24 ms·
Has wine gone bad?
- SlowRobotAhead 9y ago"In 2000, a French government report noted that vineyards used 3% of all agricultural land, but 20% of the total pesticides. In 2013, a study found traces of pesticides in 90% of wines available at French supermarkets." Ok, that seems like legitimate concerns. "Wine is regularly passed through electrical fields to prevent calcium and potassium crystals from forming, injected with various gases to aerate or protect it, or split into its constituent liquids by reverse osmosis and reconstituted with a more pleasing alcohol to juice ratio." Pearl clutching nonsense. Does sound a lot like antivaxxer concerns right there. Not sure who to believe here, but I'll lean towards organic wines that used efficient machines and process if I was concerned over the "GMO ARE ALWAYS BAD CROWD" that would rather see the world starve.
- simion314 9y agoMy family makes wine just for ourselves(we live in a village) no tech or chemicals are used but the taste is not bad, I do not understand why they say it should taste like vinegar.
- eftychis 9y agoIt doesn't and shouldn't taste like vinegar. Same here regarding family wine production. Note families tend to share their wine among themselves, so there is some comparison. You can taste the difference if there is some additive or it is industry produced. It is just different. Personally, I find the term "natural wine" kind of laughable (I hope) and a result of marketing. Techniques used in the industry are towards making wine more average and consistent over the years. Not sifting your juices and checking over the yeast, just means you won't know if your wine sucks till it's ready. Hence a significant portion of years will just taste bad, with a few of them being acceptable. You still need to intervene to get true gems (controlled environment etc), as the article implies. There is still a lot of oversight going on. >> According to this view, natural wine is a cult intent on >> rolling back progress in favour of wine best suited to >> the tastes of Roman peasants. I think this hostile sentiment is unwarranted. Wine in general has gotten much better over the years (consistency and taste) as we know much more about the process. I can see why French winemakers want consistency, but I would argue they could label possibly inconsistent wines with a new term than branding them as "garbage".
- petre 9y agoDepends where the grapes are from, what species they are and of course also the winemaking the process. There was a joke going around about the difference between German wine and vinegar: the label. In sunnier regions the grapes are sweet but don't get enough acidity and the winemakers have to compensate using tartaric (also citric or malic) acid or ideally more acidic grape juice (imported or from other grape species). In less sunnier regions the grapes don't get enough sugar and they become too acidic. Fermentation naturally stops at about 13% alcohol content but if it's warm in your cellar (>18°C) it can start again and exhaust all the sugar in the wine. When this happens, you can stop the fermentation by adding suplhur. A small amount of sugar is necessary to preserve the flavours in a wine if it's kept in barrels or stainless steel drums. Commercial wines are filtered, pasteurized and bottled after fermentation stops if they're not aged in wooden barrels. Once a bottle of regular (unaged) commercial wine is open, the flavour goes away if left overnight.
- vkou 9y ago> in 2013, a study found traces of pesticides in 90% of wines available at French supermarkets. > Ok, that seems like legitimate concerns. How many pesticides, though? Are we talking about ppb for compounds that are harmful at ppm levels? Or ones that are harmful at ppb levels? Do they accumulate in the body over decades, or are broken down in a matter of days? Of course, none of those questions are answered.
- bvinc 9y agoThat's a legitimate question that someone should try to answer. But to be honest, I don't care. We live in a world where margerine was touted for decades to prevent heart disease. The fact of the matter is that even if we can find no safety issues now, they can't rule out everything. Health and nutrition is complicated and I don't trust unnatural additions to my food that merely seem safe. I'll opt to ingest zero pesticides any time I can.
- jimnotgym 9y agoOne world-class expert in the wine trade told me that he favoured vineyards that were careful about pesticide use rather than fully organic ones. The reason as I recall was that some of the nasty things that can damage grapes/ vines and must-be-killed are stopped by a low dose of a specific pesticide if there is an infection, whereas organic growth requires heavy pro-active doses of copper. He felt that was more damaging.
