19 ms·
I Don’t Know How to Waste Time on the Internet Anymore
- scottmf 9y agoThis is exactly how I've felt for the past few years. Besides Facebook, I think a large part of it is not being quite as young and open to new things. E.g. I'm under 30 but I never got into Youtube, I don't even know how to find good content on it.
- pen2l 9y agoI'm above 30 and oh man, I am wasting my life on Reddit/Youtube. It depends what you're into. Are you into music? Youtube has all the music (you type "youtube<TAB>daft punk<ENTER>" and you're there... and you can put it on repeat using $TRICK if you desire). Are you into music-playing or fitness or anything? There are thousands of guitar/piano instruction videos, and countless fitness videos (on how to have correct form when you're lifting), and after you watch a couple you sort of... just keep watching. There are a number of "fitness personalities" and at some point it becomes something of a series show, that you want to watch each new video that they put up every other day. It's really bad. I want it to stop, but I have poor self-control. Following r/politics, following the Trump trainwreck will add zero positive value to my life, I'm aware that following news in this day and age is a pure waste of time: but I can't take my eyes off of this trainwreck, I wish I could stop because it's affecting my work and career.
- packet_nerd 9y ago> but I can't take my eyes off of this trainwreck I wonder whether this has been his intention all along.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- 8bitsrule 9y agoIt's like a maelstrom, don't swim too close!
- yodsanklai 9y agoYoutube has an incredible amount of high-quality content hidden in tons of garbage. Unfortunately, I find the recommendation system to be inefficient. It's good at suggesting videos very closely related to what I watched before but it's not able to suggest new things that could be of interest.
- sho 9y agoThere is an astonishing amount of good content on youtube. In the last 3 or so years it has blossomed into something of a renaissance and begun to grow into what I always kind of hoped "citizen content" could be. To my mind it is the most obviously beneficial of all of those "web 2.0" companies. Do you like jet engines? Prepare to lose the rest of your day watching AgentJayZ talking about his job repairing jet engines in such detail I'm surprised his channel isn't a national security violation. Like teardowns of tools and sardonic commentary? AvE. Electrical engineering discussions? EEVBlog. Planes landing? Cargospotter. Interesting shit? Wendover/half as interesting. Analysis of famous Roman battles? Historia Civilis. 2 hour long videos of japanese train rides from the cabin? ato5kgyasetaito. I could go on.. and on.. and on. I suppose I am letting my tastes show a little here but to me the issue isn't finding the content, it's knowing when to stop!
- 8bitsrule 9y agoYa, YT is a bottomless well of helpful info. (Just try stumping it with some obscure musical artist or band from whenever. Good luck.) YT's great especially for doing things. A relative of mine with -some- car repair experience (mostly engine) just acquired the parts and rebuilt the car's entire front end, learning how from YT sharers. (I used to be into electronics ... pre-surface-mount ... and from what I can tell it's the same way.)
- blhack 9y agoLove seeing another agentjayz fan here! Want to spend hours watching somebody repair marine props and shafts on machine tools? Keith Fenner does excellent, detailed repairs. Regular car reviews makes incredible car reviews of mostly normal cars (this detailed review of the PT cruiser is amazing. Watch the WHOLE thing: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hoxqtnI4I4c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hoxqtnI4I4c) Ben Krasnow (on applied science) is an intellectual and engineering treasure. Watch anything he makes. Youtube has for sure become one of my favorite websites. There is SO much good content there.
- sho 9y ago> Love seeing another agentjayz fan here! Honestly his stuff just comes first to mind as "outstanding, fascinating videos I would never have seen without this platform." Say what you want about Youtube but they sure have enabled an amazing flourishing of creativity and sharing. Will check out your others! RcR though... there really should be a warning. That is some advanced cynicism. Don't get me wrong, I love them. But your link is, how should I say, "the deep end"
- cylinder 9y agoThis has been happening to me and I was just about to post an Ask HN about it. I'm sure part of it has to do with me just being older but I'm going to the same few sites over and over and there really is no magic to the internet anymore. The 90s felt like you were part of a wild west frontier.
- askafriend 9y agoWhat if the novelty of the internet just wore off for you? Just like the novelty of flying in the sky in a metal cage propelled by giant jet engines to far away lands has probably worn off. Everything is magical, but even magic becomes mundane after a while. Relevant: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8LaT5Iiwo4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8LaT5Iiwo4
- cityzen 9y agoI have been saying I've "reached the end of the internet" for awhile now. I am 44 and have been working on the web since mid 90s. I remember so much cool stuff from then. Trying to get a 56k modem to work, dealing with the fact that you couldn't always get online or if you did you could get kicked off at any time. I remember streaming the Tibetan Freedom Concert with realplayer back in '98. The first mp3 i got, napster, rotten.com, the excitement of ordering from amazon, searching for cracked passwords for photoshop and dreamweaver... in general just figuring shit out. The internet was a mess back then and even though it was frustrating as hell, it was exciting. Now it just seems like every website online is trying to steal and sell your data. I feel like I have to have a heightened sense of awareness around anything I do. The internet used to be just barely within reach and now it's just crammed down your throat all day long. Nothing seems to work and all for the wrong reasons. Nothing worked back then but that was part of the experience.... now it's just... blah. I have fallen into a terrible habit of looking at reddit since I don't use any social media. I read crap on r/politics before bed and end up being so frustrated that I have a hard time falling asleep. Recently I decided to check out a book from the library (House of Leaves, very interesting so far!) and have been reading before bed and not looking at my phone at all. I have been able to fall asleep much easier and I actually have crazy dreams and wake up refreshed. For the first time in years I look forward to going to bed. Not sure what to make of all of it. Fortunately I have found lately that I'm desiring more analog activities (reading, woodworking, hiking) than I have in a long time. It is nice to be able to use the internet as more of a tool to augment my activities rather than being THE activity.
- charliepark 9y agoIt sounds like you're content being offline more, which is great. If you miss it, though … per your comment that "nothing worked back then but that was part of the experience", you might enjoy seeing if there's a local Homebrew Website Club meeting near you (https://indieweb.org/Homebrew_Website_Club https://indieweb.org/Homebrew_Website_Club). I've gone to a couple meetings of the SF one, and it's a nice, earnest, group of makers, looking to build cool stuff on the internet, independent of corporate efforts "to steal and sell your data". They have a sense of that feeling that "The internet was a mess back then and even though it was frustrating as hell, it was exciting."
