8 ms·
Save the nuclear power plants that generate 50% of America’s clean electricity
- sebazzz 9y agoThe problem with nuclear power is not the techniques. The problem is the human part. At some point, some director of manager wants to save money, which can often be at the expense of safety. If you look at all indicents in nuclear reactor, one of the causes is often not having the money or the desire to safe some money. Nuclear power is not a toy, and every expense should be made so that it is safe. You can't always prevent evidence, but with something so risky as nuclear power, having an indicent where money is (one of) the causes is just really stupid.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> At some point, some director of manager wants to save money, which can often be at the expense of safety. This is true in any system. The downsides with nuclear don't seem to be as grave as the downsides that come with fossil fuels. (On a kilowatt-hour adjusted basis, at least.) > having an indicent where money is (one of) the causes is just really stupid Money is always a factor. Money represents resources. Finite resources. No problem can be worth infinity because we don't have infinity to play with.
- klondike_ 9y agoIt is impossible for modern nuclear reactors to fail like Chernobyl. In the worst case scenario, the damage would be negligible and the reactor would shut itself down.
- hansthehorse 9y agoIn over 28 years in Nuclear Plant Operations I've never seen, or heard of, an incident that could be attributed to cost cutting. If anything nuke plants could be more profitable if they did cut some costs. Control room operators are, in some ways, over trained after obtaining a licence from the Feds to operate that plant. They then, and forever, spend one week in 6 in 40 hours of training. That could easily be halved after holding a license for 5 years or more. The admin size of each plant has ballooned over the years, in some cases more than tripled. Again, cost cutting is not on the list of nuclear plant troubles.
- zamazingo 9y agoWhen something happens in these plants, it's not like a power line is cut off and so the fridge goes out for a few weeks. You end up with large aread becoming inhabitable for hundreds of years, surrounding land and underground water contaminated, loss of human and natural habitat life from hard to document illnesses, etc. Are you suggesting cutting costs in nuk plants as an efficient population control technique?
- sjwright 9y agoWhen a hydro plant fails, hundreds of thousands of people could die as a direct result. And they have. Where is your outrage?
- codingminds 9y agoThat's bad of course. But after a short time people can live there again. If something like Chernobyl or Fukushima happens the land is lost for decades and has a very huge impact (fallout, radioactive waste, groundwater contamination, etc.). You may argue that these are just two big incidents but with all the old plants with bad condition (e.g. Beznau, Fessenheim, etc.) in mind I'd say we'll see more bigger incidents in the next years. In most discussions the time is ignored. Nuclear power plants already produced waste for many generations which is irresponsible.
- 9y ago
- tehabe 9y agoNuclear power plants are not clean. Far from it. Radioactive waste is still an unsolved problem.
- Lazare 9y agoHere's a solution: You take the nuclear waste, and then you put it in a small pile somewhere geologically inactive, and then you don't touch it. Problem solved. The issues with nuclear are almost entirely related to cost.
- tehabe 9y agoBut where can you find such a place? In Germany people believed to found such a place in an old salt mine, now they have to get the stuff back before the mine is completely flooded with water and will contaminate the area around it. And that wasn't high radioactive waste. You need to store is from 100,000 to a million years and you need to inform people about it. Which isn't easy b/c we couldn't really understand the writings on the Pyramids in Egypt which were build just a few thousand years ago. Nuclear power is also dangerous because you can't easily tell apart if a country use it to generate power or build a bomb.
- TomMarius 9y agoWhat about space? And we're talking about plants in the U.S., I don't think there will be the problem with bombs.
- EvilTerran 9y ago> What about space? Great in principle, but sending nuclear waste hurtling through the upper atmosphere strapped to a tank of rocket fuel seems like a really bad idea in practice. You'd be one mishap away from spreading radioactive dust over a huge area. Some kind of railgun-like launch system big enough to achieve escape velocity could work, I guess - but that technology's not there yet.
- hennsen 9y agoHow is nuclear power „clean“ with all the radioactive waste that needs to go somewhere when burnt down?
- krastanov 9y agoWhen the used fuel rods are properly stored, even the primitive nuclear reactors we use today release quite a bit less radiation than burning coal (not event mentioning CO2 and so on). Even after including all major nuclear accidents, nuclear plants have saved lives compared to coal plants (and they have pretty good track record when compared against even renewable sources). However, storing the fuel rods properly is borderline impossible due to politics, so your questions probably still stands.
- hennsen 9y agoI admit i don’t know much about the coal burning radiation output. And im even further away from knowing the perfect solution to the worlds energy needs. So i have many questions, driven by the wish to live in a intact environment and leaving it to those who come in a good state. Where and how exactly is the radiation release of coal plants happening? I can imagine its maybe a difference if a smaller dose of radiation is put out slowly and spread more (in time and space terms)than if it’s concentrated on one point? Radiaton is anywhere thats clear... but we rarely get strong radiation caused illnesses from just catching cosmic radiation do we? And how exactly are politics preventing proper storage? I definitely don’t wanna promote coal, but where are these numbers proving coal killed and harmed more people than Fukushima and Tchernobyl and the many smaller incidents? Also i often wonder - where could science of reusable energy and reduced consumption be if the billions invested in nuclear research were invested there instead?
- danmaz74 9y ago> And how exactly are politics preventing proper storage? Basically, NIMBY. Even if it's perfectly safe, some people will always worry about "but what if all physicists, seismologists etc. etc. are wrong (or lying)"?
- mlazos 9y agoThis needs to be said, and I’m glad Vox is finally saying it. The nearly 100ish nuclear power plants in the US generate almost 1/5 of the total electricity output. It irks me beyond belief when environmentalists try to close them down just for existing. There have not been any major incidents in the US (apart from Three Mile Island), and if Congress got its shit together and sacrificed a single mountain in Nevada for waste disposal we could finally stop all of the actual damage that the coal/oil industry has inflicted over generations.
