10 ms·
Google's Plan to Make Tech Less Addictive
- reificator 9y ago> Big Pharma's Plan to Make Prescription Drugs Less Addictive > Local Heroin Dealers' Plan to Make Heroin Less Addictive > Coca Cola's Plan to Make Soda Less Addictive LGTM.
- jonex 9y agoOn point 1: That's often one of the big selling points of new (and therefore patented and more expensive) medications. It is much easier to convince doctors to prescribe medications that doesn't risk causing addiction, which in turn means that profits can go up. If the trend is towards people being more cautious of the addictive properties of tech, being able to offer a less addictive alternative could be a selling point in the future.
- Qwertie 9y agoMost of googles products are not based on addiction. You use google search because you have to find something. You don't spend hours randomly browsing search results. Youtube will take a hit from this but the rest of google is not an addiction business.
- reificator 9y agoMost of Google's revenue is based on addiction. You see more ads the longer you use the internet.
- collyw 9y agoI spend a large amount of time on the internet, but I use duck duck go and have ad blockers turned on. When I turn off add blockers it makes me want to spend less time on the internet.
- Qwertie 9y agoGoogle search is very needs based. You need to search things pretty much every day, You will use their service regularly simply because it's so useful for getting things done. You don't need to check facebook every 5 minutes and make regular posts or comments.
- teknopaul 9y agoSometimes you Google cos you carnt be arsed to think about it. Sometimes you google something and get a full page of paid for clickable links and you click one of them instead of scrolling to the "organic search". Sometimes you dont pay enough attention to what are real search results and what are adverts. A statistically significant sometimes. Is instant gratification at the cost of long term gain adiction? Not sure. Its pretty close. Dont put your phone face down, put it away.
- dschuetz 9y agoIt's clearly a contradiction. Companies like Google thrived on addictive behavior of users online. Now that Google basically is the Internet for consumers they want to crack down on online and tech addiction? Really? What I've read in the article means to me that Google will toss away the responsibility to users by making them aware of their usage patterns. "We told them they need a break from consuming our apps, but they won't listen! ¯\_(ツ)_/¯" Well, good luck with that, I guess? Consumers will buy anything, even that joke about "making consumer tech less consume-ry".
- psibi 9y agoSo what exactly is the solution you want? Do you want google to block the service after a threshold period of time.
- mseebach 9y agoIt's only a contradiction if you think short term. Long term, it's clearly in Google's interest to engender sustainable consumption. People who are comfortable with the role their smartphones play in their lives are much more valuable consumers than addicts who are apprehensive over it. They are also much less likely to seek radical action which may damage Google in hard to predict ways.
- teddyh 9y agoIt has not, historically, been in the nature of companies to think or act in the long term. People inside companies have incentives to bring short term profits, while long term profits benefits only the company as a whole, not any individual internal actor who may be positioned to make them happen. Therefore, they don’t happen, and large organizations basically always act only in the short term.
- mseebach 9y agoYeah, that's common knowledge but like most such knowledge it may contain a nugget of truth (yes, there are certain structures that reward shorttermism), it just doesn't stand up to scrutiny as a general framework. In studying practically all companies that has become successful at scale and sustained both success and scale over a period of time, you can find plenty of evidence of long term thinking. Google in particular has shown itself to be perfectly capable of setting and following a long term strategy.
- ghostcluster 9y agoI am inherently suspicious of these types of nanny-tech initiatives. Nintendo did something similar recently in many of their games — warning you that you've been playing for X amount of time, mayba take a break? — and it came off very grating and presumptive, to the point that there were many popular memes created to make fun of it. It's hard to do these types of warnings with a naive implementation because the system doesn't know the context in hich you are using the progress, it can only guess, and when it guesses wrong, it leaves a bad impression. Maybe Google can do a better job with its execution, and maybe making it 'opt-in' will solve that disconnect. I guess we'll find out.
