8 ms·
Pity the Poor Couple Who Make $450,000 Per Year
- grandalf 16y agoSee my comment in a related thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1711490 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1711490
- dmor 16y agoHe's already taken the original post down, did anyone capture it and want to repost?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- latif 16y agohttp://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:kpzaEp0IVw4J:truthonthemarket.com/2010/09/15/we-are-the-super-rich/ http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:kpzaEp0...
- gaius 16y agoDamn, you would think a lawyer of all people would be more careful with trying to destroy the evidence!
- atomical 16y agoContent removals can take up to 24 hours with Google webmaster tools.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- exit 16y agohttp://pastebin.com/BvHwvnrb http://pastebin.com/BvHwvnrb in case that gets removed
- robconery 16y agoThe link is here: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:kpzaEp0IVw4J:truthonthemarket.com/2010/09/15/we-are-the-super-rich/+todd+henderson+poor&cd=2&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:kpzaEp0...
- ww520 16y agoThank you. The original blog post seemed to have been removed.
- lotusleaf1987 16y agoI wish he could lose his job for being so ungrateful and out of touch with reality and learn how truly privileged he is. This guy needs a wake up call ASAP. Also, look at how disgusting some of the comments are on the cache, truly disgusting: "The poor are inferior to the rich in the U.S. The ones who are rich have used the system to generally move up, not manipulate the rest of the population as the liberal biters/haters would have you see the world you created."
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- houseabsolute 16y agoHopefully he will keep his job if he is good at it. No sense wasting that education when lawyers can learn good practice from him, even if his politics suck. You are basically advocating employer censoring of employees' private political opinions and expression, which is a dark road to advocate if there ever was one.
- sliverstorm 16y agoWe can wish for bad karma though
- houseabsolute 16y agoWe shouldn't. There's enough evil in the world already, and this man losing his job is not likely to make things better.
- netcan 16y agoNot really saying all that much. We earn over $250k so we're considered superich though that's not fair because we're not really rich because we spend all our money on normal stuff like house and groceries and richer people evade taxes offshore but we're not rich enough to do that and we could evade taxes by pretending to be divorced but we're too moral to do that and if you tax us we'll have to fire our gardener and cleaner and sell our house and that's not good for the economy and who said that you can spend money better that me anyway you Marxian.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- houseabsolute 16y agoAs much as I sometimes differ with Obama's policies, you do not seem to understand what Marxism is at all and would do well to read up on it before trying to say who is or isn't a Marxist. You can start here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marxism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marxism. See the part about the proletarian revolution? Not exactly something Obama is pushing for, among many, many other differences between his policies and Marxism.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- houseabsolute 16y ago> Please tell me where things went wrong. Among other things, you've failed to demonstrate that Obama believes Capitalism is inherently exploitative. Even if you'd managed that, you'd still need to prove that he also supports the other tenets of Marxism, like the one I called out in my comment. A person is not automatically a Marxist merely for having some affinity to any part of the overall philosophy. Instead, one is a Marxist if the overall body of their philosophy matches. Obama has never advocated the a revolution of the proletariat, one of the core ideas of Marxism. There is also no evidence that he sees Capitalism as inherently exploitative, nor that he endorses the view that a person is exploited if they produce more than they consume. To the extent that he has supported policies to enhance equality of well-being, they have mostly been aimed at shoring up a necessary minimum level of well-being via taxes, not by transferring the means of production from the bourgeois to the proletariat. For these reasons and many others, it is completely misguided to call him a Marxist. Say rather that he has implemented some economic policies that would be vaguely similar to a small subset of the policies that a Marxist leader might implement. Better still, say nothing at all; you have demonstrated that you are not qualified in either duty to truth nor possession of knowledge to comment.