- kapauldo 9y agoDon't be so irked. There are tons and tons of nuclear waste being stored on site. Nuclear energy is 90% solved but not 100%. Once the waste solution is solved your point will be much more valid, but don't discount the storage problem. It's a ticking time bomb.
- TheRealPomax 9y agoKeep them, but calling them "clean" is pure grade A bullshit. Sure, they're "cleaner" but they are absolutely not clean, yielding a waste product that stays a danger to every single living thing near it for tens of thousands of years.
- Ygg2 9y agoIt has fewest deaths per TWh, and zero carbon emissions. It's safest the same way, airplane is safest form of transportation.
- TheRealPomax 9y agoPretty sure solar, wind, and hydro have fewer deaths per terawatthour, which also happens to be an absolute nonsense x/y plot to be looking at. I am 100% pro nuclear power, but I'd love to see proper new approaches that don't lead to barrels of radiating waste that transporters seem to keep fucking losing, or dump in the ocean, or do any number of illegal other things with. I prefer to stay grounded in reality and look at the entire pipeline rather than naively just looking at what happens after the plant's been built, and only looking at the plant's site and not a millimeter beyond its perimeter.
- klondike_ 9y agoPeople seem to overstate the risk of nuclear waste. Surely a few tons of radioactive waste is better than millions of tons of CO2 in the atmosphere? Nuclear could provide a solution to our energy needs NOW instead of having to wait around for solar and grid storage to be reliable on a nationwide scale. Right now radioactive waste is stored in pools on site at the reactor. If the US government would actually fund the Yucca Mountain project [1] the risk would be negligible. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_repository https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_r...
- majewsky 9y agoWhen you have too much CO2, there's a pretty obvious fix for that: plant a ton of trees. When you have nuclear waste, you're stuck with it for at least a few thousand years, probably longer.
- sjwright 9y agoAssuming neither gets "fixed" to your satisfaction—we couldn't physically plant enough trees anyway—I'd rather deal with a few piles of inconvenient material over a planet-wide fucked up atmosphere.
- plankers 9y agoYucca mountain isn't a great solution... more of a stopgap really. Besides, how do you convince the fine citizens of Nevada to go along with having the nation's nuclear waste buried under their water table? We're not talking about Native Americans defending a river here, these are actual Americans we're talking about.
- sjwright 9y agoLow level waste (medical, scientific, etc) is such trivial matter that worrying about the water table is paranoid ignorant bunkum. As for high level "waste" — it should be reprocessed and reused or burned as fuel in breeder reactors. Burying it underground is a criminal waste of productive resources.
- makomk 9y agoThe fundamental problem with nuclear power plants is that, even if you do count them as clean power, they're not an economically viable way of generating it in the modern renewable era. They have the same flexibility and operating cost issues that are killing coal, only more so, and there's no real way around this. Sure, it's possible to operate them in load-following mode somewhat (though US regulations don't allow it), but even French energy giant EDF doesn't think that's going to be enough to cope with a grid with high levels of renewable generation; their proposed solution is to change the rules so solar and wind power has to shut down instead of the nuclear plants. (I think it may only get you to coal-power-plant levels of output modulation at best.) Output modulation also reduces plant lifespan and increases operational complexity; not good for something that's already too expensive to build and operate. Similarly, large-scale storage would substantially increase the price of nuclear power. There just isn't any avoiding the fact that nuclear power is expensive, and the only to make it viable is to put up everyone's power bills substantially, whether it's by increasing the cost of other generation options via taxes and less favourable operating rules for renewables or just outright putting a tax on electricity that's paid straight to nuclear operators.
- klondike_ 9y agoMost reactors in the US are old and require a lot of maintenance. I think that if the US built modern reactors like those in Canada and France nuclear could be more price competitive. Unfortunately most proposals to build new plants are shot down pretty quickly by red tape and NIMBYs
- fulafel 9y agoNew reactors are plagued by huge, hundreds of percent cost and schedule overruns, over originally expensive plans. See the current EPR projects.
- fulafel 9y ago> They have the same flexibility and operating cost issues that are killing coal Do you have any references for this? The common characterization that you hear is just the opposite: nuclear is expensive in upfront investments but cheaper to operate than coal. In the future when the production mix gets more unpredictable, always-on generation should get a profitability boost. A producer who can promise 24/7 production is in a strong position on a market that is largely based on unertain producers trying to sell future uncertain output to producers whose demand is inflexible.
- plankers 9y agoNuclear reactors won't be politically feasible unless either a) we find a country that will sell us the rights to dump our nuclear waste there or b) launching nuclear waste into the sun becomes economically feasible. I just don't think it's possible to convince the lay American that nuclear waste can be stored permanently and safely (I'm not so convinced myself). Not sure about a) but b) probably won't happen until all the reactors running today have been retired.
- naranja 9y agoNo – nuclear is not "clean" energy. It's one of the messiest form of them. And coal is "clean" neither.
- jagermo 9y agoFor me, it boils down to this: do you trust the persons responsible for the security and maintenance to do more than the bare minimum? Do you trust the company execs to not cut corners and try to save a little more by switching to cheaper materials/labor/waste management? Are you sure that the architects and engineers had enough foresight and put in enough wiggle room for changes in the enviroment? How much are you willing to pay with your taxes when something goes wrong?
- kapauldo 9y agoIt's not clean yet. We still don't have a nuclear waste program. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-does-the-us-do-with-nuclear-waste/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/what-does-the-us-...