- bullen 9y agoI think media is moving from Movies and later TV Series (none are good since 1 year back) to now become MMOs. Just the MMOs we have are really bad still. Follow the lineage of WoW, then PUBG; and extrapolate. The internet will become MMOs; hell, life will become MMOs. MMOs are virtual reality more than VR itself could be if it tried real hard (yes, I'm looking at you Nevell). Edit: Maybe streaming of MMOs is where the mass audience kicks in, though in the long run everyone will jack in.
- jbluecreek 9y agoI also find myself lacking ideas for places to explore. I usually wastes time like this: - Do I know of a youtube channel I like and want to watch: mps-youtube [1] - Do I want to get youtube content randomly/reddit-recommended: reddytt [2] - Do I just want some images and gifs, not whole videos: redditp [3] - Do I want to explore twitch, but do not know of a streamer I like: ryck [4] [2] and [4] are my own tools for a more optimised time-wasting (I apologise if self-plugging is considered bad behaviour). [1] https://github.com/mps-youtube/mps-youtube https://github.com/mps-youtube/mps-youtube [2] https://github.com/johanbluecreek/reddytt https://github.com/johanbluecreek/reddytt [3] https://github.com/ubershmekel/redditp https://github.com/ubershmekel/redditp [4] (early stages of development) https://github.com/johanbluecreek/ryck https://github.com/johanbluecreek/ryck
- cyberferret 9y agoI can really identify with the author of the article. I used to be able to successfully distract myself from 'real work' a lot years ago, but lately, most of the internet is just plain boring to me, or even extremely hostile. I used to hang around several guitar forums which took up a TON of time, but I closed my account on all of them years ago when hostility and snarkiness accelerated to dizzying highs. It just stopped being a fun hangout. Twitter and most social media is now just a cesspool of antagonism. Most interesting news articles are now behind paywalls or layered under a ton of ads. The only thing that takes up some of my online time now is watching chess game analytics on Youtube - but I NEVER scroll down to the comments on Youtube any more because I value my sanity. Other than that, I find that I spend those minutes between long downloads/uploads or compile time actually turning around in my home office and picking up a real guitar and playing for a few minutes. I am starting to enjoy the offline tools around me nowadays far more than online distractions.
- InfiniteBeing 9y agoTHWAP
- hprotagonist 9y agoI waste time on IRC. The old internet didn't exactly leave so much as it retreated to its primordial media. Fark, SA, and friends are still around. Slashdot is gutted.
- cyberpip 9y agoI feel like this problem wouldn't be limited to a person's use of the internet but would be an indicator of a person's lack of curiosity in general. The internet, at its most fundamental level, is just information. Saying you don't know how to "waste time" on the internet is like saying nothing interests you anymore.
- fardo 9y ago>I feel like this problem wouldn't be limited to a person's use of the internet but would be an indicator of a person's lack of curiosity in general I don't agree with that idea. When people say "The internet isn't fun anymore", I don't think this generally is a change in the person so much as fundamental changes in how the modern internet is experienced. By analogy, if content on the internet is like a liquid flowing into a container, then it's predictable that the liquid will ultimately match the shape of its container. If you change the shape of that container, the liquid's ultimate shape (and thus the way it is experienced) changes in a predictable manner. When people say the internet isn't fun anymore, this isn't a comment about what's being poured, but the structure in which it's received and presented. Say what you will about streams of "information": I believe if you switch a man's wine glass with a dog dish, only a wino would say nothing has changed.
- ergomarky 9y ago>I don't think this generally is a change in the person so much as fundamental changes in how the modern internet is experienced. It's not a change in the person, it's a shift in perspective due to boredom. There was a podcast about boredom from freakonomics I believe, and a lot of people (largely those 40+) simply don't view themselves as bored when all signs paint a different picture. This is what is happening to a lot of people (ITT), they are unaware of their boredom which feeds into a lack of curiosity, and so they keep doing the same routines and feel somewhat claustrophobic. They could very much break out of that routine, could look for new places to visit, new sites to sink their fangs into, but they won't because routines are very comfortable, and heck most of the top 100 alexa sites fulfill nearly every desire. When people say the internet isn't fun, it's not about presentation at all. Yes, Google has a lot of power in where people go, but there are so many alternative search engines and variety of leads that it really just takes one good afternoon being the excited curious cat you were as a teen.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoMy guilty pleasure is 9gag. It's blocked in the office (thankfully), so I spend way too much time on it when I'm not at work. I used to read a lot of webcomics (XKCD, Joy of Tech, Pon and Zi, QuestionableContent, Poorly Drawn Lines, The Brads) and user-generated art (DeviantArt). 9gag lowered the barriers to entry and made it easy for images to become viral. It's also now transitioned into auto-playing videos instead of static pictures, which is killing comics :(. My boss asked me to watch the CS231n lectures and learn TensorFlow, but he didn't give me a dataset. So I downloaded the history of the 9gag hot page, over 60k images. I'm also interested in learning languages, and I find that comics with dialogues are a great way to learn how to talk to people. I then wrote my own image viewer to let me tag pictures as a comic/not comic. So now I'm still wasting time looking at memes, but I can pass it off as "productive" work, training a machine learning model to find dialogues for language learning.
- roboyoshi 9y agoThat sounds awesome and now I want to know how it performs. Is the dialogue like 2 teenagers communicating purely with memes? Also I'd love to get my hands on those 60k images.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoRight now I'm still just sorting out the comics (with dialogue) from memes (without). If I transcribe them, I could build a chatbot like you describe. I'd rather just hand them over to friends who could translate them. HowardInterprets has translated some comics from Chinese to English, and when one of those reached 9gag, I got my inspiration to use this with my tutor for weekly Mandarin class. https://www.facebook.com/pg/Howardinterprets/photos https://www.facebook.com/pg/Howardinterprets/photos Do you have a server that can receive 7.12 GB? I like Mega.nz but it makes free users wait 5 hours after 2 GB. Make contact if you need the data; you should be find my email address without much difficulty.
- C_System 9y agoThis is a great story, it's like triple-dipping. You're getting a) paid to b) learn and c) look at memes.
- doctorraags 9y agoGod i miss bash.org
- flyinghamster 9y agoIt's still around, and lately there's actually new stuff on it.