- mmaunder 16y agoA few lessons here re the blog post being referred to: 1. The title "professor" does not confer knowledge, intelligence or wisdom. 2. Know that your online audience is diverse even if your regular readers aren't. 3. If you're in a prominent non-activist position, avoid discussing politics, religion or sex. 4. Never disclose details about your personal life, especially financials, unless you've thought it through and had a trusted and objective friend to review your post. 5. Be careful about making yourself the subject of a blog entry. It's tough to avoid coming off as narcissistic. And the obvious cliche: Write your emails and blog entries as if they're going to be published on the front page of a very popular newspaper that holds opposing views to yours.
- atomical 16y agoLook at the whole picture. As this man's salary grew he started to add services and dependents and a wife and a lot of other things to his budget. He basically has reached a point where it is unsustainable but now he has convinced himself that he is in a hardship. Not so different from the general public that believes owning a home, having three or four kids, and driving new cars is a right.
- btmorex 16y agoEveryone spends more as they make more money. It's pretty much human nature. The difference is that most people keep some bearing on reality and realize that they have it better than almost anyone else in the world (speaking of wealthy Americans here). They can also probably imagine cutting some stuff out if need be without blogging "woe is me".
- berntb 16y agoThat is a point. But with today's blogging, you'll find idiots at all salaries/educations having any possible stupid opinion you can imagine. And you'll find some other idiot with moral outrage flaming him, for eyeballs... Here, that might be needed and motivated. But it is a bit boring. What was that US expression? "Move along, people. Nothing to see here". Edit: Grammar.
- sliverstorm 16y agoWhile it does piss me off to read someone who makes so much money complain, I don't think it's ridiculous for someone who already looses nearly half their income in taxes being concerned about a further hike. Suppose that last year I made $10k. Someone, somewhere, thinks that's a hell of a lot of money. But I bet most people on HN would not condemn me for being concerned about the government taking a few extra thousand. His closing comment: >The problem with the president’s plan is that the super rich don’t pay taxes – they hide in the Cayman Islands or use fancy investment vehicles to shelter their income. seems like it might have some merit as well, although I am not in a position to actually know for certain. Although, I have asked my father in the past what he pays for taxes, and he has told me well above 50%. He makes nothing like this man's wages, which makes me wonder how this man is getting away with less than 50%...
- dangrossman 16y agoVery few occupations lead to a cash salary of more than a few hundred thousand dollars, tops. All the rest of their income (interest and other gains from investing, appreciation of assets, etc) is taxed at lower rates. Long term capital gains are only taxed at 15%, for example. So the richer you are, the lower your marginal tax rate can be as the proportion made up of ordinary income becomes smaller.
- sliverstorm 16y agoI think I may have just tasted the flavor of the "the rich are getting richer while the poor are getting poorer" kool-aid for the first time.
- lionhearted 16y ago> Perhaps Henderson's outburst should be chalked up to the influence of degenerate white culture This would be unacceptable to say about any other ethnic group - I've got to say, if you're Caucasian you should get upset at general hate speech and slapping "white" on something like it's a bad thing. I keep the company of people of all color and background, I'll do business with anyone I like, but it's time white people stop taking abuse like this passively. Any other ethnic group would be up in arms, calling this guy a racist asshole, and writing off his credibility permanently.
- houseabsolute 16y ago> Any other ethnic group would be up in arms That is because the other ethnic groups are not the dominant ones in society, and are typically disadvantaged on the whole because of their race. My personal view as a White person is that I have enough advantages by my White male-ness that I do not need to demand more, or do anything to offset whatever minor inconveniences might arise from the same. Doing so would seem petty to me if I walked in another man's shoes. Is this racist? Yes, I suppose. White privilege is real, though. A recognition of this fact requires some ability to discriminate between race when observing the state of society, so perhaps "racist" should not be the bad word. Instead, "racial oppressivism" might be a better thing to demonize.
- lionhearted 16y agoEdit: Obviously this argument isn't going to get resolved and it's unlikely anyone's mind will be changed. I'll bow out here, leaving my opinion that his conduct is hateful and inappropriate, and my opinion is if you're Caucasian you shouldn't have to accept that passively. Others may have other opinons or think it's okay - if so, we'll agree to disagree.
