4 ms·
One of the most difficult problems we have in Michigan and the Midwest in general is that a large percentage of our most talented developers leave the state upo
by rmason 9y ago
One of the most difficult problems we have in Michigan and the Midwest in general is that a large percentage of our most talented developers leave the state upon graduating college to go to work for the Silicon Valley giants.
If you talk to them a few years later they long to return to the Midwest and they want to do a startup. What if Michigan had an accelerator in Silicon Valley, one where it's native VC's and angel investors had first crack at funding these companies with the provisio that they move back home?
- cyberpunk0 9y agoI mean do you blame them? It's cold, not much to do, political turmoil in recent years. I don't see MI offering a lot
- bischofs 9y agoWas warm enough for Henry Ford, The Dodge Brothers, William Durant, Herbert Henry Dow, Louis Chevrolet etc. Maybe some thicker skin and a harder winter would benefit folks ;)
- nemonemo 9y agoAt that time, Silicon valley didn’t exist and California was barely getting mass migration. About a century later, now even the car industry seems to move toward California..
- bischofs 9y agoDoesn't seem like a good thing to me, with the cost of real estate, energy and labor in California, building sprawling manufacturing plants for cars probably won't work. Plus the margins on building cars are very low at high volumes - not something SV is used to.
- Retric 9y agoCalifornia is huge and has plenty of cheap land as long as you don't need to live next to the ocean. Ex: ~1000$ an acre. https://www.landandfarm.com/property/Freeman_Ranch-7072064/ https://www.landandfarm.com/property/Freeman_Ranch-7072064/
- prklmn 9y agoCalifornia started getting gold rush migration far before the car industry started flourishing. Silicon Valley is now essentially the heart of the modern gold rush, but of course not everybody will be lured there.
- nemonemo 8y agoI'm not sure what's the point you're making with the gold rush migration, but most of the population to California came after Model T, and it was during and after the World Wars that California saw much of its population growth. Michigan had more population than California up until 1930s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_historical_population https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_histori... I believe the population growth has contributed to the growth of Silicon valley significantly. There seems some feedback loop between the population growth and the industry growth.
- Nasrudith 9y agoThey were from a different part of the industrial era when the area was more desirable. There is a funny cycle to labor and skill labor level relative demand. Near the start skilled artisans were being disrupted and displaced by factories set up to use the unskilled masses who were previously doing things like making money off of digging through street trash for resellable goods like rags and bones. While labor conditions were often frankly horrible they often sadly were still an improvement. Later automation reversed the trend to favor skilled labor to administer machines as being better quality and cheaper than mass cheap labor. The point being then they had to cater to the bulk of their labor. I do not know the precise history of the region but farm families tend to produce an excess of people with larger family sizes than suburban or urban families.
- noobermin 9y agoWhat "political turmoil"? There is political turmoil across this country by that criteria.
- FullMtlAlcoholc 9y ago> If you talk to them a few years later they long to return to the Midwest and they want to do a startup. As a biological Michigander (Detroit) that now identifies as Californian, my friends and I have anecdotally experienced the opposite. Lack of opportunity was of course a factor. However, the major con for us was the entrenched segregation. I had amazing parents who did their best to teach me not to judge people by their race. But growing up as a black kid from the city who had friends in the burbs, you see a lot of ugly shit. I have bad memories of places like Howell (which still, if I'm not mistaken holds annual KKK rallies) and there are still lots of areas not far from the city where it still isn't safe at night. Like everywhere else, gentrification is picking up steam. But it isn't as much as an issue since increasing tax revenues far outweighs maintaining communities in a city that had an epidemic of vacant houses. City services have vastly improved and it is heartening to see more diversity in my old neighborhood as whites and others no longer have as much fear of the city, but it's slow going as the scars from the 60's are still evident. Don't get me wrong. I still appreciate the natural splendor and experiencing the rhythm of the four seasons. I spent this past winter there and it was actually unexpectedly refreshing (if you have someone to shovel your snow). I did end up tacking on 20lbs. That I had to travel 7 miles to find Mexican food that wasn't Taco Bell is a deal breaker for me. One thing I noticed on my last trip back home is just how much of the Detroit metro area's economy is still driven by staid, stuffy dynastic enterprises such as the old Big Three, health care firms, same old top law firms with the kids now running the show. A lot of the so-called startups are spinoffs that are wholly owned or seeded by Quicken Loans via Rock Ventures. People still have that mindset that work consists of getting a job at a large firm and they aren't as willing to work for startups or become entrepreneurs.
