9 ms·
The American Housing Crisis Might Be Our Next Big Political Issue
- ummonk 9y agoToo late for us but hopefully it will make obtaining a home easier for our children!
- twblalock 9y agoUnfortunately it seems so far that voters in California are reacting to the problem by supporting more of the policies that caused the problem in the first place, e.g. rent control, opposing new market-rate housing, etc. It's pretty easy for politicians to sell those bad solutions, which is why we ended up with them in the first place. I doubt the YIMBY movement is going to solve the problem, because they have alienated many lower-income voters.
- ng12 9y ago> because they have alienated many lower-income voters. How so?
- twblalock 9y agoThey think the YIMBYs are dismissing their concerns about gentrification and displacement. I'm not sure that's true, but either way, the YIMBY movement's image is of a bunch of affluent white tech workers who don't care about low-income, minority residents whose neighborhoods might get gentrified. That image will need to change if the YIMBYs want to succeed.
- wbl 9y agoMinorities in CA are more likely to support building more homes than whites.
- abalone 9y agoYes but not necessarily market-rate developments that accelerate gentrification and displacement. BMR housing, for sure.
- hunter23 9y agoI don't know why you are being downvoted - SFgate recently published an article talking about Yimby members yelling over minority groups and those minority groups basically called Yimby a bunch of "affluent white tech workers". So it's definitely a problem of Yimby not managing it's image and forming alliances well.
- ng12 9y agoI think anyone who's trying to shout down another group based on their race doesn't deserve to be allied with.
- hunter23 9y agoBecause they don't have low income leaders in their organization and they've been dismissive of minority concerns. See: http://www.sfexaminer.com/sb-827-rallies-end-yimbys-shouting-protesters-color/ http://www.sfexaminer.com/sb-827-rallies-end-yimbys-shouting... While I support the Yimby approach the truth is it is largely led by upper middle class white people. To get things done in politics, you don't to have the best argument, you need to have the best consensus of citizens and $$ supporting you. The yimby org doesn't realize this - they think they can steam roll over minority groups to get things done, but frankly they need to a better job building bridges with these groups. This is how politics work.
- cavisne 9y agoA hilariously biased article... how anyone could dream of linking that as a reference astounds me
- smallnamespace 9y agoThe fundamental interests of the various groups aren't necessarily fully aligned, are they? E.g. it may be the case that rent control and other roadblocks increase the cost of housing in the long run (bad for anyone new moving to the Bay Area), but it certainly benefits the current occupants of rent-controlled housing. That's one reason to be slightly skeptical of the label 'minority' organizations—it's unclear whether all minorities have the same interests at stake. In particular, minorities who currently live in below-market cost housing have markedly different expected payoff from a change in policy than minorities who currently live outside of the city. Certainly, good politics and making nice can smooth over some amount of disagreement, but is there really a mechanism right now that could make everyone better off? I, too, would like to live in a world where: - Minorities and/or lower income people aren't priced out of the city - ... and will have enough units to live in in the future - and widespread construction so tech workers or other immigrants have cheaper rent - the character of our neighborhoods aren't gentrified away - and it isn't too expensive to build ...but experience as engineers tells us that there is always a compromise to be made when you ask for everything. The political fight here is who is will end up compromising, and how much.
- 9y ago
- api 9y ago> they have alienated many lower-income voters. It seems like lower income voters reliably vote against their economic self-interest across the United States.
- Larrikin 9y agoWhich voting block, besides rural land owners, does this?
- majos 9y agoThe amount of popular support for rent control depresses me in the same way that the popularity of lottery tickets does. People in general seem to have an endless capacity to believe that the rare, improbable, valuable opportunity will go to them.
