11 ms·
> [If you’re a dude and you’re reading this article] Go befriend a girl in your class or company. It’s not creepy. Include her, ask her for advice, introduce he
by hn_throwaway_99 9y ago
> [If you’re a dude and you’re reading this article] Go befriend a girl in your class or company. It’s not creepy. Include her, ask her for advice, introduce her, learn about her work and her life in the same way you would with any male friend or coworker. If you’re an investor, professor, journalist, or manager, take it on yourself to sponsor a young woman’s career.
While I totally agree with this advice, I think this is very difficult to get men to do in the tech industry. There is a real concern, and to be honest I don't totally think invalid, that many men don't want to be perceived in any way as doing something that could be construed (or misconstrued) as harassment. I think there may be an subconscious/unconscious evaluation going on where men think "Well, I might be socially awkward talking to this girl anyway, so I'll just avoid the complication."
I think one of the unfortunate unintended consequences of the #MeToo movement is that men don't want to even get close to the line of doing something that could be perceived as inappropriate, which unfortunately results in more isolation of women, not less.
- kenning 9y agoI agree with your first (non-quoted) paragraph. Please don't blame this on #metoo. it just happened, and I think the first point you made was just as legitimate before #metoo
- Upper_Onion 9y agoWe will implement cultural marxism, one meaningless job at a time. https://i.imgur.com/viFweMa.jpg https://i.imgur.com/viFweMa.jpg I can tell you how was the jobs situation in Romania, during Soviet times. When a 14 years old Romanian went to the high school he chose a direction in life. For example he wanted to be a mechanic, than he passed an exam to the high school. When he finishes 10th grade he was assigned to a state owned repair shop or he was sent to a factory (floor). If he wanted to be a technician, like my father, he had to finish studies with a high-school diploma, called a “bachelor degree”. Then he was assigned to a repair shop or a factory, in the native town. There were very few people with college degrees. The Communist did not like educated people. The college was highly restricted. Less than 10% ever went to faculty. The college was al least 5 years long, and after the studies a commission assigned you to the place you were needed. For example a young lawyer from Bucharest might be sent to Iasi, in Moldavia. An engineer from Cluj might be sent to Tulcea, in the Danube delta. In short, in Communist times, you did not find a job. You were assigned to a job, in a specific factory. You were expected to work there until you died, or be old enough to have a pension. Nobody changed jobs. My father was a sailor. He gave up, when he was 28. The government sent him to technical school, to learn to repair tv sets. After 6 months he passed a test and he was assigned to a TV repair shop. The end. My mother finished high school and she became a teacher for kids age 6 to 10. She was sent to a school very far away and she worked there for 20 years. After the revolution and the disbanding of communism she was able to change schools and come closer to home. The job situation in Romania was similar to the job situation in the Soviet Union. Our system was built after the model of the Soviet system
- bmarquez 9y ago> men don't want to even get close to the line of doing something that could be perceived as inappropriate Yeah I am wondering why someone would stick their neck out, especially if they have below-average social skills. Lots of personal liability for little personal gain, and #MeToo just publicized the existing uneasiness with professional interactions. It's not like any women helped when I was evaluating a career in nursing.
- sp332 9y agoBecause social skills can be practiced and learned. #MeToo is about physical abuse and abuse of power, not some peer who has a hard time making eye contact.
- skookumchuck 9y agoThere's a large grey area. There are also false accusations.
- bmarquez 9y agoI agree that social skills can be practiced and learned. But I think something like Toastmasters, improv classes, or Meetup groups are a much safer way, instead of the corporate environment.
- thucydidesofusa 9y agoNot yet. But there's clearly some trend towards making smaller and smaller transgressions into #metoo issues. I'd hate to find out that I rolled the dice on ostracism (or worse) just to be friendly to someone who doesn't care enough to reach out to me. In fact, it's much riskier for me to reach out to them than for them to reach out to me. If they're too stupid to realize that, I'm not interested in being their friend. And if they're perceptive of my risk and they still expect me to submit myself to it for their convenience or whatever then I'm not interested in being their friend.
- Jackalopiate 9y agoWhat about the incel hate that feminists are throwing around nowadays? There have been 2-3 instances of self proclaimed incel men lashing out because they can't get laid, and they have been branded as psychopathic women-haters by the far-left. The #MeToo movement was a farce anyway, and led to a lot of false accusations that some men have to deal with forever now.
- lilactown 9y agoJFC. If you're afraid of accidentally harassing or molesting someone I think you have the wrong idea of how to interact with people.
