20 ms·
Buses Need Our Love More Than Ever
- evo_9 9y agoNah how about we all work from home 2 or 3 days a week. People will actually do that and it saves not only the city but whole bunch of other things for the employee and the employer.
- cookiecaper 9y agoYes, it'd be really interesting to see cities try to develop that as a partial solution to congestion and pollution. Offering a formal 3/5 days telecommute option for a large enough portion of your workforce should qualify for some type of rebate, subsidy, or credit.
- wool_gather 9y agoInteresting idea, but the law of hidden consequences will surely bite in some form or another. For example, the aggregate of employees' houses is almost certainly less efficient energy-wise than their offices. I feel confident that many neighborhoods' internet service would struggle under the weight of simultaneous videoconferencing from every house.
- munk-a 9y agoPeople remoting might have a detrimental effect on cities. Some business (especially restaurants) make the majority of their money off of regular customers during business hours, these are extremely healthy businesses for a city economy. I don't disagree that we should probably all remote more, but don't think it it all up sides.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jonbarker 9y agoMy favorite line ever from any kids book of all time "The Bus is For Us" https://www.amazon.com/Bus-Us-Michael-Rosen/dp/0763669830 https://www.amazon.com/Bus-Us-Michael-Rosen/dp/0763669830 "The bus is the best, the best is the bus, the bus is the best because the bus is for us!"
- dmitrygr 9y agoI keep hearing a lot of anti-car sentiment on HN, and a lot of claims that cities with good public transit are wonderful. Amsterdam is often cited as an example. So I decided to find out for myself. I went there. It convinced me more than ever that I will always prefer car/uber/lyft to public transit. Wait, hear me out. Yes, buses and bikes were wonderful. But, they do not stop at my door, and they do not stop at where I want to go. Sometimes they stop close, sometimes a few blocks away. Lots of people will argue that this is OK, but it really is not when the weather is a freezing rain. So basically to subscribe to your vision of the future city, I have to subject myself to walking and waiting in freezing rain? No thanks. Car/Uber/Lyft for me. PS: I am not saying let's stop having buses. Just that everyone who claims that everyone should be on buses and we should ban cars from cities is delusional or a masochist. [bring on the downvotes, thanks for proving the point that no rational debate can be had here]
- peterwwillis 9y ago> buses and bikes were wonderful. But, they do not stop at my door, and they do not stop at where I want to go. Welcome to planet earth. It doesn't revolve around you.
- dmitrygr 9y agoNor you. We each get a vote. And mine is for cars.
- peterwwillis 9y agoAlso, what about bicycles does not allow them to go to your door or where you want to go?
- dmitrygr 9y agoBiking in freezing rain isn't wonderful either
- 9y ago
- lifeisstillgood 9y agoThere is a huge problem here - we are designing cities around the manually operated car, focused on the commute to and from work (and lesser extent school) But these are dying trends - but they will be baked into our cities by concrete and tarmac for decades. I travel by coach from outside London (basically they drive round a commuter belt town picking up about 30 people then hop on a motorway. Dozens maybe more of similar coaches run each day). And I work in the City and right now there are, I kid you not, a major 50+ storey building going up on each point of the compass at work. London is adding major office space. But the jobs will become more remote working - and the infrastructure can barely take it - funnelling millions of people from suburban beds to inner city offices is what half the infrastructure of a city is for. When this stops, it will stop suddenly. Remote working is nicer. you spend more time with your kids, you walk, take part in your community, see people. It wins hands down. So when something shifts, and remote working hits that tipping point, what happens? My last position almost everyone did one day a week from home. Turn that into three at home and 2 in meetings and coffee and ... I'm sorry there is a point i am making but it's late and i need to think on it
- barrkel 9y agoBuses are the public transport of last resort for very good reasons. They go through all the busiest areas to maximize passenger numbers, which is what makes them slow. Delays compound; since per-stop timetables are unpredictable due to traffic, buses normally just try to make the best time they can. Which means you wait for the bus, possibly for a long time. So a late bus becomes later, as it takes longer to board the extra passengers, and then the next bus catches up, and you get bunching. You're much better off walking or cycling to a rail option if you have it. Buses in busy cities are barely faster than walking at the worst of times, especially when you add in waiting time. As a result, the bus works best for those people who can't walk or cycle - old people, mothers with buggies - and poor people who have little choice but to sit in a bus for an hour or more as it crosses town. Point to point longer distance, special purpose buses that don't need to follow main routes can work much better. Airport shuttles, work shuttles, that kind of thing.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoYou really should come visit Copenhagen sometime. Our buses work amazingly well :-) The only times it gets a bit busy and bunched up is during rush hour, but I've rarely had to wait more than 10 minutes for the next bus, even in the worst cases.