- foolofatom 9y agoI think the internet is less fun now -- I can't decide if its from maturation of technology or maturation of people though. (Has anyone else felt like things became less fun as they got older?) I felt a greater sense of community 10 years ago when I mostly used IRC and PHP BBs. The communities were smaller, and it was fun even if you disliked people. Flame wars and trolling were mostly for the audience's amusement, because even if you really disliked each other you had nowhere else to go aside from quitting entirely. Nowadays there are so many options that people don't really commit to communities anymore. I'm glad this thread was posted. It'll be interesting to read people's thoughts.
- JimboOmega 9y agoI don't know either but I have absolutely had the same experience. Although for me the heyday of IRC was 20 years ago, and even then (in the late 90s) it felt dated and quaint. People at that time were moving on from ICQ to AIM, and IRC was the old, weird place you went to get anime DivX videos in particular. I do think the maturation of "troll culture" has really devalued a lot of the Internet. Virtually any event or topic has groups around it dedicated to being as loud as they possibly can, and that kind of sucks some of the air out of it. Loudness is way overvalued by the Internet. I enjoyed going into IRC chats and spamming offensive things when I was 14 (more than 20 years ago), but that phase lasted a few months, if that, for me. It seems to be almost a profession now - my idea of offensive was just repeated curse words and flooding. Trolls these days go all out. And it's not that I can't ignore them, but it feels the broader world can't, and we have to always fight about what to do about them, and how whatever asshole on twitter said whatever super offensive thing or how somebody doxxed somebody or whatever. Plus! Wikipedia has gotten old. When I was young I was curious about tons of things but going to the library to look them up was way too much work. Answers at the touch of a button? Links to related content? It was endlessly valuable and interesting but I've kind of exhausted most of the random topics I was interested in. I still spend a lot of time on wikipedia, and I'm still curious about new things, but the backlog isn't what it was then. It's sort of like 80's music. For a few years in the mid-2000's I kept being shocked how a favorite 80's station would find yet another hit I had never heard but now fell in love with. But the musical content of the decade was indeed finite, and I can't remember the last time I fell in love with a new 80's song (I've moved on to KPop but that's another story).
- nanomonkey 9y agoThe author hasn't come across the decentralized web (ie scuttlebutt or dat). That's where I've found all the personalized interesting content.
- slagfart 9y agopls help me get online, nerd Seriouspost: Agree with all that’s been said. Corporations have turned the web into an unpalatable wasteland. The prospect of someone finding out my name and job has taken all the joy out of calling someone a fuckhead online. I want to find it again. I will start searching, but the good communities I’ve found have been invite only.
- lancewiggs 9y agoDid your joy of calling someone else something bad remove the joy for everyone else?
- slagfart 9y agoIn a small enough community, the Boy Who Cried Wolf remains a pertinent tale. If you had the reputation as a decent and polite poster, the sudden use of a vile cuss, judiciously applied, yielded far greater aggregate results than someone who used them all the time. At the very least, you would save it for someone who really did deserve it. Perhaps the sanding off of the web’s edges is simply a product of its size. Maybe we should go back to Usenet.
- andrewmcwatters 9y agoBelieve it or not, there are a few of us out there who grew up on the web calling each other shitheads in both endearing and insulting ways. It was certainly in the spirit of earlier Internet communities.
- 80386 9y agoMost people strongly prefer to hire their friends, so there aren't many social spaces anymore. And if you're lucky enough to get a job in the industry at all, someone might try to get you run out of the industry for violating whichever ornate Versailles-like code of etiquette they carry around in their head. Or just because they don't like you. I'd like to get involved in the indie-web stuff but it's pretty hard to do when I have to not only stay anonymous but ensure that none of my anonymous web presences can be connected to any of my other anonymous web presences. I mean, I'd also like a job that pays more than $15/hr and doesn't involve lifting boxes for eleven hours a day, but it's also pretty hard to do that when etc., because all professional spaces are also social spaces and if you can't social with the calculation of a Parisian courtier, well.
- ricardobeat 9y agoI miss GeoCities/Tripod, and the time where search engines would always return new, quirky pages for whatever you searched for - no big media publishers or professional bloggers. Lots of fan-built pages, or just people showcasing their hobbies. These days I find myself stuck in a loop of HN, BBC, Reddit, eventually designernews or YouTube. The latter makes me feel trapped but is still mostly valuable content, whereas reddit just feels like a massive time sink in the worst sense.
- CM30 9y agoThis. The way search engines seem to prioritise company run sites and the way everyone's turned everything into a business venture now are the biggest issues with the modern internet.
- mo3gut 9y agoTry https://wiby.me/ https://wiby.me/
- krapp 9y ago>I miss GeoCities/Tripod, and the time where search engines would always return new, quirky pages for whatever you searched for - no big media publishers or professional bloggers. Lots of fan-built pages, or just people showcasing their hobbies. Thank Google and SEO for ruining that. A lot of that old-school and personal content is still out there, (obviously not on Geocities) though... but the process of discovering content on the web has been ruthlessly optimized to favor content aggregators and corporate sites, and as a result, a lot of communities have either moved to those platforms or just go dark.
- Gosper 9y agoI've seen a few references around here lately to https://wiby.me https://wiby.me I've made a habit of visiting to press "surprise me...", which delivers delightfully retro gems like, just now, the RollerCoaster Tycoon Technical Information Depot: http://tid.rctspace.com http://tid.rctspace.com It's a small breath of fresh air from the rest of the web that merges into a unsatisfying blur of over-produced, monitored, and hyper-optimised-for-engagement "content".
- 9y ago
- excalibur 9y ago> I never even watched Saved by the Bell U wot m8
- two2two 9y agoIf the internet were a bar that got boring, then you’d find a new bar. Too bad there isn’t a new internet, separate from the old, to explore and rebuild freely.
- grub2 9y agoJoin the Tor Onionweb, there's almost no content beyond crappy test home pages and memes despite what the mainstream media wanted you to believe. And there's also IPFS, ZeroNet, MaidSafe, I2P and lots of other competing projects based on different designs. But this is also a problem, nobody wants to live in a ghost town...
- hugh4life 9y agoI don't have this problem. My problem is that I'm so good at finding interesting live internet drama and stories that I get extremely bored with most fictional forms. The only fictional books and movies I have any desire to consume are the books and movies I wish I had read or watched when I was much younger.
