6 ms·
> "Looks like in the future people hoard currency instead of spending and investing it then. That ought to be interesting." That sounds like the current to me.
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
> "Looks like in the future people hoard currency instead of spending and investing it then. That ought to be interesting."
That sounds like the current to me. Too much is locked up (in too few hands) instead of doing what currency should do. That is, reduce the friction of trade (i.e., goods, skills, etc.) Currency is a lubricant. It's no surprise things are drying up.
- conanbatt 9y agoA poor village in africa has starvation. They do not produce enough food to feed themeslves properly. So they are given an aid of 10,000 U$S. So they turn to their own farmers and say "Behold the currency, we were dry of it before and we were dry of food because of it. Now take the money and transform it into abundance and plenty!" The farmers put the bills in the ground, right next to the seeds, but it does not make the farm more plentiful. The villagers learnt the hard lesson: that plenty does not follow money.
- GavinMcG 9y agoThis is a really pat analogy that needs a lot of justification.
- zeth___ 9y agoThen the village chief said >You fucking idiots stop burying the money in the ground and use it as a medium of exchange. And lo, as everyone has more faith in the US treasury than the village tin roof hut a market was opened in the middle of the village and they exchanged the dollars for food grown by farmers less stupid then them. The villagers then became wealth investment managers and charged fees to the farmers to invest their money, which involved holes in the ground.
- imtringued 9y agoYour analogy is flawed because the larger issue is that poor villagers can only buy US products with US dollars which means they import food from the US which then displaces domestic production. This causes even more poverty because of the high percentage of subsistence farmers in africa. If you really wanted to help them grow their economy then you would try to offshore production into that country which leads to infrastructure investments and productivity growth.
- frockington 9y agoWhat group is hoarding currency? With interest rates and the global economy roaring low we've had an explosion of investing in the past few years. I don't know of one group of people that would benefit from holding cash in the present environment
- wilde 9y agoPeople have been investing in stocks, but entrepreneurship is declining. [1] What I think this person is getting at is that the increased economic activity doesn’t seem to be correlated with opportunity for social mobility, regardless of whether the value is stored in securities or currency. [1] https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-slow-death-of-american-entrepreneurship/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-slow-death-of-ameri...
- rabbitonrails 9y agoAll first world governments?
- emodendroket 9y agoI don't think you can really describe their situation as "hoarding currency."
- richardknop 9y agoTop 1%? They have more wealth than ever and keep accumulating more and more while the differences in wealth between everybody else end the top class keep widening. Look at Warren Buffer, one of the best investors in the world and he has hundred billion dollars just sitting around as he sees no good investment opportunities. Apple & other companies are hoarding money as well, much faster than they can spend it or invest. Instead they are buying back there shares because what else to do with all that cash.
- briandear 9y agoWhat is Warren Buffet’s cash holdings? There’s a good chance they are in Treasuries or Money Market accounts which mean that money is being used by banks or the government to loan and invest. It isn’t like he has a room in his house filled with cash. The idea that cash is being hoarded is absurd. On deposit at a bank isn’t “hoarding” as the bank is able to make use of that capital to provide loans. Without the “rich” “hoarding” cash, banks have less capital which means it’s harder for you to get a car loan because the supply of money available to lend would be less. These class-warfare arguments are interesting because rarely do they actually include the benefits to the financial system. These arguments also make the assumption that governments are more efficient at spending money than individuals, a claim that just isn’t proven out by facts. Dead-weight loss is a real thing. Warren Buffet spending a dollar means a dollar goes into the economy. The the State of California spending a dollar means that perhaps $0.75 actually goes into the economy. What you seem to be arguing for is redistribution. But redistribution has deadweight losses as well as the unintended consequences of changing behavior. Perhaps a new business wouldn’t be started if taxation were at 75% — the reward wouldn’t be worth the risk, so the new economic activity from the new business wouldn’t happen at all — the associated jobs and tax revenue from that new venture would be zero. Individuals with a million dollars to create a business would create more than a million dollars in economic activity because they’d ostensibly be producing a product or a service which would result in more economic benefit than the taxable value of that million dollars. If government taxed that money at 100%, and just completely redistributed it, that would result in $1 million - x% actually reaching the economy because government doesn’t create any new value and in fact, it reduces value because of unavoidable deadweight loss. Not to mention government taxing that money at 100% means that money wouldn’t likely be earned in the first place — why even bother?
- st26 9y agoThat sounds like the current to me. Too much is locked up I wonder if you can trace parallels between this observed circumstance, and our current low interest rates & low levels of inflation.
- simias 9y agoI completely agree with you that the concentration of wealth in the hands of a tiny portion of the population is a huge problem today, but don't deflationary cryptocurrencies make it objectively worse? At least if the current "1%" hoard dollars or euros in their mattress they slowly lose their wealth thanks to inflation. After a generation or two they'll have lost a significant share of their treasure. Therefore they have an incentive to actually invest the money to fight the effects of inflation. In doing so they contribute to the economy. With a deflationary currency like bitcoin it goes like this: 1/ Buy bitcoins 2/ Bury your keys in a bunker in Antartica 3/ There is no step 3, just watch as you become wealthier while doing absolutely nothing. You want a loan to start your business or buy a house? Well tough luck, you should have mined BTC in 2013. The deflationary nature of Bitcoin is why it managed to be successful in the first place, it gives a strong incentive to be an early adopter. However in the long term I don't see how it's sustainable, it makes it borderline useless as a currency. On the other hand I don't see how an inflationary cryptocurrency could gain traction if it's not backed by a huge entity such as a government or multinational company because who would bother buying SimiasCoin if you know it's going to lose value at a steady pace in the future? And why would a government or multinational corporation bother creating a cryptocurrency they can't easily control instead of printing bills like they do today?
- keymone 9y agoBitcoin is inflationary at least nominally, until 2140.
- simias 9y agoThat's definitely not what the overwhelming majority of people buying bitcoin today are counting on though. Like, at all. Otherwise "HODL" wouldn't be the meme it is. It doesn't make sense to hold inflationary currency.
- keymone 9y agoI disagree. HODLing is a thing not primarily because hodlers believe in deflationary aspect of bitcoin, it’s because inflationary schedule is known beforehand and is not subject to change by bunch of central bankers and more importantly it’s the belief in that value will increase due to growing adoption.
- s73v3r_ 9y agoYeah, but right now, that money is locked in bank accounts, investment vehicles, etc, where the money can actually be used for stuff by others. With crypto, that money is locked away in "cold storage" where it's not available to do anything.