- rdl 9y agoThe challenge here is riding the bus is inferior in convenience and comfort, fundamentally, vs other options. Unless price (likely by eliminating any subsidies for other methods; today even a $0 bus fare would still not be enough) or other features (bypassing traffic) make up for it, why would a rational person take the bus? There are probably places on the margin where buses are more acceptable right now (in a downtown core area where they replace a long walk, where other methods are inconvenient), but if the goal is wide usage, this has to be addressed. Private bus networks with access limited to certain people (employees of companies or groups of companies, universities, etc) seem to work ok; what generally doesn’t seem to work are public buses. Is the problem density (I doubt Google employees across Bay Area are denser than bus riding public overall within SF) — probably not. A lot of the unpleasantness is other riders. Without the ability to ban certain riders (either via a whitelist or blacklist), bus ridership will remain limited. BART is bad enough, but whenever I’ve taken muni or peninsula bus service (very rarely)it made the case for this. Transit agencies are also highly political — unionized labor, political appointees running it, expensive contracts for everything, inflexible policies — so I doubt they could provide the same service as private bus companies. The solution is probably not public transit, but possibly is multi passenger vehicles. Something like Lyft Line with more passengers, dynamic routing, etc, plus some core routes with scheduled higher capacity service.
- jdavis703 9y ago> Private bus networks with access limited to certain people (employees of companies or groups of companies, universities, etc) seem to work ok; what generally doesn’t seem to work are public buses. This sounds like an argument for restricting transit access to the most privileged members of society. The real reason private buses are successful is because they have a limited amount of stops, it's more like riding a train than a local bus that stops at every block. If anything cities should be investing way more in BRT, as the private sector has proven that high quality buses can work.
- rdl 9y agoThe public “express buses” seem to have most of the same problems. This is possibly due to inflexibility in how/where they are deployed, or riders, or other factors.
- prostoalex 9y ago> such as L.A. and Denver, are watching transit ridership decline across the board, in part because investment in buses has trailed so far behind the commitment to trains That's not completely true for LA (and for the record, train ridership in LA is on decline as well, while the population is growing). Here's the actual reason http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-metro-homeless-20180406-htmlstory.html http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-metro-homeless-2018... "People looking for warm, dry places to sleep have barricaded themselves inside emergency exit stairwells in stations, leaving behind trash and human waste. Elevator doors coated in urine have stuck shut. Mentally ill and high passengers have assaulted bus drivers and other riders." "More than 1 in 5 current passengers has been harassed on the train. In a 2016 survey, 29% of former riders told Metro they stopped taking transit because they felt unsafe." "Sim said she saw a man pull down his pants, squat over the edge of a platform and defecate onto the train tracks at Union Station. She said she has sat in urine on the subway, “hopscotched through peoples’ feces” on sidewalks, and endured verbal and sexual harassment on the train." "In one more serious case, Loew said, LAPD officers used a Taser on a man who was brandishing a knife and threatening passengers." "He kept riding, until he sat down one morning on a seat that was wet and hot with urine. With no change of clothes on hand, he wore the urine-soaked pants to work. Then he started driving to work again."