- thankthunk 9y ago> I am inherently suspicious of these types of nanny-tech initiatives. As you should be. It just gives google more excuse to monitor you. They have justification for monitoring you more closely. To "help" you. It's so funny to me how the HN crowd who attacked google,facebook, etc relentlessly for monitoring their users are now demanding google,facebook,etc monitor their users even more to manipulate their behavior. What happened to individual responsibility? And why the focus solely on social media? Should ISPs do the same thing? What about 24/7 stores? What about TV? What about news organizations? Should we only allow news organizations to print on odd numbered days to help news junkies? I know most of the anti-social media rhetoric is just paid propaganda funded by the elites who want control over social media. But I just don't understand the supposedly "independent minded free thinking" liberals on hacker news advocating for nanny-state and nanny-corporations. Is this hacker news or geriatric news. It seems like most posters on here are bitter 50+ year olds who rail against technology. There is something so eerie and strange about the HN crowd lately. Is it that most HN are just old now? I would never expected this type of thinking from developers, let alone "hackers" on "hacker" news.
- bitL 9y ago> warning you that you've been playing for X amount of time, mayba take a break? You've been playing /r/outside for too long. Maybe take a break?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI like all the 3 features mentioned, good they're coming. They really should have been something implementable as an app though. I guess I'll get to test them in 2 or 3 years. (Yeah, this is annoying - Android versions come out really fast, but their support in most phones lags couple of years, even if you just throw away your current one and go buy a flagship.)
- sharcerer 9y agoBuy an Android One phone. I think some pretty good ones will come within the next 10 months with Android P built in, just like thry had Android O built in. The fragmentation problem is now being solved. Its effects will be visible by 4th quarter of 2020.
- anpago 9y agoWith Project Treble that may change who knows?
- siempohn 9y agoCheck out http://www.getsiempo.com http://www.getsiempo.com - we built a launcher that incorporates this thinking throughout the UI. We'd love feedback on the beta!
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThanks! I will play with this. Based on the website and the PlayStore video, I already love two of your ideas: unbranded icons and batching notifications. Not sure if the former might have much productivity or health impact, but it sure as hell makes the interface looks nicer. EDIT: I saw a comment on PlayStore about opt-out telemetry in your product. Could you elaborate on exactly what kind of data you're sending? Or do I have to packet-trace it myself?
- siempohn 9y agoAwesome! Most of what we collect is aggregated & anonymous. Our privacy policy explains the categories of information that we collect and how we use it. Within each category, we collect too many data points to create an itemized list. For example, for users who haven’t opted-out, we collect aggregated & anonymous event logs for every tap on every screen within the Siempo launcher. However, we could offer to answer any specific questions. Anyone is welcome to do there own packet trace, but that won’t help them understand what is anonymous and what isn’t.
- baxtr 9y agoRegardless of how serious google is about this (their main customers are advertisers not android users), I don’t find the measures convincing - shush: if you place your phone on the table you’ll pick it up from time to time anyways, it won’t be out of sight - colors: I’ve turned my smartphone screen B&W, I haven’t noticed a big difference yet, but maybe there is some research out there - monitoring: I installed a monitor app a while back. While I was observing my usage in the beginning regularly, today, I just don’t care about the numbers anymore I highly doubt that these measures will be effective
- cromwellian 9y agoThey don't have to be effective on you, if they are effective on even a small percent, it might be worth it. We hear this every time there's a new public safety campaign: Drunk driving, seat belts, texting and driving, safe sex, stop smoking, gun safety, etc Every single time, the cry is "but but, this won't solve all the problems, it won't work on everyone." But we have reduced drunk driving deaths, we have reduced highway deaths with mandatory seat belts and airbags, we have lowered the spread of STDs. Sure, you can give people a label listing calories and tell them to eat healthy and many won't. But an increasing percentage of people are becoming more aware, and awareness is really the first step. There's way too much cynicism, and way too much, I dunno, either alpha-male macho behavior that chafes at being told to eat your Brussels Sprouts, but being nudged by your phone to stop using it once in a while isn't a bad idea. Something has to break people out of their skinner box once in a while, besides hunger or bankruptcy.
- Flenser 9y agoThis is a good point, and the people who this will help most are probably driving a lot of notifications to their friends, so this will help their friends too.
