27 ms·
From the article: “All of the official samples passed the test and were within the legal limits of glyphosate residue. But those off-the-record, unofficial sam
by TaylorAlexander 9y ago
From the article:
“All of the official samples passed the test and were within the legal limits of glyphosate residue. But those off-the-record, unofficial samples, though done with the same equipment and tested by the same chemists, showed glyphosate.
That’s right. The chemists found glyphosate residue on just about everything: crackers, granola, cornmeal, honey, oatmeal, baby food, and even corn. Their surreptitious corn test—one of the four items the FDA is actually testing—found glyphosate significantly over the legal limit set by the EPA. The chemists emailed their bosses to ask what to do. The FDA’s response (which was also captured in the FOIA documents): That corn was not an “official sample” and will thus be ignored.”
I remember watching a lecture from Vandana Shiva who claimed that glyphosate was harmful and making it in to our food. She cited some European studies that found glyphosate in a wide variety of products. She claimed that there were shady things going on in the US government that seemed to obscure these facts. At the time, I saw people writing her off as a nut, or claiming that her masters degree in physics and PhD in philosophy meant that she didn’t have the expertise to evaluate the biological effects of glyphosate.
And yet, I feel as though this article, if the claims are verified, does seem to back up her claims that glyphosate is more prevalent than our government would like to admit, and that there could really be official cover ups going on.
I’d really like to know what’s in our food.
- dfxm12 9y agoI remember watching a lecture from Vandana Shiva who claimed that glyphosate was harmful and making it in to our food. She cited some European studies that found glyphosate in a wide variety of products. She claimed that there were shady things going on in the US government that seemed to obscure these facts. While this might prove her true that the US government is trying to hide the glyphosate levels in food, does it prove her claim true that it is harmful? It seems like the jury is out: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glyphosate#Humans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glyphosate#Humans
- random4369 9y agoEvery time the jury is out on a topic where one side has a vested interest and a billion dollar budget to protect it, you can be reasonably sure what the outcome will be. See: pesticides and bees, fossil fuels and climate change, food packaging plastics and cancer, pain treatment meds and addiction. The answer in all those cases is the harmful effects eventually became known, but the jury was out long enough for the vested interests to make a ton of profit and cause a ton of damage which they'll never pay for repairing. All made possible with a series of comparatively small investments to buy scientific research to keep the jury out. The Wikipedia section that the parent post links to straight up says that the only research that found no links was sponsored by Monsanto. Edit: to be really clear, 'jury being out' refers to scientific consensus. We are not talking about issues where public opinion is uncertain despite scientific consensus, such as vaccines+autism. We are talking about issues where scientific evaluation of some phenomenon is actively prolonged or hindered by vested interests to delay regulatory action.
- asfasgasg 9y agoCounterexamples: asbestos, tobacco, alcohol, fossil fuels, climate change. (On the latter two, the studies mostly have the correct outcome. What is difficult is convincing half of the American population that that matters.)
- briandear 9y agoWho has supported the asbestos industry? Has there ever been a company that actually promotes asbestos?
- dvogel 9y agoYes, in fact asbestos is still mined and marketed today: https://youtu.be/cy3piCUPIkc https://youtu.be/cy3piCUPIkc
- userbinator 9y agoOnly white asbestos (also known as Chrysotile) --- and the great number of people who have been exposed to large amounts of it and lived long healthy lives certainly makes one wonder; AFAIK it's only the other types, particularly blue asbestos, which are unanimously carcinogenic and the industry stopped using them a long time ago, but the effects from that (and contamination of white asbestos with the other types) have continued and led the majority of fears. This article is worth reading: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3581056/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3581056/
- dboreham 9y agoIn the case of Mesothelioma I believe there's a fair amount of evidence that you need both : 1) Asbestos exposure and 2) to be a smoker. This might explain why some people exposed to asbestos remain healthy. https://www.mesothelioma.com/blog/authors/staff/smoking-asbestos-and-asbestosis-increases-risk-for-lung-cancer.htm https://www.mesothelioma.com/blog/authors/staff/smoking-asbe...
- notadoc 9y ago> It seems like the jury is out Ah yes, the jury is always out. Better do nothing and instead politicize the issue while pretending to debate the "science" for a few more decades.
- shakna 9y ago> the jury is out What we currently have is galf a dozen independent studies suggesting it might be a carcinogen. And one Monsanto backed study saying it has no immediate harm. It is not so easy to dismiss. Both groups of studies can be correct.
- mannykannot 9y agoIf the assumption has been that it is not getting into food, when in fact it has, it is reasonable to ask whether studies have been based on valid models of exposure. Furthermore, the article you link to is almost entirely preoccupied with the cancer risk, which is far from the only danger of environmental toxins. this seems to be a case where the burden of evidence belongs on those calling it harmless.
