7 ms·
In Austin, TX we've outlawed these kinds of bags. All grocery store bags are required by law to be sturdy enough to be reusable. This results in a few different
by brundolf 9y ago
In Austin, TX we've outlawed these kinds of bags. All grocery store bags are required by law to be sturdy enough to be reusable. This results in a few different things:
- Bags are heavy enough to not get blown away in the wind
- Half of the time, the bags are made of paper instead, meaning they're recyclable and (presumably) at least partially biodegradable
- The plastic bags that do exist are larger, robust enough to be brought with you to the store again and again, and at least at HEB they cost 25 cents, which discourages people from getting them unless they actually need them
Seeing things like this make me proud of my city.
- newswriter99 9y ago-Plastic is recyclable. Why would you think it's not? -Besides that, paper bags are made up of (dun dun dun) plant material. Which means CO2 is being brought into the equation. -The energy required to make a paper bag versus a plastic one are still neck and neck. https://ecomyths.org/2014/05/27/myth-paper-bags-are-greener-than-plastic/ https://ecomyths.org/2014/05/27/myth-paper-bags-are-greener-... I'm not saying plastic bags are better than paper, but they're not really worse, aside from the fact that people suck at disposing of them. You need to get society better at recycling. It's not really the bag's fault.
- koube 9y agoIIRC plastic bags are not recyclable, you cannot meaningfully put them in the recycle bin[0], and the plastic bag collection bins outside of grocery stores go directly to the trash. Looks like that may have changed recently[1] but I'm a bit skeptical that all grocery stores have set up the correct supply chain to have the plastic bags be recycled. [0]: https://livegreen.recyclebank.com/because-you-asked-can-i-recycle-plastic-grocery-bags-in-the-recycling-bin https://livegreen.recyclebank.com/because-you-asked-can-i-re... [1]: https://sfenvironment.org/plastic-bags-plastic-wrap-recyclable https://sfenvironment.org/plastic-bags-plastic-wrap-recyclab...
- tialaramex 9y agoThe plastic bags are made from can be recycled. If you're determined you can recycle almost anything. However, the bags are a total nightmare for automated or semi-automated sorting of mixed recycling. If you give me 10 trucks per day of mixed soda cans and newspapers, I can build a factory the size of a small building that separates and processes them into bales of crushed steel cans, bales of crushed aluminium cans, and bales of newspaper, all three have recycling markets and I can sell them. If we add "some plastic bags" to those truckloads my machine is now a nightmare. The bags will tangle with anything, and they might more or less at random "hop" over or fall into holes sized to match objects, the machine that sorts alumium cans can't handle them, the machine that bales newspapers can't handle them, everywhere is now "also plastic bags", and all my customers don't want plastic bags, their specifications are clear, a little bit of Pepsi or Budweiser in the bale of steel cans is tolerable, a plastic bag is not; One cardboard loo roll mixed in with the newspaper is tolerable, a plastic bag is not; And so on. I visited a plant in Central London that handles their area's recycling - very noisy, very interesting, they said if visitors took away just one single idea from their visit that idea should be "Don't put any fucking plastic bags in the general recycling".
- _bxg1 9y agoThis is a great insight. I always knew they didn't recycle well but I never really understood why, given that they are in fact made of plastic.
- telchar 9y agoDoes this apply to bags that aren't of the grocery bag type? Take for example the large linked plastic bubbles that Amazon and such use as padding in their boxes. They have a recycling mark on them (#4, I think), but I'm never sure whether to mix them in with the grocery bags, which I separate from other recyclables, or with the other recyclables.
- kingosticks 9y agoThey should probably invest a bit of money in communicating that fact to the general public. For example, on the side of council recycling bins. I can't work out if my neighbours are ignorant or just lazy but it might help a little.
- bcheung 9y agoRecyclable is a relative term. Given a really long time you could say fossil fuels are a renewable energy source too. I think the point here is that other types of bags are either sturdy enough to be reused, or paper, that decomposes MUCH faster and is not anywhere near as harmful to wildlife. In the ocean, paper would break down even faster than on land.
- efa 9y agoGrocery store bags used to all be paper back in my day! Then someone demanded they be replaced with plastic.
