8 ms·
This would be a nice thing for Disney to do, but they won't. Iron Man was a second rate Marvel character that they ignored for years, and they've subsequently m
by nailer 9y ago
This would be a nice thing for Disney to do, but they won't. Iron Man was a second rate Marvel character that they ignored for years, and they've subsequently made so much money from that. Monkey Island is an excellent storyline and world and Disney will happily ignore it until Pirates of the Carribean is forgotten they they will find the right treatment and throw some celebrities in there and make a bunch of money. Or not do anything and deprive someone else from doing the same thing. Not saying that's good or bad, just saying that's what will happen.
- Jaruzel 9y agoThey don't have to hand back the full rights, just give Ron enough rights to develop a new game. They could also keep an option to expand on Ron's work for anything Monkey Island-y later on down the line. It would be low risk for Disney to do this, as they could basically get a Monkey Island reboot, for free.
- dingaling 9y agoThat would seem to be a sensible workaround. It's not a case of handing or selling back rights, as I understand it. The games were developed as works-for-hire under contract to LucasArts. Therefore Ron Gilbert didn't own the rights once completed.
- crankylinuxuser 9y ago"So this idea came out from your head, and completely made by you, but because you took some money, its like your act of creation never happened. We will deprive you of your very minds creativity and create holes in which you can never discuss again." .... And here I thought software and content piracy was unethical.
- lozenge 9y agoWork for hire is a globally recognised principle of copyright law. How else could it possibly work?
- crankylinuxuser 9y ago> Work for hire is a globally recognised principle of copyright law. Yes, that idea was made by Disney and similar orgs. And then the USA exported those laws to other nations. > How else could it possibly work? The ideas are innately in a person's head. Simply put, the licensure of a creation could travel around with whomever hires the person. But in reality, I'm allowed to criticize a broken system without having to come up with a "better" system. Just an FYI.
- dingaling 9y agoThe counterpoint being that without the money provided by the contractee, the individual with the idea in his head may not ever reify that concept. None of the IP of commercial software I've written resides with me. I don't feel deprived of it though.
- seba_dos1 9y agoProvided that Ron would want to do it in such scenario at all.
- jamesrcole 9y agoRon has said "The only way I would or could make another Monkey Island is if I owned the IP." https://grumpygamer.com/if_i_made_another_monkeyisland https://grumpygamer.com/if_i_made_another_monkeyisland
- wiz21c 9y agoI guess M. Gilbert deliberately chosen to work for money, chosen to sell its IP to Disney or some publisher. So basically, his choices determine the current situation. We should respect that.
- SmellyGeekBoy 9y agoHe never owned the IP in the first place.
- danmaz74 9y agoBy the way, I'm getting increasingly worried about the sheer dominance that Disney is increasingly having in the children entertainment business. Looks like they're aiming at owning all the relevant franchises in that field...
- fwsgonzo 9y agoI feel like its a failure of government, and it's happening pretty much everywhere. https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-3n_GbJVCIuI/UnUmZ-3ntzI/AAAAAAAAX04/WShRP19HwEc/s1600/10+Mega-Corporations.png https://2.bp.blogspot.com/-3n_GbJVCIuI/UnUmZ-3ntzI/AAAAAAAAX... There are charts like this for banks and anything else you can imagine, so its not "just" those companies.
- Sharlin 9y agoHonest question: Are there some convincing arguments for why this isn’t also a failure of free-market capitalism? It appears to me that without government regulation (the irony!) most if not all free markets end up as oligopolies sooner or later. Indeed, isn’t that exactly how we got antitrust legislation in the first place?
- white-flame 9y ago"Free" doesn't mean unregulated free-for-all, it specifically means that people are free to enter the market as buyers or sellers, and free to choose what and when to exchange, at what price. The government does not regulate who is allowed in the market, nor the prices; but rather would get involved by protecting those freedoms to engage & price. Monopolies work against a free market, as do barriers to entry. Businesses make more money if the market is not free, i.e. if others in the market are not free to choose competitors' products or to become a competitor themselves. The "invisible hand" is about reflecting pricing movement of free exchange, not enforcing the freedoms. If a society wants a free market, they need to set up rules that promote market freedom as a societal goal, which would (ideally) end up working against individual profit maximization (compared to a usurpable market) but for greater overall robustness and correction.
- cornholio 9y agoIndeed, the simple fact that this petition is successful is itself proof that the franchise is valuable and should not be given away. Maybe a better course of action would be to convince Disney to allow a sequel owned by the original author, while retaining future rights.
- toomuchgov 9y agoYes, call the sequel 'Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge'. Just brainstorming, folks.
- jamesrcole 9y agoCopying and pasting what I wrote in another comment, Ron has said "The only way I would or could make another Monkey Island is if I owned the IP." https://grumpygamer.com/if_i_made_another_monkeyisland https://grumpygamer.com/if_i_made_another_monkeyisland (He has also said this in podcasts).
- WorldMaker 9y agoAs an easy counterpoint to this scenario, Tim Schafer and Double Fine talked Disney into letting them revisit/enhance Grim Fandango, Day of the Tentacle, and Full Throttle. Disney has no problem relicensing IP, it just doesn't care to sell it. (IIRC, Tim Schafer has even mentioned they have the option to create sequels in some of the licenses, but they don't have strong ideas for them at the moment.)
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y agoPirates of the Caribbean is basically already a Monkey Island adaptation. Naive young protagonist falls in love with governor('s daughter), love interested is kidnapped by ghost pirate, there's a secret island you can only visit by magical means, turns out love interest didn't really need all that much saving anyway... There's no rubber chicken with a pulley in the middle, but basically all the parts are there.
- logfromblammo 9y agoThat's a rather important part. Without it, everything else completely falls apart. And the only monkey didn't even have three heads.
- fixermark 9y ago... literally. """ The Monkey Island movie never got the green light and years later Ted Elliott wrote 'Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl', which took several ideas from Monkey Island. So basically the first two PotC movies are the Monkey Island movie. """ http://monkeyisland.wikia.com/wiki/The_Curse_of_Monkey_Island_Movie http://monkeyisland.wikia.com/wiki/The_Curse_of_Monkey_Islan...
- roryisok 9y agoI've said it already on this thread but both MI and PotC, while influenced by each other (yes, MI is also influenced by the original pirates of the Caribbean ride) both have more in common with On Stranger Tides by Tim Powers. Ron Gilbert has stated in interviews that the book was a big inspiration, and the fourth PotC film is actually called On Stranger Tides and is essentially an adaptation. The second and third movies also borrowed a lot from it, most memorably the scene where two characters get married during a swordfight is lifted straight from the book
- givinguflac 9y agoAs a lifelong Marvel fan, how dare you call Iron Man second rate, sir/madam.
- shp0ngle 9y agoThe only good Iron Man runs were the two Michelinie/Layton runs and Extremis. Marvel has tried to constantly "fix" Iron Man because they really didn't know what to do with him. Before Extremis, they tried to put a reset button on him and make him a teenager (that didn't stick); later they made him a secretary of defense (that didn't stick); then they made Extremis, which basically completely ignored all previous continuity, because Warren Ellis thought it sucked; and then they made him a villain in Civil War. He was kinda important in Avengers I guess, but even there he was always "just a bodyguard"
- moorhosj 9y agoDisney bought Marvel in August 2009, more than a year after the first Iron Man movie was released in April 2008.