4 ms·
I agree it's not an effective currency. But I disagree that it's an investment. I think the correct technical term is speculation. Investment is where you find
by wpietri 9y ago
I agree it's not an effective currency. But I disagree that it's an investment. I think the correct technical term is speculation.
Investment is where you find something producing value in the real world and then buy and hold a piece of that. You're expecting a long stream of returns from the value being produced. Speculation is where you are making a bet on price movements in a way where economic productivity is irrelevant.
When people buy and sell commodities and currencies, they're speculating. They don't care about utility. There's no economic value being created, so one's investment doesn't grow during the time you hold, say, gold. Instead, it's a zero-sum activity: considering all participants together, wins and losses are equal. (Well, technically, losses are larger than wins, because there are always overhead costs.)
Bitcoin is easy to mistake for an investment, because it's meant to be deflationary. (It was even easier to mistake for one during the period where it only went up.) But I don't think holding Bitcoin means you own a slice of an economically productive asset. I think it's just a bet that the commodity price will go up, in the same way you bet if you buy gold or euros.
[1] Warren Buffett has talked about this distinction a lot, over the years. E..g: http://www.businessinsider.com/warren-buffett-investors-versus-sepculators-2016-3 http://www.businessinsider.com/warren-buffett-investors-vers...
- charlesdm 9y agoBy that reasoning, investing in gold is also speculation. Because it only has minimal industrial uses and most of its value comes from the fact that people say it has value. And a piece of art is not a productive asset either. Yet, it can and will have value. I don't think there is anything inherently wrong with that. I'm happy to invest in things that I believe are likely to go up in value, whether those are companies, mineral rights, art, watches, Bitcoin, or water deposits.
- dragandj 9y ago> By that reasoning, investing in gold is also speculation. What else? However, gold has some utility as jewelry etc. Cryptocurrencies are (currently) pure speculation.
- 282883392 9y agoCrypto certainly has, if not more, at least the same utility than jewelry. Trust less, distributed ledgers--these aren't tulips.
- gefh 9y agoTulips and jewelry at least look pretty. And you're trusting, at least, the implementation and the underlying math. Personally the risk of recourse-less outweighs the value of trust-less.
- wpietri 9y agoThey do not have the same utility. I can walk out of my house and find people deriving value from wearing jewelry. Trustless, distributed ledgers, on the other hand, not so much. At the moment, Bitcoin's primary non-speculative use case is light financial crime: money laundering, capital control evasion, ransomware, buying various illegal stuff, ponzi schemes, etc. I agree that it's possible that one day trustless, distributed ledgers will deliver enormous amounts of value. But it's important to distinguish between delivered value and potential value.
- actsasbuffoon 9y agoThe only developments in cryptocurrency that I've personally found interesting have been smart contracts. Even then, there's no reason that couldn't be done by a traditional financial institution using fiat currency. The fact that smart contracts were first implemented with cryptocurrency is an implementation detail, not a fundamental requirement. Frankly, I'd probably rather use smart contracts with regular currency. If there was some kind of scam or theft then the financial institution might be able to reverse some of the charges. Most of the advantages of cryptocurrency don't really sound like advantages to me.
- wpietri 9y agoExactly. Reversability by a trusted party when things go wrong can be a huge benefit. Even financial markets will do it as needed. I used to write trading software. Some of our traders were trading on the DTB; being German, they were sticklers for rules. One day our traders jumped on something and made a lot of money. But it turned out that somebody at another company had fat-fingered an order at a very low price for a very large quantity. Large enough that it would have destroyed their company. The exchange decided there was no point in that, so they unwound all the trades. I thought our guys would be mad. They were a little disappointed to lose the expected profit, but they were otherwise fine with it. They didn't see any sense in that kind of destruction just for a short-term gain.
- wpietri 9y agoYes, buying gold with the intention of selling it later is speculation. Buying anything with the intention of selling it later for a higher price is speculation. If you were a jewelry-maker, I suppose you could call buying gold an investment.
- coryfklein 9y ago> Buying anything with the intention of selling it later for a higher price is speculation. I'm buying shares of an S&P 500 index now with the intention of selling them at a higher price in ~40-50 years. Am I a speculator or an investor?
- wpietri 9y agoIndex funds receive dividends from the stocks, so you're investing. This may be hidden from you if the index fund (or your broker) automatically reinvests. But either way, you own economically productive assets that a) create value for customers, and b) throw off a stream of cash. Even if the S&P 500 is at the exact same level in 50 years, you'll still gain significantly. That's obviously not true of commodities (e.g., gold, silver) or currencies.
- actsasbuffoon 9y agoAgreed. Even trading fiat currency through Forex is a form of speculation. The Wikipedia page for Forex even describes it as such: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_market