- majormajor 9y agoRent control to reduce uncertainty for people already living there isn't a lottery odds thing - it's not a solution to the problem of hard to find new places, it's a solution to the problem of getting priced out by external forces. It has side effects, but is also addressing a specific problem people want to handle that isn't necessarily fixed by "just build a bunch of new market-rate housing." Weakening rent control in the 90s in CA didn't prevent the current homelessness problems, so I have some skepticism around taking that even further. Pushing people who could afford marginal housing into no longer being able to afford it seems like a bang-up way to increase homelessness. Part of the root of the problem seems to be cities that trying to both avoid densifying but also increase commercial and office space and occupancy and jobs. Either policy would be fine by itself, but they explode when put together. Some cities are slowly starting to realize this, but saying "we don't need a constant economic growth rate of X% if we don't want the feel of our city to change" may not be an easy choice for politicians to sell.
- majos 9y agoGood point. I was thinking of this from the perspective of people who can't afford to live in place x, not people trying to avoid being forced out of place x by rising rents. I'm not well-versed in the state of rent control in CA, but I am seeing more rent control put forth as a viable alternative to just building more residences. That strikes me as a bad idea.
- roenxi 9y ago> It has side effects, but is also addressing a specific problem people want to handle that isn't necessarily fixed by "just build a bunch of new market-rate housing." It is a sad fact of life that the best outcome for everybody is to let the economically productive take first pick of any available resources; because they will by definition take them and turn them into more resources. This idea that someone has a right to live somewhere because they were there first is not unreasonable, but the path of least suffering is that people pay the market price for rent. There needs to be pretty overwhelming evidence that the problem is with what consenting adults agree to rather than the government being unreasonable with the rules on constructing new building. I'd bet that the US hasn't reached that threshold yet.
- cft 9y agoThat's one of the fundamental problems "bugs" with popular democracy- most popular decisions are often far from the best.
- Shivetya 9y agoGreen lining, red lining of old disguised with terms and claims that make you feel guilty opposing.
- mc32 9y agoI’d say even the present form of rent control needs reform. People should be means tested every so often so that you don’t end up with situations like where the burning man self described founder, mr. Harvey, who had money kept his rent controlled apt till the end.
- intopieces 9y ago> People should be means tested every so often This would create disincentives for seeking a higher salary (because an increase in salary might be offset by getting kicked out of your BMR unit).
- mc32 9y agoThat’s okay, if people wanna shoot themselves in the foot and undermine their own career development, so be it, but often enough you have people who can afford market rate housing living in rent controlled properties, more or less undercutting the programme itself.
- abalone 9y ago> I doubt the YIMBY movement is going to solve the problem, because they have alienated many lower-income voters. I think you're right and part of the problem is reflected in your comment. YIMBYs are supremely confident in its diagnosis of the complex housing problem: it's rent control and other impediments to the free market. They are so confident that it's literally at the level of flipping the bozo bit[1] on low-income and minority housing activists and attempting to speak on their behalf. They think the answer is so obvious that to think otherwise means you're being manipulated by rich white NIMBY homeowners. That's understandably a bit insulting. It's led longtime housing activists to note that YIMBY has a "white privilege problem... They don't understand poverty."[2] Meanwhile housing activists are saying things like, hey, maybe it has something to do with, I dunno, massively defunding the major force in constructing affordable housing for the poor and working class (HUD)?[3] Perhaps the income disparity is so great between low-income renters and tech workers that there is a wee bit of understandable skepticism that market-rate development alone will bring down the market price to something the working poor can afford? YIMBYs need to do a better job of listening to and understanding the legitimate concerns from these communities if they want to be successful -- not attempt to talk over them (literally[4]) or rush through legislation that gets patched up later after protest. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bozo_bit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bozo_bit [2] http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-housing-bill-failure-equity-groups-20180502-story.html http://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-housing-bill-failu... [3] http://www.sfweekly.com/news/the-great-eliminator-how-ronald-reagan-made-homelessness-permanent/ http://www.sfweekly.com/news/the-great-eliminator-how-ronald... [4] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3WrVEYKVtfU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3WrVEYKVtfU
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- epistasis 9y ago> YIMBYs are supremely confident in its diagnosis of the complex housing problem: it's rent control and other impediments to the free market YIMBYs do not have a position on rent control, because both sides are advocated for and debated. The biggest problem with the YIMBY movement is people blindly accepting criticisms of YIMBY without bothering to investigate what YIMBY movements actually believe. When there was a big panel discussion in my small Bay Area town last year, without a YIMBY member on the panel, the panel all concluded that YIMBYs oppose affordable housing. However, in this small town, the ONLY PEOPLE WHO SHOWED UP to advocate for recent affordable housing projects were YIMBY members. And it turns out that SB 35, the only YIMBY legislation I know about, is actually about building affordable housing. So please stop reinforcing false beliefs. YIMBYs do a great job of listening. They have changed their engagement in response to this. They are politically naive in that they believe they can advocate for ideas and trust that people will listen to them, instead of seeking out engagement of current power brokers first. And for example they didn't expect SB 827 to get the momentum that it got, perhaps not realizing that including transportation and basic good urban planning they will wake up a lot more people than with they did with the SB 35 affordable housing bill. California politics is all about optics, unfortunately. At least, it is, until we stop letting that happen.