- peterwwillis 9y agoHe's just old. Go to Tumblr, Facebook groups, Instagram. There's thousands of places to waste your time with vapid, unyielding streams of barely entertaining content. I recently spent hours going through bad geography memes. Geography. Memes. Or you could go old-school. Fark.com is still around, as is SomethingAwful. Reddit has tons of content. And if you're not at work and looking for a horrifying thrill ride, 4chan. IRC is just kind of depressing after you've been away from it for a while... like, a decade later, these same people are still sitting on these channels every day, all day? Then again, I'm still on this waste-of-time news feed...
- keithnz 9y agoExactly this. They just got old. I started playing on the internet in 91, I used IRC mainly, it was exciting and fun talking with people around the world, not many people were on the internet..... to me it went down hill from there, it started being more of a tool with the various phases of new amusing things :) other people started at various points and they would go through a similar thing, it's a great toy that slowly becomes a tool but you can still use it as a toy, but often less inclined to do so, mainly because the toy changes shape all the time and the way you originally played with it morphs into something else.
- silveroriole 9y ago“Go to Tumblr, Facebook groups, Instagram... Reddit... 4chan” All of those have one thing in common to me, which is that they’re not meant for holding conversations on. Facebook pretends to be but if you post more than a couple of replies they get collapsed up. All those sites are “here’s a picture/video, make a kneejerk response, move on.” Ok sure that’s optimised for timewasting - I just want to see content, I don’t want to have to dig through text to get it - but it’s boring, non-interactive, repetitive timewasting. I think we lost some magic when you stopped being forced to deal with individuals in chatrooms/forums/their own personal sites in order to see stuff, even though it was also really inconvenient.
- viridian 9y ago4chan is nothing but conversations. They can span 7 minutes or 7 months depending on the board and the topic, but they otherwise work exactly like forums where the order is determined by post bumping. Try hanging out around a slower board like /lit/ and you'll notice they are essentially forums.
- recluse00 9y agoThis guy seems to have not spent any time on Youtube, Reddit, wikipedia etc. It's easier than ever before to get trapped in curiosity vortexes of various kinds.
- InfiniteBeing 9y agoYeah, it probably has been counter productive for me.
- draw_down 9y agoThat just means you haven't come across any new ideas or personalities in a while. There's a podcast I've been enjoying recently- last night I listened to a podcast about that first podcast. I'm not suggesting any of this, I'm pointing it out because it's ridiculous, we're talking about wasting time here. I'd say this person is standing in a grocery store complaining of hunger, except I sort of see what he means. A lot of energy goes into just a handful of websites like Facebook and Twitter, where in earlier years those people would have ended up on a crappy phpBB forum, each with its own weird sub-sliver of internet culture. Still, I'm pretty sure the internet has more bounty in this area than ever.
- 8bitsrule 9y agoworse, the fun things they had supplanted were never coming back. Forums were depopulated; blogs were shut down. I get what he's saying. In the beginning the net opened the doors to self-expression. Lots of people had fun playing around, exploring, lots of new toys. Then conventions and concentrations arrived, and it BLEW UP. There's still a lot of personal, fun stuff out there, but it's harder to find. As of 2015, PER DAY: 50,000 new -Wordpress- websites; ~ 3 million new posts. Good luck digging through THAT slush pile. https://expandedramblings.com/index.php/wordpress-statistics/ https://expandedramblings.com/index.php/wordpress-statistics... I find new, interesting websites by pouring through aggregators and topical forums (still out there). Takes time.
- strkek 9y agoThere's definitely something about forums that can't be found in social networks. I don't know what that is, but I know it's very unlikely that I'll have as much fun as in those days. Not sure if it's because I was a teenager back then and perceived the internet differently, but nowadays everything looks way too "serious".
- dannyw 9y agoForums are pseudonymous. You could be yourself, or express a part of your identity, without it following around the rest of you on the internet. They're also more homogenous and focused in terms of their users than a big social network with their giant node graph.
- exodust 9y agoWhat do you mean "those days"? I still use forums today for all sorts of focused topics and community discussion around games, audio, design, software etc. The best forums have always been where you learn something and get help and share your work. I'm still doing that because I have many hobbies from gaming to photography to 3d printing. If you don't have serious fun hobbies, what the heck are you going to talk about in an online forum?
- iKlsR 9y agoHad a like experience and got a premium subscription to a manga service and haven't looked back, every week I start a few new ones. These are often surprisingly well written (of the last dozen or so, 4 of the authors had at least a degree in some field and the knowledge showed in the writing). Might not be everyone's thing but getting something interesting to read was the solution for me.
- dcw303 9y agoLooking back over the last twenty years (yes I'm old, like a lot of the you in this thread), user growth has been responsible for both the Internet's success and its demise. I like to to separate content from community, because they have different end results. There's so much music, video, comics, games, ebooks, etc being generated now that we are spoilt for choice. That's great for consumers and not so much for creators, but that's another very large topic for a different conversation. Let's just say that there's so much great stuff out there, and the barriers to getting it are very low. But that low barrier to entry is also what I think has made communities less fun for me. Not for everyone, but definitely for people who are a little bit outcast, or who like to challenge the status quo. Kinda like the people who are drawn to HN. Because online communities are so easy for anyone to enter, conversations tend to congeal into "popular" points of view. Even when those points of view are extremes epitomized by types like SJWs or alt-right, they're still large collections of groupthink. And I find those conversations boring. This has been well documented as the Eternal September phenomenon and it has been happening long before I got onto the net in 1995. The best fun I had in an online community in recent times was the forums and then the slack channel that came out of the Starfighter CTP games from 'patio11 'tptacek & 'elptacek. It was announced here on HN, so the initial exposure (in the scheme of the world) was low, and because everyone involved had to have a common interest of hacking market order books and/or AVR emulators, it turned out that I had quite a bit in common with the average participant. Moreso that standard comment threads here, where it's very likely I'll be arguing with some HN rando who is just looking to score karma so they can shill their upcoming React e-book. Good communities are still out there; what makes them good is that they are hard to get into. We shouldn't give up on the Internet and consider it "done". We should be casting wider nets to connect with people that we find interesting.