- phyzome 9y agoIntegrated Pest Management (IPM) is a great approach that I'd like to see more of. I don't think there are any (useful) labeling standards, though, which makes it harder to promote as an alternative to organic. It really comes down to trusting the farmer...
- phyzome 9y agoSeparating and then reconstituting the wine is the part I would personally draw the line at. Maybe it's fine. Maybe they're grossly altering the wine in a way that negates e.g. health benefits, and it's not "wine" in the sense that consumers understand it to be. More generally, I think people are just tired of producers fucking around with their food in various ways.
- hendiatris 9y agoThis isn’t a big deal. You should probably be more concerned about the pesticides. These machines do dealcoholization, remove volatile acidity (vinegar), alter acidity (done with ion exchange, as opposed to adding tartaric acid directly to the wine). Yeah, there are probably some negative side effects as a result of these techniques, but I'd bet big that they are vast improvements over the alternatives and that the negative effects are dwarfed by those of pesticides
- phyzome 9y agoAh, I should be clear, I'm not on board with most synthetic pesticides either. I was referring to just the additional list of electrical fields, etc.
- akamaka 9y agoThere’s no similarity to antivaxxers here. Natural wines are mostly consumed by wine lovers, not health nuts, and the main concern is what the heavy processing is doing to the quality and distinctive character of the wine.
- nilkn 9y agoI think maybe you're reading something between the lines here that isn't actually there. I think I'd summarize this article as being about groupthink more than anything else. The wine world is overwhelmed with all sorts of rules about what's good, what's not, how something should be produced, and how it shouldn't. "Natural wine" is an attack on all of that. It's just saying, "screw you, we're going to potentially disregard every single rule in the book, and we don't care what you think of the result." I think this paragraph sums up the whole article: "The inconsistency, the impurity, the strong smells, the bits of stems and yeasts that sometimes make it into the bottle – all this signals to the consumer that natural wine is an alternative to the bland, monotonous “perfection” of commercial products, in the same way that slight asymmetries distinguish handmade furniture. Natural wine offers a nothing-to-hide-here image at odds with the stuffy culture of the traditional wine world. To many people for whom a restaurant wine list represents a hellish combination of a geography, history and chemistry test specially designed to make them feel stupid, there is something very appealing about upending the critical hierarchy, or at least being told it can be ignored."
- chiph 9y ago> split into its constituent liquids by reverse osmosis and reconstituted with a more pleasing alcohol to juice ratio I'd regard that with the same esteem as one of the factory-made whiskeys. Technically true, but violates the spirit of the spirit.
- tptacek 9y agoThe best whiskeys in the world are made by the largest commercial firms; ironically, it's the "artisanal" indie stuff that's most likely sourced from huge industrial concerns like MGPI --- and even MGPI whiskey has merits (you just shouldn't pay extra for it).
- DennisP 9y agoThat's true in the sense that many well-known Scottish distilleries are owned by some large corporation, but some of those distilleries make their whisky the same way they did a hundred years ago. The American whiskey scene is much as you describe though. The indie scene is fairly new, and they have to do something while they're waiting for the barrels to age. But some are producing their own offbeat whiskeys; for example, Balcones makes one from blue corn, and another with malt smoked by mesquite.
- __jks__ 9y agoSeems to still run fine on my Linux VM. :)
- paulddraper 9y agoYeah, it was news to me too. Then I remembered than non-hacker stories get posted to hacker news.
- draw_down 9y agoThe stuff about "purity" seems a bit much to me, but they are probably right that the increase in demand for wine has led to the industrialization of its production and homogenization of the result.
- jotm 9y agoWine from concentrate. Blergh. Give me that not quite fully fermented homemade wine from wild grapes any day.
- HeyLaughingBoy 9y agoI've made wine both from various concentrates and from wild grapes growing on my property. While I can tell the difference between one wine and another, there's no way I could tell if it was made from concentrate or not.
- lisper 9y agoHuh? Where do you see that? The word "concentrate" doesn't appear anywhere in the article (AFAICT).
- jotm 9y agoHas wine gone bad? Yeah, some assholes are selling wine from concentrate as real wine. It has gone really bad.