- reaperducer 9y agoSpent a very little time in the grocery industry. Remember that back in our day the paper bags didn't have handles. Even today, paper bag handles suck (I'm looking at you, Whole Foods). The reason consumers embraced plastic bags was the handles. Then manufacturers figured out how to make them super cheap. Now there's an entire generation of people who have never heard the phrase, "Paper or plastic?" Or "Smoking or non-smoking?" in a restaurant or airplane for that matter.
- jmulho 9y agoOr "Leaded or unleaded?"
- cimmanom 9y agoFor a long time, the default in many grocery stores in NYC (where the typical method of getting your groceries home is on foot, a bag in each hand) was a paper bag (for strength and structure) inside a plastic bag (for handles).
- Sohcahtoa82 9y agoWhen I was a retail cashier between 2000 and 2007, the store I worked at offered both paper and plastic, but we were told not to ask and to just bag plastic and if a customer wanted paper, they would have to specifically ask for it. We were told it was because plastic bags cost a fraction of a penny, while paper bags were about 7 cents, and they didn't want to waste money on paper bags for customers that honestly didn't really care.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoWe use paper bags at our retail outlet, they're more expensive and suffer catastrophic failure vs cheaper plastic which is, well, plastic (stretches first usually). You have to take more care with paper (people are lazy) and it costs more from sustainable sources (people are miserly).
- nickthegreek 9y agoMy buddies and I went to Austin on a motorcycle trip and one of our bikes broke down and we had to go to an auto store for a few small parts. When we asked for a bag to put the items in to transport them to other bike and they said "we don't have bags" we started laughing and were floored when we realized that they did not in fact have bags. Most places didn't stock paper bags either, which we would of gladly paid for. We got used to it during the week but it was some big culture shock for us. Great for locals, infuriating for travelers.
- _bxg1 9y agoI've never been to a grocery store that didn't have some kind of bags, and to be honest I've never bought enough things at once from a retail store to warrant a bag, but I can see how that could be a problem in certain situations
- ghostly_s 9y agoI can certainly see how it could be frustrating to be without a bag if you need to transport your items on a motorcycle (though you were on a motorcycle trip and no one had a saddle bag they could put the things in?). Extending your experience to 'travellers' at large is a bit much. I'm from one of the dozens of other American cities with a plastic bag ban(yay!) so I think I would be quite non-plussed were I traveling in Austin. :)
- protonfish 9y agoI wouldn't be too proud of yourselves. There is debate over the relative environmental impact of plastic, paper, and reusable shopping bags. If you jump to the conclusion that plastic bags are the worst, it's probably because you haven't researched enough.
- pyrotrout 9y agoI've always thought the debate was in terms of energy required to manufacture the individual bags. In terms of recyclability and sustainability doesn't paper win out? The stuff literally grows on trees on farms
- airstrike 9y agoTechnically, it grows as trees
- _bxg1 9y agoFrom what I've read, all of the types have different tradeoffs. The thinnest plastic ones technically have the smallest carbon footprint because there's less weight to ship around, the materials are easier to acquire, etc. My personal reasoning is that there are lots of other (more significant) ways to combat climate change, but there's no other way to stop whales from choking to death on plastic. Then again, I could just be more emotionally affected by the tangible images of plastic pollution than by the more abstract notion of carbon footprint.
- azemetre 9y agoI'm honestly doubting this, it seems outright insane to not take into the external costs of plastic (lasts forever) compared to fabric or paper. Where are you getting this from?
- _bxg1 9y agohttps://www.theverge.com/2018/5/12/17337602/plastic-tote-bags-climate-change-litter-life-cycle-assessments-environment https://www.theverge.com/2018/5/12/17337602/plastic-tote-bag...
- pathseeker 9y agoEveryone who wants plastic can just drive to Manor, TX and do shopping there though. Possession of the bags isn't actually outlawed, the stores just can't give them to you in city limits.