- sudosteph 9y agoSeattle is in a similar situation. Ridership is growing still, but mostly due to driving and parking being very expensive and inconvenient. We also have a program where major employers (including Amazon) will provide cards for unlimited transit use, but not re-imburse or provide for the full cost of parking. Even so, it's very common for people to get on the bus without paying and make everyone else uncomfortable. I've seen harassers, people vaping and shooting up, obviously unstable people yelling and making a scene. That's not to say anything of the people who just bring an awful odor or take up a whole row with absolute junk. I've never seen feces or urine, but definitely seen vomit. There's no enforcement against this kind of thing most of the time, and riders are too afraid to speak up on their own. If I'm given the choice between a 30 minute walk and a 10 minute bus ride, I'll almost always walk if it's not just pouring rain. Luckily Seattle sidewalks and pedestrian friendliness in general is pretty great. It's a drastically different situation from my hometown, Charlotte NC, where the buses don't get much use and it really is due to service stinking and general perception of the bus being for poor people only. Also cars are fairly cheap and ubiquitous. I would frequently be the only white person on a crowded bus, but even though I sometimes got weird looks, I was never harassed or made to feel in danger like I've experienced in Seattle. It was mostly just working class folks or people and some people with DUIs going to work, city services, or community college (which was my reason for taking it, I just hated driving though). An improvement in service and getting some nicer buses probably would have helped, but now that light rail is a thing (just barely though), I do think they are putting all their resources there instead.
- zucked 9y agoBuses have two main problems as I see it. Number one is an image problem - they aren't sexy. Here in the States, we are obsessed with the 'European' way of life. Most major European cities have some form of streetcar system or underground metro, if not both. To us, those are sexy. Nevermind that those cities have buses, too. The bus _could_ be more sexy. BRT with dedicated lanes, priority signaling, clean & modern interiors, at-grade egress, and most importantly, consistent and reliable service. Those changes would go a long ways towards making the bus 'cool' enough to ride. The other is that because buses are inherently at least a little inconvenient, there has to be an incentive to use them. For most people, the main driver is financial. Ten years ago when the economy was shaky, I, a consistent multi-modal commuter, saw a huge uptick in the number of people riding the bus. When the economy got stronger and more surefooted, buses started to empty out again. Now I see fewer and fewer people of 'means' on the buses - the ones that remain likely don't have other options. When people can afford _not_ to be inconvenienced, they won't be - whether that means buying a parking pass, ponying up for gas & insurance, or taking rideshare everywhere.
- tathougies 9y agoI recently moved to Marin county and use the bus to commute to SF. The Golden Gate Transit buses are pretty amazing. They come on time, the seats are clean and comfortable, and they have (usually fast) wifi. The clientele is clearly professionals commuting to the city in the morning and evening, and it works. Honestly, if more bus systems simply got wifi and nice seats, that would be a huge step forward. I've taken the Muni buses before, and they are frankly disgusting. I actually look forward to my bus commute each morning now.
- jessaustin 9y agoComparing those buses to those that serve other areas seems a little bit like admiring charter schools that only accept rich smart kids...
- tathougies 9y agoWhy? Golden gate transit buses are public buses paid for by tax payer dollars and fares, like every other bus system. They are not private systems. What an odd time we live in, when being proud of our public civil infrastructure gets one labeled an elitist. Should I be ashamed of our schools as well?
- tgb 9y agoHere's a possibly dumb proposal: don't support wheelchairs on buses, instead give them a city/state-run uber-for-wheelchairs service. The problem is that supporting wheelchairs adds an inordinate burden to buses and makes sticking to a schedule completely impossible even if there is no traffic. If you want to take the bus 3 miles, a wheelchair user getting on could double your ride time. So would giving the wheelchair users their own service actually even cost much on the net? Presumably the bus service could save money by not handling wheelchairs on the bus while still sticking to a given level of service and reliability. I'm not sure it's economically feasible but if service to wheelchair users improves too then it might be something you could sell as a good thing above and beyond the improvements to the bus service.
- DrScump 9y agoinstead give them a city/state-run uber-for-wheelchairs service The San Jose area has that: "Paratransit". It was supposed to serve mobility-impaired people who have difficulty using buses (although all buses have lifts). As it turned out, they just let anybody ride who has the gall to call them. 90% of their trips amount to a taxpayer-subsidized cab service for the self-important. The award of the contract was suspect, too, and the subcontractor had to be dumped at great expense... just like the county's ambulance contract with Rural/Metro.