- gkoberger 9y agoI think a lot of people here are missing the point. Yeah, there's a lot more content to consume now. However, it doesn't feel like a community... it feels more like watching reruns on TBS. I remember making actual friends on message boards. Friends I eventually met in the real world. I don't think relationships like that are really formed anymore. Most of social media now is a broadcast, not a conversation. People (myself included) want upvotes, retweets and more followers. And now, real identities are involved, so they have to be professional. Back when I started using the internet, there were no "celebrities". At most, there were community leaders, and their "reach" was within the same order of magnitude of the rest of the community. And to be one of those leaders, you needed to learn HTML and build a community the hard way. Nobody was trying to get famous, get more likes, etc. They just talked and made stuff and shared content and learned. Sure, maybe it is just an age thing, and nothing has really changed. But I don't know... I feel like the Internet used to be something special, and now it feels like flipping through TV channels in your office break room.
- querulous 9y agothis absolutely still exists, it's just different than it used to be. go find a twitch streamer that averages 10-300 viewers and you'll find a community. join a slack/discord organization for some niche hobby and you'll find a community. start an instagram account chronicling your trips to craft breweries and you'll find a community
- Qwertie 9y agoThere are a lot of friends to be made on IM groups. I have found the best way to create a good community is to have it be invite only so you don't get random people joining and leaving constantly and the people who are there tend to stick around for a long time.
- Robotbeat 9y agoThat's why I have private Tweets now and still use a pseudonym.
- lostctown 9y ago
- abledon 9y agoKids can see the f*in cosmos on their phones these days. hookup with 20+ chicks with tinder before their 20th birthday. I tell ya, by the time the next generation is 50 years old they wont want to live, the suicide rates will be high, nothing to live for... seen it all done it all lol.
- torstenvl 9y agoHookups and stargazing apps are not the sum total of human existence. It makes me deeply sad that anyone could even fathom having nothing to live for after such a shallow facsimile of experiencing life. There are so many amazing experiences in the world that even someone with no commitments and scads of money could barely scratch the surface of they lived a hundred years.
- saboot 9y agoHas no one, the author or the comments, thought to ask their teenage kids how to waste time on the internet? My younger brother seems to be able to do so all day. I'm also stuck in the reddit/facebook/youtube loop but I have no idea how to do snapchat/instagram, what youtube celebs are popular, or other things I'm not even aware of. I remember learning about vine.co after it closed and apparently that was a huge thing.
- Double_a_92 9y ago> snapchat/instagram Well first you look hot (or at least think you do), then you take cute/hot/slutty pictures of you.
- sreejithr 9y agoI'd like for millennials to comment on this.
- Dirlewanger 9y agoA milliennial wrote the article.
- kipchak 9y agoMid 90s here, to me there's something to it. To me the shift became noticeable around 2008, with it at least feeling like a good portion of my time online is spent on a smaller number of less exciting sites. Perhaps I simply burnt out early though. On forums getting to know the groups members and it's in-jokes has the advantage of giving interactions a sense of scale or place, in that you roughly know who the people you're talking to are and have a degree of rapport or common interests, while still being pseudonymous and the freedom that brings is I think part of what made them appealing and special. Forums can also become somewhat clique-ey and insular if new blood isn't rotated through, or can die out if the topic is too narrow to keep them active. More content stream based social media (Instagram, Facebook, Reddit for the most part) has less of a focus around specific topics and discussing them and more presenting content and reacting to it. This results in people both tailoring what they make to generate hits, and interactions with other users being rather fleeting if you're not already connected to them, as the pool of people you're interacting with is often too large and unfocused to see those people again. I'd say there are some exceptions though, such as subreddits that stay in a sweet spot of user numbers or Discord channels and Twitch channels for example. Additionally 4Chan is somewhat of a blend of the content stream and a forum system. Part of the reason it's going this way is that the content stream approach is better-suited to advertisement and appealing to larger audiences. In school a surprising number of people would browse through the front page of Reddit never going into subreddits or commenting for example. I would guess Lurkers like that make up a good portion of users now, and I think advertisers and site builders will tailor to them. In general a slight shift from the internet being a space for collaboration between people to a place for companies to sell things seems to have happened. A small example is game maps, servers and skins going from being things people made and shared with each other to something companies sell.
- Aliyekta 9y agoI used to have a plethora of offline materials on my pc to delve into, if the internet was down or someone had to use the phone line; nowadays internet’s been shoved down our throats in many aspects that once there’s a network outage, the offline laptop seems useless, unfortunately for the wrong reasons... PS: I think we’re all trying to relive bulletin boards days here in the comment section of HN.
- billybolton 9y agoI think the internet is much better than what it was before. Discord and Telegram are just so much better than what we had when I was in high school. 4chan, reddit, Digg etc suck.
- hyperpallium 9y agoInternet is now TV.
- xnodeza 9y agoI've often wondered what happened to those hours spent trawling for interesting stuff on the web. I spend more time than is probably healthy on YouTube now, but that's just a second TV via iPad while the wife watches shows on Netflix. I think that it was the newness of the experience back then. Nascent technology is always more fun, as are novel experiences. Now, the net permeates our lives. We work on it, we play on it, we order things for our lives on it, we book our entertainment on it, and we carry it around in our pockets. You're no longer part of a community of people learning things and sharing newness. You're part of a collective engine of "doing things" that everyone is plugged into 24/7, where broadcast is fully enabled and the simple joy of just figuring what you're doing and where you're going on the Internet is gone. Also, at 39, my opinion on on the state of the Internet is irrelevant. Damn kids. Back in our day, things were much better ;) Edited to mention MUDs. I can't seem to find many these days. Still a thing?
- bkul_ 9y agoI got the impression that MUDs evolved into MMORPGs. But I have thought for a while that a text-based MUD with a lot of modern polish might be a good idea.
- hitchhiker999 9y agoGreat! We're all old here it seems (I'm 42), a few of us joined back in the 90s... It started as a great human experiment, such fun. It became co-opted by commercial enterprise. The two largest gateways into the experience are now Google and Facebook. Really, what did we expect would happen? Probably best to take it back now.
- krapp 9y ago> Probably best to take it back now. Why? The internet isn't for us, it shouldn't be a quirky clique only for the technorati, it should to be for everyone. "Normal" using the internet for mainstream, banal and commercial content that doesn't appeal to us is more or less the culmination of the dream. The world has been liberated (at least in part) and connected. Let's please at least take a moment to appreciate what's been gained for humanity as a whole as we mourn the loss of our own cultural relevance in the greater scheme.
- drb91 9y ago> Let's please at least take a moment to appreciate what's been gained for humanity as a whole The ability to interact faster? It’s a big wash: positive and negative. It’s hard to see the internet as objectively good for humanity.