- 21 9y agoUmm, what a nice palate of aged Roundup with a bit of phosphates.
- matchagaucho 9y agoMy nit with Napa and Sonoma wines lately is that the bottles may say 14% ABV, but are actually 16%+ ABV. This is regressing back to Night train levels of alcohol.
- bluetidepro 9y agoIs there any laws around this having to be accurate? What makes you say it's higher than the bottle says? I know nothing about this, so mainly just curious for you to expand more on your comment.
- jimnotgym 9y agoIn the UK 16% alcohol wines attract a higher rate of duty, so being accurate is pretty important. The higher alcohol percentages in fine wine are due to more sugar in the grapes from variations in the weather rather than any choice by the winemaker
- AndrewBissell 9y agoMy wife runs a natural-ish winery and I help out with some of the regulatory filings. All bottle labels have to be approved by TTB and include the ABV. They don't require you to submit any lab results in support of your claimed alcohol percentage, but if you're caught selling wine outside a certain margin of error it can result in some kind of sanction. High alcohol wines are somewhat in favor for Napa/Sonoma reds, but 14% is a cutoff for lower excise tax rates and a lesser regulatory burden in general, so it wouldn't be surprising if people are trying to game this somewhat. A funny thing about wine industry regulation is it's entirely focused on whether or not you are paying taxes. We've never had to file or demonstrate anything related to the safety or purity of our wine.
- swensel 9y agoIn the US, New Zealand and Australia, wine is permitted to have a variance of 1.5% ABV. In Europe, wine is only permitted to have a .5% ABV variance. Taxes may be one reason why ABV is under-reported. [1] [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/01/06/how-wine-labels-lie-to-us/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2016/01/06/how-w...
- 21 9y agoI had no idea that most wine is made from concentrates. Makes you wonder why this is not common knowledge. Do they maybe fear something?
- svnsets 9y agoIt's not in the best interest of the wineries or the distributors to advertise that unless legally obligated to do so, which is why it isn't really common knowledge. The whole "natural/organic/non-gmo/no-pesticides-added" labels common in the food and beverage industry would likely cause unwanted contrast to wines labeled as "from concentrate".
- phyzome 9y agoThe fact that alcoholic beverages do not (in the US) require ingredient labels is something I've long regarded as suspicious.
- nasredin 9y agoMaybe alcohol companies used the same ad men and lobbyists as the tobacco ones?
- joering2 9y agoTo be clear, there is nothing wrong from being "from concentrate", other than probably a huge PR campaign by major OJ companies to make you think juice "not from concentrate" is somehow more healthier or something. Fun fact is those are the same PR companies that Kellogs used to coin "breakfast is the most important meal of the day" which still as of today many doctors argue that actually your last meal is the most important because as you sleep your body regenerates and besides it will be left for the time of your sleep (8 hours?) without food or water. Anyways there is nothing wrong with orange juice from concentrate. Its always been like this: 60% OJ concentrate, rest water. As that a good healthy ration. "Not from concentrate" is a PR gimmick. Think for yourself: A glass of "not from concentrate" orange juice would have 4-6 grown oranges squeeze to fill it in. What was the last time you ate 4-6 grown oranges at one sitting, and do you really believe thats healthy? If anything it makes your liver works super hard to put all that extra vitamin C into your bladder so you can rush to tha bathroom.
- cascom 9y agoKey for me is are the pesticides and additives beyond yeast ending up in wines.. "Yet, as natural wine advocates point out, the way most wine is produced today looks nothing like this picture-postcard vision. Vineyards are soaked with pesticide and fertiliser to protect the grapes, which are a notoriously fragile crop....The modern winemaker has access to a vast armamentarium of interventions, from supercharged lab-grown yeast, to antimicrobials, antioxidants, acidity regulators and filtering gelatins, all the way up to industrial machines."
- dx034 9y agoThere is organic wine. It'll still contain lab-grown yeast (to ensure quality) but gets rid of the additives. It's quite expensive (as grapes are fragile) and not very common but can be found in a lot of supermarkets by now.