- mjevans 9y agoThat's unfortunate. However this sounds a lot more like corruption and a shady business issue "fulfilling" a contract, or a /very/ poorly written contract.
- sabareesh 9y agoSimilar to lyft line we want these services to be convenient to the passengers at the same time there is a pool. Based on location and time we might need to change size of the bus and also reduce the number of stops. Unless this is solved no one is going to use it nor going to be profitable
- BoorishBears 9y agoI would if it didn’t smell terrible, have extremely limited routes across the state and ran a little more often...
- Dwolb 9y agoI love the bus because it runs express from my Chicago neighborhood directly into the loop. I get on, play with my phone, and get off 25 minutes later. I don't have to fight traffic driving myself and I can multi-task if I choose. The problem comes when trying to take the bus to any other part of the city. It's slow, stops at every block, and is unpredictable when it arrives. It's a mode of transport that supports everyone and that inherently makes it less useful to the individual. Personally I'd like to see bus systems get more fine-grained about their routes, timing, and size of vehicle. We should be able to model some optimizations that improve service while remaining accessible for everyone. It'd be a shame if over the last several years major cities haven't been collecting the required data to make this possible. If not, now would be a good time to beging recording this data.
- ravitation 9y agoExactly this. When I moved to Portland (from NYC, unfortunately), I hoped that I would have access to the MAX, but if not then I'd be able to take the bus to work. I ended up being about 20 blocks from the nearest MAX stop, but there was a bus stop right outside my apartment. I took the bus maybe a dozen times before I realized that it really is a non-option; what takes me ~15 minutes (20 on a extremely rare bad day) in a car takes me at least 45 minutes (to an hour) on the bus. It's really all about what bus route you're on, and your ability to find housing on the bus with the most direct line to your office (in a city like Portland). That's usually not super easy. I have coworkers that have 15-30 minute bus rides from farther out because they're on efficient bus routes.
- edaemon 9y agoPart of Portland's problem is that its transit is built to move people into and out of downtown. Very little of it is built to move people between neighborhoods or across routes. That's somewhat understandable since downtown is the most common destination, but plenty of people (like you) end up without many options.
- ajmurmann 9y ago
- Piskvorrr 9y agoI have mixed feelings towards the bus. The light rail is okay, the underground is great, but the bus experience is...greatly variable.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoGetting to the underground platform and getting back to street level adds 5-10 mins of wasted time which the bus makes up for but the problem with buses is traffic. It’s taken me 1 hour to go a mile and a half in London more than once in areas where there is a congestion charge (toll to discourage private cars) in place.
- Endama 9y agoI suspect the uncomfortable truth behind a lot of the problems regarding public transit isn't the transit itself, but the passengers. If you had the choice of riding a public bus with a large collection of the public or paying a few bucks and selecting a preferred subset of the ridership (e.g. chariot in SF, uber, lyft, etc.) I think most will choose the non-bus option to feel comfortable during their ride. I'm not saying that this is a morally acceptable thing, I just suspect this is a significant reason why bus ridership has been declining.
- stevehawk 9y agoNo one's going to publicly agree with you, but they all do.
- jdavis703 9y agoThe public already publicly agrees on this. AB716 gives BART (and other CA transportation agencies) the right to give riders a "stay away" order. If my personal interactions with BARTPD are indications, this law is however designed to keep away people who look like "undesirables," which is why these kinds of things are generally a bad idea.
- busterarm 9y agoThis is exactly why I take the bus outside of peak hours though! In particular the M20 from State St/Whitehall up 8th avenue. The MTA is so stigmatized by people under 50 here where "only crazy people and the elderly take the bus". I'm guaranteed a nice, quiet ride where I get a seat the whole way. It's a little slower, but not much. Meanwhile, the subway is just about unbearable always. The tricky part is getting the bus driver to even stop for you if you don't "look like you take the bus". 80% of the time I'll be waving them down at the stop and they'll just blow past it if nobody requests the stop inside.
- komali2 9y agoWoah, is this a reverse no true Scotsman? What fallacy is this? Just to instantly dismember your argument, which hinges on the word "they all," I'll put my hand up as a "I'd ride next to homeless every day if it saves me transit money."
