8 ms·
California’s next bold step on climate should be building near transit
- capkutay 9y agothat was already struck down by california voters who value sparse, low populous neighborhoods more than the environment. https://sf.curbed.com/2018/4/18/17250876/california-senate-bill-827-housing-transit-vote-wiener https://sf.curbed.com/2018/4/18/17250876/california-senate-b...
- api 9y agoIt was struck down by reps, not voters directly. Make a note of yes and no votes and now you know who to vote for or against next election.
- DrScump 9y agoNot even. It was killed in committee, as only two of nine Democrats supported it. Half the Republicans on the committee voted Aye; only one voted against.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jpao79 9y agoA better rule than SB827 would be a rule for every office worker employed in the city, there must be an equivalent housing unit provided by that same city such that the jobs per resident ratio is maintained. If Menlo Park wants to allow Facebook to build an office complex to support 2,000 more Facebook employees than it needs to create 2,000 more residential options for those employees. Otherwise Redwood City and East Palo Alto have to shoulder the burden of housing, education and other services for those new residents without the benefit of the tax basis. Or if San Francisco wants to build 5 more Salesforce Towers, San Francisco should be required to present a plan to build 5 neighboring residential towers to support those office towers. Or pass on the opportunity and encourage Salesforce to take a look at Oakland/San Jose/Sacramento/Fresno. Let's put it this way, if Wiener really had concerned about housing, then the really good solution would be to let Brisbane build the Salesforce/Uber office towers in Brisbane and then for Wiener find a transit rich location within San Francisco for the housing development to support those office towers. From an outsider perspective, it just seems like SF is perfectly happy to scoop up the office/commercial rent tax revenue and let Brisbane do the heavy lifting of housing those office workers [1]. [1] https://sf.curbed.com/2018/1/16/16897174/brisbane-city-council-silicon-valley-land https://sf.curbed.com/2018/1/16/16897174/brisbane-city-counc...
- ryanx435 9y agoLol only in California would this be suggested. Why not just repeal the stupid housing laws you have now instead of adding more complexity to the situation?
- Nasrudith 9y agoThe main reason why not is political viability. Voter ballot initiatives are required to ammend or revise the state constitution. The problem is that voters are selfish and expecting that to change is unreasonable. Not only because of the scale needed but because the degree of selflessness required in exchange for no guarantees is unreasonable to expect. Existing owners gave a sweetheart deal and are reluctant to raise their own taxes or allow the rate of tax assessment to rise faster, especially when much of the population is in a high desirability high cost area. Their property value is a considerable store of value and they are incentivised to be against further housing. Renters fear that changing the situation would open up further gentrification as if true value is assesed there is no reason not to upscale the property, indeed it would be required to make the value sustainable. It might make things better long term afterwards but when they don't want to stomach the risk in the short term. Add to the love of keeping the area after they moved in and things get deeply personal. It seems to be a nasty democratic deadlock resulting from the fundamentals of the rules and how they may be changed resulting in the can getting kicked down the road. Prop 13 isn't viable long term nor wise. There are only three ways it can end really, four if we get really fantastic. First is the unlikely result of a supreme court ruling that invalidates a lesser state constitution. Not likely to make it there and there would be few arguments as to why it is not allowed. It would likely cause a real estate crash in the short term. Even if the legislature holds a paniced mass tax cut much of the damage would already be done un reaction to the explosive real estate tax growth. The second is if voter balances change to repeal Prop 13. This would likely call for a substantial change to voter populations or things getting bad enough to change minds. It would cause real estate prices to get very unpredictable and volatile but the panic would be lessened by time to prepare for the possibility. Third would be if the real estate disaster hits first such that there is little resistance to a repeal or it becomes unnecessary as the actual accessment now matches the frozen prices largely. Prior real estate bubbles didn't do it so this would be huge and have global financial ramifications. Fourth is in the realm of science fiction, reducing housing demand technologically and beyond any ability to restrict to preserve the status quo. Extradimensional living spaces, widespread teleportation, alternate universe copies of California, antigravity houses floating over international waters or other things possible only in imagination.
- diogenescynic 9y agoThis would be great. We also need to take away local housing regulations and give control back to the state because all that has led to is NIMBYism and blocking new construction.
