4 ms·
Of those, only "Seamless Payment" really seems relevant to most people. The rest is just stuff transit nuts like to think about. But being able to pay as a re
by ajross 9y ago
Of those, only "Seamless Payment" really seems relevant to most people. The rest is just stuff transit nuts like to think about. But being able to pay as a regular person without buying a pass or finding change or using a vending machine is big. Just walk on the vehicle unimpeded and pay using nothing but what you carry around with you (e.g. a smartphone).
And it inexplicably misses the single biggest and most obvious criterion: SERVICE FREQUENCY. No one cares about how slick the bus service is if you have to wait 10 minutes for it to show up. Because while 10 minutes might be OK for most people what that really means is that inevitably a vehicle gets skipped or breaks down (this happens a lot more than you think) and you have to wait 20 on a day when you really can't wait 20 minutes for a ride.
If you can't get the buses to show with no more than 10 minute wait at every stop on every day, people won't take them. If you can, they're better than cars. But you have to have the service level first before worrying about glitz like the stuff in the linked article.
- bryanlarsen 9y agoFrom the article: "“If there’s a 12-person little vehicle coming down the street every 5 minutes versus a 40-person vehicle coming every 20 minutes, then you’ve got more capacity in that corridor and and a much better experience for people,” Total game changer.
- sdhgaiojfsa 9y agoThe idea of a trackless train also appeals. If they had a separate right of way and could get integration with the stoplights the analogy could be extended in terms of utility as well.
- Frusteek 9y agoWe had buses like that in my part of the UK in the early 90s. They disappeared many years ago, we just have normal buses now and have for many years. I don't know why they got rid of them. Maybe cutting costs by having fewer drivers?
- ars 9y ago> If there’s a 12-person little vehicle coming down the street every 5 minutes What about a 5 person little vehicle that only comes exactly when people call it? And for even better service it works point to point, which cuts down of fuel and wasted time. And to reduce costs even further maybe drive it yourself instead of paying a driver. Although we need to a cost analysis on this. It could be some people would prefer to pay a driver, and other would drive themself.
- ajross 9y agoBecause there's an external point that having a million "5-person" little vehicles driving around the city containing on average only 1.2 people is a tragedy of the commons. Personal cars simply do not "cuts down of fuel and wasted time", and to argue that is to argue in bad faith. Personal cars are a disaster in the modern megapolis.
- ars 9y agoBut a 12 person car is alright? Where's the sweet spot between 40, 12, and 5?
- ajross 9y agoA vehicle carrying 12 passengers literally increases the bandwidth of the road it travels on by an order of magnitude. Yeah, that sounds acceptable to me. If you have alternative numbers I'd be happy to evaluate them. But "drive my own car" is just not going to work in this realm.
- ars 9y agoIt's not that simple. First of all they are never full. Second the trips are longer, since they have to drive fixed routes, so people are in the vehicle for longer - sometimes MUCH longer, so more road capacity is taken up. They way they stop and start constantly also reduces road bandwidth. To me bus service is about money and parking - not being able to afford a car if you only rarely drive, and a place to put the car. I am not convinced buses help with congestion. (Trains/subway/T are different because they have a whole new road built just for them.)
- gipp 9y ago> By eliminating the costly overhead of the driver, AV shuttles could provide more frequent suburban service at a lower expense, making transit a more viable option for communities that are now poorly served by buses. “If there’s a 12-person little vehicle coming down the street every 5 minutes versus a 40-person vehicle coming every 20 minutes, then you’ve got more capacity in that corridor and and a much better experience for people,” said Colin Murphy, director of research and consulting for the Shared Use Mobility Center. “In a lot of cities that could really make a huge difference.” ?
- wgj 9y agoNot sure what city you're in, but hardly any buses in Seattle even have a 10 minute schedule. In fact, in Seattle you have neighborhoods actively lobbying _against_ transit because transit frequency is legally coupled with rules for housing density.
- electricEmu 9y agoOP is talking about the RapidRide [0] system. I want to add some additional information for those not familiar with Seattle. A RapidRide route brings buses more frequently. It also adds additional infrastructure. It's a noticeably larger level of commitment than a regular route. Density requirements make a lot of sense if a RapidRide route is created. The Roosevelt neighborhood illustrates why this is important. They received a Link Light Rail station in the middle of their urban neighborhood. Home owners subsequently fought to lower height restrictions to 12m [1]. I'm a firm believer if a neighborhood receives well-done public transit then they should have to meet density requirements. [0] https://kingcounty.gov/depts/transportation/metro/travel-options/bus/rapidride.aspx https://kingcounty.gov/depts/transportation/metro/travel-opt... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roosevelt_station_(Sound_Transit) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roosevelt_station_(Sound_Trans...
- electricEmu 9y ago> And it inexplicably misses the single biggest and most obvious criterion: SERVICE FREQUENCY. Seattle seems to agree. The Rapid Ride buses attempt to keep headways between buses very short. I don't own a car and travel via public transit frequently. I find that an accurate OneBusAway/Transit estimate is much more useful than headways. I absolutely agree that some kind of predictability is extremely important.
- nopinsight 9y agoAutonomous driving can increase service frequency by reducing operating costs. The cost of bus driver per passenger could be quite high off peak hours and in sparse areas.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI'd venture to say it's both. That is, lower the wait for the bus showing up, and then lower the wait to get onto the bus. To that I'll add: Protection from the elements. If train stops were like bus stops, no one would find that acceptable. On that note, one can't help but wonder if the neglect of buses isn't a passive form of racism / class-ism. Anecdotally, one of the patterns I've noticed is the further down the economic ladder you move, the longer you wait for services. Given that time is money, this works against those who likely need the time most.
- xbmcuser 9y agoWell 1000 Buses going electric can displace 430 barrels of diesel use a day. That alone is a big enough reason for the world buses to go electric as that would mean removing a million barrels of smog producing diesel from the world's streets a day.