- maxharris 9y agoI love light rail, not the bus: http://setosa.io/bus/ http://setosa.io/bus/ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_bunching https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bus_bunching
- craftyguy 9y agoIn Portland, OR, the light rail does 'train bunching', with the exact same consequences (inconsistent schedule, overcrowded trains followed closely by empty ones, etc).
- blang 9y agoIs this because the train is not grade separated?
- craftyguy 9y agoIn many places it is, but downtown it is right there on the street sharing lanes with cars. I've been on the light rail when it was hit by a car, and when it hit a car (both low-speed, but still delayed things by quite a long time)
- maxharris 9y agoYup! The fix is to prioritize trains over all other street traffic, especially cars. (I suppose you could do this with buses, too, but people don't really see it that way because they have rubber wheels just like cars...)
- evandijk70 9y agoBuses in my country have priority over all other street traffic. They never have a red light, it goes to green automatically when the bus arrives.
- maxharris 9y agoIn Seattle (where I lived for three years, until just recently,) there was this dedicated bus lane. Cars for the most part stayed off of it, but the bus still had to stop at traffic lights. Anything on rail is just way more suited to nonstop use! People in cars can (or should) more easily understand that trains/streetcars can't just start and stop just for them.
- komali2 9y agoMe: I would ride the bus if it was available more than once every 30 minutes. At this point it's faster for me to Uber. City councilmember: why should we allocate even more funds to the busses? Nobody's riding them!
- busterarm 9y agoGod I would love it Manhattan banned Uber and all non-commercial traffic (exile all civilian traffic to the highways and parking garages alongside them) and upped the number of buses. Clean new yellow cabs too and tougher requirements to drive them (raise the fares, I don't care).
- kpil 9y agoIt kind of works for Venice, it's so nice to be in a car free town with a slow but nice public transport (the vaporettos) so I started to dream about if it would be possible to a similar thing with buses, combined with the existing subway and trams, and just exile all cars. The thing is that where I live, the bus network is heavily funded and I'm suspecting that it's probably operating already with too little efficiency most of the day and most lines - basically a lot of buses driving around nearly empty at times. Since I bike in the city, I can't fail to notice that buses also seems to generate most of the dust, if not all of it - sometimes you basically have to stop and wait a few minutes if you are biking behind a bus, since it's not possible to neither see or breathe. Even on an at least nominally clean tarmac road. I haven't noticed that behind a Nissan Micra. Further, large diesel engines running heavy start-stop duty cycles like buses probably generates unproportionally more particles than just about everything else. Since this city have one of the highest count of both PM10 and PM2.5 - source could be either oil or dust - this also have got me thinking. Where I live, the focus on buses is driven by a political agenda - basically the environmentalists and the left have defined buses as "good" and cars as "bad" - and I suspect regardless of any facts in the matter, exemplified in an interview where one politician admitted that they'd really love to ban cars even if the had no environmental impact at all. I'm not particularly fighting for more cars and less buses, but I like my facts straight before implementing public policy. I haven't been able to find any official published statistics in fuel consumption per passenger mile for the public transport in the region - should be somewhat trivial to calculate now that every passenger conveniently carries a tracking device with them. I also haven't been able to find any studies about particle emissions for buses and if it's possible to find any correlation between the ratio of buses to other traffic and particulates. Unfortunatly, I suspect that research on topics like those is probably heretical and a thought crime in most Universities' departments for environmental studies. Still, electric buses on the larger streets instead of vaparettos on the Grand Canal is a lovely thought.
- ThrustVectoring 9y agoThe bus system has to make pretty aggressive tradeoffs in order to be useful to commuters. You can't make it stop at every block in order to make it take less walking to get to the bus stop. Similarly, you can't have parallel lines a block apart. You have to limit the service area so that you can afford to run busses every 5-10 minutes. And you'll want to improve streets so that busses can run down the center and pick up passengers from protected islands, rather than fighting with parking and turning traffic for space. Like, I take the BART every day into work. It's fantastic. I walk for five to ten minutes to get to the station, a train comes every 5 minutes so I don't have to worry about the train schedule, then I walk another five to ten minutes to get to the office. If the bus experience could match that, it'd take over a lot of commuting.