- houseabsolute 16y ago> That's not petty either. I don't really expect you to see it any other way. You too are part of the advantaged White race, and it's far easier to turn a blind eye to the advantages you receive over Black or Latino people than to recognize them and deal with the fact. Of course, you may actually recognize those advantages and just choose to deal with them differently than I do. I also see nothing wrong with that. I'm not trying to say that all White people should behave the same as I do. I'm just offering up one possible reason why some do. > . . . upper middle class sanctimonious bullshit. Not necessary.
- liedra 16y agoThis is ridiculous. Any American (or Australian for that matter!) who whines about their taxes should come and work for a few years in Europe. In Belgium, on an entry-level salary (for a post-doc academic position) I was being taxed at over 50% (my communal tax was at 8%): "For 2010, marginal income tax starts at 25%, rises to 30% over EUR 7,900, 40% over EUR 11,240, 45% over 18,730 EUR with a top limit of 50% for incomes above EUR 34,330. Residents also pay communal and regional taxes at rates between 0% and 8.5% of the total income tax payable. The most common rate is 6%." (source: http://www.expatica.com/be/finance_business/tax/taxation-in-belgium-8618_8286.html http://www.expatica.com/be/finance_business/tax/taxation-in-... ) Throw in a 21% VAT on top of that and watch most of your income go to tax. Mind you, Belgium is one of the heaviest taxers, but coming from Australia, where it is significantly less hard-hitting (top tax bracket is 30% for 180k AUD, then 45% for every $1 after), it was astonishing. I don't think I got what I paid for in Belgium either, to be honest, but that's a different issue ;)
- houseabsolute 16y agoWhile it may be true that Europeans are taxed more heavily than Americans, that does not necessarily mean that Americans being taxed more heavily is a good thing to happen. Your argument seems to boil down to, "You think that frying pan is hot? Join me in the oven then you'll really have good reason to complain." Thanks, but what if the best thing is to sit near the AC instead? I'm not claiming, by the way, that it would or wouldn't be better to tax American rich more, I'm just saying the argument you made is not a very good one.
- liedra 16y agoWhereas I'm all for experiencing how others live, and thereby gaining a greater appreciation and experience of how the world works :) My argument isn't that Americans should be taxed more, just that Americans should come and see how the rest of the world works before having a good old whinge ;) (which is basically the theme of all the objections to this article -- I'm just expanding it out from rich/poor). 'tis the same with socialised medicine -- if those against it lived in Europe/Australia/Canada/etc. for a bit and saw how well it worked and how well loved it was in these countries, they'd probably have a different idea about it for their own.
- jasonkester 16y agoAs somebody who stands to get clobbered by this high tax bracket, I sometimes feel like I'm the only one out here who thinks it's just fine. I've always been in favor of a flat tax with a lower bound. So, say 50% of all income above $20k. Let the regular folk (like me last during the last couple years of getting a bootstrapped startup off the ground) get off without paying any tax whatsoever. Take up the slack by making those with plenty (like me now that things are going well) pay our fair share. I mean sure, losing half your income to taxes is a problem, but it's one of those good problems, because to get it you need to be making four times what everybody else is making. As long as you figure out what your actual means are and live within them, you'll still do fine. EDIT: 50% -> "high" thanks to the below:
- guelo 16y agoThere is no "50% tax bracket". Obama's proposed plan would raise the 33% and 35% brackets to 36% and 39.6%.
- jasonkester 16y agoThanks for that. This was actually the first I'd heard of this tax hike, since the little bit of news I get generally comes filtered through HN. I've modified the number in my comment for you.
- rdl 16y agoThere is if you count state and local taxes. In California you can be paying 9.3% + 1.0%, and in other places (NYC) it can be even higher. At 39.6 + 9.3 + 1.0, you would be above most countries in the world.