- brudgers 9y agoTo me, expecting US housing markets facing affordability problems to build their way out of their affordability problems ignores the fact these markets are markets. And it ignores the timelines and investment goals of real estate investors. Sure real-estate investors often complain about regulations. But those complaints are rooted in the effects of regulation on liquidity and profits, not on afforadability. Up market housing gets built because that's what people with money want [1] and where the net returns from developable parcels are often higher...commercial development has much higher potential returns still. That's why the big money like insurance reserves often prefers Class A office, retail, and industrial REIT's over single family or condominiums. The big money in real-estate that drives markets is at a scale where affordable or even ordinary housing deals aren't big enough. The timelines of big real-estate money are often 30-50 years to match liabilities like life-insurance. The only part of the US housing market which comes close to that timeline is conventional 30 year mortgages. But at $100-200k per deal, it takes thousands of deals just to get $1 billion out the door. Then the thirty years is still just theory: there's refinancing and home sales making the practical investment turnover five or ten years (times thousands of investments). Unaffordablility is a sign of high market demand where affordable housing is less preferred by investors than raw land or unredeveloped redevelopable property. Holding developable property means there's a real asset beneath the investment and the risk/reward can be spread across multiple economic cycles. Construction not only requires the injection of additional capital, but ties the risk/reward to a particular economic cycle. Again, it is worth keeping in mind that at the macro level the real-estate markets are largely driven by parked capital not borrowed money in the form of money. B2C isn't what drives real-estate markets over the long term. The US housing market is driven by government intervention. FHA mortgages and the mortgage interest deduction are two easy examples. These exist because traditionally there has not been much incentive for the bulk of capital in the real-estate market to invest in houses for ordinary Americans. Historically, the sprawling checkerboard suburbs are largely the result of smaller ad hoc deals not the really big players. Though that's changing a bit, the involvement of the big players tends to encourage housing to move upscale and into multi-use developments with commercial and retail components..."the affordable lifestyle" doesn't look good on a sales brochure. [1] Selling to people with money is a good sales strategy.
- deleted 9y ago
- api 9y agoLook at Canada (Vancouver and Toronto specifically) for a glimpse of how bad it can get if anti-development urban policies combined with pro-home-inflation monetary and banking policies are allowed to run unchecked. The prices are even more insane than San Francisco / Silicon Valley when considered as a multiple of median income. It's really kind of incredible. These prices seem economically impossible, yet there they are and houses are apparently selling. It seems like there actually is no ceiling to house prices. A lot of people blame cash buyers from overseas using real estate as a financial instrument but I have yet to see hard evidence that this is prevalent enough to explain this madness.
- khuey 9y agoToronto at least seems to be starting to deflate. e.g. https://twitter.com/JohnWake/status/996524868102336512 https://twitter.com/JohnWake/status/996524868102336512
- graeme 9y agoI think TO housing starts have outpaced population growth. I think it's actually just a bubble. Different from a place like SF where supply is the limit and demand is exploding from real economic factors.