- Mythanar 9y agoWhat you think is harassing might quite well disagree with target female view of what harassing is, complicated by the fact that HR department might disagree with you both. And should that whole thing become public, you'll be judged by the entire office, with the entire spectrum of views on what harassment is. Personally, as a male, you have absolutely nothing to gain, and everything to lose. The most rational thing is to not engage at all.
- lilactown 9y ago> as a male, you have absolutely nothing to gain, and everything to lose. Having friendly, healthy relationships with your colleagues isn't valuable? Or just with the ones who are women? Some of my best friendships/allies/contacts have been women who I worked with. I'm very thankful for the opportunities they have provided me and the value they add to my life. The fact that you see /zero/ value in having genuine connections with women has me even more worried than the fact that the OP was afraid of harassing someone accidentally.
- Mythanar 9y ago> Having friendly, healthy relationships with your colleagues isn't valuable? Or just with the ones who are women? Just with the ones who are women (from a male perspective). This specific point is because of #MeToo - this movement normalized the fact that "friendliness" and "healthiness" of a relationship is judged post-factum, sometimes years and decades post-factum, and the male perspective is rarely taken into account. Think about it this way, even if one follows OP advice, and builds what he considers very healthy and friendly relationship, he exposes himself to (based on recent news stories, very real) risk of the relationship being second-guessed by the female, at any point in time in future, with the severe penalties resulting from mere accusations, not convictions, even if not true.
- 089723645897236 9y agoYou don't get to check out because you are a jerk and are afraid you won't be able to stop being a jerk. You have to try HARDER because you are PRIVILEGED to be part of the majority. This applies to race, culture, whatever. Just because you suck at social skills (hello HN!) doesn't mean you get to check out and not try. In fact if you are reading this and making excuses on why you don't have to make an effort, YOU ARE THE ONE WHO NEEDS TO MAKE THE MOST EFFORT. The fact that men can't interact with women without making them feel excluded is the whole point of this whole thing. You have to include women, POC, trans people, regardless of if you are capable of it. You. Have. To. Do. This. Or you are a fascist. Full stop. Frankly this whole male ego "I can't stop myself" excuse is bull hockey. Get with it nerds.
- wyoh 9y agoAre you a troll account? Because you speak like a troll account.
- 089723645897236 9y agoAm I troll if I'm sharing an opinion you don't agree with in a style and tone you don't like? Nope, just a contrarian trying to make you pay attention. Downvotes are just upvotes in reverse. edit: I noticed my reply was flagged. Congratulations to the fascists who missed the point as it flew whistling over their heads. HN echo chamber in full effect.
- dang 9y agoPlease don't post ideological rants to Hacker News, regardless of which ideology you favor. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- mywittyname 9y ago> "Well, I might be socially awkward talking to this girl anyway, so I'll just avoid the complication." This is exactly how I am, but it has nothing to do with the #metoo movement. The reason is because I discovered at a young age that girls didn't want a ugly boy talking to them. It makes them uncomfortable, and as a result, it makes me uncomfortable. So in my mind, avoiding attractive women is being polite. Something nobody will admit is that "creepy" is really 90% based on the looks of a person, and 10% what they are doing. People aren't comfortable with the idea of an unattractive person potentially having a romantic interest in them (regardless of whether they do or not). edit: My horrible solution to the issue of a lack of women in tech is to get more conventionally attractive men in tech. More guys like in that Napa photo and less ones like that chubby, 1980s stereotype one.
- gnulinux 9y agoThis is exactly me. All my, maybe >10 (of course in college, not in work), attempts ended up me being called out for being creepy so I basically quit trying because I don't want to make women uncomfortable. When I say this to my friends they act as if I'm inflicting self-harm. We should really let people being at peace with their sexuality.
- stcredzero 9y agoSomething nobody will admit is that "creepy" is really 90% based on the looks of a person, and 10% what they are doing. It's based mostly on relative status, and it mostly exists in the mind. People aren't comfortable with the idea of an unattractive person potentially having a romantic interest in them (regardless of whether they do or not). It's different between women and men. Men are a bit more physically dangerous to women, so a man liking a woman carries a bit more risk than a woman liking a man. Also, the state-of-nature potential downside cost of unwanted attention, should it go very badly, is higher to a woman than it is to a man.
- bittercynic 9y agoI think if you approach someone with "this person is very attractive" at the fore of your mind, you're likely to present in a way that could be perceived as creepy, and maybe not approaching that person could be a good move. If very many people have that effect on you, it might be worth checking to see if you want to change something about yourself, though.