- specialp 9y agoThe main thing causing off flavors is not the fact that the grapes are grown naturally and organically, it is that they are being fermented by wild yeast. That is the part that is kinda lost in this article. Fermentation with wild yeast can produce unpredictable results and what we would consider bad flavors. Over time yeast strains have been colonized and maintained that make for a clean and fast fermentation. I mean think wild wine and beer is cool, but we have yeast now you don't have to worry about your wine tasting like a stinky sock, or lit matches. There's nothing inherently more organic by doing that, and the possibility that you are going to have a funky tasting wine is high. The discussion about pesticides and mechanization is another issue.
- emodendroket 9y agoWell, yeah, but the funky and weird flavors are the whole point of the exercise, aren't they?
- foobar1962 9y agoUsing cheese as an example, it's the difference between camembert and gorgonzola: same basic ingredient, different yeast. Different colour and massively different flavour. Same with yeast for wine: fruity citrus with overtones of vomit.
- emodendroket 9y agoI mean I am a lot more familiar with sour beers, but I love the funky flavors they give bizarre names like "sweaty horse blanket."
- foobar1962 9y agoAs a brewer you want to have a consistent product. Once you'd got a brew with just the right amount of "horse blanket" you'd cultivate that yeast culture and use it again. To do that you need to make sure there are no other yeast strains in the raw ingredients. Louis Pasteur was working on beer brewing when he discovered the microbes, and invented the heating process to kill them.
- dmitriid 9y agoThe wine produced today is the best wine that humanity has produced, ever. Thanks to modern biology, technology etc. Even the "natural" wine is nowhere close to the "natural wine of yesteryear" thanks to the modern barrels, modern temperature control, modern bottling techniques etc. etc. The problem with modern "natural producers" (be it wine or any other produce) is that they pretend to be anti-technology, anti-pesticides, anti-<you name it> while selectively enjoying the very same advantages they are speaking out against. And when it comes to grapes... I wonder if their organic wines can survive only because they enjoy the group immunity against the very many grape diseases [1][2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_French_Wine_Blight https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_French_Wine_Blight [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_grape_diseases https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_grape_diseases
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- AndrewBissell 9y agoThere are a fair number of self-proclaimed "natural" producers who are using fruit from vineyards sprayed with Roundup and other industrial pesticides.
- emodendroket 9y agoOK, but from what the article describes, these wines often look and taste wildly different.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nrclark 9y agoIt's crazy how much of the wine world is an 'emperor's new clothes' kind of situation. There was a study done a little while ago (http://www.caltech.edu/news/wine-study-shows-price-influences-perception-1374 http://www.caltech.edu/news/wine-study-shows-price-influence...) which showed that people perceive wine very differently depending on price. Even if it's the same wine. So somebody who's told they're tasting a $90 bottle will rate it much better than somebody who's told they're tasting a $5 bottle, even though they're both drinking the exact same thing. After all the uproar over Brochet's "The Color of Odors", I did a tasting with a few friends where I chilled red and white wines down to the same temperature, and had them try the wines blindfolded. Across 6 people who all considered themselves wine enthusiasts, it was pretty dicey even being able to tell a Merlot from a Sauv Blanc. Maybe it was my just my lame friends, or maybe I chose bad wines. Or maybe not. Different professional wine tasters will rate a given wine extremely differently. And they'll comment on different 'subtle notes of chocolate' in a product that is entirely made of grapes and yeast. I would be genuinely surprised if a double-blind test revealed that aging a particular bottle actually makes it taste better in a measurable way. Different, maybe. But if 'better' is subjective, then it's by definition not 'better' in an absolute sense. I enjoy a nice glass of wine, don't get me wrong. But the culture around it is elitist and unscientific, and I'm glad to see winemakers trying to tear it down a peg or two.
- gascan 9y agothey'll comment on different 'subtle notes of chocolate' in a product that is entirely made of grapes and yeast. This, at least, is IMO not a valid criticism. I make beer, and two easy examples are cloves & banana. Fermenting beer too warm leads the yeast to overproduce esters, which taste like bananas. Too cold leads the yeast to overproduce phenols, which taste like cloves. It's very real & very obvious.