- jcoffland 9y ago> It’s hard to see the internet as objectively good for humanity. You could say the same about the automobile.
- drb91 9y agoDefinitely agree.
- krapp 9y agoIt's a lot more than the ability to interact faster. Prior to the internet, the paradigms for mass communication were the telephone and paper mail. Either slow, or expensive, over long distances. Mass media was entirely centralized and corporate owned, and information meant finding physical references at a library. Now, mass communication is nearly instantaneous and multi-paradigm (text, images, video, documents, whatever) and pretty much free, or at least no longer priced as a function of distance. My Australian in-laws Skype almost daily with my family, something which would have been, at least, prohibitively expensive before the internet, and wouldn't have involved video at all. Mass media is dying out to web content. Instead of subscriptions to newspapers and magazines, and whatever is on television, we have literally more content than is possible to read, watch and listen to, on every conceivable topic, professional, amateur and archival. And thanks to the internet, media is no longer tied to physicality. You can watch movies without a DVD, play games without a cartridge, etc. I would argue that the internet has been more revolutionary in terms of the way the common person accesses and harnesses information than the printing press. The mere fact that an ordinary person can publish to the web, as opposed to, say, printing out flyers or a zine or being lucky enough to write for a mass-print publication, has been transformative. I don't really see that as a "wash." There have been some negative effects, and damage to privacy and personal liberty (as one could argue there are with any form of mass communication) but I struggle to think how the negatives would equal, much less exceed, the positives.
- susam 9y agoInternet Relay Chat (IRC) is still around and that's one of the few places on the Internet where I still see tightly knit communities with old Internet buddies from the early 2000s. I am quite happy that IRC is less popular than the world wide web. As a consequence of it being less popular, it has not become riddled with ads, political influence, and addictive content popping up every few minutes, like the web has become. Some IRC channels can be unusually quiet with nothing more than phatic expressions exchanged occasionally for days before any engaging conversation comes up. Yet these channels maintain a tight sense of community. Among some of the active channels I have found due to my interests, I find the Freenode ##python and ##math to be very good quality channels. There is a #not-math channel which is good fun. Then there is #not-not-math too. I have been an operator of the ##algorithms channel for over 10 years now, and although I participate rarely in this channel these days, the channel continues to have good quality discussions by other operators and members of the channel. By the way, my nick is "spal" on Freenode. These days, there are web gateways to IRC, that make it easy to connect to IRC networks without having to install a new client. For example, there is https://webchat.freenode.net/ https://webchat.freenode.net/ which is a bland but decent interface to connect to the Freenode IRC network. Note that the "unaffiliated" cloaks are not honoured while connecting via the web gateway. Using a proper IRC client like WeeChat or HexChat provides a better experience than the web gateway. Pidgin supports IRC too.
- eswat 9y agoI’ve had this idea once or twice of developing an always-active IRC web client to help the newer generation of users join networks and channels that they’d most identify with. Mostly in an effort to get more people in these said channels and keeping discussions flowing. Given what a more accessible Internet has done in general, I’m not sure if the IRC idea would be better or worse…
- lerie82 9y agocompletely ridiculous, it just sounds like this guy has no imagination left and no drive to keep learning new things, and most importantly, no desire to move with technology.
- rrickardt 9y agoMaybe it is time to explore deep/dark web. It is more like nineties on the Internet.
- silveroriole 9y agoFunnily enough I recently watched a YouTube video of a guy exploring the “deep web”. Went on for ages about how you need to use a VM and proxy and Tor browser for your safety! ...and when he finally started, he was just going to sites we would have considered the bog standard of shock sites in the 00s, more tame than goatse. He even started from an aggregator site that listed all of them conveniently for him. Deep!
- abrookins 9y agoNothing I've found on the internet has yet replaced the sublime excitement I felt when dialing into a local BBS in a small town in California when I was a kid. There were maybe 4-5 people on at a time, but I still remember the total thrill of chatting with them and imagining who they might be, where in town they lived, what they looked like. Oh, and how much money I could make in Tradewars that day. My biggest question about this feeling of a long-lost treasure has always been, am I just getting older? Is it just nostalgia for those first experiences of connection through a network? Because if I liked local BBSes so much, you'd think I'd like Facebook or Nextdoor ... but no, I strongly don't. I can't even explain why I don't like them, but it certainly has something to do with anonymity and imagination. In dial-up BBSes, MUDs, IRC, AIM, ICQ, and Livejournal, I was always anonymous. I could be whoever I wanted to be, express myself freely, make friends, and only then choose to reveal my identity — to individuals. Today, so much of the internet is predicated on establishing my identity as quickly as possible, and then profiling me -- tracking my behavior, building a chronology of my behavior, showing my timeline, revealing what I liked or disliked, compiling that data, repackaging it into a derivative, mining the derivative for value. It's so far beyond fun that it's exhausting even to describe. The one thing I am pretty sure about is that this feeling of "I used to do X, it was so simple and fun, what happened?" can be more than just nostalgia. That is, I felt this way about something else several years ago -- tabletop role-playing games. I kept thinking, damn, the guys and I used to have so much fun playing those games: face to face, low-tech, up all night with our D&D sheets, laughing and drawing, etc. It seemed like simple nostalgia for childhood, until I got together some grown-ups and ran some D&D games. And you know what? Three years later, I’ve made some great friends, deepened existing friendships, and had a blast. So I wonder if, for me, what’s missing in my internet is that feeling of a small community — and local, maybe? — with anonymity at its core. I’m not really sure and more thought is needed.
- xnodeza 9y agoSome of the best experiences were posting under a handle on a local gaming site and combining being a sarcastic troll with decent contributions to the forum, as well as writing game reviews for the parent web site. That online community fostered involvement in an RL community through holding LAN gaming events on a weekend, or hanging out with other forum members at a few bars around town. I think you're spot on that localisation is key. I'd go on the world wide web and end up talking trash with a bunch of dudes who lived at most 60km away.
- thallukrish 9y agoI feel you brought out the critical point very well. There is the internet sucks the vacuum from our lives like FB, Twitter or blogs, News...while there is a whole lot of utilitarian needs fulfilled on the other side...And, yes, I have felt the same, the fun part has diminished except following News and occasionally some brilliant links..