- 0xBA5ED 9y agoThe first two features are nice, but the cynical side of me thinks this is all about the third feature. They will simultaneously appear concerned and helpful, easing the growing negative sentiment against them while introducing even more pervasive tracking.
- svckr 9y agoI'm surprised your's is the only comment even mentioning tracking…
- WildGreenLeave 9y agoThis was my first thought too. Don't get me wrong, I truly think Google wants to be the good guy here if possible. But if they can combine that with even more tracking (= more money) they won't hesitate for a second.
- gnicholas 9y agoI’m not on Android so I’m not familiar with the level of tracking that currently exists, but can’t they track this usage data already, even if they’re not showing users the results right now? My understanding from talking with folks at Apple and Microsoft is that they track time spent in various apps/applications so they know what is popular with users. Is Android different?
- scarface74 9y agoYes. I was shocked when I logged into my dad's Google account that Google recorded every app that he opened and closed and the times.
- amelius 9y agoHow about an option where a parent controls during what times the phone has a data connection?
- visarga 9y agoI tried that and my kid hacked the phone (and PC). So now I just take the keyboard in the evening and return it the next day. I think Google and Apple have an opposing interest to parents.
- eutectic 9y agoCorporation's are made of people and people don't only have the direct interests of the company in mind. I don't understand the commenters responding negativepy to these proposals; by all means be circumspect, but don't criticize a company for making a positive change just because you think it doesn't go far enough.
- ghostcluster 9y agoI responded with apprehension and gave an example of a similar initiative that Nintendo has already shipped [0], which has been widely mocked, and I explained why these sorts of nagging notifications are a tricky balancing act (the product doesn't know the context of your use, but can only guess, and it is grating when it gets it wrong). [0] https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/997614-nintendo-3ds/74785546 https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/997614-nintendo-3ds/747... https://www.neogaf.com/threads/does-nintendos-oh-youve-been-playing-a-while-why-not-take-a-break-annoy-you.997577/page-5 https://www.neogaf.com/threads/does-nintendos-oh-youve-been-...
- Qwertie 9y agoIt wasn't widely mocked. I have met numerous people who played Nintendo games with this warning and seeing some neckbeards on the threads you linked I had never seen anyone complain about it. Most people just take a break or don't play for extended times to even see the warning.
- ghostcluster 9y agoOnly 'neckbeards' had a problem with it? That's simply not true, and the links I provided are full of people explaining why Nintendo's execution was flawed.
- dschuetz 9y agoSo, you clearly don't understand the hypocrisy behind Google's efforts? How naive can you possibly be? People at Google are having a job which is essentially having only the interests of the company in mind! No-no-no, do not try to spin it like that! Corporations are made of jobs. People have obligations working those jobs. Sure, they are people, but only in the sense that they have human rights as well. What Google is trying to do is not "positive change", it is an effort to make the user responsible for their addictive behavior instead of being responsible selling addictive tech themselves.
- sloxy 9y agoHaving better default notifications on Android would be a start. Everything off(bar calls & messages) unless turned on by user. every app now wants to notify you about everything.. so every phone i get, i need to go in and turn off notifications for everything bar calls & text messages. Pity they don't sync your preferences when you get a new phone.
- siempohn 9y agoTry the Siempo launcher - only product that lets you batch notifications.
- agumonkey 9y agoInteresting to watch tech trying to negative feedback itself :)
- mcintyre1994 9y agoMy cynical read of this is that it's an attack on Facebook. Google has a giant attention platform in YouTube, but Facebook and Instagram are attention platforms. I think YouTube will decline a bit as a result of this, but the rest of Google - and the data collection of Android are untouched. If people become less addicted to their phones, they're still going to have their phone when they go to restaurants and take photos of things on their phones, they're just not going to post about it on Facebook or Instagram or Snapchat or Twitter. Google will still know everything they do now, they'll still be the default photos experience and search experience and maps experience for Android, you'll just spend less time in attention apps like YouTube and Facebook. The real genius is that it fits Apple's brand really well, way better than Google's. If they can make this a serious digital wellness campaign, I could easily see Apple joining in. It won't affect their bottom line and it'll make them look good. And with that, both mobile platforms and ~all of Facebook's user base get nudges to become less addicted to and pay less attention to Facebook.