- petermcneeley 9y agoEncourage remote work. Dont we all just work in front of computers?
- azinman2 9y agoYou’re forgetting meetings, culture development, and ad-hoc knowledge transfer and awareness. Yes you can find digital equivalents, but if they were clearly superior then we would have a lot more remote work. I think you’ll see a lot of such tools augmenting the office so people get the best of both.
- daslicious 9y agoDon't forget the travel for frequent pizzeria visits
- squiggleblaz 9y agoNo. I'm a programmer - I need more peers around constantly to bounce ideas of them, to learn from them, to mentor them etc etc. The source code is much bigger than I can fit in my head alone. I need to work as part of a team.
- flukus 9y agoI do this remotely everyday. Email, IM, and voice chat can do this, many of the people I interact the most with are on other continents. Unfortunately I do this from my office to remote offices because we can't work from home, but that's a stupid corporate limitation, not a technological one.
- d0lph 9y agoSeriously, people act like verbal communication is the only way office workers can communicate.
- kristianp 9y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transit-oriented_development https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transit-oriented_development
- joshe 9y agoMore housing would also massively improve the cost of living in California. Estimates put housing expanse at nearly 50% of monthly income in San Francisco. The usual is 30%. High housing cost is also the cause of all the other high costs. It's a regressive expense, so all workers need much higher incomes to live here. It makes restaurants, grocery, and car mechanics more expensive. CA taxes aren't even that high, the total tax by percent of state income is only 11%, rank 6 in the nation. "Low" tax states like Arizona and Nevada are 8.8% and 8.1% respectively. Dropping our housing cost to the national average would save you twice as much as eliminating all California income and sales taxes. https://files.taxfoundation.org/legacy/docs/State-Local_Tax_Burden_FY2012.pdf https://files.taxfoundation.org/legacy/docs/State-Local_Tax_...
- jakelarkin 9y agoNevada figure probably includes taxes paid by casinos. Income taxes are closer to 5%.
- njarboe 9y agoNevada state income tax is 0%. One of the few without one along with Alaska, Florida, South Dakota, Texas, Washington and Wyoming.
- rb808 9y agoI remember hearing how in Japan the railway company builds a new line to somewhere then owns and develops the land itself, is that really true? Is a neat idea.
- k_sh 9y agoI don't think that would really apply to an existing urban environment - that sounds like the public transit equivalent of subdivision development.
- culturestate 9y agoThat's mostly true - JR develops the land above and around the stations, but not huge tracts like you'd think of an American subdivision. The MTR in Hong Kong has a similar grant of rights, but invests mainly in shopping malls rather than residential or office developments.
- r00fus 9y agoAlmost every single shopping mall in HK seems to have residential on top of it. It leads to massively good flow and all the good things that come of that - the customers come to you (assuming you don't completely suck).
- ekianjo 9y agoJr does the same thing in Japan. Its mostly malls and shopping venues, not residential areas and rarely offices.
- Johnny555 9y agoAnd it's super convenient, you can get off the train and pick up groceries on the way home -- or just stop and have dinner at the station, you'll have dozens of restaurants to choose from. Have time to kill before your long distance train? You can go shopping while you wait knowing that you only need to be at the train a few minutes before departure time.
- pinot 9y agoIt's how a lot of cities were built in the old days of rail. Land grants to build the rail (incentivizing private infrastructure), then the railroads themselves would build towns around stops. It's not always a good thing. See the land ownership in the Sierras around Truckee. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_town https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_town
- xvilka 9y agoWhy not just build a new lines of subway and other means of public transportation in those newly populated areas? Like every big city in Asia does?
