3 ms·
> But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of the richest men in
by kbenson 9y ago
> But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of the richest men in America?
Would you be willing to give the lion's share of the money you were paid to code it back if the site flopped?
> We here in SV have evolved a culture and a set of business practices that do a much better job of compensating us fairly.
It'ss not culture, it's market economics.
> But we're very lucky in that people with our talents and skills are still much rarer than business types would like.
Exactly. The rarity is key here.
> There's no reason this guy shouldn't get as fair a shake as we do.
He did. Plenty of programmers do work for hire and contract work, and aren't paid in partial ownership.
If I'm a farmer, and I hire someone to work in my field, do they deserve a share of my crop just because they worked it? Does the amount I paid them, if what was agreed upon, change their rights of ownership beyond the up-front agreed upon terms?
I don't see this being any different just because it's an artistic work. There may be a disagreement on what was actually sold, the image and all future uses of it or the singular representation that was handed over, but I hardly see that as worthy of some greater discussion of work, it's worth, and how people are compensated. There are worthy discussions to be had over that, and how we deal with it as a society, but a contract dispute in a case because nobody bothered to even create a contract, such as this, seems a poor start to me.
- Dylan16807 9y ago>> But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of the richest men in America? > Would you be willing to give the lion's share of the money you were paid to code it back if the site flopped? That's why you'd only get a little bit of the money, rather than half. But it still makes a lot more sense than 0% > If I'm a farmer, and I hire someone to work in my field, do they deserve a share of my crop just because they worked it? Does the amount I paid them, if what was agreed upon, change their rights of ownership beyond the up-front agreed upon terms? If each unit of crop takes one hour of labor, and you sell it for $2000, you're a terrible person if you still pay minimum wage.
- ozim 9y agoOk it is quite normal that people do not understand risks and costs involved in running enterprise. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damocles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Damocles
- Dylan16807 9y agoIs it really such a huge burden to only get 95% of the rewards, as the person taking risks? You pay more in taxes, anyway... (And the other costs and risks in farming are nowhere near 250x the cost of labor, are you joking? Any situation where you're paying minimum wage AND labor costs are less than 1% of revenue is unconscionable, and I can't believe anyone would suggest otherwise. I wasn't intending for anyone to jump up and become a hyper-capitalist strawman, I was using a stupidly huge profit number so that everyone could agree that fair pay shouldn't be unlivably low...)
- wpietri 9y ago> It'ss not culture, it's market economics. As if the two were separate. The idea of market economics itself is a cultural artifact. But this is obviously culture, not some sort of universal law of economics, because Silicon Valley is a unique ecosystem that people keep trying to copy by adopting behaviors, practices, and ideas. Those are all cultural traits. > He did. Plenty of programmers do work for hire and contract work, and aren't paid in partial ownership. Sure. And, back to my initial point, if Zuckerberg, or some other entrepreneur had used that to get his initial product built and then said, "Fuck you, buddy" to the person that helped make him rich, people here would have empathized with him. Some would have called it wrong. Because we are part of a system that believes that the benefits of great success should be shared among those who created it. The principle is the same. It's disappointing to me that people here will apply that to themselves, but suddenly turn to "might makes right" when it's somebody they don't identify with.