3 ms·
Easy thing to say. But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of t
by wpietri 9y ago
Easy thing to say. But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of the richest men in America?
We here in SV have evolved a culture and a set of business practices that do a much better job of compensating us fairly. We make good cash money, and we tend to get a share of the success when things get big. It's not like we as individuals were clever enough to negotiate all of the details; it's a system mostly other people worked out over time.
But we're very lucky in that people with our talents and skills are still much rarer than business types would like. That's not true with artists, and the music industry's default practices, especially then, were generally shitty. There's no reason this guy shouldn't get as fair a shake as we do.
(And before anybody has a personal story of not getting a fair shake: yes, that sucks, which is exactly why you should want to see systemic changes that minimize that happening to others.)
- soperj 9y agoIsn't this exactly what happened with Dos & Microsoft?
- rangibaby 9y agoI’m not going to miss a chance to suggest watching the (excellent) movie “Pirates of Silicon Valley”!
- backpropaganda 9y ago> But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of the richest men in America? So? I agreed to be paid a few thousand bucks for a few hours of work. Why does he owe me anything other than what we agreed on?
- rangibaby 9y agoCounterpoint: the Nike logo was designed by an art student for $35. Phil Knight recognized her work’s role in the success of his company and later paid her a lot of money.
- cableshaft 9y agoWhile that was a very nice thing for her to do, she wasn't obligated to do so. And in that particular case the visual branding plays a very prominent role in selling the shoes anyway, so the artwork matters a lot, lot more. I remember feeling embarrassed for not wearing shoes with that swoosh logo back when I was a kid, the marketing and subsequent judging by other kids was that overwhelming at the time. It carried over into adulthood too, because when I bought my first article of clothing that had the Nike swoosh on it (a t-shirt and basketball shorts, no big deal), there was this crazy sense of relief, like "Finally, I'm no longer the outcast," even though it was more than a decade after I was out of school and hadn't seen 99% of those kids since.
- kbenson 9y ago> But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of the richest men in America? Would you be willing to give the lion's share of the money you were paid to code it back if the site flopped? > We here in SV have evolved a culture and a set of business practices that do a much better job of compensating us fairly. It'ss not culture, it's market economics. > But we're very lucky in that people with our talents and skills are still much rarer than business types would like. Exactly. The rarity is key here. > There's no reason this guy shouldn't get as fair a shake as we do. He did. Plenty of programmers do work for hire and contract work, and aren't paid in partial ownership. If I'm a farmer, and I hire someone to work in my field, do they deserve a share of my crop just because they worked it? Does the amount I paid them, if what was agreed upon, change their rights of ownership beyond the up-front agreed upon terms? I don't see this being any different just because it's an artistic work. There may be a disagreement on what was actually sold, the image and all future uses of it or the singular representation that was handed over, but I hardly see that as worthy of some greater discussion of work, it's worth, and how people are compensated. There are worthy discussions to be had over that, and how we deal with it as a society, but a contract dispute in a case because nobody bothered to even create a contract, such as this, seems a poor start to me.
- Dylan16807 9y ago>> But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of the richest men in America? > Would you be willing to give the lion's share of the money you were paid to code it back if the site flopped? That's why you'd only get a little bit of the money, rather than half. But it still makes a lot more sense than 0% > If I'm a farmer, and I hire someone to work in my field, do they deserve a share of my crop just because they worked it? Does the amount I paid them, if what was agreed upon, change their rights of ownership beyond the up-front agreed upon terms? If each unit of crop takes one hour of labor, and you sell it for $2000, you're a terrible person if you still pay minimum wage.
- ozim 9y ago
- colordrops 9y agoBesides the obvious argument that there is no obligation to compensate beyond what the contract specifies, it's a bit presumptuous to take credit for the success of others because of a painting or some website coding. Jethro Tull's success was due to their music, and not the album cover. Facebook's success was due to Zuckerberg's savvy and not the amazing nature of the code.
- threatofrain 9y agoEven if the artist wasn't presumptuous, what does it matter?
- tvmalsv 9y ago>> He was paid what he had agreed to. > Easy thing to say. But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of the richest men in America? The GP still has it right. Paid for a task. Done. It would be different if he toiled away for 100 hours/week for no pay, with the hope of having a hit. As originally described, he has no more of a claim than the guy that made Zuck a sandwich at the food truck.
- jacquesm 9y agoBad example. Zuckerberg himself was hired to code the first version of HarvardConnection.com.
- chrischen 9y ago> Easy thing to say. But imagine Zuckerberg had hired you to code the first version of his site, paid you a few thousand bucks, and then he went on to be one of the richest men in America? That may haunt me, but I still wouldn't deserve any more than what I got.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]