- meddlepal 9y agoAnd it's often done on purpose.
- ravenstine 9y agoAre there any studies that show how reliably people can perceive these subtle notes?
- cascom 9y agoI read somewhere that essentially any wine that retails for less than $15-20 is generally the wine equivalent of fast food and industrially manufactured, wines from $20-$40 vary considerably in their process, and wines $40+ are generally made in ways that conform to ones "mental notions" of how wine is made... same article also said that at ~$100 there stops being any quality difference among wines and it is all taste/preference/supply & demand
- jimnotgym 9y agoIn the UK a standard wine attracts duty of £2.17+20% vat (from memory). Then there is the vat on the price of the wine itself. Consider the cost of the bottle and shipping from France and you will see that the wine in a cheap say £6.99 bottle is worth less than 1 euro!!!! In a £12 bottle the wine itself could be worth 5 times as much! A classic fixed vs variable cost problem. Then take a £24 bottle, the wine itself is only around 2 times more expensive. So yes there can be a real sweet spot (in the UK £12-15). I don't know anything about US taxes to translate, but the point is still valid.
- cascom 9y agoSee this article/thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17078319 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17078319 Basically in the US a $100 wine in a restaurant retails for $50, Wholesales for $33, and the winery sells it for $19, and it costs them ~$14.25 to make it (all pre-sales tax)
- dx034 9y agoDon't restaurants buy at wholesale or wineries directly?
- cascom 9y agoYes - restaurants typically buy at that $33 wholesale price - hence the rule of thumb is restaurant prices are 3x wholesale and 2x retail. Generally, I don’t believe restaurants can but direct from the winery as a result of absurdly complex tiered distribution laws
- api_or_ipa 9y agoI have to say I hope the wine industry goes the same way as the craft beer industry: towards innovative techniques to differentiate brands by distinct taste and sourcing. Walk into any liquor store and half the store is filled with wine labels that most people can't differentiate. Compare this to the beer aisle: A wild yeast lambic is only similar to a Bud Light in that they are both beers. I'd be hard pressed to ever debate drinking one or the other because they are so distinct. Not that either of them are bad, but they serve different times and places. I'd love to see the same with wine. Give me bold, ambitious wines that either use long-forgotten techniques or pioneer new ones. Give me as much variety as possible, and hell, wrap it up in feel good micro-winery stories. Let consumers choose what they like, just like how the Craft Beer industry has done for the last couple of years. If there's one lesson to learn, it's that consumers love to try new varieties, and there's a lot of money to be made for being ambitious. For everyone in the Bay Area, it's worth your time to go up to Sonoma county and hangout at Lagunitas and Russian River Breweries. Both are famous for not holding back and brewing whatever beer comes to their mind, and it's delicious.
- AndrewBissell 9y agoAllow me to plug our winery here, only because I think we're aiming for just what you're asking :-) https://www.inconnuwine.com/ https://www.inconnuwine.com/
- ebikelaw 9y agoA lot of those innovative West Coast beers are, at best, hoaxes. I think maybe the craft brewers could swing back slightly to tradition. I seek out craft pilsners and lagers because a clear, tasty pilsner is very difficult to produce in quantity. It's a sign of a decent brewery, whereas a cloudy barrel-aged grapefruit sour is a sign of mental illness.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoWhat makes a beer a hoax?