- Draiken 9y agoI'd also add partners and gossip into the mix. It's very easy for a third party to see a man and a woman having regular workplace relationship and associate that with flirtation and even cheating. Of course this varies wildly in intensity depending on companies/partners, but it almost inevitably generates gossip. It's even worse if you're above her in the company hierarchy. I know I would probably stray away from attempting this sort of work relationship with a woman for both my job and my partner's sake. It's a really thin line to navigate on both cases. I've seen people get fired because a woman hinted that a man harassed her when I knew it was not the case. But as said on another comment, this was true way before #metoo, that just brought even more visibility to this.
- everdrive 9y agoThis is dead on. To be honest, girls can get creeped out whether I have platonic intent or not. Part of what defines a guy as "creepy" is the mere fact of whether or not he's reading a girl's signals correctly. This can be problematic, since it doesn't necessarily follow that failing to read a girl's boundaries correctly means I have anything other than platonic intent. This can be circumvented for sure, but my usual method is simply to keep conversations about work only, and not to linger when a work topic has concluded. This might seem like overkill, but I'm trying t err on the side of caution here.
- InstanceOf 9y agoI've seen women call men creepy for literally no reason (this is more common in pre-college aged girls), I assume it's equivalent to "you're ugly and not a person to me and I'm offended you tried to talk to me (even if it was purely school assignment related)". I've even met one girl who _wanted_ it to be a term of endearment (considering the above, there was no way that was going to work). I've also seen a shit-ton of creepy borderline sociopathic behavior from males, much of it gone uncalled out (by the supposedly sane males who were standing by), which often will lead to a woman calling the person creepy (and hopefully she isn't physicslly hurt in addition to merely the scare of something terrible about to happen).
- stcredzero 9y agoI've seen women call men creepy for literally no reason I'm corroborating this. I've also seen a shit-ton of creepy borderline sociopathic behavior from males, much of it gone uncalled out (by the supposedly sane males who were standing by) Let me guess: It was from the highest status male in the immediate vicinity?
- ajkjk 9y agoYou've described "calling men creepy for no reason" and then described the reason. I think you're really saying that the word creepy means something different than its 'face value', as it were. Put differently: the word "creepy" means one thing. Actually saying someone is "creepy", however, is a social signal with a very different meaning (namely: your attention is unwanted / you are lesser / something like that). Parsed that way, it makes sense that that message would not be sent in situations where it doesn't seem socially unacceptable to send it, even if everyone is thinking it. One of the better things about being an adult is that it becomes socially acceptable, usually, at least in good company, to do what's right even if it violates some status-signally thing.
- mikeash 9y agoWomen are people. Talk to them like people. If you’re so bad at socializing that you might accidentally harass someone, fix that! Don’t just retreat from the world because you can’t handle a basic skill. Edit: Interesting downvotes. Is it the suggestion that women are people, or the suggestion for self-improvement if you’re incapable of treating them accordingly?
- furi 9y agoIt's the ignorance of reality mostly. Whenever my girlfriend gets a guy approaching/messaging her both of us default to an immediate suspicion of romantic intent. It doesn't require them treating her in a dehumanizing way or harassing her (although those certainly happen and quickly remove all doubt about his motives), they just have to turn up and the suspicion starts. That suspicion alone (especially in an environment with third parties who are watching and talking) can be quite damaging, no hysteria about false accusations of harassment required.
- mikeash 9y agoIt sure doesn’t match the reality I live in. I see guys with really bad social skills struggling with this, but that can be overcome.
- furi 9y agoWell perhaps it's regional to some degree, I can't say, but I certainly know other people who think this way and it's what I'm scared of when approaching women. I'm not scared of harassment accusations (that seems like it's been blown out of all proportion). I just don't want to be perceived as sexually interested in them and I know that if the tables were turned I would immediately assume exactly that.
- eberfreitas 9y agoI don't know why this is being downvoted. This should be the top response to this thread...
- colemickens 9y agoThis comment is in every single one of these threads. I am not trying to be hyperbolic here, but it reminds me of people that act as if "laws" are the only thing keeping them from murdering their annoying neighbor. I don't know how to read it without thinking "wow, this confirms what women are saying about men". I mean, I guess I should be glad there's some self-awareness? Maybe I just can't empathize as a gay man though, but I've never, ever felt this way around a male coworker, gay or otherwise. edit: To further explain my thinking... what's the alternative? The only way I can understand the comment is "Oh, well this is a witchhunt and I'm afraid of being swept up" ... or else, "I have done those behaviors that men are getting in trouble for and am worried about doing them to a coworker." Maybe there's another interpretation that I'm not able to understand? Trying to understand here. Thanks.
