3 ms·
I hate to mince words but...instead of free, I'd prefer if we used publicly funded, or similar. 1) Usage might be "free" but ultimately someone somewhere is pa
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
I hate to mince words but...instead of free, I'd prefer if we used publicly funded, or similar.
1) Usage might be "free" but ultimately someone somewhere is paying for it.
2) More accurate wording would actually better reflect the priorities of that particular culture, often in contrast to others of different priorities.
Free here sounds like "oh, a ride doesn't have to pay a buck. How nice." But the accomplishment is much bigger (and requires a larger financial commitment) than that.
p.s. As a side note, I hope someone is going to study the health related side effects. That is, for example, will riding more mean walking less? Will that add up to an unintended consequence?
- C4K3 9y agoSingle-payer transport, just like single-payer healthcare. That said, I would like to add an anecdote to your P.S. I commute to Copenhagen, so I take a train and then a bus to reach my destination. I have a travel pass that lets me take public transport for free in a specified region. Copenhagen also has a bike sharing system, but using the bike sharing system costs money, even with a travel pass. As such, I'm incentivized to not use the bike sharing system and take the (usually crowded) bus instead. In fact, I know of no one who uses public transport for some part of their journey, who also use the bike share. People either live within biking distance, and therefore use their own bikes (unless broken or for other reasons unavailable,) or they live far enough away that they need to take some public transport no matter what (my situation,) and then just take public transport the entire way. In the end, the bike share mostly just gets used by tourists, when it could very conveniently replace the bus for last-mile transport for many people.
- imtringued 9y ago>1) Usage might be "free" but ultimately someone somewhere is paying for it. That is the definition of free. Free always means that someone is paying for it. If I give you a book for free I still had to pay for it. The purpose of the word is that the receiver of the good didn't have to pay.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoThe point is, those using the service are paying (in taxes, or similar). They just don't pay at the time of being served. Pre or post paying doesn't make it free. Let's not be so naive.
- swebs 9y agoA better analogy would be if I gave you a book for "free", then take the cost out of your paycheck.
- mmt 9y agoMy knee-jerk reaction was "well, if you don't want to, then just don't mince the words". It's not too far a stretch that to abbreviate "toll-free" or "fare-free" as "free". TANSTAAFL. I think everyone understands (to varying degrees) that someone has to pay, though it's arguable how much anyone understands just how much these things cost in the end. :) However, as others have pointed out, the instant situation makes the criticism of calling it "free" more apt. It's not that all riders aren't paying a fare. It's that only riders that are, in effect, voting with their taxes, to the tune of 1000 euro per year, by registering as city residents, don't have to pay the fare. Suburban commuters might want that annual kilobuck to go the municipality where they actually sleep, instead, in which case, no "free" ride for them. > But the accomplishment is much bigger (and requires a larger financial commitment) than that. I think even that is arguable in many locales, given how high the existing public/tax subsidy of public transit already is as well as how high it costs to collect fares.
- chiefalchemist 9y ago"I think everyone understands (to varying degrees) that someone has to pay," I see it differently. 1) I'm absolutely certain "free" and "taxpayer funded" would result in two very different impressions. 2) Along the same lines, how many times do you hear "...government grant..." as if that's manna from heaven. Not at all. It's a euphemism for "tax dollars that Uncle Sam took from taxpayers, took a cut, and then gave it back after we begged for it." As subtle as it is, the use of "free" is vague, lacks transparency, and in most cases misleading. Why don't we get better language? Better communication?
- mmt 9y ago> 1) I'm absolutely certain "free" and "taxpayer funded" would result in two very different impressions. Maybe, but that's a false dichotomy, anyway. It's "taxpayer funded" either way. You'd have to say "fully tapayer funded" to be accurate, and then the difference in impression may have nothing to do with the content of the message but the tedious verbosity of the form. It certainly would for me, and I'd smell an agenda on the part of the person using those words in, say, a headline. > As subtle as it is, the use of "free" is vague, lacks transparency, and in most cases misleading. Again, maybe you're right, but, without even basic psychology research showing that's the case with that word, by intuition says it's not misleading for most cases. > Why don't we get better language? Better communication? A combination of there being no incentive (or incentives to the contrary), or we just don't want it. Headlines are especially notorious for having something like the opposite of "better language". Ultimately, who are you to say what's better? Language is usage is language.