- 9y ago
- misiti3780 9y agoI quit drinking "non-natural" wines 3 years ago and have not looked back. They are more interesting and give you less of a hangover (less sulfur). Robert Parker needs to be against natural wines because he put alochol-bomb Bordeauxs on the map in 1982. Responsible people (that can afford to) prefer to eat organic vegetables and cage free chicken + beef - why not take it full circle with your beverage also
- Quanttek 9y agoAdmittedly, I haven't read the article yet but still wanted to make a small point: In both conventional and 'ecological' wine production, wineries have to use different sprays to keep off fungis that destroy the wines. Convetional wineries use fungicides while ecolgical ones have to spray much more often, mostly using materials like copper. This is at least true for Europe after certain fungi were imported from Asia and America during the Renaissance where the local grape varieties are naturally resistant. There are fungi-resistant varieties which are crossings between European and Asian/American varieties that try to keep the taste but (mostly) eliminate the need for spraying. Had the chance to taste some local varitieties, and they were (for my amateur taste buds) wondeful. https://www.piwi-international.de/en/information-en.html https://www.piwi-international.de/en/information-en.html
- jimnotgym 9y ago> – and have triggered the biggest split in the wine world for a generation Interesting. I don't care to go into the reasons but I am pretty exposed to professionals in the wine trade, and I have not heard much about this beyond the two articles on Hacker News. I don't think the industry is paying much attention at all. I think it is a bit like I have seen numerous hipster-ethical-organic coffee-shops come and go in my town, but Starbucks just keeps on opening new stores.
- Kalium 9y agoI've seen a handful of hipster-ethical-natural wine shops pop up around the SF Bay. The wine doesn't seem to be inherently better, but it does seem to start at $12 a glass.
- sincerely 9y agoAre you being purposefully dense? The reason "ethical" or "natural" wine would be more expensive isn't because it would taste better , but because it costs more to produce (or present, in the case of "hipster") in a specific way that's appealing to the consumer.
- Kalium 9y agoOh, you're absolutely right! Of course more ethical or natural wine costs more to produce and present appealingly. You're absolutely, completely, 100% correct on every point. I might be a bit skeptical that it costs $3-4 a glass more, however. I wonder if it's not at least somewhat about having an aspirational label that can be applied to justify a significant upcharge.
- sincerely 9y agoOh, I think I agree with you then, they're probably milking the label for all it's worth :P
- dx034 9y agoNot sure about wine but in other areas, organic agriculture can halve the yield (more for meat). Could imagine the same for grapes. That plus more expensive handling after harvest (often simple due to lower scale) can easily triple the price.
- AndrewBissell 9y agoAlthough she's herself partial to wines that fall in the "natural" camp, my wife has grown frustrated and wary of the term. Robert Parker's opinion may not be the most reliable on the subject, given that he's spent most of his career lauding huge, unctuous, oaky Napa wines, but it's true that there's very little in terms of concrete boundaries for what constitutes "natural wine." And some of the practices the natural crowd wants to jettison, like adding sulfur, are essential to creating balanced, pleasant wines, and have been used for centuries. As one of our distributor friends said, "the first duty of wine is to taste good." During a recent bottling we found ourselves forced into an interesting high-vs-low intervention experiment. My wife felt her Sauvignon Blanc was too cloudy, so we were trying to filter it as it was bottled. We made it through about 50 cases' worth, but the filters kept clogging as we bottled, which was stretching out the bottling time and threatening to cost us a bunch of money. So, for the remaining cases we bottled without the filter. For the first month or two in bottle the unfiltered wine was definitely a bit "funky" and a lot more volatile on the nose than the filtered. But now, although it's still quite a bit more cloudy, we both prefer the unfiltered Sauv Blanc.
- kleiba 9y agoFrom the headline (and given that I was looking at HN), I literally thought this was going to be a piece on a potential vulnerability in the windows-compatibility software. https://www.winehq.org/ https://www.winehq.org/ Quite surprised to find out it's actually an article on the drink.
- emodendroket 9y agoI'm very curious to try sour, cloudy wines, and think I've been motivated to find one.