- anigbrowl 16y agoThat's funny, because on my federal tax return there's an entry where you deduct your state income tax. Sales tax, of course, is entirely different from income tax. http://www.irs.gov/publications/p17/ch22.html#en_US_publink1000173147 http://www.irs.gov/publications/p17/ch22.html#en_US_publink1...
- aresant 16y agoAnother article in the same vein http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/money_co/2010/09/obama-bush-tax-cuts-high-income-earners-wealthy.html http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/money_co/2010/09/obama-bush-...
- nhebb 16y agoWhat's with all the class warfare in the US lately? There isn't anything wrong with making money. I'm no where near the 450k/yr earnings range, but I certainly don't begrudge anyone who is. Some people seem to have the perspective that your earnings are the government's money, and they, through the goodness of their hearts, let you keep a percentage of it.
- rdl 16y agoI think people don't (at least in the US, and probably globally, generally) begrudge people what they view as "fair" rewards, especially if they themselves might have a shot at them. Most of the political supporters of low taxes in the US are actually not incredibly high income, but people who think they may have high income in the future. If you view most wealth and income as coming from fraud/crime or deceit, then it is much more reasonable to want some kind of confiscatory taxes. I think in the past, most Americans with relatively high incomes (doctors, small business owners, etc.) were well respected for contributing more value to the community than they took out in salaries. It is a lot harder even for me as a libertarian to defend those who make huge amounts of money from wall street, government regulation, etc. In most third world countries with pretty open class warfare, the rich have largely made their money from extractive industry or other exploitation. I'm not sure if this is cause or effect -- there's a strong argument that living in a country where wealth only comes from that kind of thing actually turns your country into a horrible place to live, any where anyone who would otherwise be productive would then want to flee to be productive elsewhere.
- geekman 16y agoTo a certain extent this guy has a point. You are rich if you can afford a good lifestyle without having to work for a living. These people have a high income, but they also have high level of spending and they have nowhere near the assets to support their lifestyles. So, rather than being rich, they are wage slaves with high incomes. When you have enough money to stop working and still have the lifestyle you want, your life is completely different. It buys you the one thing that is really precious - the time to do what you want with your life. Although I am not extremely wealthy, I have enough savings to stop working and to spend my time the way I want. The other interesting aspect of this case is that it is a classic example of the hedonic treadmill. No matter how rich you are, how successful, how productive, after a while the joy wears off and you think: If only I had a bit more, then I'd be happy. The millionaire thinks he or she needs $10m, with $10m you think $100m, etc. "The only way to win this game is not to play".
- ju2tin 16y agoLost in the bashing of this professor who had the temerity not to want to pay higher taxes, is the fact that he had to invest lots of money to be able to earn his big salary. He probably has at least 7 years of higher education. His wife, as a medical doctor, probably has at least 8, if I understand correctly how med school and internships work. They sank a huge amount of money -- maybe close to $500,000 -- into investing in their careers, while most people in the lower income brackets have spent little, if anything, in that way. And the cost to the professor and his wife is even greater if you factor in the opportunity cost of not working high-paying jobs all those years they were in school. Call it a cool million sunk into their education and training, easily. So it's hardly greedy of the guy to want to be able to at least pay back his wife's student loans before Obama hits him up even harder to help finance a new era of government expansion. There's a difference between revenue and profits, after all. As for saying he shouldn't have bought a million-dollar house, that's hardly an unreasonable price for a couple with a combined annual income of roughly half that amount. As a multiple of their income, it's comparable to a couple who makes $125,000 a year buying a house worth $250,000. That doesn't sound so crazy, does it?
- alextingle 16y agoI think you're living in la-la land. If he had $500,000 to spend on education in the first place, then he started rich and just keeps getting richer. If he'd foregone the education and invested the $500k in something else, then he'd still be rich, and (presumably) he'd still feel hard done by.