- maxxxxx 9y agoIt will probably be a big issue and be solved as well as education costs and health care are being solved right now. There will be many words and no solution. There are way too many people benefiting from the current state.
- tptacek 9y agoThis is a regional issue, not a national one. Most urban Americans do not live in cities with skyrocketing housing costs.
- nerfhammer 9y agoit's a national issue because it keeps people from moving to where jobs are. http://neighborhoodeffects.mercatus.org/2017/01/26/why-the-lack-of-labor-mobility-in-the-u-s-is-a-problem-and-how-we-can-fix-it/ http://neighborhoodeffects.mercatus.org/2017/01/26/why-the-l...
- Spooky23 9y agoThen the jobs will move to where the people are. A community near me is booming because telecommuting makes it practical to commute to NYC by train twice a week. Eventually that will lead to new business and economic activity. We shouldn’t be screwing up property rights everywhere because tech companies are too stupid and have too much dumb money to geographically diversify and prefer to pay too much for talent instead.
- brm 9y agoOut of migratory curiosity, what community?
- Spooky23 9y agoThe one my friend was telling me about recently was Catskill, NY. It’s about 30-40 minutes south of Albany. Some of the market attracted to Columbia County is crossing the river. It’s a struggling area with a lot of nice cheap property, both in and out of town. The Hudson Amtrak is about a 15 minute drive and 2-2.5 hour trip to Manhattan. IMO Upstate once you get out of the Hudson Valley is relatively cheap and nice.
- nerfhammer 9y agoWhat property rights are violated by blocking an apartment building from being built on a vacant lot? The rights of the owner of the vacant lot.
- grabarz 9y agoStop printing money.
- posix_compliant 9y agoCould you elaborate?
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoIt’s not really a solution so much as it is a bandaid. Sure, you could raise interest rates and nominal house prices will go down. But it doesn’t solve the problem of limited housing supply in places like the Bay Area.
- jMyles 9y agoIt's not a terribly elaborate solution, just a simple and good one: let's have the federal reserve stop promoting monetary policy that encourages reckless spending, easy money, expensive houses, and tons of plastic shit. Some people present it as a solution to all the world's ills, which it is far from. But it's a good foundation for many solutions for many ills.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoIt still won’t matter in real terms. Real housing prices will still continue to rise, until the fundamental housing shortage is solved in places like the Bay Area.
- pjmorris 9y agoNot GP, and this comment is copied from earlier in my history, but... One example: the US central bank's (Fed) Quantitative Easing (QE). In my view, QE's inflation happened before QE started. A significant purpose of QE was to prop up the loans made before the financial crisis. The inflation happened with the creation of trillions of dollars of securitized sub-prime housing loans. Rather than allowing those loans to default, the Fed is acting as a buyer of last resort through QE MBS purchases [0]. Without the Fed, much less money would be available for housing loans, and their prices would return to historical ratios to income [1, 2]. [0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MBST https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MBST [1] https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2006/.. https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/imagepages/2006/.... [2] Blue line in http://www.econ.yale.edu/~shiller/data/Fig3-1.xls http://www.econ.yale.edu/~shiller/data/Fig3-1.xls
- dionidium 9y agoCheap detached homes are the norm in the vast majority of the United States. What's happening in California and the Northeast Corridor is a serious problem that should be addressed, but the issue isn't going to catch on at the national level, because, again, cheap detached homes are the norm in the United States. When Millennials on the coasts talk about how their generation won't ever own homes, I have to wonder if they're seriously that out of touch. Here's a house that's for sale in my hometown of St. Louis. I just picked a neighborhood at random and selected the first house I saw for sale around this price (~$100k): https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Saint-Louis-MO-63116/3019850_zpid/85934_rid/1-_beds/0-600000_price/0-2428_mp/globalrelevanceex_sort/38.564794,-90.290579,38.56295,-90.29346_rect/18_zm/ https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Saint-Louis-MO-63116/3... This is a quiet, safe, well-maintained, working-class neighborhood. That house is nothing to write home about, but it's not a bad little bungalow, either. That'd be a great home for any young family. I get it, I get it -- "but then I'd have to live in St. Louis!" That's funny, I guess, but who is the joke really on? How much is that ocean worth to you?