- miduil 9y ago> This means using only organic grapes, picked by hand, and fermenting slowly with wild yeasts from the vineyard (most vintners use lab-grown yeasts, which Riffault says are engineered “like F1 cars, to speed through fermentation”). This sounds kind of wrong, almost every single plant we are eating has been optimized for our needs over the past ~200 years (citation needed). Cucumber, tomato, strawberry, zucchini, eggplant, avocado, watermelon, carrot and corn, just to name a few, have been engineered "like F1 cars" for each specific demand. So why should it be an issue to use optimized yeasts for wine too? PS: Probably unambiguous, but I was instantly scared this article is going to be about Wine Is Not an Emulator. https://www.winehq.org/ https://www.winehq.org/
- kevinqiu1 9y agoBut has it been optimized for taste? Or for the marketplace and maximum profit? You mention the tomato. If you've ever had a fresh heirloom tomato I think you'd agree that they're much more delicious than the "optimized" tomatoes from the local chain supermarket. However, the supermarket tomato is a lot easier to grow and lasts longer in storage and transport. We're just seeing people with the knowledge and money demanding taste and a general cultural shift in that direction (all the artisanal products that have been cropping up). Because in the last 100 years, we've optimized for profit and the global supply chain rather than taste. Nothing wrong with either IMO, it depends on what you want. Delicious tomatoes, or having tomatoes in January. Specifically regarding yeast though, spontaneously fermented beers have very interesting and IMO delicious flavors going on, but it'd be impossible to make such beers on a Budweiser scale, by definition it's more of an art and not an industrial process.
- dlwdlw 9y agoI think it helps to think of wine more as consumable art. Art, like the mona lisa has its value tied not in the intrinsic properties but its position within its cultural and historical context. The trick being that this environment is a sub environment available only to those with a lot of time and money. Ability to appreciate indicates knowledge and belonging to this sub environment. The mind actually activates more strongly when the context is known. Similar to how a certain degree of discipline is necessary for classical music or sailing to actually enjoy them. But because the actual context is much smaller than the perceived context its also a ripe context to BS in. Similar to emperors clothes except that maybe perhaps once upon a time such invisible thread did/does exist.
- mafro 9y agoI think you are over-intellectualising the experience of the vast majority. It's a drink. It tastes good. You learn about wine (like most things) through practice.
- sudosteph 9y ago> At a recent natural wine fair in London, I encountered winemakers who farmed by the phases of the moon and didn’t own computers; one man foraged his grapes from wild vines in the mountains of Georgia; I wonder if those wild grapes were muscadine or scuppernongs? They grow wild in NC, and are absolutely delightful. They're big, juicy, super sweet, with the only downsides being a pit inside and tough skin on the outside. Still would prefer them to the seedless grocery store grapes any day. I've only tried a few wines made from them, and though I'm no expert on the topic, I think it's worth a try if you're in the mood for something a bit more adventurous. The price is usually quite reasonable too.
- partycoder 9y agoWhenever I hear or read "wine", I interpret it as "fermented juice". The more you keep in mind that wine is just fermented juice, the less susceptible you are to snobs, enthusiasts or people selling you $100+ juice. Then, listening to a snob feels like listening to a fortune teller fraudster. e.g.: you are "cursed" until you try this elixir called wine that will change your life. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fortune_telling_fraud https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fortune_telling_fraud
- sjg007 9y agoBuy based on the region.
- johnboyer 9y agoOh, I thought this was some kind of play on words for the Wine software, turns out it's literally wine.
- tangue 9y agoYeah I was thinking about the Wine 'emulator' too when I saw the title. Guess we should spend less time on HN.
- the_watcher 9y ago> “You need to be OK with losing some barrels, or to simply accept the wine you made.” I once met someone who started a microbrewery that was reasonably successful at that point (I am blanking on the specific brewery, it was moderately successful in Austin at the time). He told me that many of the "seasonal" or "special" batches that taste substantially different than typical beers are simply bad batches that the brewer finds a way to package and sell another way. Habanero and other spicy beers are apparently particularly likely to be this. I wonder if that will be the ultimate solution to the bad batches that natural wine-making produces.
- ingmarheinrich 9y agoI literally thought this was about the Windows emulator.
- ousta 9y agothere are two key problems overall most of the people who drink wine haven't really tried once in their life a really good wine. and im not talking price wise. the common palate that those kind of people like are woody wines or Ill say wines that taste like wood chips. even big bordeaux name do it that way and mix that with pesticides and lot of other ingredients. the greatest estate on earth, Romanee Conti has always been doing "Natural Wines" free of pesticides and only with a little to none additives beyond grapes. this is what wine should be. POINT.
- madshiva 9y agoSame apply to beer. There's several study that if you put the price higher you will sell more and make more money and that sad.