of its path, however, and isn’t very urban (goes nowhere near downtown Changsha). It only averages 57km with stops. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Changsha_Maglev_Express https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Changsha_Maglev_Express
- stirlo 9y agoHaving ridden on the Changsha Maglev I wouldn't suggest its a very well refined design. Lots of shuddering and certainly didn't seem designed for anything much more than commuter speed.
- bobthepanda 9y agoThe problem is the rule of diminishing returns. Unless you want your passengers vomiting everywhere, there are limits to how quickly you can accelerate and decelerate, and you spend less and less time going at the top speed. It's why subways don't generally bother going much above a 50-70MPH top speed. Unless you're building a straight line, you need larger and larger curves to accommodate high speed traffic, which makes the cost of higher speed rise significantly since you can't just buy a curve and split a property in two. A train going at 220 km/h has a minimum curve radius of 2.5km; a train at 300 km/h has a minimum curve radius of 4km; and a train at 350 km/h has a minimum curve radius of 7km.
- melling 9y agoWhat about a train going 120 kph (75mph)? No one said you need to go 300 kph. What’s an acceptable time to accelerate to that speed?
- bobthepanda 9y agoThe train already has a top speed of 79mph. Anything further requires new investments in signalling and whatnot according to American regulations, because that tends to be the speed at which wayside signalling becomes hard to see.
- melling 9y agoA lot of trains have a high top speed yet average under 50 mph. What’s it take to get the average speed to 120 kph, for example?
- masklinn 9y ago> The problem is the rule of diminishing returns. Unless you want your passengers vomiting everywhere, there are limits to how quickly you can accelerate and decelerate This thing has 30mn legs (Miami to Ft Lauredale and Ft Lauredale and West Palm Beach have no intermediate stops), it's not a commuter rail. Subways have a few minutes (and km) between stations. French regional trains run this kind of route in under 20mn: https://www.google.fr/maps/dir/Dijon+Gare,+Dijon,+France/Beaune,+Beaune,+France/@47.1736448,4.8004868,11z/am=t/data=!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x47f29d941a8e4e09:0x1780bd7e0436c84e!2m2!1d5.0279!2d47.323534!1m5!1m1!1s0x47f2f339cb36834d:0x517cc661f66110c5!2m2!1d4.8485343!2d47.022977!3e3 https://www.google.fr/maps/dir/Dijon+Gare,+Dijon,+France/Bea... And from experience I can tell you that they can be used comfortably standing, they accelerate no faster than a subway.
- ubernostrum 9y agoThe full Caltrain line is around 77 miles long. Just the San Jose <-> San Francisco portion is ~47 miles. Caltrain's timetables give the following for San Jose Diridon Station to San Francisco 4th and King Station, weekday service: * Train 101, local, 20 stops, 04:28 -- 06:03 (1 hour 35 minutes) * Train 207, local south half / limited north half, 12 stops, 05:59 -- 07:24 (1 hour 25 minutes) * Train 211, limited south half / local north half, 17 stops, 06:23 -- 07:57 (1 hour 34 minutes) * Train 215, limited, 9 stops, 06:54 -- 08:07 (1 hour 13 minutes) * Train 305, "Baby Bullet" pattern A, 4 stops, 05:45 -- 06:47 (1 hour 2 minutes) * Train 309, "Baby Bullet" pattern B, 5 stops, 06:04 -- 07:08 (1 hour 4 minutes) So the best the system manages (the 4-stop "Baby Bullet" pattern) is 62 minutes for 47 miles, averaging just over 45mph. The worst (the local making all stops) is 95 minutes for 47 miles, averaging just under 30mph. Factoring out the time spent stopped at the stations is unfortunately not possible from Caltrain's timetables, which only give the scheduled time of departure from each station.
- masklinn 9y agoAn other commenter above quoted ~50mph average for the inaugural run. > For a distance of 30 miles, shouldnt we be able to build a train that averages 60 mph for 30 minutes? Euro regional rail does 80+mph for this sort of non-stop distances.
- exabrial 9y agoTop speed on i95 also hits 80mph-95mph, not during rush hour