- Zach_the_Lizard 9y ago> Cheap detached homes are the norm in the vast majority of the United States Perhaps by land area. But not necessarily by population. Something like 1/3rd of the population lives in the DC-NYC-Boston corridor. Throw in the West Coast, Chicago, etc. and you're looking at a much more national problem.
- dionidium 9y agoThat's a good point, but, despite what some may wish, we don't actually have a national politics that's decided by a straight-up popular vote. There are a lot of people in those cities, but they don't always wield proportional influence on national issues.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>Something like 1/3rd of the population lives in the DC-NYC-Boston corridor. Throw in the West Coast, Chicago, etc. and you're looking at a much more national problem. There's a lot of people who live in single family houses in those areas.
- patrickg_zill 9y agoI keep seeing parallels to the situation in USSR after WWII - there was a chronic lack of housing: some of the housing stock had been destroyed in WWII, there were new couples that were owed (by the state) housing, and of course the existing housing stock had further deteriorated (it was that many years older than before the war). Khrushchev championed the construction of pre-fabricated concrete "plank" 5 story buildings - they built 2 factories in different parts of USSR and cranked them out, delivering them mostly by train to all corners of the country. The designs were pretty much the same, down the interior furnishings and apartment layouts (a plot point of the perennial New Year's Eve favorite movie, "Irony of Fate"), and fit and finish were sub-standard. BUT, people did get their housing, had kids, went on with their lives. With all the post-USSR criticism of Soviet leaders, you realize that Khrushchev had very few bad things said about him... I think the person, or organization, that is seen to (somehow, however they do it) solve the housing problems we have, will have a great deal of political goodwill and possibly political power. EDIT: some "Khrushchevka Housing" info https://www.citylab.com/equity/2017/03/the-disappearing-mass-housing-of-the-soviet-union/518868/ https://www.citylab.com/equity/2017/03/the-disappearing-mass... https://themoscowtimes.com/articles/moscows-new-housing-megaproject-confronts-soviet-history-57312 https://themoscowtimes.com/articles/moscows-new-housing-mega... https://khrushchevki.wordpress.com/ https://khrushchevki.wordpress.com/
- resource0x 9y agoSome readers unfamiliar with the matter might conclude based on your post that Khrushchev somehow managed to solve the problem. No. In most places, you had to wait a couple of decades (or longer). I left USSR at the age of 36; we , the family of 4, occupied a 160 sq ft apartment (with "partial conveniences" - you probably know what that means), which we inherited from my grandmother, with no chance of getting anything else in a lifetime. We couldn't buy an apartment either, even if we had money (we didn't) - "cooperative" housing was not available. BTW, I worked as a project lead in a military research center back then, so the situation was not due to low status or something. Here's an article that provides some details (in Russian, sorry): https://masterok.livejournal.com/2892813.html https://masterok.livejournal.com/2892813.html EDIT: BTW, would it be a good idea to organize AMA thread for those who'd like to get some first-hand account of what the life in USSR looked like in the 60s,70s,80s (all aspects, including technology)?
- dba7dba 9y agoThe REAL cause of the housing crisis is more and more rich people/companies view real estate as a way to make money. Not just as a way to park wealth to defend against inflation, but to make $. With astounding return rate. Frankly, I think the only way housing crisis can be resolved is 1. taxing severely anyone who owns multiple house/condos (not apartment units) with the plan of renting. Probably gradually higher tax rate based on number of units or monthly rent fee. 2. Heavy tax for profit made from flipping a house. The goals of the tax would be to control excessive amount of $ from flowing into real estate. Real estate investment is made out to be a really smart/great investment. But why?
- maxxxxx 9y agoAgreed. Real estate investing should be disincentivized.