- stretchwithme 9y agoI think doubling down on mass transit is a mistake with automated vehicles on the horizon. It doesn't make sense to incur massive debt when the customers are going to drive away. We should instead think about a system of tolls that has demand-based prices and that takes into account vehicle size. Tiny one person vehicles are going to be way cheaper than mass transit and there'll be no waiting, missed connections or end of service. They'll be as cheap as mopeds to operate. Point to point will work if we have a sensible pricing system. Instead of waiting in traffic, we'll wait at home until there is space for us. If we can buy a subscription and get paid to wait or go earlier, we can put an end to most traffic jams and keep people from driving into those that do occur. You might normally leave the office at 6:30 and drive 10 miles to your house. But if there's an accident and the "spot" price of your trip goes up, you'd be able to sell your trip for that day. You could make money by waiting. Or maybe you just take a bus. And by reducing the number of people that jam the roads at peak time, we can spread out the load and spend less money building for peak traffic. This is how many markets work, like the hotel market. They don't build a hotel room that sits idle 90% of the time so that nobody ever has to pay a high price for a room. They charge more at peak times and that makes some people change their plans to avoid the peak price.
- bigdubs 9y agoOr, we could just build more houses.
- pietroglyph 9y agoI think that the approach you outline doesn't effectively consider the waste and emissions of everyone having their own car (even single person), nor the increased inequality of paying more for peak times (you can only commute at reasonable hours if you're rich enough to pay for it.)
- stretchwithme 9y agoIf it costs more for someone to start work at a specific time, employees will demand more to work for you. In fact, if you were to require employers to pay for that peak travel, it wouldn't really make a difference. Most employers understand that such costs affect wages and how much money they'll save due to having a road system that breaks twice a day. And most employees will think they are getting something for free. It's win/win. Or neutral/fooled into thinking you won. And these same employees don't realize that their commute is currently costing them a lot more in opportunity costs than whatever the toll might be.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- almost_usual 9y agoI’m interested in the time frame some YIMBY supporters expect radical new housing laws to be passed in California? It’s obvious locals don’t want things to change, especially for tech workers.
- mesozoic 9y agoWhy would they. They're sitting on million dollar shanty houses because of tech workers. Start actually using the technology, empower remote work and they'll come begging to build more housing and get workers forced back into paying for their overpriced garbage homes.
- toast0 9y agoBuilding housing near transit isn't nearly as important as building offices near transit, if you want to make transit (more) viable. I can easily drive to caltrain and walk to work from the station, if my office is walkable from the station, and my house is drivable from a station with sufficient parking. It's much harder to walk to caltrain and then drive from the station to the office.
- Johnny555 9y agoBut if everyone drives to the station, you need to build parking for them all. Garage parking efficiencies run around 350 - 500 square feet per car. So if you are your spouse drive to the train separately, you're taking 700 - 1000 square feet of space. It seems better to build 1000 square foot apartments on that space instead of wasting it on parking. I say, get rid of segregated zoning and build more mixed use residential+retail+commercial developments and put everything closer to transit.
- flukus 9y ago> But if everyone drives to the station, you need to build parking for them all. If no one takes the train you need to build parking for them all, this is significantly cheaper and easier outside the city center.
- Johnny555 9y agoBut one thing that's cheaper than building parking lots and garages for thousands of cars is to use zoning to encourage developers to build dense offices and housing close to transit so you don't need to build parking at all.
- toast0 9y agoWhen the parking lot at the transit stops are overfull, it's clear that people want to be there, so they might want to live there. But keep in mind that the caltrain lots also backfill for not transit parking -- event parking for SAP center and parking for Sunnyvale downtown. If everybody drives 5 miles and parks at the transit stop, instead of driving 15 miles to park at work, that's a lot less driving.
- Karishma1234 9y agoYaawn... The last thing California needs to do is to battle climate change. When poor residents of your state are unable to find decent housing despite having reasonable income, when your farmers are paying highest energy prices in USA, when you state has major inequality problem the focus should be on increasing housing, simplifying zoning laws so the poor working middle class Californians could afford a roof on their head first. This climate change rhetoric is being peddled by fat-cat rich people who have got rich on tech or hollywood and have absolutely not compassion for ordinary working class people.
- pietroglyph 9y agoYou're constructing a false dichotomy; battling climate change isn't mutually exclusive with reducing housing inequality. In fact, this article specifically highlights how the two go hand-in-hand.
- ojbyrne 9y agoSB827 is dead, this article seems kind of pointless. At this point it’s neither “next” nor “bold.”
- mesozoic 9y agoWhat a revolutionary idea? Common sense how dare ye!