3 ms·
That’s not a sustainable way to run an industry though. Who decides what constitutes wildly successful? Who decides how many percent and who gets what share of
by simonh 9y ago
That’s not a sustainable way to run an industry though. Who decides what constitutes wildly successful? Who decides how many percent and who gets what share of it? Whoever went on and did the work to make the project so successful would have had other costs in doing so, they must have budgeted it out, they might even sell on the rights to the project at some point as happened in this case. Is it fair to then hit the new owners with extra costs out of the blue when they already paid for full rights and appear to be fully legally entitled to them?
- Dylan16807 9y ago> That’s not a sustainable way to run an industry though. Sure it is. Just because nitpicking is possible doesn't make the basic idea impossible. For example, of course the new owners would know what they were buying. > Who decides what constitutes wildly successful? Who decides how many percent Just as an example, it could be "more than 4x the expected revenue cited when doing the original negotiations", and 5%. (Or if "wildly successful" is too likely to get cheated, make it unconditional.) > and who gets what share of it? Plenty of ways to do it, just pick one.
- simonh 9y agoHow about everyone writes a contract laying out their rights, and we have default contractual arrangements if they don’t? Aside from some occasional entitled, envious whining it seems to work out ok so far.
- Dylan16807 9y agoProbably okay, as long as the default contract has a little bit of royalties. The article is about someone who used the default contract, but the default at the time sucked. Let's make the default better. The risk of course is that there becomes a boilerplate that strips out such things, and it gets used so much that it becomes the new "default".