5 ms·
When you buy a house, your name and the purchase price are public information. Any one at any time can look up who owns a house, how much they paid for it, and
by jedberg 9y ago
When you buy a house, your name and the purchase price are public information. Any one at any time can look up who owns a house, how much they paid for it, and how much they pay in property tax every year.
I get a ton of spam because of this. However, I'd rather have this system than one in which all the owners are secret. I've had to look up owner information before to contact owners of various properties, and having that hidden would have made that task impossible.
You can hide the ownership information of a house, if you pay extra money, by hiring a lawyer to create an entity and put the entity on the property, but then the lawyer has to put their address, and forward any requests on to you, just like the whois privacy folks.
I think it is a good thing that every domain has valid contact info.
- dictum 9y ago> However, I'd rather have this system than one in which all the owners are secret. I don't mean to be cynical, but isn't this system also the one in which some people simply register their houses under a shell company?
- jedberg 9y agoYes, but at least the shell company forwards on the messages. And most people don't do it because it's a hassle.
- woolvalley 9y agoAnd you lose a 250-500k capital gains exemption if you sell the house and it's not owned & lived in by you directly AFAIK The issue with this system is it also lets people look up where you live by name alone, which can be bad if you want to own your house and have a stalker problem. The map works 2 ways.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoNot true with a revocable trust, which costs under $1000 to establish and provides all the same benefits of owning the real estate directly without disclosing ownership. Disclaimer: Applies primarily to IL and FL, not an attorney, nor your attorney.
- koolba 9y agoIf you do that in CA can you “sell” control of the trust to circumvent reassessment of the real estate taxes after a sale?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoMy apologies, I’m only familiar with Illinois and Florida real estate law. A CA attorney should be able to answer that with a short, no cost phone consultation (if a trust can’t support such an arrangement, an LLC might).
- njarboe 9y agoIf a company or other entity is owned by a single person and just owns a single piece of property, this does not work and California will not let the prop 13 tax rate stay with the company. You are obviously trying to cheat to get around the law. As there are more owners of the company and the company has more diverse holdings, California is less likely to insist on resetting the assessed value of the real estate owned by the company upon sale. One REIT buying another REIT is fine. Like many laws, one does not really know what they mean on the edges until you do something and are taken to court.
- mynameisvlad 9y agoIsn't that exactly the same as PrivacyGuard or other WHOIS anonymizing services? If anything, it reinforces the analogy even more.
- AckSyn 9y agoThis is kind of a weak comparison. You can always look up the whois and send email to the privacy address, just like you can send mail to the physical address to reach the owners of a specific property. I wish home ownership were private. Aside from the DMV selling your data it's where I get most of my junk mail from.
- ktosobcy 9y agoIs that a US thing? I understand that having some registry with this information is needed (but maybe not with details down to taxation) but... having it behind some officials "firewall" would solve that?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- greglindahl 9y agoWhat problem are you trying to solve? The problems that having an open land and property tax register solves are problems like finding fraud, money laundering, tax cheating, better valuation of properties for bank loan purposes, and so forth.
- ktosobcy 9y agoWhy would YOU have to do it? For me it's enough that officials have access to this information (and common folks when requested, but with valid motivation). And as a result I don't have problems with my identity being out in the open (and I don't get a single spamy mail)
- greglindahl 9y agoThe reason this is done in public is because plenty of fraud happens when only officials can get access to property ownership and tax info -- even in countries that are relatively less corrupt. Also, the bit about mortgages means that mortgages rates are lower when appraisals are more accurate; the largest inputs to home value appraisals in the US are sales data and tax data.
- ktosobcy 9y agoBut the thing is - not only officials can get that data. Its simply not that easily available (so you can't harvest it like mails on the Web) As for house market - in other counties (where dará is more hidden) it still works. and as far as I know housing market in the US is quite... weird, so it seems this data doesn't help that much?
- tyrust 9y ago>I think it is a good thing that every domain has valid contact info. Does your "valid" include domain registrars that provide WHOIS protection that includes forwarding messages to the protected owner? And, honest question, why do you think that domains should have contact info?
- leetcrew 9y agooff the top of my head, valid DMCA takedowns?
- jedberg 9y agoWhen I used to work in security, I used Whois every day. In many cases it was to notify a domain owner that their domain had been compromised and was being used for spam. I also used it a lot to track down bad actors because most of them are dumb and don’t hide their Whois.
- tscs37 9y agoIn germany there is an imprint requirement so you'll always have a contact point for these things. Unlike WHOIS it's on a website so you can protect this information much more easily from scraping and spamming.
- icebraining 9y agoNot all domains have public websites.
- tscs37 9y agoIf those create any abuse then you can still contact the registrar. From what I understand the eventual plan for WHOIS to only allow access if there is truly legitimate interest. Everything else can be filtered over the registrar.
- dx034 9y agoThat's where WHOIS protection comes in handy. If you don't want to get even more spam (the imprint has to be clear text, no obfuscation so gets spammed a lot) but a website that could target Germans (or you're in Germany), you'll quickly get costly letters from specialised lawyers. Having Whois protection usually helps, they tend to give up if they can't get your address easily.
- rubicon33 9y ago> When you buy a house, your name and the purchase price are public information. Any one at any time can look up who owns a house, how much they paid for it, and how much they pay in property tax every year. Uh, really? Where?
- woolvalley 9y agoIt's a US or at least California thing. In many countries this is not reality.
- ratsmack 9y agoIt is the same in Washington state, and I suspect most other states also make this information available. I believe it is required because the taxing authority data is considered public information.
- vollmond 9y agoPA, checking in. My county has a website where you search the address, and get back the owners, acreage, square footage, assessed value (land and building(s)), and last sale price and date.
- oliwarner 9y agoUK too.
- math0ne 9y agoDef true in Canada.
- SmellyGeekBoy 9y agoI know that this is all managed by a government department called the "Land Registry" in the UK.
- connorgreenwell 9y agoIf this is true in Europe, I'm curious what the implications are w.r.t. GDPR.
- stordoff 9y agoProbably very little. The data will be being made public under a law mandating that, and the GDPR allows for that: > Processing shall be lawful [...if...] processing is necessary for compliance with a legal obligation to which the controller is subject https://gdpr-info.eu/art-6-gdpr/ https://gdpr-info.eu/art-6-gdpr/
- icebraining 9y agoEDIT: nevermind, misread the context.
- detaro 9y agoI believe the parent is talking about the example of a land ownership database.
- icebraining 9y agoOh, oops, you're right.
- krageon 9y agoIt's not true where I am in Europe, this sort of info is accessible to government employees only.
- zaarn 9y agoNot in my country unless you have a damn good reason to get that info. The only way to get access to someone's address or phone number is to show up at the local community office and provide sufficient information (which means name + any previous address or known phone number registered with the office) I think the same should go for domains. Unless you have a good reason (which IMO means spam complain, journalism or legal contact) you shouldn't be able to get any way to contact me. And for the above I have an imprint too which is protected against scrapers and spammers as best as I can unlike the WHOIS.
- xfitm3 9y agoThere is no reason for anyone to contact me outside of methods I publish.