8 ms·
When physics meets biology: a less known Feynman
- mlechha 9y agoNot a very good abstract. It doesn't tell me anything about Feynman's contribution to molecular biology.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Ultimatt 9y agoVery little. He did some work on what would now be called mutational "recovery" of frame shift insertion/deletion variants in phages, for about a year on sabbatical. Which at the time would have been enough for him to have predicted several aspects about the genetic code, such as DNA triplets forming codons. Which was funnily enough anticipated by George Gamow around the same time looking at the number of naturally occurring amino acids and the number of nucleobases.
- oli5679 9y agoThere was a really good chapter on his time in a biology lab in his book, "Surely you're joking Mr. Feynman". I have always remembered this quote: When it came time for me to give my talk on the subject, I started off by drawing an outline of the cat and began to name the various muscles. The other students in the class interrupt me: "We know all that!" "Oh," I say, "you do? Then no wonder I can catch up with you so fast after you've had four years of biology." They had wasted all their time memorizing stuff like that, when it could be looked up in fifteen minutes.
- ItsMe000001 9y agoI've been taking medical and biology related courses for the last five years or so, well over 1000 hours in lecture hours thus far - thanks to the Internet (a counterpoint to the "I Don’t Know How to Waste Time on the Internet Anymore" thread popular on HN right now). I concluded that while I find it all extremely interesting and exciting as far as anatomy, physiology, neuroscience, organic and biochemistry, genetics, statistics (which I had learned - and forgotten - before but now I actually found useful and therefore interesting for the first time), etc., I could never study medicine to become a doctor. All that rote learning! For a CS graduate, it's like learning everything there is about Oracle 9i. For years. By heart. Not even about databases in general, you learn the basics of course, but then you spend most of your time learning by heart every command and every setting of Oracle 9i. I'm sure it makes you an efficient doctor within the given system, and when trying to solve some example cases there sure is value in knowing pathways (real ones, e.g. neurological ones - where is the damage if the patient feels this and does not feel any of that?, as well as biochemical ones, but also organizational stuff like various ways invented to categorize broken bones, e.g. http://www.thieme.com/media/samples/pubid1252333231.pdf http://www.thieme.com/media/samples/pubid1252333231.pdf). Quite frankly, I find most of it a waste of time. Right now I'm re-taking edX "Principles of Biochemistry" (https://www.edx.org/course/principles-biochemistry-harvardx-mcb63x-1 https://www.edx.org/course/principles-biochemistry-harvardx-...), and while it's a lot of fun I also feel it's quite a bit of a waste: From part III on it feels more and more useless. The course is done very well, and every bit is interesting, but how - WHY - am I supposed to learn soooo many paths in such great detail? What's the point? If I need it I can always look it up! No wonder that while there are several "Hello I'm new here, excited to start this course" messages in the forum every day there are only a handful of forum messages for the later sections of the course - after many months of running. I suspect >90% of people never get past part 3 (of 5). Because the brain just does not see the point of all this rote learning. If there was a larger project as context, a problem to solve! But just "here learn this" for no other reason than "it's interesting" (so are a trillion other pieces of information!!)... it does not work very well. Learning needs both a PUSH and a PULL. The teaching is mostly about push(ing knowledge into brains), but where is the pull (reasons other than abstract "you need to know")? Brain have their own ways of detecting actual need, and that comes from having to solve actual problems, not from being told "this is important". And learning millions of facts when you don't need them but know you can always learn them/look them up quickly at any time when you do actually need them is soooo demotivating.
- chatmasta 9y agoYeah, totally with you on that. I knew lots of pre-Med majors in college and I could never wrap my head around how someone could enjoy such a masochistic form of learning. But the common thread of successful pre-Med majors is that they get straight A’s and are very successful memorizing everything. Medicine is basically all rote memorization, from pre-Med to the MCAT. It makes sense to select for doctors who are good at it, because they need to have a quickly queryable, but wide breadth of knowledge in their head at all times. Personally I’m happy to know that my doctor is able to memorize and collate so much information. But I do worry that the way he learns may also restrict his creativity and problem solving. Perhaps as AI moves into medicine, doctors won’t need to rely so much on their own memorization, and can focus their efforts on problem solving.
- sykh 9y agoI think you underestimate the role of problem solving skill in medicine. It’s not all rote memorization. A good doctor is good at problem solving and has to have lots of information ready for instant recall.
- agumonkey 9y agoI think medicine, being both a very old, and having a very complex subject, is guilty of a lack of abstraction. I tend to joke that if a doctor discovered a keyboard he would name it a negra quadrodepressus-hectomatrix. Accurate.. and semantically useless. That's how you name things when you have no clue about it's function. And medicine likes its superbly tough anatomical projection/cut of internals. Honestly I find it's a miracle how doctors can look at organs in every angle and still find their way (same for radiologists). Coming from CS with a taste for multistage compilation and the likes, I find no beauty in anatomy.. I need a little more principles and less description.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ItsMe000001 9y agoEDIT/FOLLOW-UP (my edit right just disappeared a minute ago): Here is a link to example patient cases, which may help to see what kind of knowledge is useful. I was not trying to say it is all useless, when I had to solve sample cases e.g. in Medical Neuroscience (Coursera, huge course, great teacher) it sure helps to know the major pathways, and it would take too much time to have to look them up when the patient is in front of you. http://sciencecases.lib.buffalo.edu/cs/collection/results.asp?subject_headings=physiology http://sciencecases.lib.buffalo.edu/cs/collection/results.as...
