3 ms·
> Taxes should not grow with income - if anything, they should drop. Why wouldn't richer people want better schools, better infrastructure, better law enforcem
by guelo 16y ago
> Taxes should not grow with income - if anything, they should drop.
Why wouldn't richer people want better schools, better infrastructure, better law enforcement, etc?
- Bricejm 16y agoThe marginal tax system that we have works, and is probably the best way to maintain stability and distribute burden. What needs fixing is the rates on cap gains and dividends. Needs to be a marginal rate too.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoBecause once these services become good enough, there is little advantage to spending more on them. If you already have virtually no crime, why bother spending more money on police? If the roads get you where you want to go, what is the advantage of building more? I can see the advantage for politicians and public sector unions. But not for taxpayers.
- Bricejm 16y agoCrime will always be a part of society. Roads fall apart and need repairs. An increasing marginal tax system maintains stability.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoTry to pay attention. I'm not arguing against an increasing marginal tax system. I'm arguing that tax revenue should not grow with income level, they should grow with population [1]. Crime is a part of society, but increasing income levels do not increase crime or increase the cost of road repairs. Take your favorite progressive tax system. Multiply all tax rates by 1/2. Your new tax system is just as progressive as the old one. [1] That's my leading order argument. As a second order correction, poor people tend to cost more money than rich people.
- Bricejm 16y agoSo what you're saying is as the average income increases, we should decrease the tax rate to maintain a level amount of tax revenue? Then as population grows their taxes should offset their cost? Maybe in a perfect world, but you can't compare our population to a fixed cost.
- guelo 16y agoRight, your ideology prevents you from seeing any good ever coming from government. You don't want better government, only less. In the real world adults realize that government is a necessary part of a functioning civil society and like anything else you get what you pay for. I am a liberal and believe that government should provide more social services. But I also agree with many conservatives that there is waste, inefficiency and corruption in government, just like in any other large organization. It would be a better country if Republicans took this passion and tried to make government better, more efficient, more business-like, etc. But instead they only ever want to tear government down and give the money to their rich daddies so John Galt can save us all.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoYou seem to have confused me with some kind of anarchist, or perhaps Glenn Beck. I didn't make any point about what services should be provided, one way or the other. All I did was point out that the cost of paving 1 mile of road does not increase just because a bunch of rich microsofties moved into town. Perhaps you could remind me when I advocated against government providing police protection or road paving?
- guelo 16y agoIt was when you implied that any government spending beyond some picked-by-you minimum level of service can only ever be waste for corrupt politicians and government employees.
- timr 16y ago"All I did was point out that the cost of paving 1 mile of road does not increase just because a bunch of rich microsofties moved into town." That doesn't even come close to passing the smell test. An influx of rich Microsofties drive up the price for everything, from roads to radishes. A mile of road costs more to build post-Microsoft because land costs more, labor costs more (they need to be paid enough to live approximately near the Microsofties!), and supplies cost more. And I don't know if you've heard the news, but Bellevue isn't a cheap place to live! Of course, that's not even counting the indirect costs: rich Microsofties like to live in big McMansions in the suburbs, which require not only many miles of new roads, but also new police departments, firemen, sewers, traffic signals, new highway lanes, gas, water and electric lines, etc. The cost increases created by an influx of rich people are non-linear.