- Draiken 9y agoI believe comparing murder to sexual harassment is plain misleading. If someone acuses someone else of murdering his neighbour they will have to go to all lenghts to prove it and it's a major moral line to cross. If someone acuses someone else of sexually harassing a woman, whether they're guilty or not, they'd most likely lose their job straight away and be labelled as a "perv" or something similar. I can't see how you can compare those. In your particular case, the equivalent would be a man screaming "sexual harassment" from another man. There's a huge stigma accompanied with that. It's just not socially acceptable on society today. On top of that the homossexual community is another minority with all the weight of discrimination following it. Let's say that happens. It's easier for you to prove he fired you because of your sexual orientation than for him to prove you harassed him. I believe there's a reason you don't feel this threatened. It's because unfortunately that's how society works today. [Edit: grammar]
- colemickens 9y ago>It's easier for you to prove he fired you because of your sexual orientation than for him to prove you harassed him. So, I can't understand as a gay man because I'm immune to accusations of sexual harassment because I can just use my orientation as a discrimination shield? Eh, no, not really. Frankly, it doesn't make sense and er, it doesn't address the fact that the other person could be gay? While I concede that a false allegation of sexual harassment carries a different weight than a false allegation of murder... false accusations are lies and presumably will happen even if you avoid all contact with someone, no? I guess I don't know what the alternative is. If I have to choose between ignoring workplace harassment and having folks err on the side of caution in the workplace behavior, I know which way I hope for us to err.
- titanix2 9y agoThis advice assume that men want to befriend women. It is understandable from a women point of view, but from a man perspective the friendzone is a big no-no. Most men would date a woman or not establish contact at all.
- tptacek 9y agoThis is an off-the-charts creepy thing to say.
- Mythanar 9y ago...that also happens to be true.
- titanix2 9y agoEvolution of creepiness: 2018: saying that men are primarily interested in women for sex 2019: saying oceans are made of water Can't wait for 2020 when saying Hello to an unknown person will so creepy it would be called a micro-agression. Oh wait...! https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4txyh4 https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x4txyh4
- pvg 9y agoThat first one has always been both creepy and plain misogyny.
- kasey_junk 9y agoI don’t know if you are joking or not, but the idea that women are only valuable for sexual gratification is weird and creepy and always has been.
- dang 9y agoYou're getting into self-parody here, but unfortunately such comments are still poisonous. Please stop. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 9y ago
- wieghant 9y agoWe recently got a new female analyst. We invite her for lunch and sometimes have small talk. Thing is, there's literally zero chemistry. We can't include here in our dumb Skype chat because its usually filled with incredibly dumb offensive memes - so we just try to keep our laughs down. We tried invite her to video game night and even organized board games just because she wasn't into video games that much. But again, there just isn't any chemistry. I genuinely think that the border isn't just between anti-social/pro-social. I also wouldn't ever consider making deprecating jokes towards her. What's considered inappropriate is too blurred also. I can make fat jokes/racist jokes/generally inappropriate jokes with most guys, since we know there's no malevolent intent. It's kinda cathartic and it's a two-way street. I genuinely don't think I can be like that with any woman in the workplace. I know comedians can have such a relationship though, so maybe there is a chance? Maybe not now when people are publicly executed for speaking their mind but in the future.
- timavr 9y agoI just don't buy into social stuff. People at work to work. As long as she is treated with respect and provided the same opportunities as everyone else it should be cool. People have different interests and it is totally fine. At our place some people are into Fortnite, some people into crypto, some people into playing the piano. So when Fortnite people stay after hours to put some games in, it doesn't mean I have to stay back and play with them.
- wieghant 9y agoThat's not really what I was getting at. Most of the guys are just like you described. We usually can't even settle on a video game to play. However, even with the one thing in common with the whole group (slight interest in board games) we just didn't hit off. And it's not like a singular attempt or case either. It's like there is a cultural divide. Now that's not the case with everyone, my example is anecdotal. I have female friends that dig board games and some video games and there's no divide there but just in the workplace, that is not the case. From my current experience and environment it seems very unlikely I'll ever meet someone like that though.