- obelix_ 9y agoThere was already a campaign - humanetech.com started by no suprise a former Googler a while back. Through internal studies, they already knew quite a few years ago that Google engineers where as likely as to get addicted and waste time on cat videos, the kardashians and whatever else as much as the people the platforms end up hooking. Those results produced some internal 'what about my kids' outrage. What they then discovered is deaddicting ppl is much more complicated and takes a whole lot longer than getting them to turn into screen touching addicts. It was so complicated not to mention the opposite of what generated rev that it got quietly shelved and ppl left No big diff between Google and Big Tobacco in this regard. What you are seeing today is them dusting off the cobwebs on that project as the unintended social and psychological consequences are finally taking a serious unignorable toll. I don't see Google or Facebook contributing to the solution. They will play the same game Exxon Shell Philip Morris et al play. And that game remains empire defense. It's up to you to keep your kids safe.
- aylmao 9y agoExactly. The PR game is tough, so they have to make moves like these, but it gleams unauthentic when you consider there's teams at Google dedicated to increasing watch-time on Youtube, for example. If they were really focusing on digital well-being this wouldn’t be a notification; they would just stop auto-playing the next video. They would hide the "related videos" list after your time is up, etc. They don’t have to be drastic; there’s "small" changes that aren’t far-fetched that they could make if this really was a "focus" for them. "Reminding" you you’re bingeing while you’re bingeing is the kind of stuff a team comes up with when they know doing something to keep people from bingeing is the right thing to do, but they also don’t want to have those crucial-yet-awkard meetings with the Growth team downstairs or argue with the Playback Time team in the next building.
- ddtaylor 9y agoI have a similar feeling about this to how Comcast/Xfinity and Disney promote their services to help reduce screen time for kids. It's hogwash, since they are actively trying everything (including AI) to maximize screen time / watch time and any other metric. Their efforts seem token.
- maelito 9y agoWhat about a warning telling us to look away from the phone every 20 minutes of intense use (eyes staring at the screen continuously) ?
- bitL 9y agoThat would be so awesome when you are reading some scientific paper for university and have to focus! "Hey, you are reading too much, get off! Phone locked for the next 5 minutes!"
- Toine 9y agoGoold old "create the problem and the solution"
- speedplane 9y agoNot quite, I think the more accurate rephrasing would be maximize profits, maximize profits, maximize profits. That plus a lot of other employee and customer stuff you that wan to keep their jobs. It's good tech companies are pushing for open access.
- blklivesmatter 9y agoYes, by stealing all users privacydata and selling it to highest bidder is very good start.
- blklivesmatter 9y agoThe main goal is to steal your privacy data with more hidden ways. Best way is that it become just way of life. Who would not want to embed google under they skin ?
- mark_l_watson 9y agoGoogle is not the only company that is trying to optimize both profits and user experience/benefits, that is a priority where I work also. I have been trying to live in Apple’s walled garden because they are more of a privacy company. But, I periodically turn Google Assistant, Google Maps, and Gmail on - largely turning my iPhone temporarily into a Google device as far as tracking goes. I do this when travelling or when I need the better ‘AI’ experience that Google provides. Google Assistant really is very useful, and sometimes turning over my life event data is worth it.
- teknopaul 9y agoI'd have to dig it out, but I remember reading an article that showed that just having phones on the table seriously interfered with ones ability to follow a conversation. I insist on removing phones from sight when eating since. I wonder if the people that implemented this face down feature know that?
- kunthar 9y agopersonally waiting for librem5 phones. currently using miui 9 with mi6 which is giving advanced control to user preventing from data sucking corps.
- OnlyRepliesToBS 9y agoSuddenly, concern.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoI do not agree with any of this. It is a personal choice. I am old and spent much of my day behind a screen my entire life. Do not need anyone to tell me to take a step away. Google really just needs to do their own thing and stop listening to all the chatter about this and that.