- j2kun 9y agoPlenty of cities (Chicago, in my experience) have parallel lines 1-2 blocks apart. For the record, I take the transbay bus to work most days, and it's a similar deal (plus I can almost always get a seat). Slightly less convenient with the schedule (every 10 minutes instead of 5)
- bunderbunder 9y agoIt sounds like you're talking about downtown Chicago. There are a lot of bus lines that converge in that area, along with every single train except the yellow line, because the city is hyper-centralized so that's where everyone's commuting to. In most the city, buses just run along the major thoroughfares, which typically means they are spaced 4-ish city blocks apart.
- mmanfrin 9y agoLike, I take the BART every day into work. It's fantastic. I walk for five to ten minutes to get to the station, a train comes every 5 minutes so I don't have to worry about the train schedule, then I walk another five to ten minutes to get to the office. If the bus experience could match that, it'd take over a lot of commuting. For what it's worth, this is only the case if you live near a station with overlap (or live in SF itself). I lived in West Oakland and had a train practically every 3 minutes. Then I moved to Berkeley. Commute in is every 15 minutes, 50/50 I have to take a transfer on the way in. Commute home is a nightmare: BART has a carriage shortage so they try to shave off cars from longer routes (such as the Richmond line). This means things get really crowded on occasion, and there's a point where a car being crowded begets more crowding, as it takes longer and longer to offboard/onboard people and therefore each subsequent stop has more people to cram on. A majority of the time on my way home when I get a transfer (as there seems to be a Richmond train from SF only for an hour span at the peak of rush hour), the trains are almost an entire cycle late, meaning I've got another 15 minute wait to see two trains come through one after the other. The point of this is: the problems you raise with busses are also with trains/BART. Some of them are even worse for BART: you have to steeply limit the service area because putting down tracks is stupendously expensive.
- jayess 9y agoTransit ridership is down across the country: https://www.nationaltransitdatabase.org/national-statistics/ https://www.nationaltransitdatabase.org/national-statistics/ I just don't see how you convince people to ride the bus vs rides haring. The bus is virtually always incredibly inconvenient and slow. It really is a last resort mode of transportation. It's no surprise that virtually all transit agencies across the country are seeing dramatic declines in bus usage since 2014.
- cgy1 9y agoI find it much more intimidating to take buses versus rail. For example, unlike most rail systems, buses will skip stops unless a passenger requests that the bus make a stop. Well, when I'm riding the bus for the first time or at night, it's quite easy to miss when I should request a stop. Meanwhile, if I take a train, I know the stations will stop at every station in its route and their are prominent signs at each station so it's much easier to figure out when I should exit the train. Plus often the same bus line may have different types of routes, such as an express route, so if I'm not careful making sure whether the bus has an X at the end of its name, I sometimes end up taking the wrong route that skips my stop.
- kd0amg 9y agoWell, when I'm riding the bus for the first time or at night, it's quite easy to miss when I should request a stop. I always thought it odd that MBTA buses announce the stop they're currently passing (too late to ask the driver to stop there) rather than saying which stop is coming up next.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoI found Transit[1] extremely helpful for this. It lets you search for bus routes that will take you where you want to go, provides a walking route to the bus stop and tells you when you need to leave to get there on time, provides real-time arrival information and tells you how many stops are left before your destination and when to get off. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transit_(app) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transit_(app)
- stevejb 9y agoOne thing that seems to have not been addressed here is noise. I was just on a quick walk in downtown Sydney, Australia. It was so loud on the sidewalks, with buses seeming to contribute a huge portion of noise. Additionally, the diesel exhaust can be stifling particularly in these urban corridor situations where the buildings trap the fumes. I would much rather be walking next to 50 Prius/Camry taxi cabs and a few private vehicles than 10 loud buses. I agree with the idea of bus utilization in cities but there are certainly some downsides.
- fratlas 9y agoWere you in the CBD? I'd say the downside of the noise is worth it. The amount of Sydneysiders driving in to work solo is staggering.
- stevejb 9y agoYeah, CBD. I can deal with the noise, but the diesel fumes get to me. It was more just thinking "if this noise and exhaust wasn't here, this would be a much more pleasant experience."