- 9y ago
- dvfjsdhgfv 9y ago> There is a real concern, and to be honest I don't totally think invalid, that many men don't want to be perceived in any way as doing something that could be construed (or misconstrued) as harassment. This is very real. Why complicate things if I can be more relaxed and free talking to my male colleagues? They will even tolerate childish jokes I'd never do in front of any women (and as we all know, some people did and lost their jobs because of that). No, thank you.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mikeleeorg 9y agoI see this not as a consequence of the #metoo movement and more of a consequence of the lack of social intelligence & skills education. Because it IS entirely possible to befriend a women and not come across creepy, regardless of your physical appearance. As the author mentioned, girls tend to "engage in more prosocial behaviors" than boys. This means teenage and college-age men - especially those who gravitate towards fields of study that are "perceived to be anti-social" - may come across as socially awkward in their interactions. And while their interactions may be entirely innocent, that awkwardness can be interpreted as "creepy" by some. IMHO, one viable solution to this is to add and strengthen social and emotional intelligence education in our schools. And perhaps, offer workshops for parents as well. Many schools are already beginning to do this. We just need more of it - and to continue it all the way through higher education.
- gnulinux 9y ago> Because it IS entirely possible to befriend a women and not come across creepy, regardless of your physical appearance. This depends on a lot more than your social abilities such your the way you look and your social status, none of which can be changed easily.
- mikeleeorg 9y agoIf you are referring to ethnicity, than yes, I definitely agree. If you are referring to your clothes, then yes, there are definitely cultural biases (e.g. reactions to burkas). With that said, I still do see some people (albeit rarely) still find a way to bridge the gap using what seems like infinite patience and grace on their part (which I would say are part of social intelligence). But even then, there are people who will always allow their implicit biases come to the surface, no matter how graceful you are.
- gnulinux 9y agoI'm not quiete sure what you're suggesting, sorry. I think there is a distinction between people who are very attractive and very unattractive. If a very attractive person does something stupid -- like getting hella drunk and asking a random stranger out -- people laugh and it's a fun memory. If an unattractive person does the exact same thing it's creepy. I think that's just a fact of life for me, I also don't care how much people here will tell me this is not true, I have seen consistently that the probability of attractive people being labelled "creepy" is significantly less than unattractive people. It is also true that some people are really adept at social skills maybe due to experience or maybe due to innate, genetic factors. Some people are really fun and fascinating to talk to. Even nerdy, unattractive people! Like, sometimes I get to know people whose only passion in life is mathematics and they're generally very unattractive but they are extremely fun to talk to. I just wanna be around then and listen to their jokes. But some people are not like that, and this makes social interactions inherently harder for them. I wasn't thinking of cultural biases (I'm mostly thinking of Bay Area cultural context since this is the one I know but I'm assuming it's pretty much the same in most Western cultures) but I guess you can say something about that too. My main point is: talkign to women is extremely easy for some people, and the hardest thing in the world for other. When you simply can't talk to anyone comfortably in non-work context, it's almost impossible to make friends with them. I honestly do not know how to properly make women friends and I'd much rather not make women friends than make them and myself uncomfortable which for me disproves the whole article.
- hn_throwaway333 9y agoIn my previous job, a women moved from a different country to join our group. We had common mutual interestss, we talked often, had a couple of drinks and dinner once. I did the same thing with a male coworker. However, the relationship with a woman is always going to be a little different, especially if your both single. After a couple of weeks I asked her if she was interested in dating. She said it was not a good idea as we were coworkers, and thinking about it I fully agreed and immediately backed of, tried to do the professional thing and did not ask her to join me for coffee or dinner anymore. It was only later that I realized that this was also not what she wanted - she was in a new country, didn't know anyone, and now she kind of lost one of the coworkers that she did have a good (friendly) connection with. It was only about half a year later, after we were both in a relationship with different people, that we reconnected as friends, and we still speak occasionally today after we moved to new jobs. I guess the point of this post is to say, it is more complicated to be friends with someone of the opposite gender than to be friends with someone of the same gender.
- jm__87 9y agoWhile this may be a contributor now, I really doubt this is the main reason why men in tech don't talk to women more at school or work. I'd guess it has more to do with the fact that there are usually fewer overlapping interests and experiences between men and women than there are between men and men and many guys in tech have a hard time socially to start with, so it's just easier for guys to hang out with other guys (as I'm sure it is easier for women to relate more with other women). Also, a lot of men use certain body language and tone when they talk to other men that just may not be appropriate when talking to most women (of course there are exceptions). As one example, at least the area I work in, guys are constantly challenging each others egos. If you grew up as a guy, this is totally normal treatment for our culture, if not welcome treatment. I've heard of at least a few stories where a bunch of guys tried to treat a female colleague like one of the guys in this fashion and it usually turns out very poorly.
- ironjunkie 9y agoI'm in full agreement with you here. This, plus seeing some of the "social media star women engineers" on twitter calling out the "White dudes" on some guys just for trying to have conversations with them. This #MeToo movement gave power to a minority of women that know how to use it in their political advantage, while creating a bigger separation between women and men in general.