- Ensorceled 9y agoThis is exactly like moderate drinker complaining about AA programs, R.I.D.E. stops[1] and Smart Serve[2]. It's not about you. Stop humble bragging about your lack of an addictive personality and simply move on. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reduce_Impaired_Driving_Everywhere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reduce_Impaired_Driving_Everyw... [2] https://www.smartserve.ca/ https://www.smartserve.ca/
- Froyoh 9y ago"Less addictive" = more dependent on Google.
- Qwertie 9y agoHow so?
- Omnus 9y ago"We know our smartphones are making us unhappy." [link to an article describing a study that put people in a contrived, artificially distracting situation and then pointed out that they enjoyed their time less] Is that the best evidence you have? Because it's crap.
- bitL 9y agoThey already did that by introducing Material Design. Its blandness, huge whitespaces, inability to recognize clickable objects are so off-putting that I ran away from Android already and interact with it only when I have to and with variable doses of cognitive pain. Thanks Google for preventing me from becoming a smartphone addict by design!
- jadedhacker 9y agoI am feeling cynical because none of the announcements mentioned notifications or random reward content. Nor am I familiar with research that shows grayscale reduces addictiveness. I like the put down gesture silencing phones, but there's two things wrong with it. 1) it encourages you to leave the phone easily accessible instead of turning it off 2) its exactly the kind of corporate move to give just enough control to the individual to make it seem like Google's business model is that person's own moral failings.
- KirinDave 9y agoWell, look I don't have data at google scale but my mobile scale info suggests people do not turn their phones off and they won't. You might say, "You should" and I'll say, "And if my family needs to get ahold of me for some emergency? Should I just ignore them calling about some emergency with my three year old daughter for dubious performative gestures?" As for 2, once can imagine a world where Google doesn't want to have such revenue concentration in ads. Destroying the industry as they leave it is not a bad idea, if it gets them where they need to be. But of course, I'm skeptical.
- gkop 9y agoYour response advances parent commenter’s point. Addicted people come up with excuses why they can’t stop. If you accept that you’re addicted and decide to end it, you will default to a 90s technology lifestyle and allow technology into your life exactly when you want it. Google’s business would be tremendously damaged if people actually broke the addiction, so they are making superficial product changes that keep us high-functioning addicts.
- KirinDave 9y ago> If you accept that you’re addicted and decide to end it, you will default to a 90s technology lifestyle and allow technology into your life exactly when you want it. This axiomatically assumes it's better or that a pejorative notion of "addiction" is bad. You raising this isn't some kind of brilliant metapoint, it's circular. "You disagree with them and therefore that proves the point!" Hrmm. I think there are pros and cons to pervasive mobile use. For example: it's realistic for me to run an entirely remote software team. Everyone gets more time with their families, but we can all adequately respond when problems exist. Because of my ability to respond, I spend more time with my daughter than my family ever did, and even when I'm away I can be engaged with her in a way that she recognizes and appreciates. Again, no one else my family had this option in your pastoral 90s. I never saw my family; they were chained to work. And in the 90s, my requirements for technology to support myself sequestered me from society. I can realistically do my job, take a lunch break and meet friends, and simply resume work wherever that ends. I could not do that before. I see mobile sturation as freedom from being cloistered by my career and interests. So maybe, just maybe, there are arguments and experiences to consider beyond a feral distaste for google?
- gant 9y agoIf Google really wanted to help here, why don't they just, you know, make every part of YouTube less optimised for maximum view time. Remove autoplay, turn down the recommendations. Nah, we're gonna throw some optional, possibly ineffective shit into our mobile OS instead so we can say we did something.
- yellow_postit 9y agoThose features you listed seem like quite useful ones for day to day usage. Many things won’t have a bright line “this makes the product useful” vs. “this makes the product addictive” feature classification.
- paulddraper 9y ago> Many things won’t have a bright line “ Agreed. Though how often have you found autoplay by default makes YouTube useful?
