3 ms·
>Biology is immeasurably harder than physics Statements of this form are essentially always false: basically everything has the same difficulty because the sta
by whatshisface 9y ago
>Biology is immeasurably harder than physics
Statements of this form are essentially always false: basically everything has the same difficulty because the standards for what constitutes progress in a field are set according to what the people working in it can do on average.
It's easy to write down what you thought of Infinite Jest, but in order to achieve any special success as a critic you're going to have to beat out everybody else that's doing the same thing. That makes it very hard. Likewise in an alternate universe where physics was easy, the standards for how much you had to say in a paper would rise until the average paper was about as substantial as it is now.
- nonbel 9y ago>"the standards for what constitutes progress in a field are set according to what the people working in it can do on average." For example, in physics they require p < 3e-7 for a discovery. While in biology it is p < 0.05 and sometimes even p < .1 is allowed.
- vibrio 9y agoBut very different things are being measured--comparing them this way is very flawed.
- nonbel 9y agoNot sure what you mean but my post was a sarcastic comment about how people choose an arbitrary level of significance so that the "right number" of "discoveries" can be published each year. If there is a lot of data they would have too many "discoveries" (it would seem too easy) so they need a more stringent threshold. If the data is very expensive they would have too few "discoveries" so the threshold gets relaxed.
- vibrio 9y agoPardon, I have a weak ability to detect sarcasm before finishing my first coffee. I fully agree that p-value limits are arbitrary, and what one is examining can greatly impact the interpretation of 'significance' or not. As you imply, data can be inflationary , incrementally increasing in volume and decreasing in value.
- sooheon 9y agoPhysical sciences have the benefit of being pitted against reality. A physicist a generation ahead of his time can make predictions about reality which will prove him correct, even if nobody else can understand what he's saying. A literary critic who truly understands more than everyone would have no recognition to show for it if everyone else were simply incapable of understanding it.
- whatshisface 9y ago>A literary critic who truly understands more than everyone would have no recognition to show for it if everyone else were simply incapable of understanding it. A successful critic isn't a critic, they're an author that writes for whoever is making them successful. So the critic at the top of academia would be the best at writing criticims that people understood: no garuntee of understanding the most, but that's still a skill that, say, Feynman would find it hard to replicate. The heirarchal nature of almost everything garuntees that there will always be "the best," and that they will be hard to beat, regardless of how much it means in the grand scheme of things. Finally, the scarcity of grant money means that participating in any field means beating the best: a regulatory effect that's at the center of the discussion.