- nikanj 9y agoFinland has similar, sturdy bags. It was a real shock coming to Canada, where they use the flimsiest POS bags. If I'm not paying attention, I get about 2-3 items per double-bag. This really seems like a weird glitch in the algorithm: 1) The plastic bag line in Excel is too damn high. We need to lower that cost 2) Order cheaper, thinner and crappier bags 3) Now we need to double-bag everything, and a bag can only handle the weight of a single chocolate bar 4) Customers use five times more bags than they used to 5) The plastic bag line in Excel is too damn high. We need to lower that cost
- Noumenon72 9y agoWhere I am the thin bags are quite strong, but all the cashiers are forced to double bag anyway because of that one time it breaks and the customer gets mad. I have to just go along with it instead of bothering them.
- mmt 9y agoWhen they did the plastic bag ban for grocery stores in California, I immediately went out and bought a case of those thin ones to stick in my car. They're far stronger and more reliable (even with the overall poorer quality control, which I believe causes the occasional breaks you refer too, easily remedied by conservatively under-filling) than even the best paper bags they're replacing. The handles on those paper bags require such delicate, special handling, and if there's any wetness, well, I'd better have a cart, because I'm not making it to my car no matter how closer I parked. The case of 1000 takes up very little space in the trunk, lasts me essentially forever, costs way less than the mandatory 10 cents per bag the stores are now required to charge, and, more importantly, is far more sanitary than reusable bags. It is enough of a challenge to shop for fresh, relatively healthy food and having it last a worthwhile length of time, without worrying about cross-contamination from the last shopping trip.
- always_good 9y agoI don't understand. You can use any reusable bag. Even a cotton or nylon one you can toss in the wash. Do you also have a sanitary issue with reusable plates and panties? Or do you just wash them?
- pishpash 9y agoOne of the worst ideas ever, spreading like a plague. All it results in is stores becoming sellers of bags and finding ways to bundle bags into the sale to capture the bag fee which they keep. Some stores didn't even use bags previously. The bags sold are not generally reusable as a practical matter, so it causes more waste (more plastic weight over all being transacted). When they are reusable they have caused sanitation issues. Why would you incentivize stores to sell bags? Has any of the bag ban cities seriously thought this one through?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- specializeded 9y agoThe bags sold are not generally reusable as a practical matter Citation abso-fucking-lutely required. I moved to Austin 4 years ago and use the exact same Wal Mart & HEB bags I got the first week here like literally everyone else, not a single one has gone out of use.
- always_good 9y agoThe bags at the store are more like a forgetter's fee. Though I don't see how they aren't reusable. I don't understand your criticism when you can bring any reusable bag into the store. Don't like the store's bags? Bring your own. If the best criticism you can come up with for the reusable bag mandate is that you need to bring your own, that's not very damning. In fact, I wouldn't mind if stores sold the same shitty bags as before but for 10 cents. The real win is a cultural shift towards reusability, not a good deal on plastic bags at the point-of-sale. Once again, just keep your favorite reusable bags in your car.
- pishpash 9y agoWrong. The bags are a tax on the poor. Not everybody has a car, are they supposed to carry several reusable bags on their person at all times? The poor also reuse plastic bags to bag trash, now they need to buy garbage bags. Wasting is a first-world problem. The "culture shift of reusability" is a rich person's luxury, like those alarm clocks that shred money, except it is mandated for everyone. I hope you see the absurdity and arrogance of it all.
- c0nducktr 9y agoHere in Michigan, they banned the banning of plastic bags. http://www.mlive.com/news/index.ssf/2016/12/ban_on_local_plastic_bag_bans.html http://www.mlive.com/news/index.ssf/2016/12/ban_on_local_pla...
- aoner 9y agoBag levies are a simple and effective solution. Here in the netherlands (and other European countries) for example you are not allowed to give away free plastic bags. That significantly reduced plastic in the north sea: https://uk.reuters.com/article/oceans-pollution-plastics/european-efforts-to-curb-plastic-litter-in-oceans-are-working-researchers-idUKL5N1RI3N3 https://uk.reuters.com/article/oceans-pollution-plastics/eur...
- lurquer 9y agoI go to Austin now and then. It gives me hope for the future when I see the organic hemp reusable tie-died bags. Amazing how many plastic bottles, plastic packaging, plastic garbage sacks, and plastic tableware can fit into those bags.