- sykh 9y agoFeynman was wrong on his view. The same thing could have been said of him and physicists. Oh, you spent your time memorizing formulas when it could be looked up in 15 minutes. This is a nonsensical point of view for two reasons. People in areas of their expertise tend to know a lot in that area off the top of their head because they have encountered this stuff so much that it has become memorized. That memorized knowledge comes from experience not a memorization exercise. It’s also nonsensical because if you didn’t have a core set of knowledge memorized in your area of expertise and instead relied on spending 15 minutes looking up each fact necessary to understand a given situation you’d end up wasting your whole day just trying to understand the meaning of the problem.
- sametmax 9y agoIt's true for formulas, but not for muscle names. You need to know what muscles do and their context, but names are just useful for communication, not analysis.
- moccachino 9y agoAlso true of street names, you just need to know physically where your town's various businesses are and where your people live. But still you kind of have to know most of the street names off the top of your head to function properly. Besides, I think most muscle names are literally just derived from their position on the body and their movement range, so their name and their function are closely linked.
- sametmax 9y ago> But still you kind of have to know most of the street names off the top of your head to function properly. I know 10 street names in my city. The rest, I look up. Well, I used to, now I use the GPS. Note that I do think you are more efficient if you know the street names and where they are. But I also do think the time and energy requires to learn 100 street names and position in my city can be better used for something else.
- skate22 9y agoI forget the exact context, but I remember my elementry school math teacher telling us "you wont have a calculator with you at all times" when memorizing the times tables. While she may have been dead wrong on that one, i'm definitely glad I don't have to rely on looking up / deriving the basics for every domain.
- epistasis 9y agoI thought that was entertaining before I learned biology, but after knowing more it's far less entertaining. They didn't know a map of the cat, they knew a map of mammals. Evolution is really cool that way. Also perhaps it was easy to catch up because it wasn't that much knowledge.
- xevb3k 9y agoHaving recently learnt that Feynman seems to have treated women quite badly [1]. I feel slightly uncomfortable about this article, it feels more like hero worship than anything else. Feynman no doubt did some interesting work in Physics. But the work discussed here doesn’t appear to be particularly distinguished. It does not follow that someone did interesting work on X therefore everything they did must be valuable and interesting. I suppose what I’m trying to say is that individuals are a complex mixture of good and bad. And that there’s a danger that an individual who has done interesting work in one area is seen as a universal genius, and an ideal to be emulated. This unfortunately is not the case. [1] https://restructure.wordpress.com/2009/08/07/sexist-feynman-called-a-woman-worse-than-a-whore/ https://restructure.wordpress.com/2009/08/07/sexist-feynman-... for example...
- jonnybgood 9y agoIndividuals are not a complex mixture of good and bad. Almost nobody commits what might be considered a bad action just for the sake of being a bad person. We should not be so readily to apply black and white moral judgments on others.
- xevb3k 9y agoGood and Bad are loosely defined terms. I guess in this case it might be better to say “currrently socially unacceptable behavior which is considered selfish and harmful to others”. It seems self apparent that calling a woman a whore for not having sex in exchange for a sandwich is socially unacceptable and harmful behavior. But I would guess it’s probably possible to find data to support this.
- icebraining 9y agoWhy do you feel this article is hero worship?
- xevb3k 9y agoWould this article be of general interest if it wasn’t about Feynman? (I don’t believe so) The work Feynman did in Biology that’s discussed here doesn’t seem to be particularly ground breaking, or interesting. It feels like it’s only being treated as such because Feynman did interesting work in other areas and is somewhat idolized for this.
- rumcajz 9y agoEven Alan Turing have done some biology-related work: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Chemical_Basis_of_Morphogenesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Chemical_Basis_of_Morphoge...
- Ultimatt 9y agoYeah which is waaaay more significant both in the field of chemistry and biology. The work Turing was doing at that time was seriously advanced thinking, and really on the right track for how things like transcriptional regulation works in embryogenesis. If he had lived longer its really depressing to imagine what he might have contributed in biology, and how much faster we would have got to where we are in molecular biology. Unlike this write up on Feynman, Turing genuinely provided a hypothesis with some insight and rigour that turned out to be important. It was first found to be a real thing in the world in chemistry with the discovery of the Belousov–Zhabotinsky reaction, which then directly tied the maths to an actual reactive process. The way biology works is a bit more digital and discrete, but the general idea and concept is similar. Turing couldn't have anticipated that his ideas on computation were probably even closer to biology than his differential rate equation models. If he had lived to see the evidence of the tie ins between his works, I think he would have dropped some seriously epic stuff we cant even imagine right now for dealing mathematically with molecular biology at various scales.
- mncharity 9y agoOT, but if you like quantitative biology, there's http://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/ http://bionumbers.hms.harvard.edu/ . The book draft "Cell Biology by the Numbers" there is also fun.