5 ms·
I really like that people asking fundamental questions about the way AI can be pushed forward beyond just ML seems to gain a little bit of traction again, at le
by Barrin92 9y ago
I really like that people asking fundamental questions about the way AI can be pushed forward beyond just ML seems to gain a little bit of traction again, at least in the public eye. Even Kissinger opined on the topic just a few days ago
https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/06/henry-kissinger-ai-could-mean-the-end-of-human-history/559124/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/06/henry-k...
I agree with Pearl that there's something deeply misguided about thinking that intelligence truly can be solved as a data optimization problem. I'd be happy if we'd see more research about AI at a symbolic level again.
The biggest hindrance seems to be funding. ML is really successful in a lot of commercial domains, general AI is a big moonshot. With most researchers moving from long term university positions to the business sector I'm concerned about this sort of research, not just in computer science.
- alexanderdmitri 9y agoOne thing that I never see brought into the equation but I believe is fundamental to human "general" intelligence is emotional response. It's hugely instrumental in terms of us deciding what's important to investigate, which input to analyze and how to mold our output. The importance of emotion in guiding and driving our learning is most evident in children, during the first four or five years of life of development. I think a huge leap forward in the field could be made by modeling an emotional system similar to ours. It also seems like it would be an incredibly difficult and fuzzy problem to solve. Addendum: After thinking about it for a few minutes more, I bet an implicit understanding of cause and effect could be derived by a system designed to try to optimize it's emotional state
- Pimpus 9y agoI do think the impact of emotions on our thinking is understated, but I also think that focusing on this aspect is going at it backwards. A value system is necessary for emotions, otherwise happy and sad mean nothing. I think this is what you mean when you talk about "modeling emotions". At the same time, some intelligence seems like a prerequisite as blindly following a value system will lead to massive hedonistic AI orgies. Er, I mean, an override mechanism is required, and intelligence is the best possible solution, so we're back at the fundamental problem. I think there is a lot more intelligence behind even our most primitive urges than we realize. Hope that made sense, typing on mobile.
- mkagenius 9y agoOr perhaps another angle can be explored - better than human intelligence directly instead of copying humans. There are certain machines already better than humans(any other life form) in physical tasks — why do we need to have human intelligence as the base scale to measure machine intelligence? I mean, the early man didn’t create his tools to compete with human nails.
- flatline 9y ago> A value system is necessary for emotion I think a value system is mostly a post hoc justification of our emotional states. I view emotions as primarily a tight biochemical feedback loop. Think more of the four “f”s than, say, platonic feelings of love.
- taurath 9y agoI think it’s the opposite - they come from innate chemical values (procreation, socialization, base metabolic needs) and emotions are created upwards from reaction to stimuli as it pertains to those values. Maybe we’re saying the same thing, but the starting point is important as it pertains to any artificial intelligence being able to be created.
- dcow 9y agoIsn't this the theory of co sciousness presented in After On? I am curious what people are formally studying emotional theories of co sciousness. I'd love to read more.
- mindcrime 9y agoYou've read After On? How was it? I picked up a copy a couple of weeks ago but haven't gotten around to reading it yet. Is it worth bumping it up the priority queue a bit?
- taurath 9y agoIt could start with a value system rather than raw emotions - at some point it might decide that it doesn’t really want to do some work. The idea of controllability in all senses I think complicates the issue, but it’s definitely a necessary safety net.
- Izkata 9y agoNot just emotion, but also aversion to certain physical states - such as hunger or pain. Because of that, I think a "true AI" - at least one without a simulated humanlike body - would have rather different desires. Optimization towards those desires rather than humanlike desires would likely result in something that distinctly does not act human. I can't help but wonder if we've ignored or disregarded any first steps to a general AI because the resulting building blocks didn't match any of our expectations from real-world models of instinct/intelligence.
- quotemstr 9y agoNature herself "solved" intelligence as a data optimization problem. We can too.
- tathougies 9y agoI don't disagree. However, the next time you find yourself pondering the question "Why did Bob do X? That's so bizarre, and it makes no sense", you should consider what the repercussions may be if Bob were not just your awkward acquaintance but rather an autonomous computer system distributed across the globe that's assigning credit scores to people. Is there really room for 'Well it just felt right at the time' in those situations? Humans are often quite bright, but we're also known to do the wrong thing for no discernible reason. This is to be expected when there's no fundamental formal system behind behavior, and behavior is instead driven by a black-box neural network.
- gerbilly 9y agoSure, I don't concede the point. But even if it were true, do you want to spend billions of years solving it that way?
- Barrin92 9y agoThere's problems with that attitude. First, it offers no scientific insight. We don't learn anything about the fundamental nature and skeleton of minds by simply replicating evolutionary processes. It does not grant us knowledge. The equivalent in engineering would be to throw over trees and rocks in the hope of building a bridge. Clearly, that is unsatisfactory, we strive to understand the meaning of systems so that we can reason about them and alter them in predictable and fundamental ways. Secondly, we don't know how likely it is that evolution produces intelligence. Maybe we're the only intelligent spot in the universe and it's an aberration. It took 4 billion years as well. That seems to be a fundamentally impoverished way to go about things. We shouldn't forego the ability to understand minds at a deep level just because we have made practical strides in closed domains. That would be to mistake a trojan horse for an actual horse.
- gerbilly 9y ago
- taurath 9y ago> I agree with Pearl that there's something deeply misguided about thinking that intelligence truly can be solved as a data optimization problem. When all you have is a hammer... I think we’re really thinking about the whole thing backwards, as if intelligence only comes from the cortex of the brain. I think human level intelligence is fundamentally an emotional state of being - our core lizard brain values aren’t something to be swept aside - they’re a fundamental part of real intelligence. It’s like trying to build a car starting from the body and electronics rather than the motor.
- joe_the_user 9y agoWell, if a computer scientist only has a bunch of data, is there any conceivable way to reason about that data that doesn't ultimately boil down to a data optimization problem? I hear that correlation does not imply causation but also that you can't distinguish correlation from causation merely with a stream of data. Is there any way out of this situation with just data?
- salty_biscuits 9y agoI think apart from the work Pearl and others did with the do-calculus, all you can do is suggest experiments. You can only ever have a true ai if it can interact and ask questions about the environment.
- joe_the_user 9y agoWell, even if an AI can interact with it's environment, how can those interactions not simply also be correlations between input and output. We have for example, recurrent neural networks which seem to do this already. It seems like saying "it's not optimization" has to boil down to "it's not generic optimization, it's a special kind of optimization." But maybe there's some formalism I'm missing.
- salty_biscuits 9y agoAs a thought experiment, imagine an AI is trying to work out if a rooster crowing makes the sun rise or the other way around (because they are always correlated in its experience). It can do the experiment of putting the rooster in a bag and see if the sun doesn't rise. It can refine it's model after doing this experiment (all with optimization). It is more about untangling correlations that come from latent variables that the system doesn't know about yet.
- evrydayhustling 9y agoMore than funding, then issue is data. Untangling correlation from causation usually requires running additional experiments. It's important for people to understand these limits of current ML, but they are happening for a good reason. You can apply associative reasoning in many environments that don't support causal reasoning, and we are still scratching the surface of the value discovering associations can create.