3 ms·
Your valuation approach would have suggested that Facebook was ludicrously over priced at its IPO and that it was a pipsqueak compared to Google. Investors were
by adventured 9y ago
Your valuation approach would have suggested that Facebook was ludicrously over priced at its IPO and that it was a pipsqueak compared to Google. Investors were betting the Facebook business would do what it has done: grow dramatically and more than offset the valuation having been pulled forward. Your approach collapses in the face of accounting for high rates of persistent growth.
Tesla is growing radically faster than GM, which hasn't increased its sales or global market share meaningfully in 15 years.
Tesla, 2016 -> 2017 sales growth: 67%
GM, 2016 -> 2017 sales growth: Negative
That kind of growth by Tesla universally gets you a huge valuation adjustment vs a company with zero or negative growth.
Investors are betting that GM's future is not particularly bright, that there is no growth in the business. It is discounted accordingly, which is why it has such a hilariously low PE ratio (six times earnings in real terms).
When Amazon passed Walmart in market value, it had minimal profit profit and 1/6th the retail sales of Walmart.
The market isn't primarily valuing Tesla based on what it's doing today. It's a bet that Tesla will continue to produce considerable growth for many years to come.
- moolcool 9y ago>Tesla, 2016 -> 2017 sales growth: 67% >GM, 2016 -> 2017 sales growth: Negative If I sold my car on craigslist today, I'd have an ∞% sales growth rate.