5 ms·
HN at its worst: using a post about creating a font as a cheap excuse to mock Airbnb's engineers and designers, their jobs and their reason for being employed t
by adventured 9y ago
HN at its worst: using a post about creating a font as a cheap excuse to mock Airbnb's engineers and designers, their jobs and their reason for being employed there.
And somehow it's the top comment in the thread, as opposed to, say, actually discussing the font or the content of the article. Wtf.
- syassami 9y agoit's a classic HN. "I can build that in a weekend!"
- rootlocus 9y agoFirst of all, nobody mentioned building anything in a weekend. Second, generic responses like yours can also be considered "classic HN", so it's kind of like the pot calling the kettle black. And third, If you've made the same font for Netflix, it apparently takes 3 months to make enough subtle changes to brand it "one of a kind".
- mephitix 9y agoActually my response was - WHY build/work on this? I understand that licensing a font can cost a company a lot of money but there is no reason why a company of this size can't just use any of the thousands of open source fonts available. It is a waste of time/resources that is pretty characteristic of a big tech company (having worked at one). In at least the cases I've seen - the reason why this happens is because design teams want to stand out and stamp their identity on the company. It is a reason to add imaginary value to internal "design studios" and promote designers to arbitrary titles. And engineers, PMs, etc. mostly do the same. Create work, features, platforms that add no real value but simply to stamp their identity and pursue (effectively) self-promotion. The original commenter makes a great point about saying that there are many other things to focus their energies. Okay, throwing engineers at a single problem is not a good way to do things. But the AirBnB iOS app has been broken for ages. Various visual and functional bugs. Offline support is arguably the most important feature for an AirBnb app (if you're traveling and don't have service). But this hasn't been tackled at all. Instead AirBnB engineers are going through all of their properties and updating their fonts, fixing issues with responsiveness/scaling, packaging on mobile platforms, etc. WHY?
- slededit 9y agoThe WHY is because they want a unique brand identifier. If they used a font anyone else could use then it would no longer be unique to the brand. Essentially they don't want you to feel comfortable or at home on a competitors site who may try to mimic their branding. This expense goes under marketing not R&D.
- Retra 9y agoLet's discuss the font then. It's boring and generic. Obviously it needs a 30-page puff piece written about it. Remind everybody the AirBnb had a super bowl ad, etc. This is not content marketing. Yada yada.
- jochung 9y agoExactly. They spend all this effort on a font that Joe Average can't tell apart from Arial or Helvetica, and which only a typographer would think is a "distinct typeface" with unique characteristics, seeing as it very closely resembles the existing font they use on this blog. "We love typography because we see it as a building block for creating meaningful connections around the world." is the kind of word salad that only an art school grad could come up with. The only substantial point is that they need to support a lot of languages and have readable text for all... So why are they already launching this font with only Latin character support? Because it's a pointless marketing excercise and nobody will care or notice the difference, or the fallback font they'll have included. This is what happens when you give your design department their own domain name: like birds on the Galapagos islands, they evolve to compete in bizarre and non functional ways, unbothered by external selection pressure.
- dawhizkid 9y agoI'm making a point on how indulgent it is to spend technical resources on something of so little consequence, and then write 2(!) 10,000+ word blogposts (including https://airbnb.design/working-type/ https://airbnb.design/working-type/) on it and also produce a video to announce it to the world. The second blogpost actually says After 18 months of creating, refining, testing, and integrating, we flipped the switch and released Airbnb Cereal across our brand and product. 18 months?! This is HBO Silicon Valley level insanity. Spend 18 months figuring out how to stop real issues on the marketplace like discrimination against minority guests. The only solution Airbnb has offered to quell the #AirbnbWhileBlack controversies that started in 2016 has been to force hosts and guests to click a button pledging to not discriminate. That is an actual issue. This is throwing idle bodies at a non-existent problem.
- coldtea 9y ago>And somehow it's the top comment in the thread, as opposed to, say, actually discussing the font or the content of the article. Wtf. Specifics of your comment aside (which I may agree with), on principle it's not necessary to always discuss the "content of the article". The post serves as a starting point. It doesn't have to confine and frame the discussion. Especially if there are other more important stuff lurking or implied behind what a post says.
- dx034 9y agoI don't like excessive complaining but isn't it valid to ask why a company such as airbnb needs to spend the money on their own font?