- sokoloff 16y agoFrom the original article, which you may not have actually read: "My wife has school loans of nearly $250,000 and I do too" They made the investment in their education and future with borrowed funds, just as I (and many others) have. It's not like he broke $500K off some trust fund he was born with...
- thrill 16y agoYeah, it's not like they worked to earn it or anything - oh wait.
- mhb 16y agoDoes the law professor have a right to complain? (Marginal Revolution): http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/09/does-the-law-professor-have-a-right-to-complain.html http://www.marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2010/09...
- Untitled 16y ago<rant> This article irritates the living hell out of me. I was extremely poor as a child, yet there are sensible ways people act who are in poverty and ways in which poor people act that causes poverty. > Because personal responsibility should not be the sole purview of single minority mothers. The popular idea (in the USA at least) is that once a person is a “single mother” they are somehow special and everyone has to pay their way. Popular politicians (Hillary Clinton) say things like “it takes the village to raise a child”. This is against the normal notion of the father and mother paying for the child and raising the child. Most single mothers probably do not know the father of their children. This is utter bullshit - a poor (and rich girl) is not supposed to get pregnant out of wedlock – that is insane stupidity. This has nothing to do with poverty. Getting pregnant does not entitle you to a big chunk of another’s money. > Being poor is going to the restroom before you get in the school lunch line so your friends will be ahead of you and won't hear you say "I get free lunch" when you get to the cashier.... Nice. I didn’t get lunch at school. > Being poor is feeling the glued soles tear off your supermarket shoes when you run around the playground. Hmm… fair enough. I only wore shoes since 8th grade (because it was mandatory). In any case, running around barefoot makes you faster (almost everyone did that). Gluing is a bad way to fix shoes – the better way is with a thick type of needle and twine (don’t exactly know what this is in English). > Being poor is relying on people who don't give a damn about you. I never had a problem with people not caring about me. Of course you will not be the most popular guy with the girls or have fancy clothes (you know that group). But that doesn’t mean that people do not care about you. > Being poor is not talking to that girl because she'll probably just laugh at your clothes. Or having extremely bad acne+teeth but no money for medicine? Been there. Still doesn’t entitle you to someone else’s money. > Being poor is your kid's teacher assuming you don't have any books in your home. You know what many teachers like? People who do well and work hard. All the money of rich kids cannot (usually) buy them good test scores. Fair enough, they have fancy scientific calculators and computers while you must do with a hand-hand-hand me down. But that doesn’t help them that much. More often the privilege that rich kids experience set them up for failure later in life. Here is what I have found with parents that are different: 1. Became super conservative – everything is saved, nothing is wasted. Even now, when my parents are doing well, my father still can’t throw away glass bottles. 2. Obsession with cleanliness (my mother used to say: “We may be poor, but we are not dirty”). 3. Obsession with education and forcing children to work extremely hard. 4. Extremely socially conservative. My father forbade dancing, alcohol. Even forbade my sister from watching television soaps, etc… 5. Extremely strict. 6. Obsessed with being successful. My father has a successful business now, but still work 15 hours a day. <\rant>
- tokenadult 16y agoA follow-up article by Ezra Klein in the Washington Post: http://voices.washingtonpost.com/ezra-klein/2010/09/the_rich_are_not_bad_just_rich.html http://voices.washingtonpost.com/ezra-klein/2010/09/the_rich...
- Poiesis 16y agoIs the title here incorrect? From the article: Our combined income exceeds the $250,000 threshold for the super rich (but not by that much), and the president plans on raising my taxes. As for the author's premise, it all depends on what you're willing to put up with. I have a rusting 25 year old car and a dead front lawn (no gardeners, scarce water, no time to landscape myself). There are likely people who disdain this, and I posit the author may be one of them. But I have a family of six in an expensive area for well under half of the money he describes. To the people with plenty of money, gardeners and private school are simply part of the cost of doing business; non-negotiable. But they remain optional, just as my choices of four kids an an expensive area are also up to me. There are others who would call me wealthy with my spending of money on such things. And they are right, in their way.