3 ms·
I sincerely wish there was more research into how to measure depression in the first place. If you don't define the problem, you can't begin to search for a sol
by perl4ever 9y ago
I sincerely wish there was more research into how to measure depression in the first place. If you don't define the problem, you can't begin to search for a solution. My understanding is that we have nothing better to guide clinical studies than giving surveys asking how people feel. We need equivalents of finger-stick blood sugar tests and A1C tests for mental illness.
- your-nanny 9y agoI can always agree with "I wish there was more research" absent constraints and dependencies. But your post really seems to be saying that not nearly enough of the effort is being spent in this direction, and I'm wondering on what basis you think this? Because it is not true in my experience of dealing with depression researchers.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- perl4ever 9y agoI donated to a research foundation, and I believe it was mainly spent on pointless experiments with rats. At the time, I didn't have a strong preference for what to fund, so I went with what was suggested to me. But at this point, I look back and see the most important thing they ever funded was some of the early development of optogenetics. So I'm coming to believe that basic tools and measurement should get most of the available funding. I think there's a lot of research directed at trying things at random that is just wasted. Any IT geek surely knows the difference between trying to debug something by flailing around with random theories and really buckling down and analyzing it. The latter seems slower, but it's the only way you make progress at all.
- your-nanny 9y agoIn other words, with only a casual acquaintence with the field and literature. Got it.
- s_m_t 9y agoI remember reading about "inflammatory cytokins" and depression from an article linked on hackernews some years ago. Can't remember the specifics but I do seem to recall talk about being able to test for them in the blood. The vagus nerve is said to be involved in inflammation as well.
- jdietrich 9y agoWe don't have any good biological markers for depression at the moment. There's a strong possibility that there isn't any good biological proxy for the experience of being depressed. The main problem with current diagnostic tests is that they give equal weight to a wide range of symptoms (sleeping too much, not eating enough, feeling hopeless about the future, wanting to kill yourself) that may have wildly different importance to the patient. A treatment can look good in clinical trials without necessarily having a big impact on a patient's quality of life. A biological test could be a retrograde step if it doesn't strongly correlate with the subjective hardships of depression.
- phkahler 9y agoThat's a really simplistic view of a complicated problem. For an example of why that can't work, read about the studies on the relatives of actress Glenn Close. One is bipolar and one scizophrenic. Both were found to have a genetic variant that might be summarised as causing a glycine deficiency (possibly just in the brain IDK). Treating them with high doses of glycine eliminates symptoms in both of them. It seems unlikely that even checking blood levels would indicate a problem. Perhaps a genetic test? But this is apparently not a common genetic marker in those two conditions. Another solution in some cases is to change a person's environment, relationships, job, etc... Some depression can be relieved by changing ones worldview or other purely psychological interventions. In short, the notion of objective physical measures indicating specific conditions is not possible in most cases. SSRIs are used to increase serotonin levels, but they dont even use a serotonin test to diagnose. I have my suspicion that there's not a strong correlation.
- amelius 9y agoPerhaps functional MRI could help make a diagnosis of depression? Even with different underlying causes, a classification could perhaps be made based on imaging. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_magnetic_resonance_imaging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Functional_magnetic_resonance_...
- perl4ever 9y agoYou can talk about MRIs, or genes, or serotonin all day, but that doesn't mean you know what depression (or other mental state) is - using the current tools you assume you know what it is and that is the problem. One way to measure objectively is to look at whether someone is employable and maintains employment. But that is far too low resolution and non specific. People change their mood during a day and from one day to a next, and there must be physical correlates in principle. There is a huge human cost to the fact that nobody knows what they are doing, because they cannot relate treatment to anything objective. Sometimes a drug seems to be not working well after several years, and the dosage is raised, and all the while the side effect of the drug is what's causing the problem, so it gets worse the higher the dosage goes. In the mean time, that person becomes unable to work, and is caught in a series of catch-22s.
- glenstein 9y agoWe often can't start from definitions- we start with loosely held type cases that are obviously important. The project of finding better outcomes can be run in parallel with the project of understanding what depression is, and can iterate as our understanding of it improves.
- amelius 9y agoFor animals, we have certain models of depression: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_models_of_depression https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Animal_models_of_depression
- Nomentatus 9y agoIn most cases the consequences of depression are all too easily measured in lost productivity, less activity, kleenex consumed, duration in weeks of mood changes (say irritability) etc. Are you referring to "working depression" in which people fill time (usually working) because they are depressed but don't realize they are depressed and don't seek a diagnosis? Good diagnostitians are unlikely to miss this either, IF the patient seeks help (which they usually don't.) Agreeing on a standard red line for treatment - when mood changes merit intervention, is a different topic, and a long one, weighing risks, the profound corruption of modern medical studies, etc.