- remir 9y agoFor multi-parts videos?
- richev 9y agoSo, not very often.
- paulddraper 9y agoMulti-part videos exist? Just...why? Youtube videos are up to 12 hours. That's reminiscent of the good ol' VCR days.
- remir 9y agoBecause for certain things, it's better to split the content on multiple parts. For example, I was watching a series of videos on Windows Server administration and the content was split into multiple parts and it made sense.
- ThomPete 9y agoWhich just means that someone else will step in. People will move towards where they needs are met. People dont want the addiction but they want what they are addicted to and you can't just put the genie back in the bottle again. I view this is a political / strategic positioning to guard against legislation I don't see it having any real effect or being of any significance just as I don't consider addiction the fault of clever algorithms but rather human nature. Instagram is probably the best example of that. It's the one considered to pushing most people into depression yet it's mostly based around people sharing images not clever algorithms (yes I know they use algorithms on instagram)
- aylmao 9y ago> Which just means that someone else will step in. People will move towards where they needs are met. People dont want the addiction but they want what they are addicted to and you can't just put the genie back in the bottle again. You're not wrong, but this is more nuanced, because it's the moral scapegoat many use when addressing this issue. Someone at Youtube trying to optimize for watch time might be aware that making people watch more videos might not the best thing to do. Yet, if it's not Youtube "someone else will step in"-- people will always watch more videos no? Might as well be us who make money out of it.
- ThomPete 9y agoAren't you repeating what I said or am I missing something?
- otabdeveloper2 9y ago> Medellin's plan to make cocaine less addictive Yeah, nah.
- BenoitP 9y agoA great move for Google would be to treat notifications in Android as Google Now cards; i.e have some machine learn if it is relevant content. Observing if the user has opened the notification, and also offer more feedback options in the long press menu. IMHO, best results would be obtained by letting the apps emit their own feature vectors to be fed to the learner. Google could aggregate these among all their users. App creators would learn to provide features that actually inform of a kind of proposed interaction. Failing to do so would boot them out of this users' "attention market". I receive about 20 useless facebook notification for a relevant one (mainly when someone is talking to me in the fb chat). Facebook could clearly publish the following along to the learner with each notification: * is it a chat message? * is it from someone I have talked to recently? * is it from a cluster of users that talks to each other frequently that I am part of * a representation of the cited cluster above * location of the content (with some additional feature engineering from the phone, who knows if I've been there previously) * it is a photo/video/text? * a doc2vec vector if it is text content * an image embedding if it is a photo etc. I believe this could reduce the amount of notifications by a solid order of magnitude, while not lowering the usefulness value too much. We would suffer way less hijacking, and reduce our addiction of the mindless novelty-seeking kind.
- gaius 9y agoPlans are meaningless - I will believe it when I see Google explaining to their shareholders that they plan to systematically reduce the value of the company. Maximising time spent online in front of ads is literally their entire business!
- mvaliente2001 9y agoI would swear that they had years doing this. After using gmail or android for five minutes, I want to throw the devices out of the window.
- kazinator 9y agoI already hate every minute of using Android, so they have made strides in that direction already for some time.
- romanovcode 9y agoThis is hilarious. Reminds of what tobacco companies tried to push 20-or-so years ago!
- Ldorigo 9y ago"It will even display what you did inside various apps–and on this front, third- party developers will be able to specify trackable metrics inside their software." Well, that sounds like a totally disinterested move that has nothing to do with Google's strive to track every single thing you do.
- golemotron 9y agoIn other news, McDonald's introduces air-locks between the kitchen and the counter to decrease scent-induced appetite.
- ahmedalsudani 9y agoThis is a good time to reread one of pg’s essays http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
- fallingfrog 9y agoIn other news, Bethesda has recently announced an initiative to make its games less fun..
- hedora 9y agoOddly enough, this was an explicit goal of windows phone 8, and they largely succeeded. It was fantastic.
- ducttape12 9y agoKind of like how soda companies encourage people to exercise. They don't want you to stop buying their product, but cut back just enough to stop people complaining.