- goombastic 9y ago>does it prove her claim true that it is harmful? Always reminds me of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovKw6YjqSfM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ovKw6YjqSfM
- geden 9y agoThe recent news is that Monsanto have known for a while that the formulations containing Glyphosate are harmful as a whole, while isolated Glyphosate may not be particularly harmful. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/may/08/weedkiller-tests-monsanto-health-dangers-active-ingredient https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/may/08/weedkiller-t...
- zasz 9y agoI'm no fan of toxic chemicals in our food and I don't trust the government or corporations to do enough to protect it, but it seems fair to me to say that a PhD in philosophy and a master's in physics are not particularly relevant to claiming expertise in evaluating toxicological claims.
- themarkn 9y agoIt's fair to say that, because it's true, but it's not in and of itself a reason to write somebody off as a nut, or assume they have not found any other way to gain expertise on the thing they are talking about. I think OP's point was just that people used her unrelated qualifications as a way to dismiss her without reference to her actual argument.
- zasz 9y agoThat's totally fair, and you interpreted what OP was trying to say better than I did.
- jMyles 9y agoA high school dropout can be a source of expertise if she commits herself to learning the subject material and understanding the context of the claims she is making. When someone with a PhD in philosophy is per se blacklisted regarding other matters of worldly concern, credentialism has gone too far.
- cookiecaper 9y agoYes. In fact, from a slightly different perspective, one can easily argue that this very credentialism is a component of the control apparatus exploited by the "vested interests". To become credentialed in a field, you must spend multiple years repeating the same things over and over, getting programmed to perceive and approach problems in compliance with the field's orthodoxy. There is a small core of people who decide whether you will gain your credential or not. These persons generally have interests besides just "train the best new $OUR_FIELDers out there", if only because that's subjective and will take many years to play out. They're generally looking for funding, projects, publications, appointments, etc. In charge of those people is university administration, and their conflict of interest is so obvious and inherent that it's a waste of time to type it out. So you have this big powerful apparatus that has many little gullets that can be made to respond much more favorably by pouring a little money here, a little prestige there, etc. Many of these "gullets" will balk if this is done openly, but if you add a thin layer of abstraction and ambiguity, very few people will even notice the relationship, let alone care. It really only takes a minimal amount of obfuscation to get people to jump on board with something that has direct personal benefit to offer. As such, the perspective of intelligent outsiders who haven't gone through an elaborate niche-specific brainwashing process should be valued, not dismissed.
- Florin_Andrei 9y ago> I’d really like to know what’s in our food. Why? Don't you trust the free market? /s
- needToSay 9y agoDang, ban this cryptonigger
- parineum 9y agoIt seems like it would be really simple to know what's in your food by simply testing for it right? If you're telling me that X substance is in some good that is freely available then it should be easy to prove it. You can catch the EPA/FDA red handed by simply doing some independent testing. The only reason I trust the EPA/FDA over the PhD you refer to is that the barrier of entry to testing something that I can buy off the shelf seems so low that lack of evidence, in this case, really hurts the accusation. Like if I said bricks float in vegetable oil. That's trivially falsifiable. Am I mistaken about how difficult it should be to test for glyphosate? The health effects of glyphosate are another story, that is certainly much more difficult to prove and is a legitimate topic of discussion, especially considering how many times industry has withheld health issues in the past.
- ItsMe000001 9y ago> Am I mistaken about how difficult it should be to test for glyphosate? Read the article? The "official" samples contained nothing. "Testing" is not just the process of testing the sample in the lab, it takes place in a context. That context matters a lot, as this example shows. Even if your lab process is reliable, you can do a lot to influence the result before you have a sample on the plate of the technician. It's the same as with any measurement, any study: Before doing the actual measurement there is far larger and more important process that remains mostly invisible or ignored (even when it is published). Focus only is on the "numbers", because "numbers don't lie"...
- parineum 9y agoMy point is that anybody who knows how to test for glyphosate can go to the grocery store, buy a box of ritz crackers, an ear of corn and some canned soup and test them. The food I eat is easily testable by an independent lab. If you make an accusation about a product you could easily test because it's freely available I am suspicious why you didn't.
- ataturk 9y agoIt's funny how Hollywood films kind of tell you what is up--the Logan movie basically told us something is up. And Thanos wanted to eliminate half the population.
- aesh2Xa1 9y agoThere certainly are controlling interests that exist in our market and government. Regarding players like Vandana Shiva, though, it's also pretty clear that the pendulum swings in both directions; you're better off reading another critic's opinion. The New Yorker had a big piece on her, by the way. https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/08/25/seeds-of-doubt https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/08/25/seeds-of-doubt