3 ms·
This was figured out in an Dept. Homeland Security "red team" test of the TSA a few years ago, where the TSA failed like 95%+ of the tests against them: https:/
by dragontamer 9y ago
This was figured out in an Dept. Homeland Security "red team" test of the TSA a few years ago, where the TSA failed like 95%+ of the tests against them: https://abcnews.go.com/US/exclusive-undercover-dhs-tests-find-widespread-security-failures/story?id=31434881 https://abcnews.go.com/US/exclusive-undercover-dhs-tests-fin...
I think the TSA has switched strategies recently, and they've been improving since then. But ultimately, its not the "bag check" where the TSA catches goons, its the random more intense check that they do these days. And sure, going from 95% failure to 80% failure isn't much of an improvement, but its still going to change the calculus of an attacker. When you have a 20% chance of failure before you even board the airplane, that's an issue to your plans.
Furthermore, TSA includes air marshals and the Israeli-style "behavioral" cops who are scanning airports. These are the more successful cops at the job, and the ones we are relying upon for real.
I wouldn't discount the entirety of the TSA just because of the failures of the bag-check program. Again, US Air marshals (armed cops who sit on every aircraft secretly with plain-clothes) are under the TSA and I think the US Air Marshals contributes a LOT to our real security.
Unfortunately, the bag-check thing is mostly security theater, but at the same time, the more "serious" checks vs attackers are more hidden and less well known (as it should be). But security theater might be enough to discourage an attack, or at very least cause our enemies to focus on the bag-check (when our REAL security really lies with other programs). So its a useful distraction IMO. There's a bit of "wink-wink lets not talk about this" going on that you need to understand though.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- fosk 9y ago> US Air marshals (armed cops who sit on every aircraft secretly with plain-clothes) Do they really sit on every flight?
- Tushon 9y agoNo, just on the basic numbers we have available, it would not be possible. https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/13264/are-air-marshals-on-every-flight https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/13264/are-air-m...
- Rebelgecko 9y agoNo. The percentage of flights with air marshals is in the low single digits.
- knz 9y agoWhich makes sense. A JFK to AMS flight is probably a much higher risk for terrorism than say FSD to MOT.
- Rebelgecko 9y agoAccording to the article I read, they're actually less common on flights out of NY and Washington DC- there were pilots complaining that they hadn't seen an air marshal in 6+ months. It sounds like they avoid putting marshals on flights that have other law enforcement officers on them, which is going to be a good chunk of the domestic flights to/from big cities
- Someone1234 9y agoNope, but I've had one sit next to me before on a US bound international flight (in 2005 ish). So they definitely exist.
- globuous 9y agoInteresting ! So they are also on international flights going to the us ! How about outbound international flights where the jet is full of fuel over the US ? Btw, how did you recognize he was a FAM ?
- matwood 9y agoNo, but I had one sit next to me on a flight to Vegas once. It's a long story, first how we suspected and then when he admitted it as we got off the plane. They do exist though.
- bonzini 9y agoHow did you suspect?... (And, who's the other person in the plural?)
- wise0wl 9y agoThe sky-marshal-starter-pack, of course: https://i.redd.it/w67t4ogdmx8y.jpg https://i.redd.it/w67t4ogdmx8y.jpg
- matwood 9y agoSome friends and I were on the way to Vegas. We had a few drinks and I guess hit the limit they serve on a flight. We had been having a conversation with a guy next to us about small talk things, joking, wharever. This guy then looks at the stewardess and says “they’re fine, and there is no need to cut them off”. She then kept bringing drinks until we landed. At that point we started joking he was an air marshall, and he laughed it off. Once we got in the terminal he kinda flashed his ankle holster and told us to have fun on our vacation. Also mentioned something along the lines that we had made a normally boring 5 hour flight entertaining. I should add this was 10+ years ago.
- freeopinion 9y agoOh, well, if he admitted it, then he must have been a real marshall.
- hyder_m29 9y ago> I wouldn't discount the entirety of the TSA just because of the failures of the bag-check program. Bag check programs are focal to these discussions because they cause the most inconvenience to passengers.