- chillacy 9y agoSounds reasonable. And I'd add that a house is not only seen as an investment but also a safe investment, so people are going out and leveraging themselves through a bank loan to 5x their downpayment. I don't think I could buy anything else that big with such great interest rates.
- anonuser123456 9y agoIf your goal is to create a Venezuela like housing crisis sure, you could do 1 & 2. I'm not sure the rest of us want that.
- dba7dba 9y agoMy goal is not to create a Venezuela like housing crisis. But housing investment is sucking in $ from everywhere, even non-American investors. Some at top are raking in money while everyone else is paying for it. There is a reason more and more wealth is concentrated in less and less people at the top.
- owyn 9y agoIt's a good investment at the right time. Most of the time it's a place to live. If you're over leveraged it could be bad. Of course it depends. But the potential rate of return can be pretty astounding. Anecdotally, I bought a modest house in Seattle a long time ago, when you could do zero down payments so I just paid some closing costs, etc. I rented out rooms to friends to cover most of the mortgage. I was making less than 6 figures at the time. After 3 years, I sold it. After commissions, etc the return on investment was 12x. And it was tax free. If I'd kept it another 10 years until the current boom, apparently the ROI would have been closer to 40x. Not many other investment vehicles can offer that. Of course I moved to the bay area and didn't immediately buy a new house so I'm totally screwed now, along with everyone else.
- nikanj 9y agoWe routinely oppose building for the majority because the homes built would not fit a minority. Vancouver is proposing new parking norms that force at least half the parking spots in a residential parking garage to be extra tall, to accommodate tall vans for disabled people. This is a great idea, but it again raises the cost of building new homes, for the benefit of the minority who need a full-height van because of their disability.
- scythe 9y agoIf you want to really address the zoning problem on a cultural level, you have to find a way to create an "expectation" of the quality of life in some category of multi-unit building which is acceptable to the modal American. It's pretty typical to expect apartments to be noisy, smelly, not-so-private places which are not so desirable to live in. I can't say my own experience living in an apartment has really contradicted this, either. I'm speculating here, but I think that part of the reason people oppose housing types considered unpleasant is that people may be less likely to stay in them if they have the opportunity to move. If you move into a nice unit (house, townhouse, apartment, whatever) in a stiff market, and the market eases up and you can afford to move, you might not, because moving is a lot of work and the expected benefit is small. But if you move into an unpleasant space in a difficult market, you're likely out of there as soon as you have the chance. This might imply that unpleasant housing types are more likely to become vacant during a market downturn, and because of problems associated with vacant housing, people might want to avoid unpleasant housing being constructed near them. The key exception here are the small add-on units recently legalized in San Francisco; because the main unit will remain occupied, issues associated with vacancy and disrepair of the subsidiary unit are prevented. However, there aren't clear standards that determine whether a multi-unit building will be a place people want to stay, whereas SFH are usually for whatever reason expected to retain their occupants. So when I say "to create an expectation", I mean an expectation among the neighbors that whoever moves in is going to like the place they live in enough that they won't move out in five years when the market cools off. And if you expect the market will never cool off, you're also assuming you never solve the housing crisis, which is not a good founding assumption for making plans to solve the housing crisis. I could imagine standards like: external entrances, private outdoor space (balcony), in-unit laundry, sound insulation, and separate ventilation. But those are just my preferences; any actual standards ought to be based on reliable evidence of some kind. It may be possible to survey the kinds of units that people move out of during housing market downturns in order to identify some predictive characteristics which can both influence housing standards and allay the concerns of voters.
- closeparen 9y agoI think you’re on to something, but at the same time it’s the nicer multifamily buildings that face stiffer opposition, due to the perception that such buildings are inherently reserved for the impossibly wealthy. Outside the YIMBY camp, no one believes that building enough of these could make them affordable. But when you really look at it, the most extravagant high-rise condos are physically equivalent to below-average houses with no yards. Made abundant enough, they should be priced that way.
