4 ms·
Hmm, I'd be slightly leery about taking advice from someone who admits they actually didn't do well learning math. Looking at the points, most of the advice so
by joe_the_user 9y ago
Hmm,
I'd be slightly leery about taking advice from someone who admits they actually didn't do well learning math. Looking at the points, most of the advice sounds good but a couple seem a bit off.
Especially: "I can tolerate ungodly amounts of frustration".
Math isn't always easy but my hunch is that if it feels hard, you're on the wrong track. The best moments in math for me are the "it's obvious" times, points where everything just flows from first principles.
I've always "found math easy" and occasionally tutored people who had trouble with it. It always seemed like those who got stuck would make the mistake of thinking math was a grind, that if they pushed through enough frustration they'd get there. I think that attitude might help some fieds but I don't think it helps math.
This isn't to say math really is easy. Rather, I think the appropriate approach is to spend a lot of time and approach from multiple angles until it feels easy (and fun and creative). Work really "hard" to attain a state of productive laziness. But that work shouldn't be a continuous grind either, rather a careful survey of all the ways one can approach the topic.
And certainly being able to tolerate frustration is certainly useful in many fields, programming among them. But I'd say that intellectual problems that benefit from overt are problems where a person has all the knowledge necessary for the solution and merely has to engage in a long, frustrating process of putting them together - like a large but not hugely sophisticated, computer program.
- Smaug123 9y agoI dunno, I'm objectively fairly good at maths (I got a first in the Cambridge MMath), but the reason I learned so much from the course was because I spent almost the entire time failing miserably to get anywhere on problem after problem. Sure, eventually you make the breakthrough - but only after hours of failure. Every avenue you try that doesn't work out is a frustration - often a blank-wall kind of frustration - and there are lots and lots of them before you succeed. Further, every avenue I try feels equally fruitful at the beginning, and frequently reaching the end is highly nontrivial even when you're on the right path, so "if it feels hard, you're on the wrong track" isn't a very easy thing for me to apply.
- joe_the_user 9y agoWell, the question I'd ask is whether you began approaching simpler math as being hard? Getting used to going up against brick to solve really hard problems is useful once you have a toolkit needed to solve those problems. But getting the relatively simple manipulations of the toolkit should be easy - and math undergrad work (at least at not super-advance school) is about putting together the toolkit.
- chibg10 9y agoA lot of this sounds reasonably applicable to applied math, but it sounds very out-of-place for describing pure math. The point of a proof (at least one that isn't a terribly contrived homework problem) is that there is no "correct tool" to solve it. You're developing the theory that creates (or demonstrates the validity of) the "correct tool." It's a very good training for a research mindset (research is similarly notorious for causing frustration, among many other similarities) and that's evidenced by the premium that great school admissions programs put on students with a track record of pure math success.
- smadge 9y agoOnce a theorem is proven, it becomes a tool in the toolbox which can be used to prove further theorems. This is fundamentally how math progresses and theories are built. I think this is what the author meant when they said math provides you with a toolbox.
- throwawaymath 9y agoYour comment runs counter to my experience learning math and the experience of basically every person I know with graduate or higher education in the subject. Sure you might be trying to learn something you're not ready for if you're frustrated, but even then I don't think anything past 300 level math will be realistically frustration-free the first time you're exposed to it. It feels to me like you're splitting hairs with your comment here: learning or doing new math is fundamentally a frustrating process, even for mathematicians. If you're doing math and it's not frustrating, you have an exceptional grasp of it and it's not new to you, which usually develops after persevering through many frustrating exercises. Technically speaking every mathematical proof is a proof "from first principles" - but if I teach you analysis and linear algebra, you're not going to just derive vector and tensor analysis easily, no matter what first principles you're working from. Beyond the first few years of undergrad math everything is so far removed from first principles that it's virtually certain you will struggle with some of the material unless you have significant prior exposure to it. There isn't really a way around that. You have the exposure or you don't, but math you haven't learned never just "falls into place", so to speak, even if it's relatively easier for some than others. In fact, every former math graduate student I can think of has told me the first year or so felt like wallowing in confusion. Likewise "working at the edges until it feels easy" seems like a distinction without a difference, in my opinion (but reminds me of Grothendieck). I don't see a meaningful difference between the frustration of software engineering and the frustration of math, either. If you're not doing research mathematics, day to day applied math work becomes just as much about routine, "grab your toolkit and put things together" work as programming.
- dmos62 9y agoI'll make an observation that you seem to equate incomplete comprehension and frustration, exploration and struggle, confusion and discomfort. An intellectual challenge can degrade to something unpleasant, like any experience, but it most definitely isn't inherently that.
- throwawaymath 9y agoI guess what I'm saying is the original comment's opening statement is vacuous. We can argue semantics over whether or not it's "unpleasant" or "frustrating" to learn difficult new abstractions in math, but the more important point is that 1) learning math is difficult for approximately everyone, even accomplished mathematicians, and 2) it's silly to avoid taking advice from people who had a difficult time learning math, because that rules out almost all your potential teachers. Even as an enjoyable experience it's frequently confounding. If it weren't, Wiles' famous analogy about stumbling around in a dark mansion looking for lights wouldn't be as oft-repeated as it is. If you don't want to use the word "frustration", then fine don't use it, but I think that misses the substance of the article author's point. You could adequately replace the statement in question with, "Be willing to endure ungodly amounts of confusion."
- j7ake 9y agoIf Terence Tao admits that doing mathematics is hard, then I am extremely leery of anyone who thinks otherwise.
- Barrin92 9y agoFive years of university math here and I can only mirror the author's experience. If having the feeling that math is hard ought to disqualify you then everybody will probably be disqualified. Maths is hard for everybody, including the people who excel at it. I've never met anybody who has spent serious time on a math education suggest anything else. If you get a sadistic pleasure out of torturing your mind with numbing puzzles and like the reward of finally figuring something out that you had to ponder for days (or longer) then you have a good chance of doing maths at the university level. But it never really comes naturally to anybody, it's not the kind of thing we're build for.
- romwell 9y agoI think here's what the parent wanted to say: math is hard, but it shouldn't be painful. Mathematicians, contrary to the opinion of the article writer, anre't masochists. We do math because it's rewarding and fun. Being hard doesn't make it necessarily painful. An analogy: to some, going to a gym is a painful experience. But a lot of people do enjoy it! Of course lifting weights is never easy - but that doesn't mean going to gym is inherently a masochistic experience. Only if one makes it so.
- resource0x 9y agoAlbert Einstein: “Do not worry about your difficulties in Mathematics. I can assure you mine are still greater.” :)
- ssivark 9y agoI think most responses to the above comment are misunderstanding its crux. Learning math (and other subjects in a similar spirit, like physics) is often a frustrating endeavor while you're leveling up to new concepts. IMHO, most of that is because you're thrashing around trying to find the correct perspective that opens up the subject and makes everything obvious. By obvious, I mean not just "this procedure solves this problem" but "this procedure must solve this problem... it couldn't be any other way". Once you're at that level, doing math at that level can be pretty easy. It's mostly conceptual, and doesn't have the tedious procedure that some other fields might involve. The emotional high of that clarity is what keeps a lot of people going through the frustrations along the way. Describing the painful journey without describing what makes it worthwhile is a disservice to readers.