- gascan 9y agoElectric buses and CNG buses are already here, and they are quieter. It might take some time for Sydney to retire old diesel buses, but they won't be that loud & fumey forever.
- jboles 9y agoCNG buses don’t seem to do as well as diesel with hot weather and lots of hills, two things Sydney has an abundance of. A few have also caught fire. That said, Sydney’s CNG buses are pretty old now so maybe the tech is updated.
- gascan 9y agoIronically, that makes it sound like Sydney is a great place for cable trolley. No engine whatsoever, works great on hills.
- cozzyd 9y agoI ride the bus every day and honestly, if it's not crowded, it's usually more comfortable than sitting in a car. You don't have to strike up conversation with anyone or anything either. You can usually bust out your laptop too. I sometimes avoid taking the express buses to work because I know I'll get a seat on the local bus, even if it takes an extra 10 mins. My biggest issue is I systematically underestimate the time it takes me to get to the stop (I use bus trackers and leave with the minimum amount of time required to make it to the stop), so I often end up running or sometimes barely miss the bus.
- downer68 9y agoBuses fucking suck. Buses make you wait in the rain. Buses get stuck in traffic very easily. Buses create traffic and make it worse with their size. Buses idle diesel fumes as they stand in traffic. Buses are noisy and idle outside of homes. Bus stops in front of homes are filled with noisy people. Buses that permit requested stops go nowhere slower than ever. Buses are a half measure. Buses fucking suck.
- TheCoelacanth 9y agoBus shelters, bus-only lanes and electric buses solve nearly all of those problems.
- abainbridge 9y agoAnd, where I'm from (Cambridge, UK), they also: Are more expensive than driving. Are regulated in such a way that prevents a competitive market. Are run by profit making companies that demand subsidies from government. Don't run at night. Are full at rush hour. Spend ages at the bus stop while everyone buys tickets, argues with the driver, asks which bus this is etc etc. A single ticket can't be used on buses from two different companies. I cycle. The buses seem like a threat to my safety because they are too big to overtake safely on a busy street. Also their engines are at the back, so I can't hear when they're sneaking up behind me. Once they don't need a driver and are electric, most of these problems could be solved. I'll re-assess then.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoCome to Copenhagen and see how a unified public transport system is supposed to work. My tickets work for all buses and all trains equally. Don't blame public transport as a concept, blame private profiteering and corruption.
- abainbridge 9y agoI've been to Copenhagen. I noticed you have a lot of cyclists! But no, I agree with your point. I think that is the main problem.
- wollw 9y agoWe need to start planning cities and towns in terms of foot traffic and stop assuming the need for other forms of transportation.
- ajmurmann 9y agoCan someone explain why it's so common for buses in the US to stop every damn block? In SF even some subway lines do this. This seems like the surest way to render the mode of transportation entirely useless.
- icc97 9y agoI'm of the opinion that buses are the best candidate for the first mode of road transport that can eliminate road deaths for passengers. They're driven by professional drivers who don't drink, have strict rules about the amount of rest, don't speed and typically (far more than amateurs) drive in a predictable sensible manner. Certainly in Belgium it's down to single figures per year. The crashes that do occur are usually caused by amateur drivers in cars, the driver falling unconscious or something like a tire blowout. I think passive neural networks can be trained to take over if the driver becomes unwell (this was one of Musk's claims for the Autopilot in the Tesla Semi) and I think they can be trained to handle the situation of a tire blowout better than a human. The final issue is amateur drivers. Not much can be done about them until we reach level 4 automation.
- imgabe 9y agoWith the push for self driving cars, I'm surprised I haven't heard anything about self driving buses. It seems like it would be a slightly simpler problem to have a self-driving vehicle along a predefined route.
- icc97 9y agoThere are, Mercedes has built one [0]. But this suffers from the same problem as Autopilot/Uber crash that it's not fully autonomous so the bus driver has to stay alert whilst doing nothing. [0]: https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/18/self-driving-mercedes-benz-bus-takes-a-milestone-12-mile-trip/ https://techcrunch.com/2016/07/18/self-driving-mercedes-benz...