- metapsj 9y agothe focus on housing is short sighted. there will always be a physical limit based on the geography of the area. most political agendas are focused on concentration of wealth to maximize public programs i.e. mass transportation. i think we've reached a point where redistributing high paying jobs across a larger geographic area is the only real solution for most large cities.
- closeparen 9y agoThere will always be a limit, but we are artificially constraining city populations to tiny fractions of engineering limits, with immense human, environmental, and economic costs.
- metapsj 9y agoi agree with your assessment that we are artificially constraining city populations. i feel it's more than just the engineering potential that limits a city's capacity. consider the political climate, the economic environment, the sunk cost by existing home owners, businesses, and city services, the accumulated technical debt of legacy construction practices, artificial boundaries developed by cities to bolster real estate values, and not to mention the accumulated debt of a city like san francisco which the last i read was at $10B. there are a lot of forces at play to gain consensus especially when you have significant momentum moving along a trajectory started easily 30 years ago that lead us to where we are today. more importantly, it's far easier to create incentives to entice companies with high economic value and high paying jobs to an area with few competitive forces.
- epistasis 9y agoWhich of these cities is even near to the physical limit? I think you're getting downvoted because none of them are at any sort of physical limit. Density is amazingly good for humans: it promotes huge amounts of intellection and economic growth. Density is what so much of the country is yearning for, and being denied by prior generations and entrenched wealthy residents. There's only one place density should go: cities. And they have a ton of room for growth in the US to even match other dense cities in world, such as Paris.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoThis is a regional issue and it boils down to the fact that micro-managing what people build on their own damn property has had negative consequences. Regulation isn't going to solve this problem. Regulation caused it.
- gradys 9y agoI see a lot of discussion of YIMBY policies like building more market-rate housing. My intuition favors these kinds of policies, but when I've tried to find high quality evidence that they actually achieve objectives like: - Lower housing prices overall - Lower housing costs for low-income households (heading off the concern that only building market-rate housing could hypothetically lower the price of luxury housing without meaningfully reducing housing costs for low-income households) - Fewer people have to leave the area because of high housing costs ... I haven't been able to find much. What are the best sources that say that YIMBY policies and especially pro- market-rate housing policies actually work? Or the converse - that affordable housing quotas or similar policies tend to make housing less affordable overall.
- anonuser123456 9y agoTokyo/Japenese housing regulation is often cited as evidence for this hypothesis. https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-costs-tokyo https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-...
- pkaye 9y agoThe Japanese are used to living in tiny accommodations. If we follow their route we could probably reduce costs a lot. Get rid of parking spots. No outdoor patio. Can easily reduce the square footage by 50%.
- jaredklewis 9y agoAs far as I can tell, they basically don't build Japanese apartments without outdoor patios. No one has dryers, everyone hangs their clothes outside. But to your point, my anecdotal impression is that even though the average 1 bedroom or 2 bedroom in Japan Tokyo is smaller than an equivalent in the US, the price per sq foot in Tokyo is also much less than in New York, San Francisco, or Los Angeles. Hard to find reliable, cross-country data but this blog post [1] pegs price for rental square foot for SF at $4.75 and Tokyo at $2.79. It's also true about the parking, but again regulations are at play here. Minimum parking requirements are the norm, not the exception in the US. Developers can’t build less parking even if they want to. Even a giant metropolis like San Francisco didn't start to eliminate minimum parking requirements until the late 90s [2]. 1. https://www.rentcafe.com/blog/rental-market/what-is-1500-worth-worldwide-rent-per-square-foot-around-the-globe/ https://www.rentcafe.com/blog/rental-market/what-is-1500-wor... 2. https://www.livablecity.org/parking-history-sf/ https://www.livablecity.org/parking-history-sf/
- rajacombinator 9y agoIt’s a fiat induced worldwide suicide pact. Only one way out.
- 8bitsrule 9y agoThe 'crisis' (an overused word) has developed since Glass-Stiegel was repealed. There used to be two kinds of banks. It became possible to think of houses as investments. Stop the speculation. Return to sound principles. Or will we wait until the same thing happens to food, water and then air? Can't happen? Why not?