- skbohra123 9y agoI think it's the age factor. No one makes friends in their 30s and no one is excited to find new things as they get older. If you ask younger people, they can tell you a 1000 ways to waste time on internet, be it instagram, snapchat or other such apps which grown-ups don't even know about. You are just getting older.
- rimliu 9y agoI am 45 and right now I feel like I need to spend some time prioritising things I am excited about.
- erikb 9y agoWhile we all love the same things that excited us earlier in our life we also know what will disappoint us again. Even after 5 minutes I can tell a lot of things that I won't like in a relationship. The other person is not a blank white board anymore, because the other person is not so different from all the other people I met before. The new stuff is also often just a reiteration of something that has already been there, which means it's not new and not exciting.
- happycube 9y agoAs a 42 year old, I read that article and think "thirtysomething old man yells at cloud!" - there are tons of diversions out there of all sorts. OTOH, I live out near Santa Barbara, and downtown SB is nowhere near as good as what it was before 2006 or so. It had Borders+B&N, good thrift stores, some random shops, etc. Pretty much all of that's gone now.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- silveroriole 9y agoI think we’re missing out on the weird and the unique. Reddit/Twitter does have massive streams of content, but they’re all pretty homogenous, and both sites have their own pretty homogenous etiquette rules. Back then every site was an amateur attempt with a bizarre design and a community of obsessive weirdos because only obsessive weirdos were posting online, and posting without learning the unspoken rules and celebrities of the community would get you destroyed. Messing with the rules and winding up the ‘big name posters’ could be hilarious, because it actually affected the community. Now ‘content’ is pretty much just memes. Memes are ‘weird’ but they’re homogenised, structured weird. They (well, image macros - we didn’t have the word meme then) were mostly banned on SA because they encouraged such crappy low effort repetitive content. Now the timewasting internet is 99% that. SA used to be amazing but over time they’ve banned or devalued more and more of what I thought was worthwhile about the site (effortposts, obsessive stalkers who would dig up incredible things about other posters, the absolutely crap but bigname fiction posters, anyone who doesn’t talk like they’re posting on Twitter) and now GBS is literally just discussing Reddit content.
- jcoffland 9y ago> Reddit/Twitter does have massive streams of content, but they’re all pretty homogenous Reddit is anything but homogenous. It has many a dark and quirky corner. Twitter on the other hand.
- paxys 9y agoThis entire thread makes me realize that what people are missing isn't the internet but their own childhood.
- WA 9y agoI thought so, too. There are still enough communities hosted on phpBB, there are still enough ways to tinker around, join IRC, find ridiculous geocities-like websites or whatever. It's more that people choose to use FB, YouTube, Reddit, Instagram.
- oblio 9y agoThere's communities even in those places. You just have to go looking for them and be a naive kid, like all these people posting in this thread were 10-20+ years ago :p
- tatami 9y agoNot just childhood, but I miss having that first-time experience for some of my (later) favourite activities. Guess I have to try new things ... but what?
- duggan 9y agoAgreed; I guess many of us will have a blind spot when it comes to recognizing our own minds aging, and our memories accreting into a golden history. Seems to be a part of the human condition. Time's arrow moves in one direction, the past cannot be reclaimed. The challenge is to not become bitter about it.
- brain5ide 9y agoSo summing up the distinct ideas on this topic: - lacking of community feel is a good point - people being older and less excitable another great point - the late stage of S curve and early adopters being overwhelmed by the scumbags is also good point - the change to identity-first internet is also interesting Did I miss something? I also feel some structural misalignment of perception vs. reality. The old adage is You can't trust anything on the internet but I notice that even if I still conform to that, I somehow end up trusting the internet as a whole - that together with the hive mind I would be able to arrive at a conclusion. It's just not true anymore. I know it's false to categorize internet as a singular entity, but I think that's what hapened on the emotional-euristic-type-1 level of decisions and it needs to go. This may be a derivative of earlier points, but may also be a whole separate point.
- heisnotanalien 9y agoI remember when I'd read genuinely thoughtful posts on Livejournal. There would be no stupid memes, no instagram style selfies, no ad spam, just people in my city or from across the world, reflecting on their life.
- Negative1 9y agoI too have experienced cyber-ennui, mindlessly half entering website addresses into my navbar. Cn-enter. Ha-enter. Fa-enter. Eng-enter. What am I even reading, I don't really care about the latest drone or how to optimize my website using Lambda and API gateway, and yet, despite keeping my IDE open so "there is no excuse", I just can't help but succumb to the mindless ether... I've thought about this a bit and I feel like anything worth doing requires hours of my concentration, which I don't usually have. Bite sized chunks of knowledge 'productivity' feels like an accomplishment, or, at least serves as a facsimile. The internet is, in some ways, like an artificial sweetener -- it tastes sweet but never actually satisfies you.
- scandox 9y agoAn attempt to summarize everything I'm reading in these comments: The Internet used to be an escape from the real world. Now the Internet is the real world.
- kowdermeister 9y agoLet me help you with that: http://www.theuselessweb.com http://www.theuselessweb.com If you ever find yourself staring at a blinking cursor, then lean back, close your eyes and imagine something. Just something you enjoy doing. Type it into Google, DDG or https://neocities.org/browse https://neocities.org/browse Profit... well not exactly, but hours can easily fly by. I'm more like this guy ( http://littlefun.org/posts/Why_I_am_reading_about_advanced_nuclear_theory http://littlefun.org/posts/Why_I_am_reading_about_advanced_n... ), I guess we all have our problems :)
- carcrash 9y ago21 year old here, I also do not enjoy the internet these days as much as I used to 5+ years ago. Everything seems dumbed down, which is a common trend with just about everything these days. I do not use social media, I browse one car related forum, and a Chan site. I mostly lurk these sites and rarely have input, but that's more of a 'me' issue. The community feeling just isn't there anymore. We've done a complete 180 from a few years back, my first online friends were from Xbox Live and I met these people in Halo 3 lobbies. When I played WoW during Wrath I played on a very low population server which annoyed me back in the day but I realise now that the memories I have are because of the small community, same goes for the private servers I played. All the friends I have now I have known for years or met them through other friends. Maybe I'm just barking up the wrong tree and I need to develop new skills, hobbies, and find new friends.