- rmason 9y agoThere haven't been any Klan rallies in Howell for a very long time. However the children of those Klansmen still reside in Howell and cast a long shadow over the town. For reference Howell is a small town of 9,500 people mid-way between Detroit and Lansing. Detroit's revival owes a big debt to Dan Gilbert's (Quicken Loans/Cleveland Cavaliers) purchase of a big chunk of the downtown and his funding of dozens of startups. But the majority of startups now in Detroit aren't funded by Gilbert though he's still a major influence. It took forty years for Detroit's destruction. We're only on year eight of the road back. Next time you're in the 'D' checkout Bamboo CoWorking center on Woodward. You will meet lots of early stage startups https://www.bamboodetroit.com/ https://www.bamboodetroit.com/ . Gilbert's startups are in the Madison building on Broadway just off Grand Circus near the Opera and Tiger stadium. That entire neighborhood is full of startups. Before 2010 none of it existed, the buildings had been empty for thirty years or more. Ann Arbor has a huge startup scene. Anchors are Ann Arbor Spark and the Tech Brewery. Much smaller scene in Lansing, Kalamazoo and Grand Rapids but it's progressing.
- castratikron 9y agoThey leave the Midwest because any company they'd want to work for in that region is run with a tech averse MBA mindset by people who don't understand how to turn software into a business. In the Midwest there is a culture of anti-innovation when it comes to high tech. So when it comes time to find a fun job there is just no comparison between there and SV.
- mark_l_watson 9y agoI moved to the Midwest last summer for a Tech job in Urbana/Champaign Illinois. I also worked in Mountain View (silicon valley) while contracting at Google. I find the tech scene in Urbana/Champaign to be much more vibrant: lots of good technical meet ups, lots of university/industry interactions and conferences, etc. And the cost of living here is very low. Perfect place for a startup.
- jacobolus 9y ago> I find the tech scene in Urbana/Champaign to be much more vibrant: lots of good technical meet ups, lots of university/industry interactions and conferences, etc. You had trouble finding “technical meetups, university–industry interactions, conferences, etc.” in the Bay Area? I find that the problem is the opposite: there is so much going on that it’s hard to keep up with it.
- mark_l_watson 9y agoThe difference is that I work in the research park next to the University and many of the meet ups are within walking distance or a few miles away with little traffic. And I live 5 or 6 minutes from work. In Mountain View, I worked from 6:30am to about 4pm to reduce my commute time. Going out again to fight traffic to get to a meetup was not so appealing. I grew up in the Bay Area in the 1960s and 1970s, great place then. Now too crowded, too much traffic - for my tastes.
- anovikov 9y agoI think Paul Graham covered a similar scenario about 10 years ago in one of his essays and pointed out that it will mean a strong negative selection for these startups - people who would leave from the place where stuff happens, to place where it doesn't, just to get some cash are probably not interested in much else but in consuming the aforementioned cash.
- sametmax 9y agoIt's a problem for everybody. My last client literally hired me in France, to work from my bedroom, because they couldn't find the expert they needed in the Bay area. Despite being quite expensive for a French, I'm still cheaper than the competition there. It's crazy.
- segmondy 9y agoLonging to return to Midwest is just nostalgia. It's usually for the "losers" The ones that are doing well in the Valley don't long to return. It's usually the one's struggling. I'm in Michigan btw. I won't say there's a talent shortage here, but folks here are not as driven as those in the Bay. We are too conservative. Hell, I just posted that I'm hiring for my startup and the languages are golang for backend and typescript for frontend. I was told that using Go is a risk for Michigan. :-/ I will never advice a young person with time on their site to come back to the Midwest, Midwest is for raising families not building a startup.
- ggg9990 9y agoThat is simply an overgeneralization. I work with two very talented engineers from “Red America” and they are eager to leave the Bay Area and get back to a place where people drive trucks, listen to country music, and hunt and fish. Their plan is likely going to be to work until their early 40s and then just retire to there.
- segmondy 8y agoYes, retire, but not start a startup. I don't have a problem with Michigan, I actually like it and won't mind retiring here. But for tech startup, it's really frustrating.