- pmlnr 9y agoI'm struggling to find genuinely fun content since the death of Flash. I truly miss sites like z0r.de. In general, I completely agree with the article.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sunyatax 9y agoA friend sent this thread my way. Our team's spent the past two and a half years designing a new breed of social media that is reintroducing authenticity and genuine relationships back into how we communicate online. Our goal is to transcend the unhealthy norms of existing platforms through intentional design, distributed technology and a nonprofit approach. Feel free to check us out here and hope to see you on the waitlist :) www.junto.love
- Gootch 9y agoI think I might actually now know how rural folk perceive the big city...
- harperlee 9y agoIronically, I think at least part of it is due to less amateur content, in turn due to the dominance of mobile phones, that enable you to easily interact casually and superficially with content, but create a myriad of minor, subtle cues not to create content, just to consume it. In a PC, in the "olden internet days" that the article misses, you had to be in front of the PC. It was an activity on itself. But creating content was easier. You had a bigger screen, a slower connection, you saved funny memes in a folder in the Desktop. When bored, in was mentally and physically easier to alt-tab into amateurish internet than to get up to do something else. So lots of people ended up losing time interactively, in front of a hundred keys asking to be pressed. Whereas today, most of the users interact through a mobile phone with one thumb, on 5 minute intervals, in a micropause throughout the day (and possibly even during a conversation). Small screen real estate, maxed out app, no hint to alt-tab, painful to create content (you have to tap in onscreen keyboard that eats up half of your screen, you have to add the second thumb and lean over the minuscule screen, you have to go to another app to navigate a folder to upload a meme, etc). Everything takes more effort, needs to be more conscious. And when the user mostly consumes, the whole UX evolves towards that, making it easier to consume and more difficult to create, in a viscious cicle. (I'm typing this on my mobile and it is a pain. I only see about 20 typed words, even moving the cursor back to noher word is a minor pain, etc. I just want to get it done, and I have already thought a couple of times whether it makes more sense to kill the comment mid-redaction and keep on browsing HN) Edit: and of course people keep using laptops an pcs, but the existence of mobile phone users change the dynamics of every content community a lot.
- Clubber 9y ago>And then, one day, I think in 2013, Twitter and Facebook were not really very fun anymore. For me, the internet stopped being fun after the Snowden revelations. Not only did it stop being fun, it became subconsciously repulsive I think. This was around that time.
- grub2 9y agoIn the recent 5 years, there has been a renaissance of "cyberspace" as in the early science fiction, the cyberpunk culture, and aesthetics and a nostalgia of 1980s in general, as shown in vaporwave [0] arts and independent/DIY music. In many works, the imagery of cyberspace was used heavily, and themes included Usenet the Eternal September, Sci-Fi themed hacking and cracking, early BBS and imageboard subculture, lots of memes, etc. And recently there is also an upsurge of cyberpunk-related fictions, games (e.g. VA-11 HALL-A [1]), TV series, etc. The reason sure includes the economic recession and political failures of the present days, but the death of the early Internet culture and the promises of "cyberspace" being a cutting-edge, cool and fun place has failed in a future that never comes, is definitely an important cause. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaporwave https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vaporwave [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VA-11_HALL-A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VA-11_HALL-A
- fuball63 9y agoI'm getting weary reading the constant lament of the "internet" as a massive entity. These articles take the same form: - "ugh social media is terrible, remember forums" - "aren't rss feeds great" - "remember when sites were HTML based" - "back in my day the internet was just me and a few cool people" The internet is not a monolith. What people are complaining about is the corporate internet; the parts of the internet that are owned by billion dollar companies. Here's the reality: - there are more interesting independent blogs now than there were pre-Facebook/Twitter. Maybe less "per-capita" of total online usage, but there's still a higher volume - every single person is capable of making an online community using cheap tech, and using corporate social media to promote it; way easier than it was in the past - developers are still "allowed" to make sites in plain HTML/CSS that look great and load fast Blockbuster movies are always bad, so people made indie films. Network TV sitcoms are bad, so people made online series. Pop music is bad, so people make great music and play in local bars and small venues. If you're tired of the "internet being bad", its time to put the work in to find (or make!) what you like, because it's all out there.
- AstralStorm 9y agoIndependent does not work at all because random websites are no longer discoverable. In the old days of the internet discoverability was via word of mouth, portals/aggregators or old "topic rings". You had bulletin boards as well. The original reason for e.g. Reddit to exist was to be an aggregator and recommendation service. However it started handling discussions which it is not equipped to deal with at all and then went downhill. A similar aggregator is HN. Again, it is not equipped for discussion. Both are curated by users which further lowers signal to noise ratio and causes popularity contest plus short lifespan of valuable content. Both are essentially RSS feeds with HTML/JS interface, comment and vote functions. Forum software is equipped for discussion but requires manual curation to serve as an aggregator limiting volume. Likewise newer chat software. Facebook and Twitter are inferior compared to forum software in almost all cases. They are broadcast media with major limitations that are user curated. Facebook main reason of existence is remembering and tracking people not matchmaking or contact - it is not equipped for that well if at all - the chat handles maybe a few people at most, comments under posts are a total mess. Nobody really cares about volume. (Unless they sell ads.) Quality is what matters and it really went down with user curated sites. For social talk and matchmaking, you need a platform that allows discussion in the long term. Neither Facebook nor Twitter help with it as a profile or a post is not a topic. The old chat survives alongside some bigger forims still, both IRC and newer platforms like Slack, Discord, Twitch etc. These have a problem with discoverability because they're rarely indexed. The major differentiator is again "user curated" vs moderated; broadcast vs chat.
- ehonda 9y ago>What happened is that the internet stopped being something you went to in order to separate from the real world — from your job and your work and your obligations and responsibilities. It seems we (or many of us) spend all our time on the internet, it no longer feels like a place to escape reality. Even when you are away from your desk, you are still connected to the internet through your phone. It doesn't have the same wonder it used to.
- FrankyHollywood 9y agotry this :) http://thecodinglove.com/ http://thecodinglove.com/
- grawprog 9y agoYup the internet sure does suck now...example...I was banned for the shit I said before I was banned...bahhhahahahahaha
- ducttape12 9y agoThe internet used to be a place to communicate, now it's just a place to mine attention for ads through click bait, poorly written articles.
- el3ctron 9y agotwitter, facebook, instagram and whatsapp are destroying the good internet, long life to sources with rss support!
- captainbland 9y ago"printed guitar tabs that would turn out to be wildly incorrect" These still exist. Plus now you can load them into Tux Guitar to figure out how incorrect they are without even bothering to learn them.